My Lords, I will also speak to the accompanying draft Code of Practice on the Right of Trade Unions to Access Workplaces. This statutory instrument and code of practice were laid before Parliament on 6 July. I also note the regret amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom.
The instrument and the draft code of practice will put into effect a key measure contained in the Employment Rights Act 2025. The importance of facilitating union access is recognised internationally, with rights enshrined in legislation. The 2025 Act framework allows trade unions to communicate with workers in person and digitally. The starting point in this framework is discussion and agreement. Employers and trade unions first negotiate a statutory access agreement. When negotiations are unsuccessful, either party may refer the case to the Central Arbitration Committee. The CAC may then determine whether access should be granted and on what terms. The regulations before the House today provide the practical and procedural detailed requirements for that framework to operate. They outline the relevant time periods, matters for the CAC to consider for access and provisions on penalties for breach of a statutory access agreement. The accompanying code of practice offers practical guidance to employers and trade unions.
I wish to highlight certain specific features of the regulations. First, the CAC must refuse access when an employer has fewer than 21 workers. Secondly, access is not unrestricted. Statutory access agreements will set up where, when and how access may be exercised. Access must also not unreasonably interfere with an employer’s operations. Union officials will be expected to comply with relevant requirements on operations, health and safety, security and safeguarding. These considerations ensure that an access agreement fits the circumstances of a particular workplace. The regulations also set out circumstances in which access must be refused. These include cases in which refusal is necessary in the interests of national security. I know the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, expressed concerns about the measure’s impact on employers and business operations. However, the framework is designed to ensure that access agreements reflect individual workplaces while recognising employers’ legitimate operational requirements.
At end to insert “but that this House regrets that the draft Regulations will impose significant new administrative and operational burdens on employers; provide for potentially weekly trade union access to workplaces despite opposition to that proposal in the Government’s own consultation; risk disruption to businesses with limited human resources capacity and in sectors dependent on tightly managed staffing and customer-facing operations; and establish a disproportionate enforcement regime without sufficient evidence that the economic and practical costs to employers have been fully assessed.”
My Lords, I am very grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument, to which I have tabled a regret amendment, but he will not be surprised to know that I take a very different view from the one that he has just explained.
Let us begin with the Government’s own consultation. When respondents were asked whether weekly access should be a model term, just 4.6% agreed and 95.3% disagreed. When they were asked whether two working days’ notice should be the model for subsequent access visits, just 7.5% agreed and 92.4% disagreed. So, rather than being carefully considered, as the Minister has contended, I am afraid that the conclusions look neither careful nor considered.
On the two most controversial aspects of this SI, weekly access and two working days’ notice, the Government have proceeded despite overwhelming opposition among the business community. So can the Minister tell the House what evidence the Government received which they considered sufficiently compelling to outweigh that response?
These regulations implement one of the most far-reaching changes to industrial relations contained in the Government’s unemployment Act. They create a statutory route by which an independent trade union can obtain physical access to a workplace, even where those workers are not union members. The union does not even have to be recognised by the employer, nor does it have to demonstrate that it already has members in that workplace, and such an intrusion is a complete violation of the property rights of business.
The exemption in the regulations applies only below 21 workers, meaning that businesses with no HR department, no in-house lawyer and no industrial relations team or experience are going to have to deal with some of these intrusions. It will guarantee that a large number of businesses will choose not to expand beyond 21 workers to avoid the hassle of all of this.
My Lords, I am pleased to support my noble friend on the Front Bench. If the previous instrument was gilding the lily, this is overegging the pudding, I have to say. The burden placed on employers to demonstrate that access arrangements do not reasonably interfere with their business, and referring the matter to the CAC, are both onerous and time-consuming.
I have to ask the fundamental question: what right do trade unionists have to come into a business every week, demanding to involve themselves in the technical, granular activities of that business? Even His Majesty’s Revenue & Customs does not avail itself of those opportunities. Why should this be part of secondary legislation? Why are the trade unions treated differently from anyone else? Weekly access as a model is a burdensome expectation of the CAC, which would significantly disrupt businesses and employers.
