That this House takes note of the action needed on skills, vocational training, and further and higher education to improve outcomes for those from deprived and disadvantaged communities and strengthen regional growth.
My Lords, I declare my interests as set out in the register. There have been so many reports about the importance of vocational education and our inability as a country to deliver. Many of us in this House have been part of these arguments for years—it is good to see the noble Lord, Lord Baker, in his place—and there is real expertise and experience here. This issue is too important for point-scoring or positioning from any of us. The change needed demands detailed work and we need to thrash this through together, not to seek a fuzzy consensus but to get solutions that survive longer than a Parliament.
I hope we can start by agreeing on four principles: first, the importance of aspiration for all students; secondly, the importance of literacy and numeracy for all; thirdly, the need to avoid completely separate vocational or academic pathways; and fourthly, a recognition that a significant group of young people are failed by the current system. I declare an interest as a member of the independent inquiry into white working-class educational outcomes, co-chaired by my noble friend Lady Morris of Yardley and Sir Hamid Patel. Its findings run through what I want to say. I will also draw on the Milburn review and a range of other evidence for which I am grateful.
The facts are stark. About 1.25 million white British pupils are eligible for free school meals, of whom only just over a third achieve a grade 4 or above in GCSE English and maths. Of course, that reflects a gap that starts pre school and is picked up at the phonics screen and at the end of primary. As inquiry members, we did not find a lack of aspiration; rather, there was pride, resilience and solidarity, and young people who want good lives in the places they come from. But we did hear of structural barriers and a slow erosion of trust—a growing sense that the system is not designed for people like them. That said, we found great schools and colleges achieving strong outcomes for exactly these children, so none of this is inevitable.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness on initiating this debate. We have not debated practical and technical education in this House since 2010, so this is the first time in 16 years, and we have three minutes—it is absurd. This House is not holding the Government to account on education; we should have an education Select Committee.
I also congratulate the Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, on holding her position in government. There was no chance of her being dropped—she is far too talented—but I thought she might be promoted; I am glad she has not been for the time being, because her knowledge in education is profound. What is more, her real virtue is that she supports the colleges I have been promoting for 15 years; that is, university technical colleges.
Those colleges provide education for 14 to 18 year-olds, and we now have 44 colleges and 21,000 students. The thing of which I am most proud is that they have the lowest level of youth unemployment of any schools in the country. If you leave a bog-standard comprehensive, there is an unemployment rate of 16.4%; it is less than 5% for those leaving a UTC. Last year, 22 of our colleges provided no one who was NEET, and that is unique.
So we need technical and practical education in our schools. These colleges are very popular; we have 45, but we have to turn 5,000 or 6,000 children away each year. We need therefore to expand, but we cannot expand by having new schools, because none will be built in Britain for five or seven years due to falling school rolls. We have devised a way in which we can improve technical and practical education fundamentally by inserting into a bog-standard comprehensive a sleeve of practical and technical education from 14 to 18—the UTC sleeve, as it is called. I am glad to say that one of these is going to open next week in Barrow-in-Furness. BAE Systems has its factories there, but it cannot recruit students from the schools in Cumbria suitable for what it wants to do. This school will be operational next week. There will be 120 students starting, and they will decide themselves whether they want to go down the technical or the academic route. Some 90 so far have elected to do the technical route and 30 the academic, all under the same roof. That is a triumph.
My Lords, I have listened to the first two speeches. The noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, hit on something towards the end of her speech that I do not think anybody who knows anything about the subject will disagree with. It is the work of a decade to correct the problems here. You have to get into a system and change it, you have to change the cultures and the training, and you have to make people think in a slightly new way.
The NEET problem, according to everything that anyone who has been here has listened to, and according to the Library briefing, has been growing for over a decade. It is a fact that a group of children, who are now young and established adults, have gone through a system of education that does not seem to have touched them or brought them in in any way or form. Many of them left the education process way before they reached the end of compulsory education, and people have been happy about it. I say that because the first report I have seen into off-rolling in the schools system came out of the House of Commons in 2020. Something about our current structure of education means that anybody who is not a benefit to their school in terms of examination grades is a real problem not only to the school but to the professional and personal development of those running it. If we can do something here that starts to address that, we will do something very positive.
