My Lords, I am very pleased to open this Second Reading debate on the Representation of the People Bill. Noble Lords across the House bring great experience of electoral law, electoral administration and the practical operation of our democracy. I look forward to the contributions that will be made today and to the constructive scrutiny that our House will bring to the Bill.
This Bill renews our democracy for a new generation, opening up participation and strengthening the integrity of our elections. It restores confidence, reinforcing trust with stronger political finance rules and better protections against harassment and intimidation, closing down opportunities for those who would seek to undermine our democracy. But it would be wrong to introduce this debate without acknowledging and reflecting on events of recent times.
When I catch the 6.15 am or the 6.31 am train from Stevenage to London in the mornings, I share the carriages of that train and then the Underground with people whose interests are at the heart of our community: tradespeople, in their steel-toecap boots; public sector workers, including those in blue light services, heading for their early shifts; and small business owners getting an early start to prepare for their day. It is a fundamental principle of our democracy that every one of their votes is exactly equal to the votes of millionaires, crypto bros and industry magnates. It is that which sits front and centre in this Bill.
My Lords, it is an understatement to say that this is a constitutionally significant Bill. Particularly at a time when the political landscape is so turbulent, this is where your Lordships’ House proves its worth—with careful, considered scrutiny to improve the Government's legislation as best we can. Indeed, the amendment in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Rooker, is driven by the need for this thorough scrutiny, and I thank him. I thank all those who are speaking today; I am sure that a number of very important matters will be raised, and we will be listening to them very closely.
The Bill seeks not only to give children the right to vote in all elections but introduces automatic voter registration, reforms political finance law and tackles foreign interference, while potentially leaving the door open for foreign citizens to vote. I also flag that the Bill was drafted with minimal engagement with other political parties. The Electoral Commission has said that
“any legislative change on elections should be informed by the experience and insight of the electoral community, including electoral administrators, political parties and the wider regulated community”.
There was no consultation with political parties on the 2025 election strategy, nor after the initial Rycroft recommendations. Why did the Government not wait two months until the Rycroft review was completed before proceeding with Second Reading of the Bill in the other place?
If the Government wanted to fast-track their manifesto commitments on the voting age, why could they not separate the election measures from the political finance measures, as indeed the last Labour Government did with the Representation of the People Act 2000 and the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000? This is not how election rules should be reformed. As Sir Winston Churchill said at the Second Reading of the Representation of the People Bill in 1948:
My Lords, in the light of the mega donations we have heard about to Reform in the past week, I start by emphasising the difference between liberal democracy and popular democracy—or illiberal democracy, as Viktor Orbán and others call it. Liberal or constitutional democracy recognises that democratic processes are open to abuse and require rules and regulations to ensure that all citizens, regardless of background or income, are able to play a positive part. Transparency in campaigning and finance is vital to maintain public trust. Safeguards against foreign interference, the buying of votes or dominance of the media by the wealthy are justified to ensure acceptance of the outcome and to prevent corruption.
Popular democracy dismisses all this. Populist leaders claim that they understand what the people really want and that regulations are there only to protect the establishment. If they spend money from doubtful sources in huge amounts, that is justified by the need to counter the weight of the mainstream media and the power of the established elite. If others question their arguments, they dismiss reasoned argument as fake news.
None of us should take our democracy for granted. In the 2024 election, less than 60% of our citizens turned out, and some 6 million to 8 million citizens were missing from the electoral register. Public disillusion with Westminster politics and with democracy itself is dangerously high in this country. Liberal Democrats argue that everything we put in this Bill must be geared to rebuilding public trust in our democratic institutions and encouraging every citizen to play an active part. Paragraph 84 of the Bill’s Explanatory Notes declares:
“The Government wants as many people as possible to engage in the United Kingdom’s democracy”.
Liberal Democrats share that objective and aim to amend the Bill to go further in pursuing it.
My Lords, before we move on, I wanted to highlight the five-minute advisory time limit for Back-Bench contributions. I ask all noble Lords to stick closely to that guidance, as it will enable the House to rise at around 10 pm.
My Lords, I will focus my remarks on Parts 4 and 5 of the Bill, relating to election finance and to the work of the Electoral Commission.
In 2021, the Committee on Standards in Public Life, of which I was then chair, issued a report on the regulation of election finance. The report recommended a number of necessary—albeit modest—changes to election regulation to simplify the rules, increase transparency and reduce the risk of bad actors gaining influence through financial donations. Regrettably, the then Government under Boris Johnson failed to respond to the report and failed to act on the recommendations. The report was effectively buried. One can only speculate as to why. I am therefore delighted that the current Government have revisited this important issue, and I was pleased to have the opportunity to discuss the process of review by Philip Rycroft which underpins many of the measures in the Bill as presented.
