My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 59 and 67 in my name. Amendment 67 requires publication of a plan for the implementation of registration without application, and Amendment 59 requires two government databases to be in use for such registration ahead of a 2029 general election.
I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Pack, and the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, for their support, and now to the noble Lord, Lord Rennard. I very much welcome the Government’s commitment to improving voter registration, which chimes with public opinion as, according to the Electoral Reform Society, a YouGov poll found that four-fifths of the electorate support automatic registration, almost half strongly so.
As the Explanatory Notes to the Bill note, in 2023, the Electoral Commission reported that an estimated 7 million to 8 million eligible citizens were either incorrectly registered or not registered at all. The IPPR has pointed out that young people, renters, working-class and minority ethnic citizens are more likely to be unregistered and that electoral turnout is shrinking, particularly among younger, lower income and renter populations. Registration is thus crucial to achieving greater political equality, a point emphasised also by Generation Rent.
We compare badly with other countries as, in most liberal democracies, forms of automatic or assisted voter registration are the norm. Research in 159 countries by the Electoral Integrity Project at the University of East Anglia shows that it has led to more accurate and complete electoral registration. The project also found that at the 2024 general election, four-fifths of poll workers turned away citizens because they were not registered. Although it was usually only a handful of people, a few workers reported turning away over 100.
The UEA academics, together with Generation Rent and Unlock Democracy, criticized the absence of any timetable for the introduction of automatic registration. This is what Amendment 67, with the assistance of Unlock Democracy, would supply through the introduction of a clear implementation plan, while Amendment 59 helps to inject an element of urgency. The amendments would help to meet the aspiration of the Electoral Commission, which, in emphasising the importance of complete and accurate registers to democratic participation, has urged
“the Government to work quickly to introduce automated systems to enable voters to be added to UK parliamentary electoral registers … in time for the next general election.”
Amendment 59 takes up its suggestion that this could be built on existing services, such as applying for a passport, updating a driving licence or receiving a national insurance number at the age of 16, which has been referred to earlier.
The Government’s election strategy, published in July 2025, made it clear that they were planning to deliver significant voter registration improvements, including registration without application, in this Parliament, yet the briefing on this year’s King’s Speech suggested that implementation during this Parliament is now unlikely. Where is the sense of urgency, when as many as 7 million to 8 million of our fellow citizens could remain excluded from full democratic engagement without automatic registration? These amendments would help to inject it by ensuring a suitably ambitious implementation plan.
My Lords, I agree with the point my noble friend makes about urgency, but I rise very briefly to support Amendment 52, to which I have added my name. It is virtually the same as an amendment I moved to the Higher Education and Research Bill, as the noble Lord, Lord Rennard, said, in 2017. At the time, my amendment was adopted at Report. I then had negotiations with the Government and I agreed to a compromise, which was rather weaker than my original amendment. The compromise was to introduce guidance to ensure that electoral officers were encouraged to share data with universities, so that students could easily be registered, thus maximising the number of young people voting and ensuring that students could vote when an election took place during term time.
At some universities, students are semi-automatically registered when they register at university, but it is certainly not happening at every university. It should be mandatory at every university, hence my support for this amendment. I have one question for my noble friend the Minister. When automatic registration comes in, will a student automatically be registered both at their home and at their university? They have the option to vote in either and it is important that they are registered in both places as soon as possible.
My Lords, my Amendment 47 seeks safeguards that would require the verification of nationality and immigration status before an individual is automatically added to the electoral register.
I fully recognise and uphold the importance of ensuring that every person who is legally entitled to vote should have the uninterrupted opportunity to register and to participate fully in our democratic process. That is a fundamental right and has long distinguished us internationally. There is an equally important principle, however, which I fear risks being overlooked in this Bill—that only those who are legally entitled to vote should be entered on to the electoral register in the first place.
I fear that, left unamended, this part of the Bill will weaken the integrity of elections. Clause 17 introduces a significant change to our electoral arrangements. It would place a duty on electoral registration officers to register individuals automatically where certain conditions are met without those individuals having to make an application to register themselves. I recognise that there could be a potential administrative benefit in this, but it is for your Lordships to ask whether the safeguards accompanying this fundamental change are robust enough, especially on establishing nationality and immigration status.
