That the Grand Committee takes note of the Statement of Changes in Immigration Rules (HC 259) in light of the 10th Report of the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee (HL Paper 42), published on 23 July.
Relevant document: 10th Report from the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee (special attention drawn to the instrument).
My Lords, before proceeding with this take-note Motion, I thank Freedom from Torture for its help. Together with the Helen Bamber Foundation, it has drawn attention to the issues raised by this statement of changes in Immigration Rules. They have since been joined by a number of other expert stakeholder organisations. I also note the assistance I receive from RAMP, as listed in the register. I welcome my noble friend the Minister to the asylum brief, which I suspect will keep him pretty busy in the coming months. I thank noble Lords who are attending. I know my noble friend Lord Dubs has to leave at some point, so he may just be here for moral support, but moral support from him is always very welcome.
I am drawing the statement of changes to the Committee’s attention following the SLSC’s 10th report, which recorded a number of weaknesses in the explanatory material provided by the Home Office—not for the first time. The statement involves the introduction of what is now being called a “single protection interview”. It was originally called “merged registration”, but while I am glad that the Home Office appears to have taken SLSC’s advice to change the name, calling it a single protection interview, given the concerns raised, does seem rather Orwellian.
The new approach will, in the words of the Explanatory Memorandum:
This all adds up to the fear that asylum seekers fleeing trauma, torture or oppression on grounds of sexuality will not be assured a fair hearing. Freedom From Torture, supported by others, argues that the substantive asylum interview and concurrent evidence submission process is an indispensable part of the asylum system, as it provides people with the opportunity to properly present their claim. This is particularly the case for claims made on the basis of sexual orientation. It applies even to those coming from manifestly safe countries who may nevertheless be at risk because of their personal circumstances, a point that has been made in the past by the Joint Committee on Human Rights.
4:30 pm
On the general issue of legal representation, the committee reported the Home Office’s assurance that the availability of legal aid is not affected by the changes. However, the sector’s experience is that the great majority of asylum seekers secure a legal representative only following the screening interview, and then they often require considerable preparatory work. Truncating the process makes it less likely that asylum seekers will get the advice they need in the context of what have been described as “legal aid deserts”. The importance of the right to legal support in such cases has been emphasised by the UNHCR. Will my noble friend please explain how the Home Office will ensure effective access to legal advice and representation at the point of referral into the SPI process, given that legal aid funding is generally not available for screening interviews?
This all adds up to the fear that asylum seekers fleeing trauma, torture or oppression on grounds of sexuality will not be assured a fair hearing. Freedom From Torture, supported by others, argues that the substantive asylum interview and concurrent evidence submission process is an indispensable part of the asylum system, as it provides people with the opportunity to properly present their claim. This is particularly the case for claims made on the basis of sexual orientation. It applies even to those coming from manifestly safe countries who may nevertheless be at risk because of their personal circumstances, a point that has been made in the past by the Joint Committee on Human Rights.
The other fear expressed by the sector is that this might be the first step towards wider use of the SPI process. The Home Office told the SLSC that the initial cohort of cases will come from a limited number of countries. The implication is that it could be extended to further countries and/or involve further selection criteria. Can my noble friend please explain what might be envisaged, but also give a categorical assurance that the welcome exclusion of unaccompanied and age-disputed children will continue and will not be qualified in any way? Can he also explain what is proposed with regard to monitoring the new policy, as I have not been able to find any mention of that? It is important that legal representatives, civil society and people with lived experience can feed into the process and that there is no extension of the SPI until there is clear published evidence of how it is working. Again, can he give us an assurance on that?
I apologise that I have gone on at some length, but I wanted to do justice to the concerns raised by the SLSC and by Freedom From Torture and other organisations. This may be a small change in the eyes of the Home Office, but it is one with potentially significant implications for people in vulnerable circumstances and it deserves our scrutiny. I beg to move.
