My Lords, I thank all who will contribute this afternoon. It is an impressive list, and I am looking forward to hearing some valuable contributions to what is, at the present time, a very important subject. I thank you for making time after a busy week. I particularly welcome the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, who is making his maiden speech here. I am looking forward to hearing his wisdom, of which he has much in this regard. I received a very supportive email from the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Gloucester, who is prisons Bishop. She is at the College of Bishops this week and is unable to attend, but she wants us to know that she would have been here if she could have been.
This is a highly relevant debate to the public. The current state of our Prison and Probation Service constantly plays out on front pages of newspapers and online media sites. One of my pleas today is for politicians to resist the media drama, particularly of a single case, and keep rehabilitation at the forefront. The fact is that punishment is deprivation of liberty, not grim conditions. On today’s news, we heard that temporary prefabricated cells, sized for one, are now being fitted with bunk beds. Ten years ago, or more, former Chief Inspector of Prisons Nick Hardwick described such circumstances to the Commons Justice Committee, saying that many prisoners are now effectively living in toilets. Headlines about prison spaces running out should not be ignored.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, on securing this debate and I am grateful for how he opened it. I thought he was going to be a little more critical and, in turn, I have written a counter speech. I want to speak primarily about rehabilitation, which he mainly focused on. As he said, one of the big influencing factors has been 30 years of sentence inflation, with more and more, and longer and longer, sentences being handed out. I too look forward to the maiden speech of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, with great interest in what he may say on this.
There have been 30 years of underinvestment, by all Governments, in the courts, prisons, the probation services and of course rehabilitation, which has been the Cinderella right at the end of the line. However, services have been particularly hollowed out since 2010, when George Osborne’s austerity programme was introduced. Then there was the calamitous, I believe, social experiment of the part-privatisation of the probation service by the Conservative Government, as well as a failure to build new prison places—we are still waiting for new ones to come on stream, as has just been mentioned.
In 2024, Labour inherited a demoralised and understaffed workforce, with prisons almost full to capacity. We were almost at a point where, without radical action, the country faced the prospect that courts would not be able to send criminals to jail, because there were no places to incarcerate them. I am glad to say that we have not shied away from that challenge. I congratulate all those who have been involved in trying to right the wrongs, especially the now departed Prisons Minister, my noble friend Lord Timpson; he did outstanding work, which was recognised across the whole Chamber. He did it with enthusiasm and endeavoured—this particularly appealed to the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, and me—to re-energise the work on rehabilitation of prisoners, especially those with addiction problems relating to drugs, alcohol or the recent growth in problem gambling, on which the noble Lord, Lord Foster of Bath, has done such valiant work. I am sure that we will hear more on that from him today.
My Lords, I am delighted to follow the noble Lord, Lord Brooke, and I join him in congratulating the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, not only on the tremendous work that he has done in this particular area but for securing the debate and his excellent opening speech. I also look forward to the maiden speech of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson.
Just over a year ago, the Justice and Home Affairs Select Committee, which I chair, published Better Prisons, Less Crime. We quoted witnesses who described the prison service operating in, or on the verge of, crisis. We acknowledged the failures of successive Governments, but our purpose was not to catalogue failure: it was to identify practical ways forward. Echoing what the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, said, our starting point was simple: we ought to understand the role of prisons.
We said that punishment for the prisoner is the loss of liberty and the role of prisons is to protect the public by reducing reoffending. We said that required purposeful activity, education and training, and, as the noble Lord, Lord Brooke said, treatment for mental health, drug, alcohol and gambling problems, and preparation for life after release. It also requires relationships, as again the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, said, particularly family relationships. They are really important, yet distance from home, restrictive visiting arrangements and limited digital access can make contact unnecessarily difficult. Family contact cannot and must not be treated as an optional extra.
I am delighted to follow the noble Lord, Lord Foster, and his most interesting speech. This is an excellent debate on crucial issues, and I am so glad that the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, has managed to bring it forward. I also say how glad I am that the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, has joined us. He will add a great deal to this House with his expertise on criminal law.