In presenting Clause 17, the Government are attempting to allow for the modernisation of the system. I welcome that, but I caution that modernisation must never come at the expense of electoral integrity and that operational convenience must never take precedence over establishing voter eligibility. Therefore, through this amendment, I am seeking to introduce an additional safeguard that will require an electoral registration officer to positively verify that the person satisfies the relevant nationality requirements and, where applicable, the necessary immigration status before being registered.
8:30 pm
I put it to your Lordships that these are not constitutional niceties. These are the questions that go to the very heart of public confidence in our electoral system. We must remember that confidence in our elections depends on ensuring not just that legitimate voters are included but that the rules governing eligibility are properly and consistently enforced. The right to vote is fundamental in our democracy and it is too important to be established by assumption. If the Government are determined to automate registration then they will also be determined to guarantee the integrity of the process. I hope therefore that the Minister will recognise the importance of this distinction and give consideration to the safeguard that I have proposed.
My Lords, the motivation of the noble Lord, Lord Udny-Lister, is very important; it relates also to the earlier comments by the noble Lord, Lord Jackson, on Amendment 51 about ensuring that eligibility is strictly adhered to. There can be nothing more destructive of democratic trust than believing that anyone is playing fast and loose with who is allowed to vote in an election. We have just sat through an incredibly complicated Statement about the various degrees of the new immigration status. That will have to be taken into account in terms of eligibility and we have to be confident that the system can cope with it.
In that spirit, I thought that the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, did us a real a favour earlier when he talked specifically about the nuts and bolts of how we deal with the fact that children will now be voting and they will not necessarily have at their fingertips the usual adult forms of ID, as he illustrated rather wittily and very well. I was rather disappointed that the noble Lord, Lord Rennard, was so cynical that he saw these comments as somehow partisan. In fact, I thought that cynicism was itself rather partisan rather than anything else. It is really important, if you are going to extend the franchise in the way that we have been discussing, that you ensure that the franchise is strictly and absolutely foolproof and safe. One of the things that the noble Lord, Lord Rennard, said was that surely we want as many people to vote as possible. In that sense, you could just carry on expanding the franchise ever younger, or you could also say that anybody who happens to be wandering in can have—
I was absolutely crystal-clear that I meant all those people legally entitled to vote; “legally entitled” is very important and a part of the principle of everything I have argued for.
Clarification understood. Therefore, I ask the noble Lord to consider that the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, was trying to ensure that people who were entitled to vote were checked up on. The accusation was that he was somehow trying to limit the franchise and I was defending him in relation to that point.
I want to ask the Minister about something that was in a government amendment in an earlier group—we kind of run out of time but it relates to this—which is that registration officers will now have to obtain information, or will be given the right to obtain information, about 14 and 15 year-olds throughout the land and to retain that information for use when inviting them to then register to vote. I thought the point about any Government’s history—I am not making a sectarian point—of looking after data and keeping it safe was a point worth noting, especially if children’s data has been gathered up.
On registration officers collecting data, could the Minister say whether there will be any consideration of the suggestion from the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, about using national insurance numbers? I thought that was a really good suggestion, but I am really asking the Government whether they are open to detailed discussions on the nuts and bolts of how we are going to make this work in relation to both immigration status and the expanded franchise for 16 year-olds. Will there be an opportunity or are there plans to ensure that this is watertight?
To reiterate, if people believe that elections are happening that are not safe, with people being able to vote who have not been strictly checked on or are not registered, then it will undermine democracy. I know that that is the very opposite of what the Government aim.
My Lords, I will be very brief. I have signed three amendments in this group—Amendments 52, 59 and 67—that all address the issue of the “missing millions”. This phrase has been used multiple times in this debate; it is a real scar on our polity and a reflection of inequality in our society and in access to participation in the democratic process.
Very briefly on Amendment 52, I commend the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, for her previous work in this area. It is really time to see this finally nailed on, as this amendment would.
