My Lords, it is probably quite appropriate that we are going to discuss this immediately after we have heard several comments about us being a self-governing House, because it enters into this as well.
I start by thanking those members of the committee who gave up so much time to put in a great deal of effort to try to get a consensus on this matter. I also thank the staff we had, who worked very diligently—Judith Brooke, Rachel Borrell and Ellie Hassan—because there was an awful lot of work involved in the production of the report. I must also thank the noble Baroness the Leader of the House for organising an early debate, because it is important that we get the feeling of the House as a whole.
I remind the House of the starting point for the discussion that we are about to have. In the last Labour Party manifesto, the government manifesto, there was a commitment to introduce retirement and participation requirements for the House of Lords, and for all Peers to retire at the age of 80 at the time of the next election, whenever that election came along. That was a significant commitment that was paired with other aspects of reform to this House, some of which have taken place.
When we were established, many people immediately got in touch with the committee about some of the wider issues of House of Lords reform, but I emphasise that the committee’s remit was tight and specific, and rightly so. We were charged with considering and making recommendations on a retirement age and a participation requirement, and the impact that any such requirements might have on the size, membership and functioning of the House. We were also given the opportunity to consider transition arrangements and what arrangements might be made for implementation.
Once established, we decided very early on that we wanted to involve as many people as possible in the decision-making process, so we embarked on a very important consultation exercise. We issued an invitation for written evidence to be submitted, we held drop-in sessions and many individual Members collared others of us at different times in different corridors. We welcomed all that and I reckon that probably 25% to 30% of active Members took part in that consultation process.
My Lords, it might be helpful for me to intervene at this point and set out the position of the Official Opposition, although I assure the House that I will listen carefully and weigh every contribution, including those from the many who may disagree with me. First and foremost, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton, for introducing this important debate in such a typically thoughtful fashion. Even if I do not agree, I thank her and all the members of her committee for their careful work and balanced report. Incidentally, I agree with the recommendation on leave of absence and declaration of interests; I hope that will be taken forward.
I declare an interest: like the noble Baroness, I will be expelled under these proposals—in my case, on 8 July 2033. Let us get the language right: “mandatory retirement” for sitting Members means expulsion. I confess that I find that prospect painful. No doubt like others here, I ask: what have I done wrong? Appendix 5 of the report tells me that up to 367 Peers could be expelled from the House over the next seven and three quarter years. In addition to expulsion on grounds of age, 94 Peers currently sitting would have failed the proposed 20% threshold. Taken together, that is a monster cull, on top of dozens of Peers recently expelled by this Government.
Of course, I concede that, as the report says, the figures may well be significantly lower. Some of us lined up for the sack may die and some may retire voluntarily. After all, as the noble Baroness said, the average retirement age is 82. Eighty-two? Eighty? What problem are we trying to solve in inflicting such a purge on the House?
Unlike the Select Committee, I am not constrained by terms of reference, so I will address some wider questions and ask: why are we here? Some have said it is to reduce our numbers. I have never really bought that argument, as noble Lords know. The largest Division this year had 475 votes. Such numbers are not an adequate reason for a mass cull of nearly half the House, potentially. What guarantee is there that prime ministerial patronage would not be used to fill the empty spaces with more compliant Members than those forced out?
My Lords, I strongly support the report, and I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton, not only on her introduction to it but on her excellent chairing of our Select Committee, which it was a great privilege to sit on. Like her, I thank the committee staff, whose professionalism and good humour aided us on that path. As the noble Lord, Lord True, said, the backdrop to this report and the debate today is the Government’s manifesto commitment to introduce a requirement for participation and a retirement age. We are a self-governing House, and the report is a workable and fair way for us to take charge of our own future.
On proposing a retirement age of 80, we would allow Members to make a significant and meaningful contribution to the work of this House over a good number of years, but the report recognises that all organisations benefit from the refreshment and new perspectives of new members. That is important. Equally, the report sets out a tapered exit for a significant number of existing Members, which will avoid a cliff edge and the problems that would cause for the workings of the House and the good work that we know we do.