I have been looking at another report: one by the Justice Select Committee of the other place called Ending the Cycle of Reoffending. It sets out, in stark terms, the present state of the prison estate: the lack of adequate education of prisoners or purposeful activity, referred to by the noble Lord, Lord Foster; the failure to educate children and young people; the lack of sufficient health and welfare provision, particularly for those with mental health or behavioural problems; gross overcrowding; and, as has been said, prisoners being in cells for most of the 24 hours. There is a disrepair of prisons. Princetown was closed very shortly after the last Government renewed the lease, even though they knew that the prison would have to be closed. There are problems with recruitment and retention of prison officers, and I am not surprised. There is a lack of training of prison officers, not only initially but on promotion. It was suggested in the Justice Committee report that governors needed some training. It points out that there is a lack of involvement by governors and opportunity for them to make decisions on who should be employed in their prison. This background from the Justice Committee is a sad introduction to this much-needed debate.
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss. I also express my appreciation for the outstanding speech of the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, and thank him for introducing this debate.
I propose to address only one point, already raised by the noble Lord, Lord Foster of Bath: the question of recalls to custody. Let us concentrate on that for a moment. In the past four years, recalls to custody of prisoners released under licence have more than doubled. As has already been pointed out, in the last year there were 51,000 recalls to prison; that exceeds the number of persons sentenced by the courts to prison, which was 47,000. For the first time, recalls now are greater than persons going to prison in the first place. A recall rate of 50,000 represents a rate of about one in five of those under supervision. As the charity Nacro points out, in 2017 the rate was about one in 13. Have we seen an increase in risk in the last 10 years? What is going on here? There is no evidence of increase in risk, but now, according to Nacro, for every 10 beds freed up by the release of a prisoner, nine are refilled by recalls to custody. This highly regrettable situation threatens seriously to undermine the Government’s early-release scheme. As has already been pointed out by the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, what is the point of early release if it is followed by a recall?
My Lords, it is with real diffidence that I rise just three days after my introduction. But the way in which we treat those convicted of crime, and in particular what happens to them when both in custody and in the community, has been a real interest of mine for some 60 years. It stems from my time as an undergraduate visiting Oxford prison and being involved in organising camps for children from approved schools; and later on in relation to the mental health of those in custody—an interest encouraged in me by my late father, who was a consultant psychiatrist. This was in Liverpool, which for over 40 years I was proud to call my home. I am also grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for initiating this debate and thus allowing me the opportunity to express some views on this critical area.
I must first, however, express my thanks to my two splendid supporters, the noble and learned Lords, Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers and Lord Burnett of Maldon, who were both Chief Justices for whom I worked, along with the noble and learned Lord, Lord Woolf, the late and very much-lamented Lord Judge, and the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, to whom I also pay tribute.
I would also like to thank the noble Earl, Lord Kinnoull, and those in the convenor’s office for their kindness and encouragement and express my real appreciation to the Clerk of the Parliaments, Black Rod and all those who work in this House and who have been so generous with the time they have given to a new boy—that is not a phrase I would have used of myself very recently. It is an inestimable honour for me now to be part of this House, although I am concerned whether I can live up to the expectations which have been expressed by most of the speakers this afternoon.
My Lords, it is a very special privilege first to have listened to the speech of my noble and learned friend Lord Leveson of Liverpool and now to have the chance to add a few remarks. I wish first to convey the apologies of my noble and learned friends Lord Burnett and Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers. Events elsewhere have detained them, and they are unable to be present, but I have that pleasure.
It is now more than a quarter of a century ago that, as what I still think of as youngish judges—though, alas, no longer so, I think I can safely say—we started to work together with responsibility for the circuit system and, in particular, for the way in which criminal justice was administered by the courts under the leadership of that great Chief Justice, Lord Judge. Lord Judge would have been especially proud and delighted to have been here today because he would have seen this as an inevitability.
Like Lord Judge, my noble and learned friend Lord Leveson had enormous experience of the common law across all its aspects, but particularly in criminal justice, and he brought that experience to bear both in trials and on appeals, and, as importantly, in the leadership he gave in the successive appointments he held to improving the criminal justice system, and in the many reports and reviews he has conducted to that end. But his experience is much wider. I have not the time to go through it all, but one particular example occupies the time of your Lordships’ House from time to time, and that is his work as the Investigatory Powers Commissioner. He is a man of enormous talent and will bring huge benefits to this House.
