That this House regrets that the Prison (Governor’s and Adjudicators’ Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026 remove and restrict social visits as a punishment despite (1) the potential effects on rehabilitation, prisoner behaviour and family relationships, (2) prison governors’ hesitancy, and (3) the lack of an assessment of likely impacts.
Relevant document: 9th Report from the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee (special attention drawn to the instrument)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have put their names down to speak and have made time to take part this evening.
The Victims and Courts Act 2026 gave judges the power to impose in-prison punishments for non-attendance at sentencing hearing. The MoJ gave these new judicial sanctions a big push in the media last month when they were laid as the Sentencing Act 2020 (Prison Sanctions) Regulations 2026. I agree with the MoJ’s intent to make:
“Cowardly killers who dodge sentencing face tough new prison punishments”.
These punishments include no visits for up to 27 days and restriction of social visits to once every 28 days for up to 84 days. For these prison sanctions to have effect, the Sentencing Code requires that they correspond to the punishments that may be imposed by a governor under prison rules, so governors who oversee them need parallel powers—hence the Prison (Governor’s and Adjudicators’ Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026. These are the subject of my regret Motion because they give governors new disciplinary powers that do not correspond to judges’ very limited sanctions but far exceed them. Whereas a judge can restrict visits at the very beginning of a sentence, governors are now able to do so at any point to punish any offence.
The prisoner discipline procedures adjudications policy framework sets parameters as to the seriousness of the offence but, first, these could change and, secondly, why are such sanctions generally available? Removing visits for non-attendance at sentence hearings is reasonable and hard to disagree with. However, the measure has been expanded beyond this initial justification and prison rules changed in a way that was not made clear during passage of the parental Act. The Government might claim they are being tough on crime, but at best it is an ineffective measure to that end and at worst a counterproductive measure. It is not being soft on crime to oppose it but the opposite.
My Lords, I normally back wholeheartedly initiatives that improve rehabilitation of prisoners. However, in this instance, I beg to differ from the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, because I believe that we must look at these new rules through the lens of fundamental justice, public confidence and the rights of victims’ families.
These new rules counter a disturbing trend of offenders refusing to leave their cells to face the court at the time of their sentencing. Let us remind ourselves that the public and victims’ families are demanding action. We saw the murderers of nine year-old Olivia Pratt-Korbel, Zara Aleena and Sabina Nessa refusing to face the families whose lives they had destroyed. This trend is becoming increasingly common; it was adopted by the serial killers at the Countess of Chester Hospital and the Southport murderer. Grieving families sitting in a courtroom watching an empty dock because a perpetrator simply chooses to opt out is an intolerable insult. It makes closure extremely difficult for them and makes a mockery of our justice system.
Traditional internal punishments, such as adding days to a sentence, mean absolutely nothing to a murderer already facing a whole life or half a century behind bars. If a prisoner deliberately defies the authority of the court, there must be immediate, tangible loss of privileges within the prison estate. I know that critics argue that these rules risk damaging rehabilitation, but true rehabilitation cannot begin without accountability. An offender who refuses to look their victims in the eye is actively rejecting the first step of reform and rehabilitation.
I thank the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for bringing this matter before the House and for all he has done over the years in trying to improve rehabilitation in prisons. However, I also have great sympathy with the Government, because they are faced with the action of both political parties in winding up the prison population, which is probably the root cause of all these problems. I will not say anything about that tonight.
I want to raise the point that shines through the excellent report of the Secondary Legislation Select Committee, which is that we do not seem to understand two things. First, what is the cause of the inexorable rise in the number of disciplinary offences and their sanctions, which have had to be increased? Secondly, if you can find out what the cause is, it is normally useful to try to understand the most effective way of preventing it. It is very clear that we need a proper examination of the cause and the best way of trying to deal with the problem.
It might be thought that we should set up some Grand Committee or ask people to look again and take a year or so to resolve this. I do not believe that is necessary. We have two expert charities—the Prison Reform Trust and the Howard League—and, as the Minister knows, we have admirable governors in our prisons and other experts in penology.
What is called for, as soon as is practicable, is an answer to the question of why prison indiscipline is getting worse, what the best way of preventing it is and how what is proposed in this statutory instrument is working. Instinctively, I feel that cutting off social relations is bad for prisoners. I also believe that incentives are probably more effective, but that is a belief; it is not based on evidence. Experience has taught me that you need to find out the why, the solution and the best way to deal with a problem. We cannot afford to make a mistake, because adding days to prisoners is increasing our prison population and we cannot afford not to seek rehabilitation through visits by families. The two policies seem wrong, but I do not know and we need to know why.