The measures in Part 4 of the Bill go a considerable way towards meeting the recommendations that CSPL made in 2021. But if anything, as the Minister said, the need for change in this area is even more urgent now than it was five years ago. Public trust in our political system is under great pressure, the risk of foreign money infiltrating our election system remains, the risk of huge individual donations unbalancing the political process has grown, and hostile states, including, but by no means only, Russia, are energetically seeking to influence our public life and subvert our institutions. We must protect them for our national security and for the health of our democracy.
One of the absolute cornerstones of our democracy is maintaining the integrity of our elections, so that it is clear that they are fair, transparent, independent of government and resilient against improper attempts to influence the outcome. We are fortunate to have an independent Electoral Commission which, broadly speaking, has the confidence of the parties and the public. I am therefore delighted to see that the Bill would abolish the right of the Government to set out a strategy and policy statement for the Electoral Commission. The Government of the day do not own the electoral system and have no business imposing their own strategy and policy objectives on the Electoral Commission.
My Lords, this is an important and timely debate, as any opportunity to re-establish trust in politics is one that we must embrace eagerly. We are sadly familiar with the phrase, “A plague on both your houses”, used in a political context. The word “both” may be rather out of date, but the sentiment expressed encapsulates the frustration that many voters feel with the entire political system, thus overlooking many principled, honest and hard-working MPs, Peers and their staff.
I will mention two points in particular. First, in my visits to prisons, I meet many men with time to think and to think deeply. Most people come to serve their sentence in prison only after a string of failures: personal failures and the failures of services, systems and institutions, including the Church. To have that direct and painful experience of system failure and yet, through disenfranchisement, to have no means to participate in efforts for their correction or renewal, can further erode any sense of civic engagement and belonging. I hope that this House will consider whether votes might be extended to at least some convicted prisoners as one dimension of the penal journey to rehabilitation.
Secondly, I stand here embodying my belief that the Church has much to bring to civic engagement and the search for the common good in which all people can flourish, but I am deeply saddened to see our faith, or any faith or belief, being used to divide, to exclude or to intimidate. Recently, we have seen cases of pictures of church buildings being used in election campaign material without permission, and I fear we may see more images of churches, mosques, synagogues, mandirs, gurdwaras and other places of worship being used improperly. I and my colleagues on these Benches would like to see greater deterrence against this kind of malign misuse. I hope that the Government will see fit to work with the Electoral Commission and with faith leaders to strengthen the guidance given to candidates and to campaign managers in this area.
My Lords, it is a pleasure and an honour to follow the right reverend Prelate, and of course we all wish him well in his retirement. We will miss him, and his views on democracy are very well established. I agree with him in relation to prisoners, but that is a personal view.
Democracy is fragile, and too many people have lost faith in our politicians and in our Parliament. We must give citizens confidence that our system is fair, inclusive, transparent and accessible.
I commend the Government for taking action to prevent overseas money influencing our politics, but the influence wielded by domestic mega-donors also threatens our political system. It is a challenge to democracy and corrupts our politics. I welcome the letter from the Housing Secretary and the First Secretary of State to the Electoral Commission asking for an immediate review of political spending caps. This is very urgent. I therefore ask my noble friend whether the Government commit to a timeline for announcing and legislating further measures to cap donations.
As well as deciding what electoral law should be, we must consider stronger penalties for breaches of the law, including confiscation of the entire donation and a substantial fine. It would be good to have the views of my noble friend the Minister.
One important aspect of electoral funding was not properly addressed by Rycroft and is absent from the legislation. The use of think tanks funded by unknown sources and foreign money to influence our politics should concern us all, as it does the Liberal Democrats. Does the Minister agree that think tanks, like charities or political parties, should be required to report and publish information on their donations?
I fervently believe that further work on reforming our electoral law system is crucial and must take place before the election. The Government must review electoral law swiftly and carefully to ensure that it is fit for purpose at every level and then urgently bring forward further legislation. I suggest that perhaps they could do this in the next Session of Parliament to close loopholes, address new issues that have arisen and ensure that our elections are free from undue influence.
My Lords, I first add my best wishes to the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Lichfield on his retirement and thank him for the contributions that he has made to this House. It has been said by other speakers, including the right reverend Prelate, that this is an important piece of legislation if we are to restore trust in our democracy, and there are aspects of it with which I agree with the Government. I must confess that I do not agree with the Government on their proposals to extend the franchise to 16 and 17 year-olds. I will say merely this. I think this was introduced with political motivations, but I will just say gently to the Government that I suspect that it may very well backfire on them.
I also welcome any attempts to tighten up the rules on electronic campaigning material, but I just say this to the Government: I fear this is an area where it is going to be difficult for legislation to keep up with developments. I worry about the ability to use AI-generated material, which can put words into the mouths of any candidate, or indeed anybody involved with a political party or an election, which are untrue and have never been said by them. Keeping up with the developments of AI in this field is going to be difficult, and I ask the Government to make sure that they continue to keep a watchful eye on this particular area.