On participation, I do not think that there is anyone in this House this afternoon who thinks that the conferral of a peerage is merely a gilded bauble; it is a commitment to contribute. That is what our requirements in this report on participation seek. However, that is balanced against the very real fact that the reason why we want to listen to many noble Lords’ contributions is the expertise that they bring from their outside professions. The fact that they have those outside professions, perspectives and experiences means they cannot always be with us. Therefore, we have to be very careful, particularly with the Cross Benches, to set a participation requirement that would not exclude the people whom we most want to hear from on particular debates and issues where they have expertise that the House needs to hear. To my mind, that is extremely important and valuable. We want people who can participate, but we also want people who recognise that there is a time when their voices are the most important ones that we need to be hearing.
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Parminter. I will not repeat what she said, except to say how well chaired we were as a committee and to give my congratulations to the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton. I thank Judith Brooke and her team, who supported us extremely well. I also thank my fellow committee members. We had four members from the Official Opposition, but they did not all think the same way. We all came with different starting points and foci as to how to deal with this issue.
Myself and many others would have liked broader terms of reference. We would have been interested in looking at—I will come to this later—how people get into this House as well as how people leave it, but we did our best. We have provided a nuance to the proposals in the manifesto that is respectful of Members of this House and that gives people the opportunity, as the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor, said, from whenever we decide this issue until July 2029 to make their own plans for the future.
The noble Lord, Lord True, talked in dramatic language of expulsion. Most of us have worked in organisations at some point in our life where our contract came to an end and there was provision for retirement. It did not strike us that there was some terrible sword of Damocles over our ability to go on ad infinitum, give our wisdom and take up precious space on the Benches in this House. The language is slightly hysterical, because the concept of retirement, though it should be later in this House for good reason and should not be destructive of the knowledge base and corporate memory that we have, is really not quite as revolutionary as to say that we have been bushwhacked by the Labour manifesto.
My Lords, I am grateful to the committee for its report and for the serious and thoughtful way in which it has approached the difficult question of the future size and composition of this House.
My right reverend friend the Bishop of Manchester, the Convenor of the Lords Spiritual, made a written submission to the committee on behalf of these Benches, but is unfortunately unable to be in his place today. The Lords spiritual have long supported reforms that strengthen the effectiveness and credibility of this House while safeguarding its distinctiveness from the other place in its expertise and culture. We therefore welcome the opportunity to consider proposals that seek to create a smaller and more sustainable House.
However, I know that he would wish me to highlight several concerns, particularly in relation to the recommendation of a mandatory retirement age. The report itself acknowledges one of the principal concerns raised in evidence: the potential loss of the experience, expertise and institutional memory of Members who continue to make valuable contributions well beyond the age of 80.
One notable example of the expertise on which the House relies is that of senior judges. I am not persuaded by the committee’s conclusion that, because committees in the other place function without senior judges, committees in this House can and therefore should do likewise. We should be cautious about assuming that arrangements appropriate to one House must automatically apply to the other. One of the principal strengths of the House of Lords is that it complements rather than mirrors the House of Commons, drawing on forms of experience and expertise that enrich parliamentary scrutiny, such as independent chairmanship and experience in interpreting the law. The contribution of senior judges to committee work exemplifies that distinction. Their role is not simply a matter of who occupies the chair; it reflects the independence, judgment and habits of scrutiny acquired through judicial office.
My Lords, I too congratulate my noble friend Lady Taylor on her skill, good humour and patience, not least with me, and I thank our fellow committee members. I actually found myself agreeing with the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde, who will speak after me today; I was quite astonished on those occasions and have reflected on them since. Either he was wrong or I was right—one of the two. When I joined the committee, I accepted the terms of reference and therefore the remit, and I will speak in support of that today.
The manifesto had two commitments in relation to the House of Lords. One was that there would be a rebalancing regionally of Members of the Lords across the regions and nations. Well, that went for a burton very quickly. The second was this ridiculous sentence, which was clearly discriminatory; I will come to that in a minute. As my noble friend said in opening the debate, the impact was to create a cliff edge of 257 Members going all at once. It was actually a greater number when we started our deliberations.
The person who wrote the manifesto pledge clearly did not understand that we do not have fixed-term Parliaments —briefly we did, but no longer. Perhaps the person, reflecting on their social democratic commitments, might have understood that discrimination applies not just to gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity or disability but also to age. I believe that the manifesto commitment was a proxy for incapacity. I say to the noble Lord, Lord True: if we do not wish to adopt the proposals in this report, we need to take that issue very seriously and find ways of dealing with it.