My Lords, I too am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, for securing this debate. I also express my gratitude to Alan Milburn and his team for firmly putting the number of young people out of education, employment and training on the political agenda. I think there is real cross-party consensus on the need to address what Alan Milburn was right to call a “moral crisis” facing our young people today. I sincerely hope that when the second part of his review is published, his recommendations will be taken seriously. Mr Milburn referred to the drivers behind rising NEET rates as a whole-system crisis; I would go further and characterise it as a whole-society crisis. There is an important role for community organisations to play—whether they are faith groups, uniformed groups, sports clubs or youth clubs—and for all of us as neighbours, friends and mentors to young people.
In my time today, I want to focus on one area specifically: volunteering opportunities. They provide the intermediate layer between individual and labour markets and can help build young people’s skills and confidence to equip them for the world of work. Many of us will be familiar with the experience trap. When you are first trying to get a foot on the career ladder, you need so many years of experience to get a job, but a job is the only way to get that experience. This is where community groups can make a real difference. In these settings, young people can learn, practise and develop new skills, and ideally have their first leadership opportunities. Developing skills is not simply a matter of absorbing knowledge—which is where the classroom environment is at its strongest. It is about having one’s gifts and talents recognised, put into practice and stretched.
In the most recent government youth social action survey—which, noble Lords might be disappointed to hear, has not been run since 2019—over half of 16 to 20 year-olds said that social action had improved their self-confidence and communication skills. Significant numbers also reported improvements to their ability to work as a team and motivate others, and to their social skills more generally. I urge the Government to think holistically about skills development, the foundations for learning—here the Government’s ambitions for reducing child poverty are especially important—and the many contexts in which all this can take place. These include, but are not limited to, colleges and universities.
My Lords, it is an honour to follow the right reverend Prelate; I strongly support the sentiments he described. I also thank the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, for putting this on the agenda in the way that the noble Lord, Lord Baker, welcomed, because it is such a fundamental subject and theme for us. I also thank her for her excellent speech; I agreed with every word.
Next month will be the 50th anniversary of James Callaghan’s famous speech at Ruskin College, in which he drew attention to the need to focus on standards and employability. We are still working on the legacy of that. The other person I want to draw attention to is the noble Lord, Lord Baker. I am honoured and privileged to follow him in this debate. We are all in his debt, not just for the amazing Education Reform Act 1988 but for his continuing 40 years of work to drive higher education standards. He is an exemplar to us all.
Over the decades since that 1988 legislation, the school system in this country has become globally admired. The reason is not the debates we have had—of course there have been disagreements—but that, underlying them, there have been some fundamental principles that all Governments have stuck to over that time: education is a priority; you need to set standards, devolve budgets and responsibility to schools, hold them to account, intervene decisively if they are underperforming and focus all the time on the quality of teaching. Those principles have been adhered to for the last 30 or 40 years. Conceptually, it is not difficult. The difficulty is ensuring that consistent adherence over time, and this has never been the case with vocational skills and FE. There has been too much chopping and changing and not enough focus on the quality of teaching. We might have led the world in this field too, but so far we have chosen not to. Now is the time we should choose to do so.
Taking the new Prime Minister’s lead, we are now in a position to do exactly that. We can develop the kind of agenda that the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, laid out. The four principles that she outlined are excellent. I add that we need better articulation between schools, colleges and universities; we need to build further and faster on the welcome recent progress in careers guidance; we need thriving apprenticeships that build a ladder all the way up to degree apprenticeships; we need a demand-led system—as the noble Baroness advocated—and employers who encourage work placements and spell out what they want in detail at a level of specificity; and, above all, across parties we will need to give this consistent priority over the decade that the noble Baroness referred to. Let us now choose to lead the world in skills, employability and vocational education. That is the road to 21st-century prosperity. It will take a decade, but we can start today.