My Lords, I begin by acknowledging the support that I have received from RAMP as one of its principals. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, for creating this important opportunity to take note of and discuss the Government’s new single protection interview process, introduced through the Statement of Changes in Immigration Rules. I acknowledge that procedural changes will often need to be facilitated through secondary legislation, but the nature of the changes before us raises substantial questions, which I am pleased can now be explored with Ministers in this House.
Organisations such as the Helen Bamber Foundation and Freedom from Torture have argued that the changes represent a “substantial shift” in procedure, as the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee highlighted. It therefore seems appropriate that time is allocated for proper parliamentary scrutiny. This is particularly pertinent if the Government wish at a future date to expand the use of a single protection interview. Can the Minister provide reassurance that, if that were to happen, there will be a further opportunity to discuss the merits of such an approach and consider the necessary safeguards that might be required?
The Government’s objective to improve the effectiveness and timeliness of our asylum system is entirely legitimate and welcome, but we must distinguish carefully between administrative efficiency and justice. As the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, has said, speed must not come at the expense of fairness. Are the Government confident that the new process will be able reliably to distinguish an unfounded claim from a genuine one that has not yet been fully understood and where additional information might be required?
The purpose of an asylum system is of course not simply to process claims but to identify people who genuinely need protection. The scrutiny committee’s key concern is pertinent here. If I am right in my understanding that the Government have confirmed that applicants will retain the right to submit further information, why then remove the Immigration Rules’ explicit guarantee of that right?
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow two such powerful and caring speeches focused on the justice of our asylum system—which, after all, in many cases addresses issues of life and death. I agree with virtually everything that both noble Baronesses said, so, rather than repeat what has been said, I will seek to add a couple of points to it.
We are focusing on the fact that we are talking about people whose lives have all too often been marked by torture, trauma, abuse and other suffering. The reality is that it is difficult for them to just sit down and talk about that. Although I almost always agree with her, the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, described a lot of the language and process here as rather Orwellian. I will take away that “rather” because our own Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee reflected, in paragraph 4 of its report, on the term “merged registration”. That is where one interview covers the registration, the screening of the individual and the establishment and assessment of the basis of the claim. The scrutiny committee says of that term that
“‘merged registration’ does not accurately describe what the process will encompass”.
We should think about those people, very often with English as a second language, being in a really confusing situation. I have a direct question to the Minister: could we not at least call it something that would be immediately understandable if it was to be translated? I note that the committee also said:
“The Home Office may wish to consider using a more helpful, descriptive and easier to understand name”.
Are the Government taking that on board?
The noble Baroness, Lady Lister, referred to a really important report in the context of what we are debating: the June 2026 report by the Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration. It is worth revisiting its conclusion, which said that the quality of decision-making in the asylum system
4:45 pm
I have one more question to put to the Minister. I note that the Home Office, speaking to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, said that it expected that between 400 and 600 cases per year would be eligible for this process. This compares to about 128,000 people receiving initial asylum decisions in March 2026. What savings do the Government expect? It is hard to see for what reasons, other than cost savings, this is being implemented. What savings do the Government expect to be made from this change? Are they not concerned that there will be further costs—both human and financial—down the line if bad decisions are made?
My Lords, I first declare my interest that, like others, I am helped and supported by the RAMP organisation. I thank those who have already spoken. A huge number of remarks and questions have been addressed to the new Minister; in that context, I welcome him. He may not be as happy as he would like in this particular role because this topic of course causes great controversy within our House. An enormous number of issues need to be raised and dealt with, and we expect to find answers from the Home Office which are sometimes lacking.
Having previously spent three years as a member of the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, I am able to recognise an excoriating report when I see one, and this is clearly such a report. It is not often that the committee goes to such lengths to make such important points when it does not get answers from the department concerned. The challenge is that the committee itself will address its concerns back to the Home Office and will get answers from it. If it does not get the answers, that will be mentioned in the report and when it does not find that the answers are sufficient it will mention that, too. This report does that and Members on all sides have said clearly that there are questions to be raised and questions that need to be answered as a result.