My Lords, not for the first time, I am feeling a bit outclassed and overawed by the legal and judicial expertise in this place that has produced so many excellent speeches. I particularly thank the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for inviting us to talk about the state of prisons and probation services.
However, I want to start by making some broader points about context. During the week, we have had the extraordinary sight of 92% of the citizens of an Oxford village, Piddington, population 358, voting in a symbolic referendum to become independent from the United Kingdom. In interviews with residents, there has been a common theme: the state is exposing them to danger. Housing 1,250 young male asylum seekers in nearby Bicester garrison means:
“Our safety, our security and our freedoms will be under threat”.
To paraphrase one woman: “If these men need government leaflets to explain that sexually abusing children or raping women is wrong, I’m frightened to go out alone. I will become a prisoner in my own house”. That is my theme, in a way.
The sentiment of being a prisoner in your own house is not confined to leafy villages but is felt in towns and cities throughout the country. It is not confined to asylum policies. One key issue that has been a lightning rod for worries that state policies are indifferent to public safety is the early release scheme—for example, those women who now feel frightened in their own homes as victims of domestic abuse, worried that their early released tormentors may show up on the doorstep. Somehow the law-abiding are unfairly becoming the victims of failed state policies.
In August 2026, the total prison population was 86,843, which is 97.6% of the usable capacity. As around 96% are men, it is unrealistic to treat the women’s estate as a readily available solution to male overcapacity. The Government’s female offender strategy admits that some have committed crimes of such gravity that custody is the only sentencing option. Of course, women should be in prison if they have committed serious offences.
The range of contributors to current major capacity pressures includes the increase in convictions for sexual offences. Many are historic, but their devastating effects on victims do not expire. There has also been sentencing inflation of 45% over the past 15 years. A response in no small part to penal populism has also clogged up our prisons and today’s need for early release of prisoners is a predictable consequence.
It is ironic that a “lock them up and throw away the key” mentality necessitated the proposed earlier release of heinous criminals at the top of the new Prime Minister’s in-tray of wicked policy issues. Early releases started under the previous Conservative Government, with their end of custody supervised licence emergency response, which allowed eligible prisoners to be released up to 18 and then 70 days before their automatic release date. But eligibility excluded many serious offences. During the 2010s, the Government found money for new prison places, which will only become available under this Government, and this Government will get the credit—whatever. Short-termism does not work in penal policy. Even when a prison has opened under a highly experienced governor, it takes time to fill up gradually. We are building a community, not stocking a warehouse.
The current scheme of early release cannot be characterised as a continuation of end of custody supervised licence. Moving the standard release point from 50% to 40% and now 33% represents such a significant change in the proportion of the custodial sentence spent in prison that sentencing is becoming increasingly meaningless. This is very worrying for public confidence in the courts and judiciary when they are under exceptional strain. We need sentences that are understandable and reflect the seriousness of the crime but also recognise the possibility and need for rehabilitation. Given the Independent Review of the Criminal Courts by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, I hope he will comment on this, and I will say no more.
One of my main points today is that the issue of prison capacity took the previous Government’s attention away from rehabilitation, and that trend has continued. The terms of reference for the Rudd review barely mention it. While it is a theme in the call for evidence, it does not look like a priority. Neither document mentions the importance of good relationships, despite them being essential to rehabilitation and to many other Rudd review priorities, such as safety, decency and strategy for future prison build. Yet I find HMPPS staff are very committed in this area. Their transforming prisons directorate is creatively building the importance of relationships into future prisons, but it is hard for them to build this culture without the oxygen of ministerial and political support.
The 2016 White Paper, Prison Safety and Reform—in which my first review for the Government was announced—was also focused on Rudd review emergency issues, such as safety, security, new-build prisons and staffing pressures. However, it treated rehabilitation—prisoner reform—as equally important and called for
“a huge cultural and structural change within our prisons—a transformation away from offender warehouses to disciplined and purposeful centres of reform where all prisoners get a second chance at leading a good life”.