My Lords, I add my thanks to the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, for securing today’s debate. I will focus on an area too often treated as niche, but which I believe tests our whole approach to skills, vocational training and further and higher education. I am talking of the training pipeline for professional dance.
My researcher, Emilia Braddon, as part of the King’s College London parliamentary internship programme helped produce our report called “Creating the Next Billy Elliot”. It found that specialist dance training, though an internationally renowned area, is under real threat from funding pressures, policy blind spots and declining access. Dance and the performing arts contribute over £11 billion in gross value added to our economy, yet the pipeline behind that contribution—the music and dance scheme and the centres for advanced training—face rising costs, no real-terms funding increase, one-year cycles that leave families unable to plan and lost outreach grants that once found the talent in the deprived and disadvantaged communities that we are focused on in today’s debate.
Talent is, sadly, not enough. Geography matters. A child in Wakefield or Bradford can reach training in Leeds; a child of equal talent in Bournemouth without the means to travel to London often cannot. Nor is this an England-only regional issue. The Royal Conservatoire of Scotland offers training of genuine international standing, but a child in the highlands faces the same barriers as one in Cumbria. Because skills policy is devolved, our funding schemes and our data on where the gaps lie stop dead at the border. I would therefore advocate a pan-UK mapping exercise and far greater cross-Administration co-operation.
Underpinning everything is funding stability. It is disappointing that the Government have yet to confirm funding beyond the current 2026-27 cycle when MDS schools are auditioning for 2027-28 right now. Funding for outreach must be treated as infrastructure, not as an optional extra, or the pipeline will never reach the children who need it most.
My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lady Morgan, who is a good friend, for introducing this debate and the noble Lord, Lord Baker, also a good friend, for his customary eloquent insights.
The Milburn review is a shocking read. If the million NEETs were to form a city, it would be the third-largest in the UK—larger than Leeds, Glasgow or Cardiff—costing the taxpayer and the economy, as already mentioned, £125 billion a year. Yet Milburn found that 84% of NEETs want to be in a job, education or training and are held back by low expectations and confusing routes into the adult world. I spoke recently at a school in Kent about the amazing opportunities available to people with STEM qualifications. Two girls came up to me and asked, “Do you really think we could be engineers?”. “Of course”, I said, “Why not?”. “My dad says it’s a boy’s job. He says I should do hairdressing”, came the reply.
I wish to advocate for girls like her who are disadvantaged just by being female. Their aspirations are not being guided towards the STEM skills critically needed—a million more workers by 2030 in AI, robotics, cyber, energy, engineering, health and more. The Royal Academy of Engineering—I declare an interest as a former director—reports that only 17% of its STEM taskforce are female. Women and girls make up half of apprenticeships, but only 14% complete them; 78% of girls aged 11 to 17 express an interest in tech, but only half pursue it. The newly introduced T-levels have only a 12% female take-up. Yet, without welcoming more girls, there is no hope of creating the workforce of the future. Their potential has barely been tapped.
The Royal Academy has called for engagement from primary school on, with STEM-related activities featuring female role models, a modernised curriculum, early high-quality careers advice and clearer routes into work. Girls need to know about someone such as Clare Grey, developing advanced batteries on the Ox-Cam growth corridor, one of the world’s leading science and innovation clusters which is generating £143 billion for the economy every year. I welcome the Prime Minister’s recent announcement on tailored access for children aged 14 to technical skills in every postcode, building on local opportunities and mobilising mayors, local leaders, employers and educators. Young people have not given up on work, and we must not give up on them. I know all noble Lords will do our work to support them.
My Lords, I am very grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, for introducing this debate and for the way in which she presented it. I sense, as the noble Lord, Lord Barber, said, that this could be a time when we might make the changes that we have failed to make over the last half a century or more. Despite our pride in what is a good and improving school system in this country, we have a record of relative failure on vocational routes.
The noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, referred to the White WorkingClass Educational Outcomes report, on which we both served. To be honest, for all my years in education, I was genuinely surprised and frightened by the level of disengagement there is between people living in these communities and what the education and school system is delivering for them at the moment.