The one aspect of this Bill on which I particularly wanted to comment and to support the Government’s moves is on the use of crypto assets. The Bill describes a crypto asset as
“a cryptographically secured digital representation of value or contractual rights that uses a form of distributed ledger technology and can be transferred, stored or traded electronically”.
I prefer the Bank of England’s statement in its primer on crypto assets:
My Lords, I think Parliament is at its best when we can get up on both sides of the House and say we agree. In that context, we make much better laws. I welcome many measures in the Bill, and my thanks go to Philip Rycroft for his excellent report on countering foreign financial influence and interference in UK politics. I am grateful to the Government for the changes already made that reflect many of his recommendations, such as the proposals to ban crypto asset donations; the call for company donations to be assessed against profits, not revenue; and the proposal to cap foreign donations at £100,000. Similarly, strengthening the Electoral Commission’s powers, improving “know your donor” checks and introducing slightly tougher enforcement are welcome changes.
Our Prime Minister said that the Bill should be seen as the start, not the end, of his ambition. In that spirit, I wish to raise concerns on which I ask the Government to urgently reflect as we consider the Bill—first, the unprecedented announcement that two crypto billionaires donated an astonishing £72 million to one political party in 24 hours. The amount is staggering, but the fact that it happened at all brings into stark focus the frightening threat to the integrity and health of our democracy presented by the growing trend that sees our politics funded by huge donations from a wealthy small elite. Anybody who believes that the donations were made simply to establish a level playing field is frankly both naive and wrong.
The truth is that large individual donations will at best influence and at worst control the policies and actions of political parties. Look at Reform with Farage’s statements on crypto, saying we should unquestionably embrace it, pledging to cut taxes for crypto traders and promising to lift the cap on the ownership of stablecoins. Look at Nathan Gill accepting bribes and then delivering speeches and interviews in support of Russia.
20 of 133 shown
We must put politics back under public control. We all share concerns about the rise of big money and its ability to dominate public power. At its heart, this Bill is about renewing the foundations of our electoral system so that it remains fair, secure, transparent and accessible in the years ahead. At the Last Night of the Proms on Saturday, the conductor, Sakari Oramo, referred to another version of AI, which was authenticity and integrity. That must sit at the heart of electoral reform, so that we restore the confidence of the 6 am crew that their voice really counts.
Delivering on our manifesto commitment, this Bill extends the franchise to eligible 16 and 17 year-olds for UK parliamentary elections and other reserved and excepted polls. It enables more automated forms of electoral registration, broadens the forms of voter identification that may be used at polling stations, and makes a range of changes to the conduct and administration of elections, referendums and recall petitions. The Bill strengthens the rules on political donations and expenditure, including measures to reduce the risk of foreign money entering our politics. It improves transparency in digital campaigning material, strengthens enforcement and information sharing by the Electoral Commission, and requires tougher sentencing where offences are aggravated by hostility towards candidates, elected officeholders, campaigners or electoral staff.
Opportunities for those who seek to undermine or illicitly influence our democracy must and will be closed down. This Bill responds directly to a changing and increasingly hostile threat environment and takes action to tackle risks by strengthening safeguards, closing loopholes and hardening defences. Taken together, these measures will help deliver a modern, secure and inclusive electoral system. They will support public confidence, protect our democracy from those who would seek to undermine it and open participation to a new generation of voters.
The Bill is ambitious but practical. It addresses the everyday operation of democracy: who can take part, how they register and vote, how campaigns are funded and conducted, and how the rules are enforced. The balance is important. The Government are not seeking reform for their own sake. The measures in the Bill respond to real changes in political campaigning, how people participate in politics and how threats to democratic confidence can arise. Some of these changes are technological, some are administrative and some reflect the need to ensure that our democratic arrangements command confidence across generations. The Bill therefore looks both to the integrity of the system and to the experience of those who use it: voters, candidates, parties, campaigners and electoral administrators.
The Bill is not the totality of our ambition for electoral reform; work will continue. As a first step, the First Secretary of State and the Secretary of State for MHCLG have written to the Electoral Commission to review spending limits, which we believe are too high. We are establishing a cross-government task and finish team to consider threats to UK democracy, including political funding, illegitimate influence and broader threats to political equality.
As noble Lords would expect, the Bill has not remained frozen in aspic since its introduction; it has continued to develop through scrutiny, engagement and the Government’s consideration of how best to give effect to its objectives. During its Commons stages, the Government brought forward both substantive and technical amendments to strengthen the Bill in response to points raised by Members and to ensure it better delivers its policy intent.