I will focus particularly on the two amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Lister. We suffer a great deal of distrust in our politics that comes from us having seen a great number of successive Governments’ Ministers saying, “Look, I’ve pulled a lever”, but everyone knew that that lever was not attached to anything. Promises were made and not delivered. Just two cases that particularly come to my mind are sustainable urban drainage systems, which were promised in planning but have still not been delivered; and the promise to exclude at least illegal deforestation from the supply chain has, again, still not been delivered.
We need to see the Government not just making promises but setting out a reasonable timeframe for delivery. As the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, said, Wales is showing that this can be done. That was an interesting cross-reference to our earlier debate on the ways in which the devolved nations can be a real model from which England can learn. It can save itself a great deal of work and effort by seeing what works and just copying it.
My Lords, I have tabled a clause stand part notice on Clause 17 to try to understand the pros and cons of automatic voter enrolment. We had 48.2 million electors at the last election. About 3 million people registered in the month before the election happened, which is about 7% or about 4,500 per constituency, on average, but I am sure it differed. Speaking candidly, that included the person who is now the MP for Suffolk Coastal, who defeated me. They managed to declare themselves as resident in that constituency before they were on the electoral roll. So there is a point here about the real authenticity of the people who are registering, which is where I come to the pros and cons.
There is a lot to be said for not having a huge rush of people registering at the last moment, but there is also something about getting it right. I am conscious that the pilots of the automatic process in Wales saw an increase of between 2% and 8%. Admittedly, only a handful of parts of Wales were covered but, basically, 14,500 people were added through the automatic process and there was a lot of manual checking. I do not know the cost of that, and the Electoral Commission said that it would need to be evaluated based on that cost, but it is worth while trying to get a sense of what happens in a regular process around the country where people have second homes. A lot of second home owners get turned down if they apply in the normal way but not based on their principal residences. I will discuss students and children at boarding school in a different set of amendments, so will not get into the detail on this right now.
My Lords, I shall follow on from my noble friend’s comments and pick up the question that the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, referred to earlier about double, if not treble, registration. The noble Baroness said that she hoped that all universities and academic centres will ensure that they have maximum registration of people resident in that town or city as voters. However, those people will have a home residence as well. Therefore, one is inflating the electoral roll in university cities to the disadvantage of those communities in other parts of the country that do not have university cities nearby.
The noble Lord, Lord Rennard, referred to boundary reviews and political advantage. I must admit that I enormously admire his comments about parliamentary boundaries in these circumstances. The places with high levels of student registration that will benefit under automatic registration are the big cities—the Londons, the Manchesters, the Birminghams. As he explained to his Lib Dem colleagues, come the next boundary review, there will be fewer constituencies in Somerset, Wiltshire, Dorset and other similar counties, such as Gloucestershire, a fair number of which, much to my chagrin, currently have rather large numbers of Liberal Democrat MPs.
I make the point quite seriously that, if one is going to include all those people who register for a second residence, one will be expanding the electoral rolls dramatically in London, Manchester and Birmingham to the disadvantage of the shire counties. I do not think that is an appropriate route to go down. There may be solutions where people register at their first home and their second residence is not included for, for example, parliamentary boundary revision, but we cannot have a position whereby large numbers of people are registered to the disadvantage of resident communities in neighbouring shire counties.
I make these comments on the basis that I have heard from a number of people, particularly the Liberal Democrats, that they want free and fair elections. Free elections are that people should be allowed to register to vote themselves—encouraged, yes, but they should have the freedom not to do so. The Bill goes through at inordinate length, saying, “Oh well, we’ll register everybody, and if you don’t want to be on the electoral roll you can deregister”. However, the process involved is pretty tortuous, and large numbers of people genuinely want to hide where they are for a whole series of reasons; I take, for example, abused women as a case in point. They are going to be on the electoral roll, and it will not be a case of, “We will take you off immediately”, because people will not know that they are on until they are notified that they are on.
