91: Clause 15, page 9, line 9, at end insert—
“(c) the development of rail freight network usage.”Member’s explanatory statement
This amendment seeks to ensure the rail strategy includes developing rail freight.
91: Clause 15, page 9, line 9, at end insert—
“(c) the development of rail freight network usage.”Member’s explanatory statement
This amendment seeks to ensure the rail strategy includes developing rail freight.
My Lords, it is immensely good that we are back here discussing this very slow Railways Bill and the attempt that it puts before us to recreate the railway system of the Soviet Union in Great Britain.
Freight is an important part of our rail business. Everyone agrees on that; there is no dispute in this Committee as to the importance of freight. However, the Bill is woefully inadequate when it comes to addressing the question of freight. The Government have a target to increase rail freight by 75% by 2050. That is a target inherited from the Conservative Government, and the originator of that target, I think I may say, is my noble friend Lord Harper, who is in his place, when he was Secretary of State for Transport. So there is a commonality of view in support of that target.
However, there is a tremendous absence of detail and a great deal of vagueness about how that target is going to be achieved. In recent weeks, the Government have announced that there is to be an interim target. That is a helpful step, but the interim target is to have a 40% increase by 2040, which is so long away that I believe a great deal of the rail freight rolling stock might well have been renewed by then. It is not an effective target at all.
The notion that rail freight is to have its own target is both positive and negative. It is positive in the sense that it shows that the Government are behind freight and want to support its growth. Remember that these are private businesses that have invested their own capital in freight, so they will be pleased to know that the Government are generally supportive, but bear in mind that a cack-handed and inept attempt by the Government to promote that target could start imposing activities and targets on the rail freight sector, which would be profoundly uncomfortable for it. I am not suggesting that there are any such at the moment, but the fear is always there. Then, in the minds of the freight sector—we will come to this in another group—there is the fear that Great British Railways will be determining access to the network when it is also a competitor for the use of that capacity. Noble Lords will understand that there is a degree of nervousness in the rail freight sector on both those fronts.
My Lords, I have Amendment 106 in this group and apologise to noble Lords for not being able to be here at the last Committee session when a number of amendments to which I had put my name were debated. I am grateful to other noble Lords who spoke so well to those amendments—better than I could have done—which was particularly helpful.
This amendment and this group are about the specifics of the target in Clause 17. It tells us that the Secretary of State must set a target to increase rail freight but does not tell us by how much. We know that rail freight has increased in the recent past, but not by the required amount—I think that it is about 1% a year on average. As my noble friend quite rightly said in moving the initial amendment, we want to see rail freight grow. We have seen substantial investment and, for a range of purposes, both economic and environmental, we want to see an increase in rail freight activity. The parliamentary task is not only to say that the target must be for an increase, but to be quite clear that it should be consistent with targets set by the Government generally.
The numbers matter. My noble friend said that there was the inherited target of an increase by 2050 of 75%. The 2% per annum was not quite sufficient to do that—I think it would have had to be in excess of 2% and something like 2.1% every year cumulatively to arrive at the target for 2050. The Secretary of State’s target of achieving 40% by 2040 is consistent with a 2% per annum compound increase in freight, so by setting a 2% figure Parliament is effectively saying that it agrees. If the increase was set at less than 2%, that would be below the trajectory that the Secretary of State has given as the target. As it happens, 2% a year between now and 2040 might meet that target, but it does not do what we need for 2050, as we would have to increase the rate of growth to 2.25% in the subsequent decade. As we have heard, the Secretary of State, in addition to setting an intermediate target, referred to a number of expectations among which, I thought quite notably, was the 65% increase in high-value goods to be carried by freight over the period to 2040. I have not extended the amendment, but I think that it is worth just stopping and saying that this means some pretty substantial increases year on year.
My Lords, I support all the amendments in this group. As noble Lords know, I am a former chairman of the Rail Freight Group. Some of the examples that the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, just mentioned have been dear to my heart for decades—including why the hell do they not electrify some of the routes to increase the capacity further?
I want to give an example that affects both access and charges, relating to both noble Lords’ very interesting speeches. In the past few weeks, I have visited a lithium mine in Cornwall, at its invitation. I do not know how much noble Lords know about the Cornish china clay works, including the holes, the mountains and everything else. There are little baby railways that go everywhere; most of them do not work any more, but some of them could be redone.
Anyway, I was invited to visit this work, which is in its final stages of getting fast-track planning permission. When the work is complete, it will, I think, produce something like 50% of the lithium-ion that is needed in this country. It is massive—there is a great big hole—but it also needs quite a lot of processing. It is not about just pouring it into a truck and hoping that it goes away: it mixes other materials in the process—including, I am told, cobalt, nickel, manganese and graphite, as well as a drop of sulphuric acid to help it along.