For example, the Government brought forward amendments to strengthen the “know your donor” requirements and further tighten the rules relating to donations made by unincorporated associations. Those changes were designed to improve transparency and ensure that the political finance regime keeps pace with the risks it is intended to address. These risks cannot be overstated. The threat to our democracy from foreign influence and hidden sources of political funding are an ever-growing danger—one that we cannot afford to delay tackling.
Responding to further evidence of the threat we face—namely, the conviction of Nathan Gill, as well as cases such as Christine Lee—we commissioned Philip Rycroft to review foreign financial influence and interference in politics. His report was thorough and challenging, and the Government have accepted its recommendations. Safeguarding the integrity, transparency and fairness of our electoral system is a fundamental priority, and the Bill provides an important vehicle for taking that work forward.
A number of recommendations from the Rycroft review were therefore implemented through amendments made to the Bill on Report in the Commons. Those amendments form a significant part of the Government’s wider response to the risks identified by the review. The first of those changes concerns crypto assets. The current political donations framework does not sufficiently reflect the particular risks that crypto assets can present, including the difficulty of identifying the true source of a donation. That creates a risk that malign actors, including state actors, could seek to obscure the origin of the funds. The Bill therefore introduces a ban on the use of crypto assets as a means of making political donations. To support that change, the Government have amended the Bill to clarify the meaning of a donation under the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. That will ensure that property, including crypto assets transferred to a party to meet an expense, is treated as a donation, so that the law cannot be circumvented simply because value is transferred through property rather than cash.
The Bill caps donations to registered political parties by overseas electors at £100,000. This also applies to individuals who were formerly resident outside the UK, who are subject to the cap for a minimum of a calendar year after arrival here. That responds to concerns identified by the Rycroft review: first, that the origin of funds from overseas donors can be harder to trace; and, secondly, that democratic fairness may be put at risk if individuals are able to make unlimited donations into the political system while having only a limited connection to public life in the United Kingdom.
Further amendments change the test for company donations so that it is based on profit rather than revenue. That change follows careful consideration of the Rycroft review and engagement with stakeholders. Profit provides a clearer indication of a company’s financial position and helps ensure that donations come from companies undertaking genuine economic activity.
The Bill was also amended to implement the Rycroft recommendation that the Electoral Commission’s information-sharing powers should be extended. This will enable the commission to receive relevant information from relevant public authorities as defined in the Bill, supporting more effective regulation of political finance and a better understanding of emerging risks. The Government also amended the Bill to extend the commission’s powers to require disclosure of information outside a formal investigation, allowing the commission to more proactively monitor compliance, support timely regulation during election periods, and take a more proportionate and effective approach to enforcement.
Beyond the Rycroft recommendations, on Report the Government introduced a targeted regulation-making power into the Bill to allow key political finance restrictions, including those relating to crypto assets, overseas elector donation caps and company donations, to be extended beyond political parties via secondary legislation in the future. This is to ensure that malign actors cannot circumvent the rules by providing to other non-party regulated donees.
While much of the consideration of the Bill so far has been focused on strengthening the political finance provisions, the Government tabled further amendments on Report to extend the maximum duration of longer-term postal and proxy postal voting arrangements from three years to five, and to better align the duration of anonymous elector registration provisions with those changes. These changes will provide greater clarity and consistency while reducing repeated administrative burdens on people who may already be vulnerable.
The Government have also amended the Bill to clarify when an overseas elector may be removed from the electoral register. Overseas electors must satisfy specific eligibility requirements when they register. Although registration lasts for three years, circumstances may change during that period. These amendments ensure that an individual who no longer meets the requirements can be removed, helping electoral registers remain accurate. Taken together, the Commons amendments strengthen the public scrutiny of political finance, reduce avoidable administrative burdens and ensure that the Bill responds sensibly to modern forms of participation, campaigning and donation.
As the Bill has progressed, our desire to engage with all interested parties and our willingness to listen to opposing viewpoints has continued. Following the strength of feeling expressed at Second Reading in the House of Commons, the Government tabled an amendment in Committee to repeal the Government’s powers to designate a strategy and policy statement to which the Electoral Commission must have regard. That repeal supports our manifesto commitment to strengthen democracy and uphold the integrity and independence of the Electoral Commission.
The Government have committed to tabling an amendment during the Bill’s passage through this House to strengthen accessibility at polling stations for voters with disabilities. We will develop that amendment in the spirit of the new clause brought forward on Report in the Commons, working with interested Members of both Houses to ensure that any new provision is proportionate, practical and deliverable.
In addition to introducing a robust regime that ensures that donors contributing above the £100,000 annual cap must demonstrate a genuine and ongoing connection to the United Kingdom, we are considering how we will strengthen the residency requirements, including ensuring that the length of time spent in the UK aligns with broader government policy. We will continue to engage with political parties bilaterally and through the Parliamentary Parties Panel, and we will provide the House with further details in due course. I am keen for that spirit of constructive engagement to continue as the Bill proceeds through this House. I have hosted a drop-in session for all Peers, and I have been pleased to meet a number of noble Lords separately. Throughout the passage of this Bill, my door will remain open to those who wish to discuss any aspect of it with me.