My noble friend has correctly highlighted how the process actually works if you go on the Government’s website, and so many of the district councils or other local councils which are registration authorities have their own skin in that same machine. When you type in your name, date of birth and national insurance number, the system goes automatically to HMRC and the DWP to validate you before you have even pressed the button; they will validate you almost immediately. I think the point my noble friend is making, which is absolutely correct, is that having this unique identifier—the national insurance number or some other method that might be defined by regulations—gives an absolutely unambiguous way of determining whether you have a duplication.
I thank my noble friend for his intervention, which was slightly longer than I had hoped for, since I want to keep to my time. As I say, there is a system; we were told it is impossible, but what have the Northern Irish done? They introduced a read-only system and have done that themselves. It operates effectively in Northern Ireland without any problem.
These massive changes are, I believe, unnecessary—although, yes, they were advertised—and without great benefit. I will quote now from the impact assessment, to which I may return on another occasion. On page 113 it says that
“we assume that the completeness of registers will increase by 3 percentage points (from 85.9% to 88.9%) by the end of the 10-year … period”.
Are we going through all these changes for that?
In conclusion, I must pick up the noble Lord, Lord Rennard, on his comments about my support for automatic registration. I believed that I had made it absolutely clear that I support it for attainers, whatever age they may happen to be, because I want to introduce them to the democratic system. Thereafter, I do not support automatic registration for that very small gain.
My Lords, we have heard two interesting contrasting themes in this group. Some of us are very keen on automatic voter registration and want to see it introduced sooner and better. Others are nervous about the potential implications of automatic voter registration. I think it is worth starting with a recap of the reasons why something like automatic voter registration is required, particularly as the noble Lord, Lord Hayward, eloquently put the case against.
In part, it is because making good use of data is, when done well, an effective way of improving services and reducing administrative burdens. It is worth contrasting how a registration process would start under AVR with the current system. Several noble Lords have expressed concerns about how a database might result in registrations flowing from that data. However, under the current system anyone can request and be sent a paper form that they can fill in, without having to provide a national insurance number. That, under our existing system, is enough to start the process rolling for registration. If we are relying on the right, good-quality datasets, that is a much more secure starting point than anyone being able to request a paper form that anyone could fill in. It is also worth bearing in mind that the current system was very well described by one of the international experts in elections we are lucky to have in this country: Professor Toby James. He called it a
“Victorian system in need of repair”.
I think this Bill’s efforts to repair it are very welcome.
A good example of that is the surge in registration applications we typically have in the run-up to a general election. The Electoral Commission’s latest research estimated that between 7 million and 8 million people are either missing from the electoral register or registered at the wrong address. There is a substantial problem that needs addressing. We have heard that in the run-up to a general election there is a surge in applications; for example, last time, there was a surge of nearly 3 million. As was rightly pointed out, many of those were duplicate applications. When you strip those out from the numbers and compare that with the 7 million or 8 million missing and wrong addresses on the register, even the general election surge is not getting us that far towards fixing the problem.
9:00 pm
20 of 78 shown
I quite understand the need to pilot arrangements, but we can learn from others, such as Wales, which, with more limited resources, will have its system of automated registration ready for May 2027, despite it becoming law less than two years ago. There will be no compromise when it comes to security and accuracy, as no voter will be registered without the standard checks carried out by the electoral registration officers, as now. The EROs would have much better and more reliable data to work with. According to Unlock Democracy, the Electoral Commission, leading academics and international experts all believe that automated registration using some government databases, as proposed by Amendment 59, is deliverable within two years.
Florence Eshalomi MP was sponsoring a timeline amendment to the Bill before her promotion to ministerial office. A commitment to a timeline or plan of some kind would represent an important statement of intent on the part of the Government. If automated registration is not in place by the time of the next election, it could be as long as 2034 before it took effect for a general election. How many of our fellow citizens would be effectively disfranchised in the meantime?
These amendments are designed to support the Government’s goals. I hope, therefore, that even if my noble friend cannot accept them, she will give a commitment to bring forward a timetable herself, preferably before Report, so that noble Lords can consider it.