Vocational education, which is the type of route to a better life that these communities particularly value, delivers poorer outcomes and poorer opportunities for people from these communities than it does for many people from more affluent ones. Instinctively, we all know that, if you begin to look at the good apprenticeships that we now have, they are not being accessed by people from white working-class communities. Fewer people from deprived backgrounds are taking the degree apprenticeship route than are attending Russell group universities or the university sector in general. This is not about saying, “That’s a route that serves people from this community”, but it is about offering real choice. While the curriculum is less rigorous, the qualifications are less coherent and the routes to employment are less clear, this route will not serve either the people in deprived communities or the nation and the economy in the way that we need it to.
I welcome the Government’s announcements so far in this field, but adding technical education to one basket in 14 to 16 education is not going to cut it. I worry that our thinking is limited by worry about our past failures. Very often when I start a conversation on vocational routes, the first thing anyone says is, “We can’t go back to splitting people into sheep and goats”. Of course we cannot. No one wants that now. A knowledge-based curriculum is there for everyone, but we should not let our past failures blind us to the need to get this right—and we should believe in our own ability to do so.
12:39 pm
20 of 65 shown
That brings me to the second principle, and I want to be blunt: no vocational offer can compensate for weak literacy and numeracy. Alun Francis, chair of the Social Mobility Commission, makes the point sharply. FE colleges already have many young people whose general education has been poor, large numbers are resitting English and maths, and a quarter of 19 year-olds still have limited literacy and numeracy. For most of that group, a technical course will not solve the problem. For those with very low grades, endless resitting helps with neither motivation nor prospects. The Government are right to identify that those with very low grades need another way to develop literacy and numeracy. Those who have a good chance of getting the grades should try again: Mr Milburn’s review identifies English and maths at grade 4 as one of the best defences a young person has against becoming NEET.
The answer at key stage 4 is not straightforward and it needs work. We need sustained investment in subject expertise, curriculum leadership and instructional coaching in English and maths in particular. In my view, the full range of GCSEs should remain but not be the only option for all students. There needs to be a new focus on work-readiness skills, and that means that accountability measures will need change.
Thirdly, and most importantly for this debate today, we must not build two separate systems. The idea that we should sort children at 14 or 16 into the academic and the practical is recurring, simplistic and wrong. Academic and technical learning are not alternatives; they are complementary and, increasingly, people need both. Technical jobs require cognitive as well as practical skills. We all begin with a general education and many then move into vocational training. What differs is the stage at which the transition happens: a solicitor after a degree, a construction craft apprentice at 16, a higher apprentice in cyber security at 18, and so on. The danger comes when we conflate technical learning with a solution for disengaged pupils. Britain has done this repeatedly, and each time we have reduced the cognitive content and lowered the bar. NVQs separated competence from knowledge and flattered league tables. Too often, the 16 year-olds who took them were not ready for work and could not progress. It was not fair on the students, so let us remember that lesson.
There is also a delivery question that we tend to duck. We know that health and social care cannot be taught out of a textbook by a biology teacher. Serious technical learning needs teachers with industry expertise, employers involved in curriculum design and delivery, and environments that simulate the workplace. The Wolf review’s answer, that colleges should deliver options for 14 to 16 year-olds alongside GCSEs, probably remains the right one, and strategic authorities or mayors could now broker it across groups of schools. But the offer must be high quality, delivered by specialists and targeted at those who want it—not aimed primarily at disengaged pupils and not there to replace academic progress.
The fourth point is the scale of the failure. Teach First defines persistently disadvantaged pupils as those on free school meals for at least 80% of their education. Its research shows that these students are three times more likely to disappear than their better-off peers. It suggests that the Government should formally define persistent disadvantage, track these pupils’ destinations and name them in the risk-of-NEET guidance. Those are modest asks, and I hope that the Minister will look at them. This matters because of where these young people end up. Alan Milburn’s interim review found more than one million 16 to 24 year-olds not in education, employment or training, at an annual cost to the country of £125 billion—more than we spend on education. How crazy is that?