Outside this House, we have worked and will continue to work with bodies such as the Parliamentary Parties Panel and stakeholders across the electoral sector to ensure that the Bill operates effectively for political parties, electors and administrators. We have also engaged with Ministers and officials in the Scottish Government, the Welsh Government and the Northern Ireland Executive, recognising that implementation will require continued close working with the devolved Governments and legislative consent in those areas within the responsibility of the devolved legislatures.
I also recognise that successful implementation will matter as much as the legislation itself. Electoral administrators, returning officers and those who support the running of elections locally will be central to making many of these reforms work in practice. The Government will continue to engage closely with them as the Bill progresses and as the necessary secondary legislation, guidance and operational changes are developed. We want reforms that are ambitious but also workable, clear and capable of commanding confidence on the ground.
Democracy is not sustained by institutions and legislation alone. It depends on people believing that their voice matters, that the rules are fair and that the outcome of an election reflects the free choice of the electorate. That confidence must never be taken for granted. This is a substantial and important set of reforms to electoral law. I know that noble Lords will bring expertise, rigour and practical insight to its consideration. I look forward to engaging with those debates in the constructive spirit in which the Bill has been developed. I beg to move.
“It has become a well-established custom that matters affecting the interests of rival parties should not be settled by the imposition of the will of one side over the other, but by an agreement”.—[Official Report, Commons, 16/2/1948; cols. 859-60.]
Some of the provisions are indeed deeply troubling and risk setting dangerous precedents. Bills such as these should not be hyper-partisan, particularly in complex areas such as political finance. Even just the perception of partisan, targeted legislation risks breaking down long-standing political conventions and, crucially, trust in the system. We will all have heard the reports this weekend of crypto donations to Reform UK. It is our current understanding that these donations would be caught by the overseas contributors cap, but I would be grateful if the Minister could clarify how this proposed cap would work. Do the cap’s provisions apply to long-standing domestic electors and not just to overseas electors and overseas electors who return to domestic registration?
Can the noble Baroness confirm the requirement for a full calendar year of prior UK residence when making a donation? The legislation commences these provisions retrospectively from March 2026, but the calendar year of UK residence requirement may predate March 2026. If an elector has dual permanent residence at home and abroad, would this class the elector as an overseas contributor? It is important that laws are clear. I would be happy for the Minister to write to me on this matter if she so wishes.
As to the Bill’s other provisions, let me be very clear that we will not stand in the way of the Government’s manifesto commitment to lower the voting age. Noble Lords opposite may see themselves as having a monopoly on progress, but I gently remind them that when the Reform Act 1832 was passed—they know the answer—the Conservatives won the general election in 1841. It was the Conservatives who championed the Reform Act 1867, and we once again defied expectations following the Reform Act 1884, when the Liberals lost their majority in 1885 and the Conservatives returned to power in 1886. When women finally got the vote in the following decades, they were more likely to vote Conservative than men—very sensible. And when the voting age was lowered to 18 in 1969, the Conservatives won the general election the following year. From the days of the Primrose League to our Young Conservatives today, we will never be afraid of making our case to the British people.
However, the Government’s position in this Bill is inconsistent with their policies elsewhere, which raises serious questions. The Government must decide whether they see 16 and 17 year-olds as children, in line with the Children Act and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. If not, then why not 15 year-olds or younger? What exactly is the Government’s rationale? Will they change other laws as a result? Children currently cannot stand for election, be deployed in the Armed Forces or buy alcohol or cigarettes. The Government have raised the age for buying fireworks, vapes and knives or for using sunbeds to 18 and are proposing to raise the age for obtaining a driving licence from 17. Where do the Government draw the line and why?
We are also concerned about automatic voter registration. We believe it is up to individuals to register, to be inspired to register rather than be forced, and to undergo proper checks to protect the system from fraud, which is why individual registration was introduced in the first place. Do we really trust algorithms to keep accurate registers when there may be out-of-date entries on other databases, for example? How will it prevent those with residence but who are ineligible being registered, such as certain second home owners or unqualified Commonwealth and EU voters? So much for tackling foreign interference. Voters’ rights are rightly based on citizenship and not residency. No EU member state allows non-national citizens to vote in its national elections. Can the Minister confirm that eligibility to vote in general elections will remain the preserve of British citizens only?
What is more, the Bill will water down requirements for photographic identification at polling stations, yet we still require photo ID to drive or for under-25s to buy alcohol. Again, what is the rationale? Where is the consistency? Amid the legitimate concerns in the recent Gorton and Denton as well as Birmingham City Council by-elections around family voting, is this really the time to water down safeguards against electoral fraud?