I am glad about the changed name. When you merge things, you are perhaps supposed to do the merging in turn, but it was clearly an unsuitable title and I am glad that it has been changed, even though it now presents perhaps the same critique and problems that the original title suggested anyway. One of the challenges we face in addressing this issue in this changed piece of guidance and legislation is whether it is a minor change or a major change. I draw on my musical experience here. Things that are minor are usually sad and things that are major are things that we can judge in a more content manner. Clearly, this is not something which can be treated as being of a minor nature.
Much of the criticism appears to proceed from the assumption that individuals will somehow be rushed through the process without safeguards, but the Home Office evidence to the committee explicitly states that vulnerability and safeguarding considerations remain central to decision-making, and that the process will be reserved for a narrowly defined cohort of cases. Indeed, the Government estimate that only around 400 to 600 cases per year will be eligible for the new process, compared with around 128,000 initial asylum decisions annually. The committee itself accepted that this represents only a small proportion of the overall asylum system. It is therefore difficult to sustain the argument that this reform somehow represents a wholesale transformation of Britain’s asylum framework.
My Lords, this is the first proper opportunity I have had to welcome the Minister to his new role. I very much look forward to working with him in future. I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Lister of Burtersett, for this opportunity to debate the changes to the Immigration Rules, and I am equally grateful to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee for its careful consideration.
As always, although I respect the concerns that have been expressed, I believe that it is important that we keep sight of the central issue. These changes do not alter the substantive legal tests for refugee status, humanitarian protection or human rights protection—rather, they are a procedural reform designed to make the asylum system operate more efficiently in a small and tightly defined category of cases.
The key change relates to what the Home Office describes as the “merged registration process”. Instead of requiring both a screening interview and a later, more substantive interview, certain claims considered suitable for accelerated handling will be dealt with through a single interview process. The objective is to reduce unnecessary bureaucracy and allow scarce case-working resources to be focused on more complex claims.
The Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee has highlighted the concerns raised by external organisations that this represents a significant change to asylum procedures and may reduce fairness for applicants. Yet the Home Office has been equally clear that claimants will continue to have the opportunity to explain the basis of their claim, provide evidence, seek legal advice and submit further representations before decisions are taken. It said that where indicators of vulnerability, trafficking, safeguarding concerns or indeed complexity emerge
“the case will be removed from the Merged Registration process and routed into the standard asylum process”.
5:00 pm
20 of 34 shown
“Involve one interview, covering the registration of the asylum claim, screening of the individual, and the establishment and assessment of the basis of claim. The interviewing officer will ask relevant and appropriate questions to establish whether an individual has protection needs and, if not, whether they can be removed from the UK without the need for a further asylum interview”.
Although the Home Office suggests that only a minority of cases will be treated in this way, and that it constitutes only a minor change, the SLSC notes that the submission from Freedom from Torture and Helen Bamber warns that it represents “a substantial shift” in the asylum procedure. While the SLSC accepted the Home Office’s argument that only a small proportion of asylum seekers is likely to be affected and that the change did not alter the substantive criteria in the rules, it did not consider that this constituted an adequate justification for the Home Office’s failure, once again, to consult on the matter.
The report states:
“it is precisely in the operational implementation where consultation can often be the most productive; we have previously highlighted numerous examples of instruments where consultation could have improved operational policy design, including in relation to changes to immigration rules”.
Then, in bold, it states:
“The Home Office has therefore not provided a valid reason for the lack of consultation in this case, which we regard as unacceptable”.
Strong words indeed. I would welcome my noble friend’s response to them and ask whether he accepts the criticism, which clearly has implications for future changes to the rules. Will he give a commitment now that any further changes to the policy will be subject to consultation with expert stakeholders and those with lived experience of the asylum process?
The SLSC was also critical of the fact that the guidance which puts the flesh on the new rules was not published alongside the statement to illuminate how the change will operate in practice. Again in bold, it notes:
“As we have stated before, and including in relation to earlier changes in immigration rules, where guidance is important to understanding the effect of a change in the law, it should be published (in draft, if necessary) alongside the instrument to enable scrutiny. We are firmly of the opinion that the Home Office should adopt this as the default approach for future Statements of Changes”.