Things have changed over the years. Aficionados of PG Wodehouse will remember Lord Emsworth, the owner and overseer of Blandings Castle. This benign, endearing, dithering old fool was only 60. Now, as some of us come towards the age of 80, as the noble Lord, Lord True, has described, we like to think that we have our marbles. To paraphrase St Augustine, “I will retire, Lord, but not just yet”.
My Lords, I hugely enjoyed sitting on the committee with the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. In fact, as he pointed out, many of his views were a revelation to me; they are ones with which I wholeheartedly agree.
I am going to speak up in favour of older Members of this House remaining here. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton, and congratulate her on chairing the committee in the way she did, and I thank our excellent clerks.
Some of your Lordships may be wondering how I can square what I have just said about older Members of the House with support for this committee report. We had many discussions and we consulted widely in the House. We came up with the scheme outlined in the report. It has its flaws but it fulfils what was set out in our terms of reference. However—this is the point—at its heart lies a lacuna that we were unable to bridge; namely, what is the justification for this desire to expel so many Members of the House? You can look at the Labour Party’s manifesto—much has been made of that—but it provides no explanation either.
I therefore hope that when the Leader of the House winds up, she might spend just a couple of sentences answering the question: what problem was the Labour Party trying to solve in its manifesto? Was it the overall size of the House, perhaps? There are many different ways of dealing with the problem of the size of the House. Is it that older Members have lost cognitive ability to be able to continue in the House? There must be other ways of dealing with that. I therefore ask again: what is the Government’s motivation and objective? It would be very helpful to allow us to know; otherwise, there is this suspicion, which some people have mentioned, that the Government want to remove older Members of the House and replace them with new, younger supporters. That does not help us at all on numbers.
As the noble Baroness reminded us, paragraph 51 tells us that the average age of joining the House is 59, and the average age of retiring from the House is 82. I wonder to what extent there is a real problem if those who wish to leave already do so at the age of roughly 82.
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde, and I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton, for introducing her sensible report that introduces retiral. Speaking personally, I will do what is recommended in the report when my time comes to fulfil the retirement proposals.
However, today I do not want to speak about the report itself but about the consequences that it will have, particularly on the Cross Benches. As Professor Meg Russell said in the brief that she sent to us all, it will have uneven effects on different groups, and particularly on the Cross Benches.
With the help of Sam Anderson in the Convenor’s office, I have managed to get some figures to illustrate this. I am afraid that after the erudite speeches that your Lordships have just heard, mine will be a boring lot of figures—but, I hope, making an important point. I have used the figures in the report but I realise that they change all the time with new appointments, retirals and, occasionally, deaths. HOLAC appointments have been declining. Currently, among the Cross-Benchers, there are 53 HOLAC appointments, compared with 101 that are mainly prime ministerial appointments. I will come back to that later.
Paragraph 33 of the report states that at the end of the 2024-26 Session, there were 776 Members of the House in total, of whom 154 were Cross-Benchers—close to 20%, which the House has agreed ought to be the proportion of representation of the Cross-Benchers. If you look at the retirals as planned, in July 2029, of those over 85 and those who will become 85 that year, there will be 38 Cross-Benchers leaving the House out of a total of 135. That means that 30% of those who leave will be Cross-Benchers. That will reduce the number of Cross-Benchers to 116.
In 2030, when the 84 year-olds should leave, there will be 43 in total leaving, of whom 13 will be Cross-Benchers. Again, that is 30% of the total who will be leaving and will reduce the number of Cross-Benchers to 103. In 2031, when those aged 83 will be leaving, the total leaving will be 56. Of those 56, 17 will be Cross-Benchers. Again, that will be 30% of those leaving. That will, after three years, reduce the number of Cross-Benchers remaining to 86—down from 154. The total number in the House will then be 542. So the Cross-Benchers will be reduced to 16% of the total House. That is already a 4% reduction in Cross-Benchers.
5:04 pm
20 of 164 shown
Of course, we had a significant range of views and I shall come on to some of those later. All the submissions were carefully considered by every single member of that committee. It was quite a heavy workload for everyone. In the end, we managed to produce a unanimous report. I emphasise that to the House, because it is important to realise that people with very different starting points came to a consensus in the end.
What do our recommendations involve? First, I will talk about retirement, because that was the one issue that concerned many Members when they were thinking about our committee. I will say a few words by way of context. The average age of Members of this House is 71. The average age on appointment is 59. The average age of retirement in the last few years has been 82. It is worth keeping that is mind when we think about the conclusions we came to.