There are also potential privacy concerns around digital access inclusion as part of the union’s right to access the workplace. It is barely believable: this is not about going in and having regular access, which is completely laudable to people who are already trade union members; this applies to people who are not trade union members. If you have one person who is a trade union member and nine who are not, on what basis should that trade union official have a right to go into that business, disrupt it and stop it supporting the bottom line, jobs, prosperity and opportunity?
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to speak in this debate and to note that, on the other Benches, my predecessor as president of BALPA, the noble Lord, Lord Monks, and my successor, the noble Lord, Lord Barber, are here. Sitting behind them is the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, who probably still has that fate to befall her, but let us see.
I noticed that the Federation of Small Businesses got a mention. I seem to remember we recently introduced someone into this House on the Labour Benches who claimed to be from the Federation of Small Businesses—so maybe the Labour group will benefit from the wisdom of that particular person.
The next point I would like to make is quite a simple one. As far as the unions I have been involved with have been concerned, this is not a payback from the Labour Party. BALPA has never given a penny to the Labour Party and the British Dietetic Association has never given a penny to the Labour Party. They are hardly getting a reward for doing nothing at all. They are good, strong trade unions in their sectors, doing a job to make the health service work for the dietitians and to make the aircraft industry work for those in BALPA.
We talk about access to companies. I point out that there are difficulties in rostering pilots—it is very difficult to get them in the same country at the same time, let alone in the same room. This is one of the problems that has to be faced and dealt with. But whenever we bring up anything regarding better rights for trade unions, we come up with a barrage of objections —objections which, frankly, are spurious and need to be overcome. We in the European Union have dozens of airlines, and they all have structures similar to this. There is nothing exceptional about giving access to businesses to trade unions. I do not think that there is an aircraft company with under 21 employees, but this has never been a great difficulty.
It is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Balfe, and I have an answer for him. When I first went to Cambridge, I had come from Ireland, so I was not familiar with the British trade union movement. Two people I worked with in Cambridge who were not academics but were doing another job told me that they wanted work but could not get it because they were not in the trade union, yet when they applied to join a trade union and were admitted, they were taken out on strike, so they could not work. But they joined the union because they could not get work unless they joined it. Perhaps they are still members of that union; I have not kept in touch. Anyway, the noble Lord, Lord Balfe, is a very old and dear friend, but we disagree about this. He introduced me into your Lordships’ House, and I have great respect for him.
I oppose these regulations because they detract from the efficient and productive operation of businesses and factories. I speak as a small employer, but an employer none the less. I would not be under these regulations, but heaven knows, if I had a bigger organisation, I would be. They bring unknown costs to employers—and they are unknown. From what my noble friend has said, there has been no reliable costing. They go against fairness and politicise the workplace. There will be a serious impact on efficiency because of the need to facilitate perhaps weekly meetings by vacating a room for them, providing IT backup and keeping compliance records. There will be a definite loss of productivity and profitability. Just think of small businesses which employ the threshold of 21 employees, or a much smaller business of maybe 10 employees but which is associated with other businesses owned by the same employer which have a much larger workforce. They will be included in these recognitions. There will be overhead costs for security, IT and energy, and moreover there will be disruption to working schedules, co-working, teamworking, and all the practices which make for good outcomes and successful productivity.
I would love to hear from the noble Lord, but not now. There are many working people, as the noble Lord, Lord Jackson, has said, who find some of the unions’ beliefs, aims, practices and ideals inimical. How can it be fair to give them a dominant position under law to propagandise among the workforce and recruit? This is quite apart from undermining property rights, which has been mentioned. The answer is not to give rights to organisations with other political views, rather it is to avoid entirely the politicisation of the workforce.