Once more, I would welcome my noble friend’s response to that.
It should also be noted that, although the guidance has now been published, there was no consultation on it, despite a written request to the Home Office from four organisations in the field. Will my noble friend the Minister at least agree to the Home Office sharing the SPI interview script with expert stakeholders for consultation, so that they can assess and advise on how effectively it will serve to identify vulnerability and safeguarding concerns?
It is to these substantive concerns that I now turn. Although I am sure we all applaud the general attempts to speed up the asylum process, they should not come at the expense of the quality of decision-making. I was rather concerned about the Home Office’s response to one of the SLSC’s questions, which said that the primary purpose is not to improve the identification of trauma but to ensure that clearly unfounded claims can be considered more efficiently where appropriate.
At the heart of the sector’s concern is the fear that trauma will not be identified but overlooked, because the eligibility criteria and case selection process do not clearly exclude cases that raise safeguarding concerns and vulnerability indicators. These may not be identified during an SPI’s accelerated process. They point to evidence of the current failure at screening to identify and respond to indicators of vulnerability, trafficking and safeguarding concerns. Although the guidance allows for rerouting back into the standard asylum process, it would seem that the onus is on the asylum seeker to make any vulnerability clear during the SPI. However, the guidance does not make it clear what criteria will be applied and how such rerouting would be decided, nor how a claimant will know and understand that possibility. If my noble friend could clarify this, that would be very helpful.
This raises the other main related concern. Research and the Home Office’s own earlier guidance identify the many barriers to early disclosure of vulnerability, trauma or sexuality. Torture survivors could find it very difficult to talk about their experience. Similarly, LGBTQI+ people often delay claiming asylum on the basis of sexual orientation, gender identity and expression or sex characteristics due to, among other things, their feeling unsafe, a history of trauma and a lack of understanding that oppression due to sexual orientation constitutes an accepted ground for asylum.
That said, where someone has already disclosed trauma of some kind or is making an LGBTQI+-related claim, can my noble friend give a commitment that they will not be subjected to the SPI process? This is more likely in the case of an in-country claim, but it is not clear from the guidance whether the SPI process will apply to both in-country and at-border claims, although I understand that officials have indicated it would apply to only in-country claimants. Can my noble friend please clarify this point and, if that is the case, ensure that the guidance is amended to make this clear?
The Home Office countered fears about disclosure with reference to the training of decision-makers, but a UNHCR study found that most staff had no or very limited training on how to spot vulnerability when it was not freely disclosed. Although training may have improved since that study, the most recent report from the Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration on asylum casework was pretty damning on the quality of both training and decision-making. What, if any, further training is envisaged?
The concern raised by the SLSC is on whether claimants will have the opportunity to provide additional evidence, such as medical or legal reports, following the SPI. In fact, that has since been clarified in the guidance, but it is still not clear why it was deleted from the actual rules. Moreover, Freedom from Torture believes that the five days’ additional time specified is likely to be sufficient only in the most straightforward cases; much will depend on whether the claimant has been able to get legal representation. Again, I would be grateful for my noble friend’s thoughts on that.
The SPI relies on the Home Office identifying appropriate cases before vulnerability, trafficking indicators, trauma, sexual orientation or safeguarding concerns have been fully explored. But as the Government know, evidence consistently shows that many survivors of torture, trafficking and other forms of serious harm do not disclose these experiences at the earliest stage of the asylum process. Even if these characteristics are identified, there will presumably need to be an assessment of whether the safeguarding or vulnerability indicator meets a threshold to qualify for rerouting out of the single process and back into the standard asylum process. Can the Minister provide further information on how suitability decisions will be made and how applicants can challenge inclusion in the process?