My Lords, the Prison Rules 1999 already provide prison governors with an extensive suite of disciplinary measures. Prisoners who offend against prison discipline may be cautioned, suffer forfeiture of privileges, be excluded from work that they carry out in the prison estate, suffer a deduction or loss of earnings, be confined to their cells, suffer removal from the wing upon which they are located or experience payback punishment. What do these existing measures have in common? They are all directed against the offender himself—his privileges, earnings, freedom of movement on the wing or opportunity to work. Prisoners serve terms of imprisonment because of things they have done; we punish people for the crimes they commit, not the crimes others commit.
My concern is that this amendment to the rules will punish not only the prisoner but those who would seek to visit the prisoner—those on the outside who have just as much interest in his rehabilitation as any. Those people, those loved ones, have not offended or breached prison discipline but, just as the prisoner will be punished by being deprived of their society, they will be punished by being deprived of the society of the prisoner.
It is undesirable to impose penalties on a person for something that someone else has done. Prison discipline is exercised summarily, necessarily and responsibly by prison governors, but I emphasise summarily. It may well be that a prison governor contemplating the use of this punishment could easily be expected to overlook the effect on someone outside who would wish to pay a social visit—a parent, relative, good friend or genuine well-wisher. Let prisons help prisoners amend themselves for the better. Let us not punish people on the outside for the disciplinary lapses of those inside prisons whom they love.
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Farmer. When we debated the Victims and Courts Bill, I had qualms about the targeted punishment of withdrawing social visits, even from those prisoners despicably refusing to attend sentencing hearings. I do not like the families, even of selfish, cowardly perpetrators, being used as a stick. Then I thought of the families of the victims, shown such contempt by such prisoners, and I swallowed my concerns.
But if ever there were an example of why we should beware laws passed here being weighed down by secondary legislation powers, it is the dangerous slippery slope on display here. It shows another type of contempt: contempt for democracy. No one in Parliament agreed to this mission creep that has amended the Prison Rules to allow restrictions on family visits as a general disciplinary punishment. None of us gave permission for that. Why would we, when it shows politicians’ contempt for any of the common-sense advice or on-the-ground expertise of prison officers and criminal justice campaigners about how real discipline works in prisons?
One of the most effective restraints on bad behaviour or criminal activity inside, or indeed on release from prison, is the influence of families and loved ones. Does the Minister understand that the way for a prisoner to have any sense of regret or shame for past crimes, or to be inspired to change, is via their mum, their fiancé, their kids? Not letting them down can be a powerful antidote to getting into further trouble. These social visits can lead to encouragement, even to tellings off, and while it cannot conquer all of the toxicity and brutality of prisons, having to face down your mum can do a hell of a lot.
My Lords, irrefutable evidence from the academic sector, independent reviews, Government-led inquiries and the Ministry of Justice itself demonstrates that maintaining family and social relationships is fundamental to prisoners’ wellbeing, rehabilitation and successful reintegration. It is therefore puzzling, to say the very least, that the Government choose to introduce a punishment that risks undermining the very conditions necessary for safer prisons, improved behaviour and successful rehabilitation.
The lack of adequate consultation with prison groups is also of great concern. Many have expressed doubts on the proposed restrictions, pointing out the possible negative consequences. These include the damaging effect on children, who are innocent and for whom keeping in touch with relatives in prison may be an important means of emotional stability and support.
Prisoners, especially those from minority groups, tend to convey instances of bullying, unfair treatment and other inequalities to family members during visits, which are then reported onward by those family members. Financial hardship, geographical distance and other inequalities already significantly restrict family visits. Do the Government really believe that removing a prisoner’s source of emotional support is likely to improve behaviour, or will it remove one of the strongest incentives for positive change?
The new powers are disproportionate, they infringe prisoners’ fundamental rights to family life and they are counterproductive. They directly contradict the Government’s wider objectives of improving aspects of prisons and of prisoners’ lives. Family contact must be recognised as an essential component of rehabilitation and not simply as a privilege that can be withdrawn as punishment.
