My Lords, the noble Lord raises a very important issue. It is critical that those who own and invest in our water companies are good custodians of these nationally important businesses. The reforms that we are putting in place will transform our water system to ensure that it delivers for customers and the environment, but also that it attracts investors who are committed to securing the long-term performance of our water companies.
I thank the Minister for that reply, but that is for the future. The Times has revealed that emails on financial records obtained from the London office of the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, the world’s largest bank, show that the Chinese bank issued nearly £1.26 billion in loans and borrowing options to UK water and energy companies up to July 2024. Furthermore, there were examples of concerns raised in the London office about internal due diligence being overruled by bank staff in Beijing, as well as concerns about money laundering when the bank moved £960 million for Huawei back from the UK into China following the arrest of one of its top officials. As a result of its investment in our strategic industries, there are deep concerns that this poses a financial security risk, especially since the ICBC has continued to accept business from Russian and Belarusian clients. What will the Government do about this potential security threat?
The Government take all security threats extremely seriously. I am sure the noble Lord will be pleased to hear that the water industry will be included in the National Security and Investment Act’s mandatory notification scheme. That will require water companies and certain infrastructure delivery providers to notify government of certain proposed acquisitions. These notifications from companies will ensure that government can undertake a robust assessment of any national security risks. It will operate alongside powers that allow government to call in certain acquisitions. If necessary, we can then intervene with various remedies. These could include legally binding conditions or, in rare cases, blocking or unwinding a transaction.
My Lords, the National Security and Investment Act 2021 allows the Government to scrutinise and intervene on certain acquisitions made by companies, including businesses which and investors who could harm our national security. The Act covers 17 sensitive areas in the economy, but although there was much discussion when the Bill was before your Lordships’ House about including critical infrastructure, it was not included in those 17 areas. I thank the noble Lord for bringing this issue up. With what we know today, is it not time to add services such as water to the list so that the Act can be used in full to scrutinise who controls our critical water supply?
As I just mentioned, the water sector is in the National Security and Investment Act. That is mainly because of the essential services that it provides for public health and the economy. There are 17 existing sectors in that mandatory notification scheme, including civil nuclear, energy and transport. We are assessing whether proposed acquisitions pose a national security risk. However, the noble Lord makes an important point, so I am happy that we consider the water industry when we review the terms of that Act.
My Lords, this PNQ refers to UK water companies. My noble friend will be aware that Scottish Water is publicly owned, so the Chinese can have no such influence. Is that not the way forward?
My noble friend will be aware that we published the water White Paper earlier this year. We are looking, in that White Paper and in the legislation that we will bring forward, at what ownership looks like and at the best way to secure our water industry for the future. Clearly, who owns our water industry and who has influence over it is a key part of that decision-making.
My Lords, once upon a time we owned the water industry: local authorities used to run water services very well up to 1974. Will my noble friend look, alongside security issues and the White Paper work that has been undertaken, at how these bodies can be made more publicly accountable locally?
My noble friend makes an important point. We have to ensure that not just water companies but any industry that is critical to our national infrastructure and our national security is fully accountable. We absolutely must look at that.
My Lords, the question of ownership is not the only security question that we should consider. There are reports that Iranians carried out a cyber attack on dozens of water plants in the United States at the same time as they attacked an electricity generator in this country. I refer to my interest as chair of the National Preparedness Commission. What assurance does my noble friend the Minister have that the security of the physical arrangements is sufficient to deal with those sorts of cyber attacks? Incidentally, the Chinese are also very capable of such attacks; it is not just the Iranians.
One of the issues the Government have to face is the increasing threat from cyber attacks. The previous Question was around AI. We have to understand what the potential for such attacks is, and for drone attacks. We are seeing drones being used much more, if we look at the attacks Russia is making on Ukraine. We have had meetings in COBRA about national security because, as a country, we have to look at how we get together proper, resilient plans that include cyber attacks, for example.
My Lords, will the Minister look carefully at the ownership of other water companies—Thames Water is obviously very much in the spotlight? Is she mindful of the contribution, over a number of years, that privatised water companies have made to the UK’s pension funds? Were these to be nationalised, what would the impact be on pensions funds?
Pension funds are an incredibly important part of how our investment works. One of the questions that the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, raised with me is: what do we consider to be good investment in this country? Actually, good investment is from businesses that and investors who are committed to the industry they are investing in. That includes the pension funds.
My Lords, can the Minister clarify what she said about whether the National Security and Investment Act covered the water sector? I was not an expert on it, I have to admit, but I have looked online at the 17 types of notifiable acquisitions and water does not seem to be there. There seems to be some indication that the Government are considering adding it. Could she clarify, for the benefit of the House, exactly what the status is of the water industry under the National Security and Investment Act notifiable acquisitions?