My Lords, I declare an interest as an employee of a large multinational employer. I wish to speak against these regulations, not because I oppose trade unions or worker representation but because this Government have chosen to ignore democratic consultation on an unprecedented scale, imposed a framework that will damage the small businesses they claim to champion and crossed a line on employer autonomy from which we may not easily return.
This Government consulted on these proposals. Over 1,600 responses came in. As my noble friend Lord Sharpe has mentioned, but I believe it worth repeating, on the central question of weekly access at the heart of this regime, 95.3% respondents disagreed. On the two-working day notice requirement, 92.4% disagreed. These are not marginal objections. They are not even 50:50. They are landside rejections—the kind of number a politician usually sees only in a province he is not expecting to lose—and the Government have ignored them entirely.
This is not how government should work. When a consultation returns a verdict this one-sided, there is a democratic obligation either to redesign a policy or to explain with rigour why you are overriding the people you consulted. The Government have done neither. They have simply filed the responses away somewhere dark and ploughed ahead regardless. That should concern this House on principle alone. But the principle is not the only problem. The competence is appalling. The 21-worker threshold catches businesses that never asked for this intrusion and barely have the paperwork to cope with it. The Institute of Directors surveyed 680 business leaders. Only 10 supported the 21-worker threshold and 74% wanted a higher bar.
Yet here we are, imposing weekly union access on firms with modest HR capacity, minimal administrative resources and no history of industrial relations complexity. The regulations will create bureaucracy wildly out of proportion to the risk that they address. For retailers with multiple sites, social care providers already stretched to breaking point and universities managing student safety and data protection, this framework is a sledgehammer looking rather pleased with itself over a nut that it has yet to crack.
20 of 31 shown
I turn to frequency of access. The regulations include weekly access as a model term. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, raises this point in his regret amendment. The Government carefully considered the views expressed during consultation on this point. Access agreements should provide a genuine opportunity for trade unions to communicate with workers, rather than being so infrequent that their practical value is diminished. The flexibility to negotiate access arrangements is intended to ensure that meaningful access or engagement occurs. Access should also allow workers to engage with trade union officials considering workplace circumstances and avoiding unreasonable interference with the employer’s business. An example of such a case of flexibility would be a business that operates a shift pattern. In such circumstances, the access agreement might be arranged so that each instance of access happens at a different time, allowing workers to engage with the union if they wish.
It is important that the framework has a robust and credible enforcement model. The maximum penalties are £75,000 for a first penalty order under an access agreement, £150,000 for a second and £500,000 for subsequent penalty orders. The CAC must consider a range of factors, including the nature and gravity of the breach, before determining any penalty. This ensures that penalties remain proportionate, while providing meaningful powers to address serious or repeated instances of non-compliance. Penalty fines can be issued to any party to the access agreement. This includes third parties.
The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, states in his regret amendment that the enforcement regime has been implemented “without sufficient evidence”. The Government have committed to reviewing the operation of the framework during its first six months following implementation. We will engage with stakeholders, including employers, trade unions and the CAC in this review, and publish our findings. The review will help ensure that the framework remains effective, proportionate and responsive to the on-ground experience.
Concerns have been raised about the burden on employers, operational disruption, the model term for weekly access and the proportionality of the enforcement regime. Safeguards include exemptions for small employers, flexible access arrangements with trade unions, protections in regulations and a proportionate enforcement regime. For those reasons, I respectfully disagree with the conclusions set out in the regret amendment. These are balanced and practical issues. I therefore hope that noble Lords will support both the instrument and the accompanying code of practice. I beg to move.
On Report on the Employment Rights Bill, the Official Opposition tried to protect SMEs from precisely this outcome. The Federation of Small Businesses explicitly supported that approach, warning that smaller employers simply do not have the HR infrastructure or the legal teams available to larger companies to navigate complex access procedures and negotiations. It is no surprise that the Government opposed us; unfortunately, the Liberal Democrats also abandoned the small business argument.