The parliamentary franchise rightly extends to Irish citizens and qualifying Commonwealth citizens. Different nationality and residency requirements apply to other elections. An individual’s immigration status may determine whether they qualify for that registration. For example, a person may be lawfully resident in the United Kingdom in employment, paying taxes and accessing public services, without necessarily being entitled to vote in a particular election. That is not a criticism of the individual but simply a recognition that lawful residence and electoral entitlement are not the same thing. It is precisely why we must make sure that this Bill distinguishes between verifying someone’s identity and their electoral eligibility. A government database may confirm somebody’s name, address and date of birth. A national insurance number may assist in establishing identity. However, neither by itself necessarily establishes nationality or entitlement.
I have tabled this amendment as I am concerned that, as the Government move towards an automated system, we risk treating the existence of an administrative record as sufficient evidence of electoral eligibility. The Electoral Commission has emphasised that the success of registration will depend entirely on the accuracy and reliability of the underlying data, so that only eligible individuals are registered. Having been around the upper echelons of government and local government through much of my adult life, I must confess that an unquestioning faith in the accuracy of government-held data is something that I have not been able to acquire. This is not a question of the dedication of the many officials who maintain the system, but my experience over the years has taught me that our systems are far from infallible.
I also appreciate the responsibilities already placed upon the electoral registration officers. They have a mammoth task in maintaining the accuracy and completeness of the registers, often against a background of considerable administrative and financial pressure caused by a lack of local government funding. My amendment does not intend to place further obstacles in their path—quite the opposite. It would establish a statutory requirement, supported by prescribed evidence or information lawfully obtained from public authorities.
I would therefore be grateful if the Minister could address three questions. First, what arrangements would exist to distinguish between a person’s identity and their legal entitlement to vote when records are obtained from government departments and other public bodies? Secondly, will electoral registration officers have timely access to the information necessary to verify immigration status where it is relevant, and who will bear the administrative cost? Thirdly, what safeguards will prevent an individual being entered on to a register for an election in which they are not legally entitled to participate?
On the broader scale, in the review after the last election, an estimate of between 7 million and 8 million people had not registered. There is a law in this country that people are supposed to register, and the council can, if it so wishes, pursue them with a fine of £1,000 per person for not registering. I am not suggesting that councils are going to start trying to generate lots of money, although it feels like a lot of money could be generated if that were the case, but rather that we think about how we do this in a sensible way. That is why there is a sense of ambition—it is not overambition—but how accurate will it be?
Other amendments propose the DWP issuing information to electoral registration officers. I think that the amendment that refers to those issued in the last year being sent on is fine. Actually, HRMC is responsible for the national insurance database and is the overall guardian of that; what happens with the DWP is linked to what happens in HMRC. For example, for people who have not claimed child benefit, it does not happen and they end up going through a manual process to get a national insurance number. But the broader point here comes back to accuracy.
That leads on to the question of what is going to happen about who is entitled to vote in that place if we suddenly have a huge expansion of the electorate. Research has shown that it often becomes an issue if people have moved during the year and end up being registered in more than one place. How does that get resolved? When it comes to parliamentary voting, what is supposed to happen is that the only place where you are allowed to be registered is the principal place in which you live. There is very strict guidance from the Government and the Electoral Commission that this is the case for local registration officers. My concern is that what often happens in the rush at the end is that none of that is gone through, so we end up having a lot of people registering in places where, if they had registered in normal time, their registration might have been turned down because it was not their principal place of residence. There is a risk of overinflating the electorate.
What does that mean for the consideration of constituency boundaries—for example, in the Cities of London and Westminster constituency and in Leeds Central and Headingley? Of course, they often match up to university towns and places of transience where people might move. Things might change under the Renters’ Rights Act, but this is something that the Government need to think through.
I would be grateful to hear from the Minister what lessons the Government have learned from the Welsh Government pilots and how they intend to ensure accuracy. I think there is a case here of rushing to an outcome that, instead of improving democracy, could significantly undermine it. So, as I said, I would be grateful to hear what the Government are doing to manage the risks as well as big-up the benefits.