We modelled many options, with the help of our assistants. We looked at a whole range of options that had been presented to us by many colleagues in their submissions. The first question we had to ask was: what should we look at as an end date? It was very difficult, because we did not know when the next election would be, so we took the last possible sitting date of this House in this Parliament. This is why our modelling was based on July 2029. Some noble Lords may be surprised at that, but there is a logic there. There was no logic in taking any other date.
We must also remember that the figure we produced was for the maximum number of Peers affected at any one time. We are not saying that everybody has to stay until a certain time; we are saying that a Member can retire at whatever point they feel is appropriate, but there is a maximum cut-off.
If the Government’s proposal that all Peers older than 80 were to retire at the next election came into effect, and if that election were on the last possible date of July 2029, a maximum of 257 Peers would be required to leave by that date or at that time. As a committee, we agreed that such a number and such a cut-off point would be too severe and would have implications for the working of the House. Unintended consequences must always be considered.
We took the age of 80, which is what the Government have been proposing. We had suggestions from other Members. Some were against a retirement age altogether. Some suggested 75; others suggested 85. We looked at all the evidence and decided that it was probably appropriate to look at the age the Government were proposing, which is why our modelling was based on the age of 80.
We considered all those options, and we recommended that, by July 2029, all Peers over the age of 85 who had not already retired should do so, and that subsequently the maximum retirement age should reduce annually by one year. As I say, that is the maximum age of retirement. In Appendix 4 of this report, we set out exactly how the transition would work in detail, and there is an app available so that anybody who wants to know how they themselves are affected can be told. For the sake of transparency, in our report we included how this would affect each of the members of the committee, just to prove that there was no bias and that we were not looking after ourselves. For anybody who is interested, my date will be 2 July 2031. We thought this was fair and workable, and that it gave individuals a proper timescale for thinking about their futures. That is where we have landed so far as retirement is concerned.
We did consider the alternative of term limits. We received submissions that were in favour of fixed terms, and I have a degree of sympathy with that. People talked about terms ranging from 15 to 20 years; I think we probably all accepted positions on 10-year terms, but there was a range of opinion. Fixed terms would provide for the refreshment of the House; people would know where they were and there would be predictability. In the end, after discussing this in some detail, we decided that the disadvantages and the problems would be too much. There would be a difficulty in transition and significant cliff edges. There was the question of reappointment and the fact that, if people had that possibility, it might alter how they behaved in the House, depending on who was making the reappointment. We also looked at the question of younger Members, who might find it difficult to re-enter their profession after 10 or 15 years here. We thought there were too many disadvantages, so we rejected that idea.
I want to be clear that we do not equate participation with attendance; they are often different things for different people. We had various suggestions as to how we might measure participation. Some of these were very complex and complicated. Many mentioned the problem that it could lead to performative activity: that is, people speaking just for the sake of getting a tick in the box. In no way would that enhance the quality of our debates, so we are not suggesting a participation threshold.
However, the committee believe that there is a problem with the attendance provision. The 2014 Act states that if you attend once during the Session then you continue to be a Member of this House. That is not good for the reputation of the House and people who are Members should take this House seriously. Although we acknowledge and appreciated the expertise from appropriate outside interests, we thought that membership of this House should be taken seriously. The committee therefore recommended an attendance threshold of 20%, but over two Sessions, to allow people to adjust according to their own circumstances and with the provision of the kind of short-term leave of absence that my noble friend talked about earlier. I think that would be helpful for everyone.
I will mention a couple of other things that we touched on, although we did not go into great detail. We made a recommendation on leave of absence, because such Members are not bound by the provision relating to the register of interests in the Code of Conduct, despite the fact that they have clear access to Members of the House and to Ministers. It was not directly for us to deal with, but we wanted to highlight it because a very impressive case had been made to us that there was a problem here. We therefore wanted to highlight it so that the appropriate committee can look at this again.
I turn briefly to another point in our report. We suggested that Peers who retire and leave the House should become “Peers emeritus”, and that there should be an association for former Peers to keep in touch, be aware of what is going on, and have access to the Libraries under the new arrangements. I am struck that several people have already come to me, asked how we can arrange this and said that they are willing to take it on. I am very happy for them to take it on, but there is merit in following that through.
