Contributions
1,499 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I was grateful that you were able to comment on the issues around self-harm. The Bill also covers policing. Do you have a view on the way the Bill treats police-perpetrated…14 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q The clause actually talks about using “reasonable force”. Dame Vera Baird: But you can already use reasonable force. As long as it is proportionate and necessary, the Prison…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (First sitting)Q They are political decisions, yes, but we face a situation where, as you mentioned, if somebody commits an offence or if a prisoner assaults a prison officer, the person will…12 Dec 2023HANSARDViolence in the West BankThe same question could be asked again: it is unlawful, but what are the Government going to do about it? Does the Minister think that one day we might actually see some…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q I want to take you back to the shop workers issue. Minister Philp, in his comments, clearly demonstrated that the Government are a bit shy of having a specific charge related to…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q You are saying that in recent times the police have not responded to shop crime in the way that they ought to have. Andy Marsh: Yes, that is very often the case. For example, if…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q How much of it is a resource issue? If there were more neighbourhood police, would that sort of thing get the attention everybody believes it deserves? Andy Marsh: When you look…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (First sitting)So, as you say, it is quite complicated. Gregor McGill: It adds a further layer of complication to an already complicated process, if I may put it that way.12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q There are two other things. The first is clause 22, which compels a defendant to attend court for sentencing. I think we all realise that that will be challenging to implement,…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q That is very helpful. This is my final point. Clauses 11 and 12 address the offence of encouraging and assisting serious self-harm, and of course there are plenty of victims in…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q So it may even be challengeable under the law at some future stage. I am looking forward to our line-by-line discussions in Committee, after the evidence that you have just…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q You will not comment on the begging issues? Professor Lewis: I am afraid that is not something that we have looked at.12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (First sitting)Q Sorry, can I interrupt? What should the regulations say? Gregor McGill: It is not for prosecutors to say what the regulations should say; that is political. As I say,…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)I beg your pardon—my phone was making a noise.12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q You are very welcome this afternoon, Penney. What does the Law Commission see as the major benefits of this Bill in better serving justice? Professor Lewis: We are extremely…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q That is a pretty full answer, thank you. May I ask you about clauses 23 and 24 and the aggravating factors in relation to grooming and the end of relationship? Do they go far…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q I assume that the same applies to clause 30 on coercive behaviour offenders, where the language in the Bill refers to an “intimate or family relationship”. I was going to ask…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Yes, please. Jonathan Hall: I do not know whether the Committee recalls the Liverpool Women’s Hospital bombing, but there was a gentleman in 2020 who blew himself up in a taxi,…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q I think you expressed reservations about a similar set of circumstances when we were considering another Bill a couple of years ago. Are you saying that the provisions in clause…12 Dec 2023HANSARDCriminal Justice Bill (Second sitting)Q Would you accept that a family that has a child with challenges in his or her life may not be the best equipped to ensure that the child adheres to any order placed on them, and…12 Dec 2023