The Home Office recognises that survivors of torture, trafficking and those from the LGBTQI+ community often disclose relevant experiences only after trust has been built up. Trauma, shame, fear, exhaustion, unfamiliarity with the asylum process and language barriers can make it difficult to disclose experiences coherently at the first interview, and the most vulnerable may need specialist support to fully disclose evidence. An incomplete first account should not automatically be mistaken for a dishonest or unfounded claim. Can the Government offer reassurance that the new process will not lead to decision-makers reaching premature conclusions before the relevant evidence has been assembled? Does the Minister envisage that identified survivors of torture, trafficking and other serious trauma will be excluded from the SPI process?
The Home Office acknowledges that interviews are often the most important evidence-gathering opportunity. Curtailing that process for this vulnerable cohort risks unfair outcomes. It is also important to remember that, even if a country is generally safe, an individual may face persecution because of their particular circumstances. The assessment must therefore remain individual, not presumptive.
I expect that not every asylum case will require two interviews, but it is important to remember that an unjust refusal, made potentially more likely through the loss of a substantive interview, is not merely an administrative error—it might expose someone to persecution or serious harm. It could also lead to costly litigation and further delays, undermining the very efficiency that the policy is seeking. The risk of refoulement is a serious potential consequence. I want to be clear that I am not suggesting that every SPI decision may be unlawful, but I urge the Government to commit to further parliamentary scrutiny and to consultation with expert stakeholders and publication of evaluation data ahead of removing the procedural safeguard of an additional interview from other groups and for other purposes.
The Government are right to want to resolve clearly unfounded claims quickly to reduce delays and to avoid keeping people in prolonged uncertainty. The policy guidance allows for further investigation and interviews where necessary, which is of course welcome. The issue is whether, in practice, those safeguards will work consistently. I therefore ask the Minister: will interviewers be trained to recognise trauma, vulnerabilities and inconsistencies that may have legitimate explanations? Also, will there be a clearly applied process for transferring a case to the usual process? I appreciate that the Minister may not be able to answer all the questions that I have asked today, but I would be grateful if he could commit to write.
The measure of an asylum system is not simply how quickly it can refuse a claim but how reliably it can recognise a person who genuinely needs protection. A fair system must be capable of refusing unfounded claims but also capable of recognising when a person’s right to asylum is evidence-based, even when they struggle to explain it at first or to provide corroborating information. The questions I have asked are in an effort to understand whether the new process has sufficient safeguards to distinguish effectively between the two. Where the consequences of error may be persecution, torture or even the loss of life, the burden of getting that distinction right is profound. I therefore hope that the Government will take seriously the concerns raised by the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, explain the removal of the express safeguard for further evidence, and commit to transparent monitoring of the new process.
“had declined … and was at an unacceptable level”.
It focused particularly on the problems of hiring staff—the appropriateness of the way in which staff are hired and who is hired—and the retention challenges. Four in 10 decision-makers left between April 2024 and May 2025, and those decision-makers had typically been in position for only 11 months. Again, I ask the Minister directly: will this simply be a cab rank system? Will the people using this process just be whoever is next in the queue or, if this system is to be used, will it be applied by more experienced and, I hope, more skilled and knowledgeable staff, who will have had the chance to experience seeing claims previously?
I also express concern about the Government’s intention to focus on a small number of countries. I will anonymise this quite heavily because I do not know the situation now of the individual concerned but, some years ago, I met a woman in Bristol who told me—I have no doubt that the fear that she was expressing was absolutely genuine—that she was the divorced wife of someone from a very powerful family on the Indian subcontinent and that she feared for her life if she was forced to go back to her home country. That is not a country issue but, as the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, said, individuals may indeed be in a position of genuine fear of persecution in those kinds of circumstances. To know and understand that and be able to read a person’s explanation is a complex thing.
Paragraph 10 of the report notes that these words were deleted:
“Where the personal interview is omitted, the applicant and dependents shall be given a reasonable opportunity to submit further information”.
The deletion of that sentence suggests that applicants may not be able to suspend the decision-making process to seek expert advice. The major change here is an operational one, bringing together two systems to try to shorten the process for a small number of cases, so we are assured.