What guarantees will prevent personal information that is supplied to, for example, HMRC, the DWP or the DVLA from being disclosed to the electoral register? Who bears legal responsibility if somebody is incorrectly registered, omitted or, indeed, registered at an address where they are not entitled to vote? Will automatically created registrations at secondary addresses be excluded from constituency election calculations where appropriate? Most importantly of all, what level of erroneous registration would the Government consider acceptable? How will they measure that, and how will they address it?
This is why, on the surface, it might seem very convenient to have automatic voter registration, but when we are talking about integrity and, ultimately, who forms a parliamentary constituency and who forms a Government, a lot more detail needs to be had than what we have in the Bill.
That takes me to another point, which is that we have to register all these people so that we can improve turnout. Might it not be a good idea if politicians—and I include in that category noble Lords and those in the other Chamber—improved their reputation with the public at large so that those people want to turn out to vote?
Talking of which, the Government have a very good website where you can register to vote. I could walk out of this Chamber now and register immediately. People might wonder why I had nothing better to do, but on Saturday evening I actually went on that site. What astonished me was that 54 people had registered in the preceding few minutes. I challenge noble Lords to go on it on Christmas Day; they will be astonished by how many people register to vote on Christmas Day and Boxing Day. It is not that difficult.
My noble friend Lady Coffey referred just now to the fact that, in an election period, 2.8 million people registered to vote—it was just between 2.8 million and 2.9 million. The problem there was that some 40% of those people were already registered. One thing we have not done today is given enough credit to both the Public Bill Office here in the House of Lords, for the speed with which it has drafted and ordered our amendments, and the day-to-day work of returning officers around the country. I shall return to this subject at a later point, but those officers do a phenomenal job. If you have 2.8 million extra people registering to vote during an election, as I say, that seems to show it is not that difficult to do it—and, by the way, if all those students who are moving off to university are unable to go on to a website, I have a serious doubt about whether some of them should be at university in the first place.
The 40% of people who registered at the last election who were double-registered imposed an enormous burden on the returning officers. I have said over and over again that we should move to a read-only access process. In other words, if Robert Hayward wants to check whether he is on the electoral roll, he just goes on the website with his password and can check that he is there. Instead of that, because Governments of all persuasions have refused to introduce a read-only system, we impose a burden on returning officers which is unacceptable at the time of an election, when they are trying to administer all sorts of other things.
It is not difficult. We have been told by government and officials over and over again that it is an expensive and difficult process. Is it? Local authorities—
Action is needed. Of course, we should not therefore think that any action is wise. But I hope, therefore, we will hear positive noises from the Government, particularly on Amendments 49, 50 and 52 from my noble friends Lord Rennard, Lord Wallace and Lady Thornhill, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Royall and Lady Bennett, all of which in different ways would improve the supply of data into the system.
My Amendment 58 would provide ward-level data, which I think is important, particularly with local government reorganisation increasing the size of many councils. Council-level data will not tell us how well or how badly registration systems are working in future; we need that data at ward level. We need it to understand how the system is working. We need it for researchers and experts to figure out whether the promises are being delivered. We need it for the campaigners, of all parties and none, who are trying to improve involvement and engagement with democracy, to be able to see where their efforts are most needed. We need it for media, and indeed for us politicians, to be able to understand how systems are working.
I turn to some of the other amendments in this group. On Amendment 8 from the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, I must admit I am not convinced by the case that the noble Lord made. Under the current system, with a voting age of 18, we register attainers with some aged 16 and most aged 17. The current system is that some people who are two years below the age for voting get registered as attainers. That is because of the use of the 1 December cut-off date and the following one-year window, which means that some people may be more than one year away and need to be in the records.
If we are changing 18 to 16, it seems absolutely sensible that 17 and 16 should, in turn, also get reduced by two years to 15 and 14. Therefore, with respect, the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, would achieve the opposite of what he argued for. We have an existing system that is well established, that people are used to using and that works; by reducing the years across the board, we are essentially transferring the existing system over to the new voting age, rather than creating a new system that would not work with the 1 December window and following 12-month period.