In April this year, the British Chambers of Commerce, the CBI, the Federation of Small Businesses, the Institute of Directors, Make UK, the CIPD and the Recruitment and Employment Confederation wrote jointly to the Employment Rights Minister, and yet they have been completely ignored. Their conclusion was that the absence of a structured dialogue had produced an outcome which failed to address businesses’ fundamental concerns over significant disruption from increased access rights.
These new burdens also come at a very peculiar moment. The new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, has said:
“For too long, businesses have been carrying the burden of rising costs”,
and he has promised that his Government will “bring down costs”. Does the Prime Minister even support these regulations? If he does, how does he reconcile potentially weekly union access, new statutory response and negotiation processes, the Soviet-sounding Central Arbitration Committee proceedings and potentially very substantial penalties, as we have just heard, with his stated ambition to reduce costs on British businesses? I remind noble Lords that those penalties can go up to £500,000. That is not proportionate.
The Government’s own costing does little to reassure. The Explanatory Note says that no full impact assessment has been produced for the regulations because no significant impact on the private, voluntary or public sector is foreseen. Well, how is that possible? Are the Government being deliberately ignorant, or are they just incompetent?
The public sector raises an additional concern. The Local Government Association warned that arrangements should not interfere with operational priorities or the provision of vital public services, including schools, waste depots and other controlled environments. The Homecare Association has said that no assessment of this cost to publicly funded care was published, and that providers have received no additional funding to meet it. For England’s homecare, supported living and extra care workforce, it estimates that if 25% of workers attended weekly one-hour meetings, the additional cost could be around £266 million. Its extreme worst-case scenario of weekly attendance by the entire workforce exceeds £1 billion a year. The association also points out that around 80% of homecare is purchased by the state. So, after all the talk from the Prime Minister about reforming care, the Government’s measures are going to divert scarce resources into paid attendance at union meetings, resources that ultimately come from providers, councils and taxpayers.
I want to finish with two very specific questions. The first comes from a business organisation which asked us this this morning. If this is what the Government think a good business must do, how they will empower trade unions against employers who fail to meet this standard, what standards will be expected of how trade unions conduct themselves, and how do we protect good employers against trade unions which do not? Can the Minister address that very well-judged concern? My second, very specific question to the Minister is: how is the CAC qualified to make judgments about national security? By definition, it cannot be.
These regulations read less like the balanced and carefully calibrated framework promised to this House and more like a trade union wish list imposed on our job and wealth creators. So, like in the previous debate, I would say enjoy it while it lasts, because we will repeal all the job-killing measures in the Employment Rights Act 2025. I beg to move.
We are told that the regulations do not impose legal obligations but that the provisions are
“admissible in evidence and are to be taken into account in proceedings before any court, tribunal or the CAC where they consider them relevant”.
This arguably gives the code a quasi-legal status, which perhaps it should not have outside of statutory or secondary legislation. Let us be honest and not be naive—trade unions are going to push the envelope on this. They are going to be as difficult as possible, using this code in order to have as much access as they possibly can. We are looking at the development of quite a draconian enforcement scheme via the Central Arbitration Committee contained in the code. It is going to be time-consuming and bureaucratic.
I would like to ask some specific questions of the Minister. An impact assessment has not been prepared for the instrument because apparently the department has concluded that
“annual costs to business are expected to remain below the De Minimis threshold”.
Is it saying that there will not be very significant costs of these regulations and this code of practice? Again, there is no evidence to support that. In respect of the costs and the benefits, the Government say:
“We expect the equivalent annual direct cost to business, charities and voluntary bodies … to remain below the £10 million de minimis threshold.
I do not believe that. They then say:
“The benefits of the policy have not been monetised”.
This is the Government who say that they are absolutely laser-like in their focus on growth, but they do not even bother to avail themselves of the opportunity to look at data to decide whether this will have a real benefit to the economy.
I come back to the point that my noble friend Lord Sharpe raised about the statutorily supported national bargaining frameworks for adult social care and school support staff. Do we really believe that hard-pressed school support staff and people in the social care sector—which under all Governments are under enormous strain in recruitment and retention, and in getting to the next client or closing down another client to make sure they are fed properly, cleaned or washed—have time to be negotiating with trade unionists, when some of them are micro-businesses in restricted geographical areas with a small workforce? It is bonkers, and it is a completely fantastical approach to the real world.