I am heartened by the response that I have had when talking to people—both groups and individuals. Some people have said that they now at least know how this will affect them; others have said this has made them think about what they should be doing, and how they should listen to their families and talk about their future. That has been very useful. We mention implementation in our report. We were told that a retirement age could be implemented by legislation very easily and quickly through a one-line amendment to the 2014 Act. As a committee, we decided that it would be preferable for the House to take control of this and introduce such a provision through a resolution of the House. That is an appropriate recommendation. I believe that change is coming and that it is better done by us than to us. I recommend the report.
If not numbers, is the reason party balance? There was an unacceptable and unequal balance between the two main parties in 2024, but that balance is now nearing equality. A difference of 14, and narrowing, between Labour and Conservatives does not justify a mass cull, and actually the group that would suffer most from the report’s proposals are the Cross-Benchers, who could lose half their number. We should be careful what we wish for.
No, as the noble Baroness said, the reason we are here is because the Labour manifesto bushwhacked the House with a draconian and, frankly, discriminatory and ageist proposal, and now we are threatened that, if hundreds of us do not go gently into that dark night, the Government will slam down a legislative guillotine. Really? Wherefore this mania to expel people from our House? Who is driving this? Sir Keir Starmer, who wrote the manifesto, is gone. Mr Burnham has said that his inspirations were the noble Lords, Lord Kinnock and Lord Blunkett, and the noble Baroness, Lady Beckett, all remarkable figures, much valued here. But, under these plans, the noble Baroness, Lady Beckett, and the noble Lord, Lord Kinnock, are booted out on 8 July 2029, and the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, on 6 June 2031. The sixth of June: it would be nice if that day could be remembered for another D than the departure of the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. Is this really the new Prime Minister’s wish, or is someone else driving all this? Can our Leader explain?
Two criteria are proposed for the cull: age and participation. First, Labour wants to expel hundreds of Peers simply because they are older. There are many over 80 who make extraordinary contributions to public life, here in this House and elsewhere. Can we imagine, on 21 April 2006, someone rapping on the late Queen’s door saying, “Happy birthday, Ma’am. You’ve had a good run, but today you’ve got to clear your desk—but you can come back for a cup of tea”? How much wisdom and leadership would this nation have lost? Is not the same true among us here? Is it wise to attack all those who can and do perform their duty here and not address the issue of capacity, of those perhaps no longer so able to act? Age or incapacity: which more risks our disrepute? Might cognitive tests be a better focus than the blunderbuss of an age bar? Can the Lord Privy Seal say whether this alternative is being considered?
This age bar will purge from our Parliament the voice and outlook of a major cohort of the British people: 7% of our adult population are over 80. After these measures, the numbers from that cohort in our Parliament will be barely 0.1%. Who then from the ranks of the elderly will speak in our Parliament for them? We should be cautious about silencing the leavening voice of experience.
Every noble Lord will judge this matter freely, but let me say a word as Leader of the Opposition. My party will not support the mass expulsion of sitting Members who are well capable of doing their job and are doing it well. We can discuss rules that may apply to new Members, but we think it wrong to quash the rights of all sitting Members over 80. If the Government seek to legislate, attempts may be made to amend a Bill to ensure that any age bar should apply for the future, not expel those valued colleagues now sitting here. This House has voted before for grandfather rights: the principle that workplace rights should not be taken from those who have them. It might well vote again for that very fair principle without overturning the idea of a future age limit.
My party has a constitutional problem with the central mechanism of the report and the precedent it would set. For the House of Lords to pass a resolution to tell people to go would mean that this House alone would seek to decide who its Members should be. It is not for the Government or a single House to decide who sits in Parliament; it is for Parliament. My noble friend the shadow Attorney-General will address the legal points. The report is correct at paragraph 84 that a resolution of this House cannot override the legal right under the 1958 Act to a writ. Some take comfort in paragraph 85, which concedes that Peers may simply say, “No”—I have heard much fruitier language—when their birthday comes, and will go on attending by virtue of the writ. This is hardly satisfactory. Most would no doubt comply, but some would not. Invidious divisions would arise.