Further education colleges should be local engines of progression, and they need serious investment in staff, facilities and long-term employer partnerships to become them. Their funding was decimated post 2010, and the 16-19 review of funding for schools and colleges that will happen in the next couple of years is important. The 16-19 cohort is the poor relation in the system. FE colleges enjoy popular support in many communities, more than any other part of the post-16 system, so there is much to build on, but they too need to change. Too much provision is still shaped by what colleges have historically taught and by what recruits students, rather than by what local employers need.
I have found alternatives and want to talk briefly about Wigan. The college there has aligned itself deliberately with the local care sector—one of the borough’s largest employers, which is facing chronic recruitment pressure. Working hand in hand with the local authority, it has built a specialist centre for health and social care. It runs a traineeship, developed with the council, which takes local 16 to 24 year-olds and combines work experience, on-the-job training and recognised qualifications—a direct pipeline into care careers. On campus, it has created a simulated home environment where students train on the care technology and adaptations that they will use at work. Practitioners from the sector teach alongside college staff. Young people leave with a job to go to, employers get the workforce they cannot otherwise find and the public purse spends less on vacancies, agency staff and unemployment.
Now imagine that repeated properly: colleges in coastal towns building provision around ports, energy and engineering, colleges in manufacturing areas co-designing courses with the funds on their doorstep, colleges everywhere working with the NHS, councils and care providers, which are so often the largest employers in exactly the towns we are talking about. That is the bargain. Employers, public and private, shape what colleges teach. Colleges give employers a reason to invest, to offer placements and to hire locally.
On apprenticeships, let us be straightforward here: the system is not working. We need a massive expansion of opportunity in poorer communities. There has been a repeated, systemic failure to deliver the scale that successive Governments have promised. Indeed, apprenticeship starts for 16 year-olds have fallen by 40%. Apprenticeships are skewed to older people and affluent areas. In areas dominated by smaller employers, there are simply fewer to be had overall, and the levy bureaucracy favours large organisations in urban economies. It must be made far easier for small and medium-sized employers to take on apprentices: simplify levy transfers, cut the admin burden, provide funding certainty and give combined authorities the money and the responsibility to broker locally, and deal with the mundane barriers that decide real lives. Do not let a bus fare be the reason a young person turns down a college place.
The Government have rightly made economic growth their central mission, but we cannot complain of labour shortages, low growth and rising welfare bills while the talent of over a million young people goes to waste. As our population ages, we will depend ever more heavily on this generation to work, pay taxes and sustain our public services. Perhaps for the first time in two centuries, ill health among the young is now actually shrinking the labour supply. What I have described is not a welfare programme; it is supply-side economics for the places growth has forgotten. Wigan’s answer to its care workforce shortage costs far less than the price of continuing to fail, and there is a version of it waiting to be built around the country.
Let me be clear: this is not an argument against university. Higher education remains and must remain an important destination for academically able young people, whatever their background. The scandal is that too few from poor communities get there. Some are deterred not by lack of ability but by fear of debt. This means looking again at maintenance and living cost support alongside bursaries, scholarships, and employer co-investment. The failure is twofold: too few young people from these communities who could thrive at university are getting there, and too few of those for whom university is not the right route have a high-quality alternative worth choosing. Higher education needs to change too: more modular, commuter-based and work-integrated study, stronger level 4 and 5 pathways, and employer-backed degrees tied to local industries. Young people should not feel that accessing high-quality higher education is possible only by leaving home or taking on excessive financial burdens.
In particular, I ask the Minister whether the Government will respond to the inquiry’s report and to the Milburn review together, because they are, in essence, two halves of one problem. Will they act on the specific proposals to open apprenticeships to smaller employers, and to reform accountability so that sustained progression into apprenticeships and skilled work counts equally alongside progression to university? Will they back further education with both the investment and the expectation of appropriate delivery—it has to be a deal—so that more colleges are tied into the needs of local economies? Crucially, will the Government commit to the long haul? Closing this gap is the work of a decade, not a Parliament.