The MoJ’s own data showed the powerful positive rehabilitation effects of contact with families and significant ties. They exceed those of, say, education and employment, and provide the motivation for the latter—hence my reviews said that relationships should be the golden thread running through all the processes of prison and probation. Narrowly seeing this as only good family visits misses the fact that everything is mediated through relationships—relationships between governors and their officers, officers and the prisoners, prisoners and other prisoners, the prison and the community that surrounds it, and the prison estate and the society that it is part of—however difficult it might to define and cost them. The culture of prisons and probation needs to change so that a relational approach becomes business as usual, working with the grain of what it is to be human rather than against it. That is how professionals in the Youth Custody Service strive to operate. Yet when young people make the transition to the adult estate, too often they still fall over a cliff edge into a relational desert.
It is 10 years since the Government commissioned my first review and accepted all its recommendations, but its emphasis on relational culture is frequently cut across by policy decisions. In response to understandable public outrage over non-attendance at sentence hearings, prison rules have been changed so that, as a general sanction, governors can remove all social visits for up to 27 days and restrict social visits to one visit in every 28 days for up to 84 days. Prisoners’ children can still visit, but that sanction rules out a very large range of other potentially prosocial visitors. When relationships wither, as they can quickly do when you are in jail, this might remove a key reforming influence on a troublemaker.
One of the most extrovert prisons I visited, HMP Norwich—with its tourist café run by prisoners in open conditions—holds a surgery for family members every week so that the deputy governor can hear their concerns. The deputy governor told me about the mother fighting her teenage son’s corner after he had given her a sob story about how badly he had been treated, and how she turned that mother into an ally by saying, “He’s doing himself no favours. You need to help us help him get through this as well as possible”.
I am also concerned about fathers in prison who might lose parental responsibility when the Courts and Tribunals Bill abolishes the rebuttable presumption in the Children Act 1989 that children’s best interests are typically served by both parents’ involvement. Being in prison does not automatically make someone a bad or damaging father or mother, but removing the presumption will make it easier to argue that they are not needed. Can the Minister confirm whether any guidance will be issued to mitigate that possible unintended consequence for these parents and their children—who are at a profound legal disadvantage—if the Bill becomes law?
Such examples suggest that the culture is still punitive rather than rehabilitative. The problem with culture is its apparent intangibility for policy purposes, but its effects are anything but intangible. Where there is a culture of each government department or public service working separately and territorially, people fall through the cracks between operational silos. That still happens, despite the duty to refer when people released from prison are at risk of becoming homeless. Some local housing authorities work very well with prisons and probation and secure accommodation for prisoners, despite similar pressures on their housing stock as less integrated local councils. According to Nacro, last year in the north-west, 12% of people leaving prison were released into homelessness, compared with more than 20% of people released in south-central. If agencies in every region collaborated as well as they do in the north-west, there would be 3,700 fewer people released to homelessness every year, potentially preventing 1,500 reoffences.
The proven reoffending rate of those released homeless—76%—was more than twice that of those released from custody into settled accommodation, at 36.4%. Some 4,500 inmates will be released early in 10 tranches between 1 October and 1 June next year, in addition to the 4,500 regular releases that take place each month. Prisons and probation are on the front line of the Prime Minister’s pledge to end rough sleeping. Almost one in six are released homeless, and the most recent snapshot found that half of all rough sleepers had been in prison at some point and that 15% of them had been released within the last year. This Government’s national plan to end homelessness calls out the deficiencies of the duty to refer and promises to legislate for a duty to collaborate as soon as parliamentary time allows.
I tabled amendments to the Social Housing Bill to seize that legislative opportunity, but unfortunately to no avail. I was even told by the responding Minister that the duty to refer was working fine, so my amendments, which would have brought the Government’s own proposed reforms into statute, were not needed. It was rather an Alice through the looking-glass moment. Can the Minister report any new progress on bringing the duty to collaborate into law? What is being done to ensure that prisoners have good relationships and that someone is there when they are released, not just accommodation?
