Contributions
1,005 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Sixth sitting)Even with the offences my hon. Friend has named so far—offences in which honesty is a factor—it is very important that the questions that he is asking are answered before we…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)I am not going to go back to third bites of the cherry again. I know there is an idea that somehow there is an unfairness or a special privilege or pleading that exists in these…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)We have explored at some length the effect of Cart as it operates at the moment, but I have not heard from the Government how they think those cases should be addressed, other…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair again, Mr Rosindell, for another sitting to consider this important Bill. I will respond briefly. The Minister correctly said that the aim…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts BillThe Bill has a whole chapter on coroners yet entirely neglects the key issue of giving bereaved families a fair hearing at inquests. Victims’ families have no right to legal aid,…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Sixth sitting)I will be brief, Sir Mark. This has been a very interesting debate, and my hon. Friend the Member for Stockton North has put forward some points that the Minister has engaged…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)We are debating the merits of clause 2 as a whole. We will not support clause stand part for two reasons. First, we believe that it insulates serious cases from judicial review,…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)I do not accept that as a separate point. I understand that that has been the thrust of the right hon. Gentleman’s argument in Committee, but it is a criticism of his own…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)The answer is that it is horses for courses, or Carts for carts. The hon. Lady says that this is just about immigration cases. Let me say first that it is important to correct…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)It is not a comparison. It is asking the Government to say why they think it is gaming if a case that has been prosecuted through the courts or taken to the administrative people…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Sixth sitting)It does seem to be a bit of a feature of this Bill. When we were dealing with clause 2, we heard that the abolition of the Cart judicial review was to be a template for other…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Sixth sitting)Listening to this debate, I am reminded that I was on the Bill Committee when the SJP was first introduced. A lot of these concerns were raised at the time and the fact that we…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fifth sitting)I am not going to speak for my right hon. Friend the Member for Tottenham, who is better able to speak for himself. Let us imagine that the Minister was correct, and that that was…09 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Fourth sitting)We are making splendid progress. I will again disappoint those who like cliff-hangers by saying right at the beginning what our attitude is towards clause 2. We find it…04 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Third sitting)I am grateful to my hon. Friend, who makes exactly the right point. He did not hear me paying tribute to him when he was temporarily detained elsewhere. I am pleased that, as an…04 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Third sitting)I absolutely agree. It is an important part of those constitutional checks and balances, and it has become more important. In a country without a written constitution, it is…04 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Third sitting)My hon. Friend has put her finger on the main objection, but it is not the only objection. It will cause a great deal of confusion, and I do not think the courts will like it.…04 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Third sitting)I am not persuaded by that. I do not want to disagree with the eminent professor, but I am tempted to say, “Two professors, three opinions”, and we had at least six professors. I…04 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Third sitting)It is not unique to this Government to be found wanting or to be challenged by the courts in such a way. Other Governments have not found favour with the courts and may have…04 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Third sitting)Much of the evidence suggests that the public are quite sophisticated about this. They see that all Governments make mistakes, get caught out and have to change their minds. In…04 Nov 2021