I end these comments not in despair but with ambition. I think we know what is needed. We also know that it needs real rigour to get the right policies and the delivery. What is needed now is the collective will to do it. I beg to move.
Quite apart from that, I am glad to say that Andy Burnham is very keen on UTCs and sleeves, because he asked us two or three years to deliver the MBacc. A sleeve will start in a Manchester school next year, providing practical and technical education between the ages of 14 to 18. We therefore have the support of rather a key figure in this area, but we need many more.
The thing about our schools is that a good technical education needs workshops as well as classrooms; some have to be converted. It needs machines such as milling machines, lathes, laser cutters, metrology mechanics, and CAD and CAM software. It also needs teachers capable of teaching those subjects to the children; that is, people who have had experience in business. It also needs the active support of local companies so that they can take their youngsters into their workshops, into their factories, for practical experience. I suppose that the Government will wait for Mr Milburn on technical education, but I hope that when we hear of their policy, they will recognise that they have a model for expansion, which is the UTC sleeve. That is the real heart of it.
I will give one small piece of advice to the Minister. I hope that when Mr Milburn has replied and the Government develop the policy and announce it, they will not just start technical education at the age of 16. That is too late; it should start at 14. We are the only country in Europe that does not teach its children below 16 practical and technical education. That is one reason why youth unemployment in Germany is exactly half of ours.
This is an important debate; I thank the noble Baroness again for raising it—it is excellent. I hope the Government will come forward with proposals as soon as possible. The thing about the sleeve is that it can be done instantly and quickly. I offer one last piece of advice to the Minister: whatever she comes up with in terms of the policy, it should not start at 16. We must start at 14. We are the only country that does not teach children below 16 a technical education. We are on the cusp of something very important and very exciting, and this will help the Government because it will stimulate economic growth.
The noble Baroness said quite a lot and referred to basic skills, such as English and maths—and the Minister will probably have written that into her response to me. I am dyslexic. I am president of the British Dyslexia Association. I still would not pass a written exam in English. You struggle with maths because it is simply a different language, and the language-processing bits in the brain do not pick it up as fast. The papering over of the cracks of short-term memory is still there, so you will always have these problems—and that is just one group. Anybody who struggles with special educational needs, or who comes from a home that simply does not take them seriously, is always going to struggle with these skills. We have to find better ways forward. I congratulate the Government, and indeed the previous Government, on emphasising the level 2 lower entrance requirements to go on and train. If we are to do this, we must stop people being isolated and branded failures so early. The new SEN paper may well start to address this but, once again, it is the work of a decade.
I see that the Clock is against me. Openers used to get a wee bit longer, but there we are. When the Minister comes to respond, I hope she will emphasise how we are stopping people being branded failures and making sure that schools and the education sector are given a reward for keeping these people in school and not punished when it comes to league tables.
I am impressed by the Government’s ambition in introducing work experience placements for young people long out of work—but, as it stands, these placements will reach fewer than one in 10 of the roughly 948,000 young people not in education, employment or training. Will the Government consider adding a supported volunteering strand, delivered through the volunteering community and faith sector, to their skills, vocational training, FE and HE strategy? In so doing, I believe the Government could help thousands more escape the experience trap, realise their potential and help society benefit from their gifts.
Finally, strengthening regional growth in all postcodes across the UK requires genuine four nations co-operation. Westminster, Holyrood, the Senedd and Stormont need to share data, best practice and—where it makes sense—co-funding routes. None of this is about one art form or one sector, region or nation. It is about whether a talented child, wherever they are born, has a fair, funded and stable route to vocational success.
I have never quite bought into the phrase, “You can’t be what you can’t see”. I never use it. I do not like it. It underestimates the vision, imagination and determination of young people to be what they want to be. But I am sure that those young people cannot achieve what they believe and dream they can if they cannot see a clear route as to how to get there. That is the challenge that we face now. I very much hope that the Minister will build on the work she has already done in delivering it.