This brings me to the rise of sectarianism in our country. In the other place, the Government, alongside the Liberal Democrats and the Greens, voted against an amendment to ban political campaigning materials in foreign languages. The Government have not said whether any assessment has been made of sectarianism in election campaigning. This is counterproductive to integration and brings into question whether this Government are serious about social cohesion.
There are, of course, some aims in the Bill which we welcome. We support initiatives to safeguard candidates, campaigners and elected representatives from unacceptable acts of abuse, intimidation and violence while protecting the right to robust debate on strongly felt issues. The previous Government took several actions on this and we are happy to build on this work. Similarly, we will be constructive when it comes to election advertising regulation. The Elections Act 2022 introduced imprints for digital material, and the Conservative Party already voluntarily labels digital content which is AI generated.
As I said earlier, the kinds of reforms proposed in the Bill should be based on consensus and cross-party consultation. Clearly, there are areas we agree on, but there are also areas of serious concern, not just about the proposals themselves but about the way in which the Government have introduced them. I would be grateful if the Minister could address the points raised and I look forward to hearing the valuable insights of other noble Lords on this hugely significant and wide-ranging Bill.
Thankfully, Hungary’s experiment with illiberal democracy, with the massive corruption that went with it, has now been defeated, but we are watching democracy in the USA being undermined by gerrymandering, challenges to voting lists and attacks on the impartiality of election administrators, as well as by enormous flows of money. I hope that most of us in this House share a deep concern about current developments in the US and a commitment to sustain our liberal democracy against the threats it now faces.
In a previous debate, the noble Lord, Lord Hannan, argued that the right to spend money in political campaigning was a part of free speech, repeating the argument the US Supreme Court made in overthrowing congressional limits on campaign funding. The noble Lord, Lord Frost, who will be speaking in this debate, dismissed the Rycroft report as “absurd”, which is to say, “fake news”. Money in politics is vital to political campaigning, but large donations—millions of pounds or dollars—distort and corrupt the democratic process. Commentary on this year’s US congressional elections frequently starts by telling us which candidate has raised the most money, as a key factor in whether they win or lose. We will support extending spending limits of campaigns and imposing clear conditions and limits on donations to prevent our democracy sinking into a similar funding race.
I find it striking that populists who campaign to defend British sovereignty get so much of their money from sunny places abroad: Gibraltar for the Brexit campaign, and Thailand, Hong Kong, Montenegro and beyond for the Reform Party. It is gross hypocrisy to claim to represent the sovereign voice of the British people when they depend on shady money from sunny places.
Some of the changes in this Bill aim to reverse the damage inflicted in the highly partisan 2022 Elections Act. The noble Baroness, Lady O’Neill of Bexley, has repeated the argument that there was an established convention dating from 1948 that changes in election regulations must be subject to consensus among the parties involved. I was the Liberal Democrat lead in 2022, and I remember no consultation from the Conservatives whatsoever. If there were such an established convention—I asked the Library to see any evidence of this but was told they could find none—the Conservatives decisively broke it during the passage of that Act. I hope we all now behave better than that.
The Conservative Party must own and admit the damage done to our country’s democratic institutions and to public trust under Boris Johnson as Prime Minister. It must own and admit its own shortcomings in allowing Russian money and influence to penetrate deeply into the party. I have just read an article by Dominic Grieve, then chair of the Intelligence and Security Committee, on Boris Johnson’s determination to limit the investigation of major donations to the Brexit campaign, as well as to delay publication of the ISC’s Russia report until after the 2019 election and to redact much of the damaging detail. Some of those involved in promoting the Conservative Friends of Russia and cultivating Russian donors now sit in this House.
Rycroft distinguished between money that flowed directly to political parties and efforts to shape “the wider influencing environment”, including
“attempts to create division and distrust among the wider public”.
Direct donations may seem easy to regulate, but I recommend chapter six of George Cottrell’s recent book, How to Launder Money, which lists a variety of ways to donate to a politician or party without being caught: from high speaking fees and book deals to paying travel expenses and funding associated foundations and think tanks. As a fundraiser for the leave campaign and now for Reform, he is an expert in this. Oddly, he does not include paying extraordinarily high fees for TV work in the way that the loss-making GB News subsidises Nigel Farage.
The wider influencing environment is a grey area in political regulation: non-party campaigners are hard to define; political movements that are not parties are not covered; and social media has become a powerful form of influence. Money from abroad is hard to trace. It is not only Russia and China that seek to influence UK campaigning; the Hungarian Government, under Viktor Orbán, reportedly provided almost all the funding for the Roger Scruton Legacy Foundation to support James Orr’s promotion of Christian nationalism. The Times last week reported that Daniel Pipes’ Middle East Forum, a strongly anti-Muslim American organisation, was funding both Tommy Robinson’s movement and Daniel Thomas’s Patriotic Platform that organised the demonstrations in Dover and Portsmouth.