My Lords, I would like to thank the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for bringing this. I hate staying up late, but this is worth it, because this is a cruel idea. The Government say that they want to tackle rising indiscipline and violence in prisons, and of course they do; nobody wants to see prisoners or prison staff living in unsafe conditions. But I am against this decision to take away social visits as a punishment, not least because the Government’s own evidence tells us that family contact is one of the things that helps people behave better, supports rehabilitation and reduces reoffending.
Plus, we should not pretend that violence and indiscipline in prisons have appeared out of nowhere; they have to be understood in the context of years of pressure on the prison system, overcrowding, poor conditions and staff shortages—and the staff who are there are often inexperienced. What is the Government’s response? More punishment.
The Ministry of Justice produced its research into the impact of social visits on reoffending, self-harm and accommodation after release. It found that people who receive visits were significantly less likely to have a proven reoffence within a year of release. They committed fewer further offences and took longer to reoffend. They were also less likely to self-harm and more likely to have accommodation when they left prison, and the more visits people received, the lower the reoffending rate.
In March, HM Inspectorate of Prisons published its thematic review and found that regular family contact was associated with better mental health, improved behaviour and greater feelings of safety. People who received regular visits or social video calls were less likely to be at risk of suicide or self-harm. They were also less likely to experience bullying and victimisation, and less likely to be restrained or held in segregation. The inspectorate was clear that family contact should be treated as an essential part of prison safety and rehabilitation, so why are the Government taking away something that their own evidence says helps make prisons safer?
My Lords, the Government advanced two inconsistent reasons for the statutory instrument. First, they say that the incidence of violence and rule-breaking in prisons is going up, and therefore governors and independent adjudicators need harsher or stricter options available to punish the serious and repeat rule-breaking. Secondly, they say that, because the Sentencing Act 2026 reduced the amount of time that prisoners will serve on their sentence, governors need to have the ability to keep them in.
It strikes me as odd and sad that the central question asked by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, has not been thought about by the Government: has anybody asked themselves why prisoners commit acts of indiscipline or break the rules in the first place? It is largely because they are incarcerated for 23 out of 24 hours a day, in a multi-occupied cell, they essentially live in a public lavatory, and they are largely mentally ill, illiterate and innumerate. The Minister used to work in Holloway prison, so she will know that everyone who spoke this evening, apart from the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, said some quite sensible things.
If you keep people in those conditions and fail to give them a sense of purpose and to rehabilitate them, you not only let them down, and endanger the lives and working conditions of the governors and the prison staff, but you waste taxpayer money and do not provide us with the requisite safety that we require of a rehabilitated prisoner—because they come back just as they went in, and so they reoffend. I ask the Government to be a little more intelligent and think a little more strategically about this, and not to resort to the usual government rubbish of reacting in a knee-jerk way without having applied their minds to the problem in front of them.
It is not surprising that, when prison governors and other prison group directors were asked about these measures, they were hesitant and sceptical. If the Minister believes that this will be a good idea, when the professionals in the business clearly think it will not, she needs to have another think.
8:20 pm
20 of 35 shown
Social visits can restrain bad behaviour because prosocial relationships improve rehabilitation—the lack of such relationships is a criminogenic need. These are an individual’s characteristics, traits, problems or issues that directly relate to their likelihood of reoffending. Offender assessment system data says that 72% of all offenders in custody have a relationships need, and 80% of women in prison. Obviously, governors are immediately concerned with reoffending that happens inside their jails. This is the justification for making harsher punishments available. However, I saw during my first review for the Government how family visits can turn around dreadful behaviour.
The mother of one young man complained to the deputy governor of a prison I visited about allegations of unfair treatment made by her son. The deputy helped her understand that the shoe was actually on the other foot. On her next visit this mother put her son right and told him to get a grip—his behaviour changed utterly. This anecdote is backed up by the MoJ’s own research on reoffending, which found that the protective factor of positive family relationships can moderate risk factors including having an attitudinal criminogenic need: a way of thinking, belief or attitude likely to lead to further offences. That young man would probably be among the 85% of male prisoners in that category.