The Government do not care about that. They were warned about this by His Majesty’s Opposition. The chickens will come home to roost. In the particular areas of school support and social care, jobs will be lost and that will be a very regrettable thing. I ask the Government to think again.
The prospect of bringing this in fulfils the demand which has been around for at least the last 20 years, and it is about time it was done. Access to workplaces is fundamental to trade unions. People are not going to be going down there every week, saying, “Oh, it’s Thursday, we’ve got to go down to Bristow’s aircraft and insist on getting through the door”. That is not the way it works. The way things work is that, if you get an employer who is determined to cause problems, they can cause them. I always go back to Eddy Shah—remember him?—who put all the objections he could find in the way of recognising the TU movement. I was delighted to be on the picket line at Grunwick with Shirley Williams, of blessed memory, and not necessarily with any party that I belonged to.
Let us get real about this. If you want to mess things up, you can, but there is no reason why, if a responsible trade union—which at least 100% of them are, and maybe a few more than that—wants access, they should not have a right to put their claim before the workers. After all, it is the workers who sign up and it is their money that gets deducted from their pay package—it is their money that gets paid over. One of the big problems in all the unions I have served on has always been keeping up the membership and persuading people not to resign and that you are providing something for them. Most of the time what you are providing for them are welfare services; people join unions to be looked after, not to be campaigned against.
I end where I did my last speech and ask the Conservative Party to have a fundamental rethink of the way it deals with the 2 million Conservative voters who hold trade union cards. These are not outsiders; these are our people, and they deserve a bit better than they sometimes hear.
My noble friend Lord Sharpe has drawn attention to the fact of our not having any reliable assessment provided by the Government of the costs and impact. It could be anything, judging by the code of practice stipulations for access in working hours, providing the rooms, digital liaison, and so on. The model for reasonableness laid down here is a weekly meeting. No wonder, as my noble friend Lord Sharpe has said, so few employers support these arrangements. Let us say each meeting takes an hour or more of working time. How much working time is lost for an employer over the whole year with a payroll of 21 or 30 or 40 employees, at a time when the total productivity and growth in this country is abysmal?
Finally, the trade unions are, in essence, an arm of the Labour Party. I oppose the politicisation of the workplace and the labour movement. There are many affiliated unions. I take the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, that not every union is affiliated to the Labour Party, but many of them support it.
The cost assumptions are thin, in the way that a stage magician’s assurances are thin. The impact assessment does not monetise every business burden. It does not fully capture management time, facilities, paid attendance at access meetings or the opportunity cost of disrupted operations. For public services, social care and local government, these are unfunded costs landing on budgets that are already down to their last few pence down the back of the sofa. The code recommends full pay for workers attending access meetings in work time. The Homecare Association estimates that this could be ruinous in publicly funded care. The Government have not told us how that cost is justified or who is expected to foot the bill—beyond, presumably, hope.
Here is what troubles me most. These regulations cross a constitutional line, and do not do so quietly. For decades, we have expected workplace relations to reflect negotiation between employer and union, not a unilateral statutory entitlement handed down from on high. This regime says that, whether you recognise a union or not, the state will now let itself in. That is not a tweak to employment law. It is a fundamental shift in the relationship between employer, worker and state, dressed up in the modest clothing of a statutory instrument. It erodes employer autonomy in ways that will not be undone merely by regretting them later, which is all that this amendment would allow us to do.
I do not oppose worker voice. I oppose this vehicle for it. It is one rejected by consultation, imposed without justification, misaligned with business reality and dangerous to the principle of voluntary engagement. This Government have in effect asked the country a question, disliked the answer and gone ahead regardless. I support this amendment and press the Government to return to the drawing board and perhaps, this time, to take on board what comes back.