The significant surge of American money into British politics, now also from the Trump Administration itself, threatens to upset the balance of our domestic debate. The Bill may not be able to close all these loopholes, but we must try.
This unregulated flow of money to the fringes of party politics is not entirely new. I recall many years ago a former treasurer of the Conservative Party telling me that when potential donors wanted to remain anonymous, he would suggest they donate to a friendly think tank instead. But it has become a more contentious issue as social media and private polling have opened up more space for unobserved funding to tip the balance of the political debate.
The Rycroft Report’s recommendation on think tanks is clear, and we strongly support it:
“The Government, working with the Charity Commission as appropriate, should ensure it has the capability to monitor the think tank landscape … to make transparent the engagement of foreign-funded think tanks in the policy process”.
I look forward to the speech from the noble Lord, Lord Young of Acton, on this.
Others on these Benches will examine the proposals on regulation of social media, on intimidation and abuse of candidates, on moves towards automatic voter registration and other aspects of the Bill. They will also address the deficiencies of our antiquated voting system, now that we have five to six parties competing in national and local elections. Noble Lords may not be aware of the magnificent Liberal Democrat victory in a recent Cornish by-election, in which the victor won just under 19% of the vote.
Liberal Democrats welcome the extension of voting to 16 year-olds, as a contribution to building participation and trust in our democratic institutions within the younger generation. But it will need to be supported by an expansion of civic education in our schools, well beyond the very limited space provided within our current curriculum. I have talked to a number of secondary schools, and I am shocked by how little they are taught about democracy or our political institutions. We will look to the Minister and others for assurances that changes are now under way.
Effective regulation, I hope we all agree, is a vital part of constitutional democracy. We on these Benches will bring forward amendments to adjust Britain’s structure of regulation to the growing domestic and foreign challenges we face.
I also welcome the measures that reduce the risk of dirty or untraceable money getting into our electoral system. Given the strict demands on the banking sector—with which I was very familiar when I was a non-executive director at HSBC Holdings—and on other parts of the professional services industry to ensure that they know their customers, it is increasingly anomalous that there is so little duty on political parties to know their donors. The Bill requires parties to assess the risk posed by their donors, but without expecting them to do so to such a level of detail that it would be unreasonable in terms of the resources deployed.
Similarly, preventing donations being made from cryptocurrency is only prudent, given the untraceability of crypto assets. There is a reason why cyber criminals normally want their ransom payments made in crypto. The new measures relating to unincorporated associations are also vital. Unincorporated associations currently provide a convenient route to obscure the source of funds going into the election system. That must change.
On the well-rehearsed and, indeed, now very fashionable question of a cap on individual donations other than from overseas contributors, my long-held view is that there should be such a cap and that it should apply to companies, trade unions and other bodies as well as to individuals. I welcome the fact that companies, unions and individuals are willing to donate freely to the political process, but we need some degree of proportionality as to the influence of any particular voice. A donation cap—and I personally would set it at quite a high level—would help to do that, but it is vital that such a cap should not be so designed that it penalises or advantages any one party. So, cross-party consultation on this matter is essential, if we are to have a stable and credible system, and that applies to the other measures in the Bill.
Even if all the measures in the Bill were passed into law, there would still be a need to reform regulation of the election system, which is complex, fragmented and subject to different statutes. As has been argued elsewhere, there is a strong case for a root and branch review of election law. The Bill is not based on such a review, but it does propose some sensible and proportionate improvements that will reduce some of the risks that the current system faces.
This is the last time that I shall address your Lordships’ House before I retire at the end of this month. My maiden speech here was in a debate on parliamentary democracy in the UK, introduced by the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. I spoke then of the contributions that faith communities can make to the flourishing of democracy in our diverse society, an important issue to which we need constantly to return. It has been my privilege since then to make occasional contributions—alas, more infrequent than I might have hoped—to the workings of this House, and it has been an honour to be able to lead your Lordships in prayer. I thank all your Lordships for the quality, the expertise and the civility of your debates, and I thank the staff and the former and present Lord Speakers and their deputies for their unfailing helpfulness and courtesy. I wish your Lordships well in all your deliberations.
I am delighted that the Bill will lower the voting age, but this must be accompanied by education to install political, digital and media literacy. We need this education as soon as the Bill is enacted to ensure that our young people have the information and confidence to participate in the next elections.
I welcome the Bill’s provision to remove the requirement of home addresses to be published on the notice of election agents, and recent changes for candidates to opt out of publishing their home addresses on ballot papers. However, home addresses should be kept private by default. Women candidates are more likely to withhold their addresses than men, which can impact on their ability to prove a local connection. A change to prevent the publication of a candidate’s home address and instead replace geographical location with the constituency, district or ward would put all candidates on an equal footing and ensure both transparency and safety.