There are reasons—perhaps 72 million reasons—why this is also a bad political precedent. Let us suppose Reform forms a Government. Prime ministerial patronage would allow a Reform leader, even in a minority Government, to do what he says he would: pack this House. His new Peers might also pass a resolution. They might say their party was elected to sweep away the establishment, so any Peer who had been in the House for more than five years should leave forthwith. No doubt many of us might refuse, as paragraph 85 says we could. The mother and father of constitutional crises would erupt between the two Houses. I submit that this House should be cautious about laying that precedent on the table. Away from such a looming example, what is to stop a future House passing a similar resolution excluding this or that category of Peer? These are murky waters, but to us the constitutional principle is clear. This House alone should not assert the right to choose who here should stay and who should go without the assent of Parliament as a whole.
On participation, I recognise that many wish to see action. The Select Committee rightly rejected the measure of performative speaking. It was sensitive to the truth inherent to a House of experts: some will come only when they have something worthwhile to say, and we will be glad to hear them when we do. As the report points out, there will be cases in which unforeseen illness or other commitments may make it hard for Peers to attend. We should not build intrusive mechanisms that probe sensitive personal circumstances.
There are other questions. On attendance, in a typical 150-day session it would cost £11,130 per Peer just for the daily allowance, simply to establish the threshold right to remain. Is the 20% threshold too high? Does the exclusion criterion favour those who live near London? Who precisely are the Peers who will be affected, and how many? The principle is wearable and, unlike retirement, legally enforceable, but it bears further reflection on the details, building on the committee’s excellent report.
To conclude, if we are to go forward, I submit that the outcome must meet four clear tests. Will it improve the ability of this House to hold Governments to account? Will it enrich the experience in this House? Will it enhance the independence of the House from recent or present Governments? Will it enable the House and its committees to do their revising work better? In my judgment, these proposals, however ingenious and constructive, would fail those tests. They gild the manifesto thorn bush but do not remove the thorns. Instead of plunging forward with haste, we should take time to think with honesty and humility across party lines about the far-reaching implications of an age bar for this House, its Members and the voice of the elderly in the councils of our nation.
This is an important report from the House. It was drawn up with cross-party membership and we came, as the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor, said, to a unanimous position of agreement. That is important. It is workable and fair, and I support it. My fear is that if this House is not seen to support these proposals, for whatever reason, that will be seen by those outside this House as self-interest. That will do nothing for the reputation of this House, which I know we all think of and worry about very deeply. If we do not accept these proposals, those who know less and care less about this House will shape our future.
I very much support the report that we brought together. I also support the approach of trying to do this ourselves, with the nuances and transition period that we have put in. The noble Lord, Lord True, is very optimistic about a one-clause Bill on this going through this House and the House of Commons like a dose of salts and making everything perfect. From my long 30-year experience in this House, and my short five years’ experience in the House of Commons, I very much doubt that it would be as simple as that.
There are two things on which I agree with the noble Lord, Lord True. One is that we have to be careful about the numbers of the Cross-Benchers. We have to preserve the view that 20% of the House should be Cross-Benchers and look at how that interacts with the age limit. The other thing that we have to look at, and on which I agree with him, is that the unconstrained prerogative of the Prime Minister to make as many appointments to this House as he wants is a dangerous weapon and the wrong place for us to be. It leads to the ratcheting up of numbers after every election. We could do that better and we should try to find a way to do that better.
The Ecclesiastical Committee, for example, benefits from the specialist expertise of judicial leadership, and that contribution helps to shape both the character and the quality of the committee’s deliberations. Indeed, the Ecclesiastical Committee has benefited from senior judicial chairs since its formation in 1919. Our current chair, the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, offers invaluable expertise on the interpretation of Church law and the measures passed by General Synod, along with her understanding of Church processes and structures. I know that these Benches and the committee are most grateful for her diligent contributions.
Introducing a mandatory retirement age within the House may significantly reduce the number of Members able to undertake such responsibilities. Their loss would therefore represent more than a procedural change; it would alter the nature of the scrutiny that such committees can provide. More broadly, if a significant cohort of Members were required to retire within a relatively short period, we would risk creating clusters of departures and arrivals that could alter the balance of expertise. Institutional memory could be lost more rapidly than it could be replenished.
It is worth acknowledging that Bishops retire earlier than any other Members of the House, perhaps explaining something of our youthful vigour. Members may have noticed that we have not benefited from a steady turnover of Bishops in recent months; rather, my right reverend friends have retired in batches. The loss of their experience and wisdom is acutely felt on these Benches and, I know, across the House. For these reasons, any reform must be introduced gradually and with great care. A phased approach is essential if continuity is to be maintained and the House’s scrutiny functions safeguarded. Equally, I wonder whether greater attention might first be given to encouraging the retirement of Members who rarely participate or attend, before measures are introduced that remove highly active and valuable contributors solely on the grounds of age.
