The following Answer to an Urgent Question was given in the House of Commons on Thursday 15 October.
“In summer 2024, we inherited a sustainable farming incentive scheme from the previous Conservative Government that had no budget control and no proper alignment of SFI actions to environmental sustainability targets. The farming schemes were underspent, meaning that millions of pounds were not going to farming businesses.
This Government implemented many improvements to the sustainable farming incentive 2026 to make it more focused, more transparent and fairer, so that as many farmers as possible could benefit from agreements. For example, we introduced the new rule that each farm business could have only one SFI26 agreement, which cannot exceed £100,000 per year. We also streamlined the number of SFI actions to remove complexity while still having plenty of actions available for all farm types.
We held the first application window earlier in the summer, which was open only to two groups: small farms and farms without existing environmental land management revenue agreements. Window 2 of the sustainable farming incentive 2026 opened on the morning of Tuesday 22 September 2026 and closed at 3.48 pm on the same day. It was open to all farmers and land managers with at least three hectares of agricultural land.
I recognise that some farmers who wanted to join SFI26 will be disappointed not to have secured an agreement this year. There was exceptional demand for SFI26, which demonstrates farmers’ desire to invest in the environment, because healthy soils and thriving habitats are fundamental to farm profitability, productivity, sustainability and resilience.
In anticipation of high demand, we allocated an additional £20 million to window 2 on top of the £50 million announced by the Prime Minister in August so that we could fund as many agreements as possible. We have therefore allocated a total of £310 million to nearly 19,000 new agreements across both application windows in SFI26, including £253 million and 12,200 new agreements through window 2.
In keeping with the commitments made in Farming Roadmap 2050, we plan to offer an SFI scheme in 2027. As part of that, we will scrap the first come, first served application process. We will look to open the 2027 window as early as possible to ensure that farmers can access funding and we will work with farming representative organisations including the National Farmers’ Union to consider how we refine the scheme for SFI27. As set out in the farming road map published earlier this year, the Government are committed to a farming sector that is productive, profitable and resilient”.
We now have 70,000 multiyear environmental land management scheme agreements in place. Those agreements will invest a total of £930 million in environmentally sustainable farming over the next three years. That is nearly £1 billion of investment in nature-friendly farming as part of £11.8 billion in funding for sustainable farming in this Parliament.
We plan to offer an SFI scheme in 2027, and we will look to open the 2027 offer as early as possible to ensure that farmers can access funding. We are already looking to make changes to improve the SFI for next year, continuing our close work with farmers and stakeholders by listening to experiences and learning lessons from this window.
In keeping with the commitments made in Farming Roadmap 2050, we plan to offer an SFI scheme in 2027. As part of that, we will scrap the first come, first served application process. We will look to open the 2027 window as early as possible to ensure that farmers can access funding and we will work with farming representative organisations including the National Farmers’ Union to consider how we refine the scheme for SFI27. As set out in the farming road map published earlier this year, the Government are committed to a farming sector that is productive, profitable and resilient”.
My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for taking this Question and I declare my interest as a farmer in receipt of environmental payments. The allocation of limited SFI funds to farmers with the fastest reaction time, rather than to the most impactful applications or greatest need, is disappointing. This lottery underscores the urgency of moving to longer-term, predictable ecosystem service schemes that deliver the best outcomes and improve incentives to land managers by bringing in private sector finance. Given the glacial progress of developing these schemes, does the Minister believe the unwieldly Defra structure with 34 ALBs is fit for purpose?
I am sure the noble Lord is aware that we have had a full review of Defra ALBs recently through the Corry report. We are looking at how we can improve their effectiveness and efficiency, and that is ongoing work. There was only a short window before SFI applications came to an end; in window 2, however, the application system did actually deal with unprecedented levels of demand and 12,500 farmers managed to apply before the budget was allocated. Many farmers, therefore, got an SFI allocation opportunity.
My Lords, does the Minister agree that the outcome in September was foreseeable? An independent estimate predicted some 40,000 applications, against funding for around 15,000. When the chair of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee asked in the House of Commons on Thursday whether the department expected so many to be disappointed, he received no answer to his question. Will the Minister tell this House how many applications Defra expected and why farmers were not warned that many of them would be disappointed?
I do recognise that many of the farmers who wanted to join SFI26 will have been disappointed not to have secured an agreement. Clearly, in Defra, we are reviewing how the process works, how to open up the next window of SFI and how that will operate.
As opposed to window 1, window 2 was open to all eligible farmers and land managers and we recognised that the demand could be high. Because of that, in August, the Prime Minister announced that there would be an extra £50 million for SFI26 window 2, and then the Secretary of State in Defra added a further £20 million ahead of window 2 opening, which took the total budget to £310 million, in order to help more farmers access support. That was done because we recognised there was going to be high demand.
My Lords, I declare my farming interests as set out in the register. What is the Minister’s advice to the majority of farmers, who did not have a successful application? If we want to farm for food and enhance the environment, we need to have a comprehensive system in order that many more farmers can get involved in what is a very important project.
The noble Lord makes a good point; we absolutely need to get as many farmers involved in sustainable farming and farming for the environment, as well as for profitability and food security. There are still other funding opportunities available to farmers, such as the Countryside Stewardship scheme, the Farming in Protected Landscapes scheme and the ELM capital grants offer. Those are still open. It is important to say that, this year, we allocated a total of £310 million to nearly 19,000 new agreements across both application windows, and we also now have 70,000 multi-environmental land management revenue agreements in place across all the schemes, and that is part of £11.8 billion funding for sustainable farming during this Parliament, which is a huge sum of money and more than has been allocated before.
My Lords, with aphids, gout fly and leafhoppers emerging in the new emerging cereal crops, reports suggest that some, and maybe a significant number of, farmers who signed up for the SFI no-insecticide option are looking at abandoning it because of the disease and pest risk. Does the Minister acknowledge that the Government need to consider providing far more support to farmers to be able to make these sustainable initiatives, build crop diversity and move away from the mass commodity crops that are so vulnerable to these pests and diseases?