What we do in this country and the way we address people’s individual needs for protection are judged against that background. People are not part of cohorts and not to be treated as part of some system that systemically makes things easier; every case deserves to be looked at on its merits. The individuality of assessments is not just present in this country but across the whole of Europe, though sometimes we have to pull those changes up and look at them in a critical way as well.
When you put together two systems, remove such a sentence and make this operational change, which is of some significance because you are reducing the opportunity of individual assessment, it is right that people around this Room ask: where is the legal aid provision? Where is the advice? Where is the training for those who will support people who are genuinely suffering from trauma and other mental health problems that come with the journeys that they have been on?
People faced with life-or-death decisions leave in a traumatic state. That state does not improve just because they have arrived here. They are nervous and their understanding of what will happen to them needs to be addressed. That is why a personalised assessment is so important. The problem with what we have before us is that there was no consultation, not even with the Government’s own consultative body. That was brought in just with the intent of speeding up the process. There was no impact assessment, because the Government maintain that it a minor change rather than a major one. I maintain that the operational aspects are entirely different from what they were before. For people going through this system, the nature of the operation is now entirely different—before there would be a process by which people’s cases would be individually understood.
Finally, as the report says, and as we have asked for, when the Government make changes to the rules of this sort, they should produce the draft guidance alongside the changes. Then we can judge whether the rules are being adjusted for a purpose that is actually accurate, rather than one of simplicity, which is what I think the original intention was. I hope that the Minister will be able to tell us that, in future, when changes are made to the Immigration Rules, which are of a major nature or can be interpreted as being such, the Home Office will do all three things: a consultation exercise, an impact assessment and guidance, which may be in draft but certainly would help us to make decisions about these matters.
I would like to talk about the trouble with shortcuts. If you take a shortcut and get a back lane instead of going down the main road, sometimes that can lead to barbed wire where the roads are closed at the end or where it is a bit dangerous to proceed. Shortcuts should be taken only if you know where the end is and whether the route is clear or not. That is particularly relevant here. This is a shortcut which has not yet determined whether the right end product is there and available.
The problem with changes that allegedly relate to a particular group of people is that, without a definition, we are left blank as to whether these people will be worse off than they were before and whether the cohort decision will blanket their approval or disapproval because of situations that are not of their making. A lot of strong messages have been sent to the Home Office, both in this debate and in the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee’s report. I hope that the Minister has listened to and heard them, and that he will act on all those matters.
I want to raise one final matter on the changes to the Immigration Rules. It concerns a case with which I, along with the noble Lord, Lord Hanson, dealt. I have now succeeded in getting the approval of the two people concerned, in order to take this matter forward, but I raise a related question around the Immigration Rules on people with religious occupations.
The case I referred to is that of two nuns from Lesotho who were seeking to come to stay with an order in Humberside. They were being looked after by the same order to which they belonged, of course, and they were going to come and spend time with it. I do not reckon that that was a religious occupation; I reckon that they were building religious certainty and confidence, and were being helped. However, they failed at the border not because they did not have the appropriate visas but because of money: they could not determine how much money they would need to look after themselves in the United Kingdom. The answer, of course, is that holy orders and religious communities, including this particular religious community, have communal funds—that is, worldwide funds, not funds that are communal in the area they are in. So being “treated”—in inverted commas—to a break and a stay with another community of nuns in Merseyside was denied to them because they did not have the money in their pocket.
These two nuns come from Lesotho, which is, as anyone who has been there will know, one of the poorest countries in Africa. I declare my interest as the honorary consul for the Kingdom of Lesotho in Wales. So it is a matter of some importance to me that, when we deal with issues that are related to the Immigration Rules, we see people for what they are: individual people. They need to have their cases looked after properly, and we need to ensure that we do that.
In conclusion, we need—I suspect that everybody in this Room wants this—a fair system in a world where people’s decisions to come to this country for protection are matters of life and death for them. We need to ensure that they are protected properly. I hope that the Minister will take all of these points on board and make sure that the Home Office behaves, as this document says, in the appropriate manner for what I regard as a major change.