As the Electoral Commission’s recent report states, the rising abuse and intimidation of electoral candidates is changing politics. This must not be normalised and requires a change of culture. This Bill is an opportunity to change the culture, so I urge the Minister to take forward five further issues that were not voted on in the Commons: strengthen requirements for running for office by including domestic abuse in the list of offences and disqualification orders, as in Apsana Begum MP’s amendments, which received cross-party support; embed a code of conduct for political campaigning, building on the recommendation from the Speaker’s Conference and the ongoing work of the Electoral Commission, which is engaging parties to create a code; require the Electoral Commission to disseminate candidate safety resources; introduce an elections code of practice for social media platforms; and include an elections advertising code of practice. Claims in non-broadcast election advertising, including social media and targeted digital ads, are currently exempt from the code overseen by the Advertising Standards Authority. Thus, no independent body is responsible for assessing whether factual claims in electoral advertising are accurate. We need to close that gap to ensure fair and factual, robust debate and political expression.
Finally, I will be moving an amendment on compulsory voting, which I believe is a proven method of increasing voter turnout at elections, ensuring that citizens use their vote to influence the shape of our country and empowering them to bring about change.
I end by thanking many organisations for the excellent briefing they have provided, including the Women’s Democracy Group coalition.
“A way of storing value electronically outside of centralised systems and away from regulators”.
The Bank of England goes on to say:
“Development is under way to make cryptocurrencies easier to use, but for now they can’t really be considered a legitimate form of money”.
I have to say that I am generally a sceptic about crypto assets and cryptocurrencies, beyond even the aspects in relation to this piece of legislation. I first came across them as Home Secretary when they were the “currency of choice” for criminal gangs. They are a currency of choice for hostile state actors as well as those organised crime gangs. It is absolutely right that the Government are moving to find ways to ensure that crypto assets cannot be used as donations to political parties. But I would simply say this to the Government: I have seen the briefing from the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Anti-Corruption and Responsible Tax, which points out that there are loopholes in what the Government are doing here in this piece of legislation. Crypto assets are banned for donations to political parties but not to candidates. There is not a sufficient attempt to look at how exchanges can be used to turn those crypto assets, supposedly legally, into donations.
I think there is more that the Government should be doing, and I would urge the Government to look at this in particular. Crypto assets are used by people who want to avoid anybody knowing what they are doing, and in terms of our democracy and donations to political parties or candidates, we actually want the transparency of knowing who is making those donations. It is crypto assets in their various forms that will enable people who we do not want to see affecting our politics and affecting our democracies, who do so with evil intent and with intent of foreign interference. I welcome the fact that the Government are acting; I simply ask them to do more.
It is not just Reform. Under the Conservatives, large donations bought access to the Prime Minister, meetings with Ministers and even a tennis match with Boris Johnson. My own party also stands accused of undue influence by the trade union barons in our policies and actions. Hovering in the wings is Elon Musk, talking of investing £100 million in UK politics, who might well try to donate to the populist, extreme-right Restore party.
We must not allow money to capture and dictate our politics. We must act now. The Reform donations have created urgency. We cannot allow our democratic politics to be infected by the corrosive influence of money, with rich individuals often donating to secure public policies that bring them private profit. The Government should bring forward amendments to cap donations from individuals, cap the annual campaigning expenditure of parties and bring down the cap on what parties can spend during the election campaign.
Channel 4’s exposure alleged that Reform would be prepared to circumvent the law and accept donations from a foreign donor. Regrettably, other parties are guilty of similar behaviour. During the 2024 election, the Conservative Party sought a donation from Mohamed Amersi, a man exposed in the Pandora papers and by “Panorama”, and who invented the term “access capitalism.”
A journalist got hold of the email exchanges between Amersi and the Conservatives. I have those emails. They contain a plea from the then treasurer, the noble Lord, Lord Leigh, for a donation—an email from a party official saying that because Amersi had not been on the electoral register for long, “We cannot accept a donation from yourself … the donation must come from Nadia’s account”. Nadia is Amersi’s girlfriend. The email continues, “We are incredibly grateful for this magnificent pledge of support.”
I also have a copy of the SWIFT notification confirming the transfer of £200,000 from Amersi’s Swiss bank account to the Tories and an email from the noble Lord, Lord Leigh, to Amersi, not his girlfriend, saying, “Thank you, Mohamed”—the Conservatives evading the law to accept a donation from a foreign donor. Shockingly, when I took the evidence to the police, they refused to act.
Loopholes such as that must be closed. Political parties must not be able to use think tanks to evade campaign spending controls. “Know your donor” provisions must be strengthened. Enforcement must be toughened, with harsher sentences and a more appropriate threshold for charging. We must clean up our politics and bring to a halt the growing, corrosive and dangerous influence of money in our precious democracy.