This report also welcomes the consideration of how new Members of this House are appointed. Do they directly replace the expertise of their retired counterparts? We must be careful, in the interpretation of this report, not to ring-fence seats on this basis; the House must remain agile to respond to developing policy areas.
While I welcome the support and the debate that the report has initiated, I am not yet convinced that we have fully considered the implications for the functioning of the House, the operation of its committees or the preservation of the expertise on which Parliament depends.
The advantage of this report is that it provides some certainty. It provides a respect for those who have given their lives and commitment to the House. It allows the House to function appropriately and properly. It also avoids us clashing with the House of Commons. Those who remember Michael Foot and Enoch Powell scuppering previous massive proposals in relation to this House, or even the demise of the Clegg Bill just 15 years ago, will understand why we should try to avoid that like the plague.
I do not pretend that I am happy with where we are or that we have had to make these proposals. We should, however, retain some influence over our own future and our reputation, a bulwark against ill thought-through constitutional changes and against those who have no clue what we do or the implications for our constitution—or, by the way, for the operation of the House of Commons. Massive reform of this place requires a complete change in the way in which the House of Commons operates. Reform and modernisation —yes; dislocating our constitution—no.
This afternoon we should send a message to ourselves. Let us get our own act together. Let us make this House work better. Let us put aside the nonsense of discrimination, but let us understand that the House of Commons can deal a blow against us in time to come. It would inevitably mean the complete disruption of its own timetable and other priorities, but we have seen over recent years how even the stupidest suggestion can be adopted and pushed through by people who do not know better.
Ever since I have been here I have always been below the average age, and it may surprise some noble Lords to know that I still am. But I have always held the elder Members of the House in great admiration. I think of Lord Callaghan, the former Prime Minister, who died in his 90s. In the 1980s, he moved an amendment to a Conservative Bill, which preserved the right of Great Ormond Street Hospital to claim its royalties from JM Barrie’s “Peter Pan”. He had the authority, the political clout and the will to get it done. Under these proposals he would be turfed out, and we would miss him.
I look over at the other side and I see the noble Lord, Lord Dubs, and the noble Baroness, Lady Andrews, who are so important. Sadly, I do not see the noble Lord, Lord Reid, but he is an old friend of mine and I am a great admirer of his. All of them would be turfed out. Of course, none of them needs to stay; they can retire voluntarily, which I think is very much the way forward.
We lose so much knowledge, experience and wisdom by expelling these Peers. In addition, constitutionally, I am not sure it really stacks up. If we have to remove Peers from this House, surely we must reform the way for new entrants to come into this House; otherwise, it is just a free-for-all for the Government, whoever that Government are.
The committee’s report has produced some very useful statistics and commentary on the work of the House. This is extremely useful and revealing, and some good suggestions lie within it. However, having done the work, I suggest respectfully to the noble Baroness and to the Government that they should perhaps think again about what is proposed. We have a new Prime Minister with his own agenda, and we have plenty of work to be getting on with over the next few years. My advice to the Government is to park this in the slow lane. There is nothing to be gained from pressing on with it.
To look briefly at participation, 42 current Cross-Benchers will come into the category of attendance of less than 20%, of whom 21 will already have satisfied the retiral age, but that still leaves 21 who will not fulfil the requirements of participation. Therefore, the total number of Cross-Benchers leaving in three years—and I have not looked beyond that—is 89 of 154. After three years, if no more appointments are made, the Cross-Benchers will therefore be 65 in number, which would be 12% of the total of 542 in the House.
If you look at the appointments, 53 current Cross-Benchers were appointed by HOLAC. As I mentioned, prime ministerial appointments and some others, who are hereditaries, total 101. Since 2014, the prime ministerial appointments have been twice the number of HOLAC appointments.
The message, therefore, is clear. Unless this is taken into account, within three years, not six or seven years, the cohort of Cross-Benchers will be reduced to less than half the number that we have now, considerably less, and they will not be HOLAC appointments. Two things need to be addressed: numbers of Cross-Benchers need to be appointed, starting now, if people are going to start leaving in 2029, which will be significant numbers; and the number appointed by HOLAC needs to change compared with the prime ministerial appointments. That is my point: the message is about the figures that need to be addressed.