4:00 pm
The concern of the company that is developing this is that it can get most of these raw materials from somewhere in the UK or from other UK ports, but as making the lithium is going to be a continuous process it cannot risk these other materials not turning up. It has quite a big stockpile, but even so it wants some assurance that it will be able to get materials in by rail.
The other thing the company has done, very sensibly, is give the residents of the clay pit area—which, for noble Lords who have not been there, has a lot of poverty and awful roads, and when there are jobs, they are good jobs—an assurance that all materials will come and go by rail. It is quite an assurance to give—“all materials”—so the company is keen to know how Great British Railways, which it will be by the time this starts, will be able to guarantee that it will have the capacity to bring in the various materials from all around the country, some in large volumes, some in much smaller volumes, but all by rail.
When one looks at the priorities, at the moment, if there is a problem you can appeal to the ORR and it deals with it properly, one hopes, but if Great British Railways decides that somewhere further up country, not necessarily in Devon or Cornwall but further up country, it would rather start a new passenger service on the line which means that there will be only one path for freight to this particular lithium-ion factory a day and that does not work, then the company is lost. It cannot continue to operate. The same comment applies, of course, to many of the cargoes that noble Lord, Lord Lansley, has just mentioned.
When one looks at the priorities, at the moment, if there is a problem you can appeal to the ORR and it deals with it properly, one hopes, but if Great British Railways decides that somewhere further up country, not necessarily in Devon or Cornwall but further up country, it would rather start a new passenger service on the line which means that there will be only one path for freight to this particular lithium-ion factory a day and that does not work, then the company is lost. It cannot continue to operate. The same comment applies, of course, to many of the cargoes that noble Lord, Lord Lansley, has just mentioned.
It is a misconception that freight does not mind when it goes or where it is going. It does not always mind when it goes, whereas passengers are much more important and they do mind, as we have been debating. But we have to have some assurance in the legislation that customers can get a train path that they believe they need, within reason, and if not, that there is an appeal mechanism. That is why the role of the ORR is so vital. I hope my noble friend will be able to explain that this is going to be all right on the night and that this company in Cornwall at least can run trains when it wants and at a reasonable price; that is another issue which may end up with the ORR. It is very important that we look at the different demands of customers, whether they are passenger customers or freight customers, and try to make sure that their priorities are looked after independently. I support these amendments and shall be coming back on some of the other ones.
I have three amendments in this group, one of which, Amendment 106A, follows on from what my noble friend Lord Lansley said. Before I start, I should declare my interests as an advisor to Hutchison Ports and a member of the UK and Ireland leadership team of AtkinsRéalis.
I tabled Amendment 106A as a bit of a challenge to the Minister because I am well aware of the issues around the statutory meeting of targets and so forth, but the Government’s announcement that they have a 40% target by 2040 has to have some meat to it. You cannot just say, “Here’s our target”. The Minister is, of course, far too experienced a railwayman to have taken such an approach, so I want to probe him today about how we are going to get to that point because this is by no means easy.
My noble friend Lord Lansley rightly referred to Haughley junction and Ely junction, the corridor from Peterborough to Leicester and the constraints going through Oxford. The reality is that significant problems are holding back freight traffic on the network today. For a variety of reasons, the projects that I put into the system as the Secretary of State were gobbled by the budgets that were taken by HS2. This Government have come in and frozen rail fares, which benefits passengers but it is a financial decision for the railways, and they are taking other decisions about public spending. In my understanding, it is very unlikely that there will be new money for enhancements to the network for the next 10 years, pretty much. Any realistic prospect of spending money has already been committed. I know that issue and I am sure that my noble friend Lord Harper knows it, too—he and I became Secretary of State and discovered that, basically, all the money had already been committed and we did not have much opportunity to put new projects in place. I am sure that that is the issue for the Minister and the Secretary of State, but you cannot then pluck a 40% growth target out of the air and hope that it will just happen.
20 of 247 shown
I have two amendments in this group. Amendment 113 calls for an annual report on progress. That is so simple and straightforward that I think there can be no doubt that noble Lords would want to support it, or, at the very least the Government would want to give an assurance that, whether or not it were part of the Bill, there would be an annual report and the Government would commit themselves at the Dispatch Box to producing such a report. That barely requires any argument.