Prisoners who have family visits are significantly less likely to reoffend than those who do not. The old MoJ figure of 39% dwarfed the effectiveness of other rehabilitation pathways such as education, employment and drug treatment. It was the reason they asked me to do the reviews, first for the male estate and secondly for all female offenders. HMPPS’s commitment to implementing all my reviews’ recommendations since 2017 has gone far beyond words on the page. It knows that the greater prize is to shift the culture towards a greater emphasis on improving relationships, whether between officers and prisoners, between senior officers and junior officers they are mentoring or between prisoners themselves. The transforming prisons directorate is reconceiving prisons and designing new builds around the need for relationships.
Yet, despite 10 years of progress, social contact is now a disciplinary sanction. The Prison Reform Trust says that this devalues family members, treats them as instruments of prison discipline and completely neglects the impact on family members despite them having done nothing wrong. Thankfully, those with children will not be so punished, but such prisoners already have a far greater incentive to keep out of trouble in prison. Category A prisoners in HMP Frankland told me they walk away from conflict because their families and children will hear of altercations and will want to know that they are safe.
Indeed, I have heard that governors do not want to use this sanction as they see it as counterproductive to running a safe regime. The report on prison riots in 1989 by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Woolf, warned that messing with the ability of families to visit was one of the most resented acts the Prison Service could take.
To conclude, this is the recurring problem that Governments of all colours face: how to appear tough on crime—which this is not—without turning our prisons into overcrowded places where rehabilitation becomes impossible. With attention on capacity pressures and early release, I fear measures are being introduced that make regimes appear tougher on crime but that are simply tougher on prisoners and more toxic to a rehabilitation culture. If this increases in-prison and community reoffending, our prisons will simply fill up.
King and Willmott’s Honest Politician’s Guide to Prisons and Probation tracked 40 years of tough penal policy and the personalities responsible for crafting it. They found time and again that once politicians had moved on from the justice portfolio, they would acknowledge the futility of bowing down to public opinion instead of doing more to shape it. I am grateful to the Minister for making herself available to discuss this SI, and I wonder if there might be room for manoeuvre. The Government could rewrite and reissue it, so that removal of visits could be used only as the judge-imposed sanction for non-attendance at sentence hearing. This could be achieved by taking it out of Rule 55, covering governor punishments for any offence, and by following the example of Rule 55AB, which specifically requires a prisoner to pay for damage to prison property once found guilty. This could then be new Rule 55AC. I hope this will be considered and I beg to move.
The Government have approached this issue with care. There are vital safeguards: the rules explicitly exempt an offender’s children from these restrictions. Wider privileges are being targeted—visits must be earned through compliance with our justice system. We need to back the Government in restoring this vital lever of authority; however, we must ensure that its implementation has checks and balances to avoid abuses. So I have a question for my noble friend the Minister: how do the Government plan to monitor the implementation of these rules—in particular, how the prison governors are using them, and that there are no violations?
In recognising that public confidence in our courts is fragile, these rules protect children, target defiance and ensure that court orders are respected. I urge the House to reject this Motion.
Cutting off this pro-social influence is inexplicably foolish, and it is performative toughness. If the Government really want to be tough on the chaos in too many prisons, then do the hard jobs: tackle the thriving drugs industry behind bars; take on the unchecked growth of Islamist gangs; expose how human rights laws are being deployed to limit staff’s ability to exert authority and impose rules. Do not take the soft option of weaponising family visits. If only the Government used their executive powers to tackle cuts in purposeful activity and prison education, to invest in training and support for inexperienced, overworked staff.
I have been involved in the prison project Debating Matters Beyond Bars. The most moving moments have been those prisoner debaters beaming at their certificates because they cannot wait to send them home, and the letters from their wives and their kids saying “It helped him see another future: something to be proud of for his family”. Families are the best rehabilitation aid ever; they are cheap, and you dispense with them at your peril.
We constantly hear the refrain that prisons have to be a place of punishment, but you cannot keep making punishments harsher; it just does not work like that. At some point, you end up filling up more prison spaces with extra days—days when prisoners should be on licence and supervised. I ask the Government to please rethink this. It is a very nasty move.
I will not complain about the English of the Explanatory Notes, but when the Government say:
“Engagement with internal stakeholders to explore the impact on external policy areas, such as prisoner family and relations, trade unions, and third sector stakeholders, has commenced and will continue to occur prior to this instrument coming into force”,
I ask myself, first, what on earth that means, secondly, has it happened, and, thirdly, when will we hear about the result. Please do not allow this House to be fooled into thinking that this is a good idea; it plainly is not.