Contributions
1,768 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)I beg to move amendment 142, in clause 39, page 40, line 12, leave out “3 years” and insert “1 year”.23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)I will be very brief, because I do not want to repeat the arguments that I have already made. Clause 64 defines “local authority” and addresses local councils. I have raised this…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)As do the Government, as the hon. Gentleman says, but the question is whether that balance has been found. I do not see anything in the real-life example that he used that would…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)Again, I will not speak in great detail, because we have covered most of the arguments under previous clauses. Clause 48 creates an offence of nuisance begging, with a punishment…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)That is an interesting case. I have absolutely no doubt that that is not the Government’s intention, but could this clause be applied to such a case? I would make a strong…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)indicated assent. Ordered, That the Order of the Committee of 12 December 2023 be amended in paragraph 1(f) of the Order, by substituting “3.00 pm” for “2.00 pm”. —(Chris Philp.)…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)My hon. Friend would certainly have passed the test of intending to sleep rough. A subjective decision would then have to be made on whether her behaviour caused damage, or even…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)I will not repeat a lot of what I have said so far. Clause 43 concerns nuisance begging prevention orders, the most severe of the three tiers of powers that the Bill covers. I…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)I am grateful to the Minister for his answer and for saying that the Government believe that, for nuisance begging and nuisance rough sleeping, support is the starting point. That…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)Using anything for a purpose for which it was not intended risks damage, because the possibility of that damage has not been designed out. What if someone is sleeping on the bench…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)No, the phrase I used was “de minimis”. I believe that there could be some degree of power in that instance—which, I must say, I am not sure is that common, likely or foreseeable…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)It is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Sir Robert. Clause 38 brings us to the provisions that concern nuisance begging. This clause, and subsequent clauses on…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)It would be an improvement to the clause, but that is not what is in the Bill, and we would still have problems with “intending to sleep rough”. There are even issues with…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)Who do not know anything about the national referral mechanism and have no criteria to make a judgment against. Frankly, an authorised person who works frequently in a town centre…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)I appreciate that, and I was getting on to that part of my argument, but that does not dilute the impact of the language “intending to sleep rough”, which is a broad and…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)It has been a good debate, and I am glad to have the opportunity to contribute to it. As we finish this section of the Bill, I have more hope than when we started it, in the sense…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)I am grateful for the Minister’s response. The “reasonable excuse” provision in clause 39(7) gives a degree of comfort, but the reality is that, particularly in the trafficking…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Eleventh sitting)There are another six to come.23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)I do think that was a useful worked exercise. The problem is that the Minister only did half of it, because he only applied the test of whether something causes damage,…23 Jan 2024HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Twelfth sitting)The Minister is right that we have already given these issues a run-out, so I will not rehash our earlier debate. With specific regard to these clauses, however, they give us at…23 Jan 2024