Amendment 91, the lead amendment in the group, requires a more subtle and nuanced response from the Government than they have been willing to give so far. It asks them to fill in to some extent the sort of detail that we and the rail freight sector need in order to have the assurance that the Government are going to achieve their target, not simply by some remote interim date, but by 2030. What is their staging post for 2030, for example, and how do they expect to get there? Secondly, it asks that the means that they are going to use to achieve that target have been worked out carefully with the rail freight sector and are practical, deliverable and something that the private sector can accommodate and work with, because all these things in the railways, as the Minister knows better than anyone else, require long-term planning. The private rail freight sector has to be involved in doing that and we want to hear from the Minister that that involvement is going to be there. I beg to move.
I want to take this opportunity to raise with the Minister—I have discussed this with him and am grateful for those conversations—that if we are going to increase the high-value goods freight traffic, a number of significant projects need to be brought forward, not least in the long-term rail strategy and the financing that the Government are going to give to Great British Railways. Noble Lords will not be surprised that I draw particular attention, as a Suffolk resident and former Member of Parliament in Cambridgeshire, to the importance of the Ely junction and Haughley junction improvements. The Ely junction improvements have a benefit-to-cost ratio of five and, as noble Lords who have been in the department will know, it is quite a rare feat for a project to show a return on investment as good as that.
We know that the Mayor of Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, Paul Bristow, is committed to trying to make this project come forward and is doing what he can, using his resources, to tackle some of the level crossing issues. The issue is whether Great British Railways, with the support of the Government, will bring this forward. My calculation, which is only my working of the numbers, is that, if Felixstowe has about a third of UK container traffic—by definition, these tend to be high-value goods such as manufactured goods, rather than construction materials—roughly half of that goes via Ely and would benefit from the Ely junction improvement. When we look at that, something approaching 5% of total UK container traffic goes through Ely, and the improvements could increase the capacity by 40%.
So it is not an answer in itself, and there are other projects, of which noble Lords might be aware, that will help enable the freight traffic to move. But what the industry cannot do for itself is put the capacity on the line through the improvements to the route. I ask the Minister to say, “We should accept that there ought to be not just an increase in this clause but an increase consistent with the trajectory that meets the stated targets of the Government, and, in order to make that happen, certainly by the mid-2030s, we will need some major projects to increase the available capacity”.
I hope that the amendment commends itself. I take heart and comfort from the fact that it seems to be consistent with Amendment 106A, which was tabled by my noble friend Lord Grayling, who is a former Secretary of State. So I think that noble Lords will find merit in setting the target in the way that is proposed.
This is also coming at a time when the sector is under different kinds of pressure. DB Cargo, one of the three major operators, is up for a fire sale at the moment, with big question marks about its future. GB Railfreight is doing okay, with a new chief executive coming in, but it none the less has some challenges ahead of it. Freightliner has just been broken in half. Half of it—the intermodal business—has been sold to CMA, a big shipping company; the rest has been left as heavy haul to do bulk haulage around the country for Network Rail and others. I would not say that any of those three businesses is at the moment in the most organised shape to drive growth. In fact, frankly, most observers of this sector would say that you have three businesses chasing the same clients and the same volumes of business, and it is not clear where the growth is coming from. If you talked to most of those companies, they would say that what we need is disincentives to carry freight by road and more incentives to carry freight on the rail. That is a separate debate, but that is what they would say. It is not entirely clear to me where the growth will come from.
I have a number of concerns about this, not the least of which is an issue that I have discussed with the Minister before: will it lead to Great British Railways trying to take on freight itself? I know that that is not the Government’s current intention, but the way the Bill is structured would allow that to happen in the future. If that happens, you could end up with the big guys squeezing out the smaller operators, and would we be certain that Great British Railways would do a decent job anyway? One of the constraints around Ely is that the last time we had a nationalised railway, British Rail, it took up the tracks between Soham and Ely and, as a result, constrained capacity for rail freight through to the Midlands. It was expedient to do so because it wanted to spend money on passenger services at a time of tight budgets. Of course, we are now in a situation where we could very well have a national rail operator wanting to spend money on passenger services at a time of tight budgets. Not only is there a risk of lack of new investment but even sustaining the existing services might be a challenge.
My challenge to the Minister is this. He is a man we all respect, who has deep knowledge of the industry, but he must stand up in front of this Committee and explain how a 40% target for 2040 is viable. What will the Government do to facilitate that? It is a private sector job to drive the business, but the Government, by definition, will create part of the environment, having nationalised the passenger railway and taken Network Rail and the passenger railway together under one roof in the way that existed under British Rail. How will he do that? What will he instruct Great British Railways to do? The purpose of Amendments 108 and 109 is to say clearly from this Committee that we expect Great British Railways to have a focus on freight as well and not to simply ignore it and concentrate on passenger services, because passengers vote and rail freight wagons do not. I want to hear the Minister explain in detail where that 2040 target has come from, how it will be achieved and, to make that happen, what necessary changes he and his colleagues in the Department for Transport will commit to.