One of the most effective ways to prevent homelessness after release is to maintain existing family and other relationships, or enable prisoners to build supportive connections both inside and outside prison. Effective peer mentoring schemes are creating valuable communities of support that start in prison but go beyond the gate for prisoners who have no contact with their families and cannot hope to have. Sex offenders, for example, lumped together as a universally heinous, also need to be given a second chance. Programmes such as these should become business as usual. When well supervised, they can be powerfully therapeutic.
Trusted relationships can bring home to a prisoner the criminogenic influences they have to shrug off if they are to change. They create a sense of agency and dispel despair. Peer support can be game-changing for the 25% of male and female prisoners who are care experienced. The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act requires prisons and probation to share corporate parenting responsibilities as part of a new, highly relational approach to care leavers. Peer support is key to fulfilling this. Can the Minister provide an overview of the spread of peer mentoring in prisons and support in English and Welsh prisons? Are there are any plans to integrate them into the Probation Service?
The 19th-century social reformer Elizabeth Fry branded our violent and squalid prisons the “nurseries of crime”. She said:
“The better the actual state of our prisons is known and understood, the more clearly will all men see the necessity of these arrangements by which they may be rendered schools of industry and virtue”.
I will finish on one neglected relationship that I have already mentioned: between the prison and probation system and wider society. Most prisoners will be released back into that wider society, which needs to know and understand what it takes to reform someone who has transgressed, how to prioritise rehabilitation and how to prioritise good relationships while still being appropriately tough on crime. I beg to move.
My noble friend Lord Timpson also recruited Professor Dame Carol Black. She was brought in, with her particular expertise, to assist with these long-standing addiction problems and with rehabilitation. The rehabilitation of offenders whose crimes are driven by drug or alcohol addiction is a crucial part of any strategy to reduce reoffending. Currently, services are still not fit for purpose. For example, half of all people on probation have a drug or alcohol problem, and over half of those arriving in prison are assessed as needing drug or alcohol treatment. Intensive drug or alcohol rehabilitation programmes in prisons were delivered to 11,000 people in 2012. We do not keep the figures now on what is being done, but the guess is that is in the order of as low as 2,000 a year—that is a terrible fall-away.
The Sentencing Act envisages increased early release, or community sentences instead of short periods of imprisonment, for offenders addicted to drugs or alcohol, but there are no plans to ensure that these people get adequate treatment. If their addictions are not treated, we will see high rates of reoffending and licence breaches. Dame Carol will be giving an update on progress in her report entitled From Hope to Delivery: Drug and Alcohol Treatment Under a New Government. She will be doing this in Committee Room 5 on Wednesday, 14 October. I hope that many of us present today, and others, will be there to hear about the work she has been done to try to address, in particular, addiction issues linked to rehabilitation so that we can then, in turn, look forward to a more detailed programme of action on rehabilitation and recovery. I would be grateful if the Minister could give us an indication of how the Government are likely to respond to the report that will be coming from Dame Carol.
I am also involved in some rehabilitation work being trialled shortly in a Kent addiction recovery centre that welcomes prisoners in its numbers. We are endeavouring to develop an AI companion linked to the 12-step recovery programme—I assure noble Lords that it will be entirely safe—so that prisoners there will be given a companion 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 52 weeks a year, if they are in need of someone to give them advice that has been based on the 12-step programme. We have managed to interest Stanford University in the USA in this, and we are hoping that King’s in London will also be associated, to validate a doctoral research project that is being set up alongside it.
We also have enthusiastic support from the charity Forward Trust, which I am sure the Minister will know does valuable work in recovery and rehabilitation within, and for those leaving, prisons. We see this project as having considerable potential in assisting with rehabilitation. I wonder therefore whether the Minister can give an indication of whether, if we get this off the ground, there may be a possibility to trial it in prison. It has great prospects of meeting some of the many deficiencies we currently have from not having the numbers around to help people with rehabilitation.
Our report found that purposeful activity was woefully inadequate overall, with prisoners spending up to 23 hours a day in cramped cells with little help for them to lead constructive crime-free lives when they leave. The consequences are predictable: boredom, frustration, self-harm and violence. With a cost to the taxpayer of approximately £54,000 per prisoner per year, we get very little benefit from that expenditure.
It is not merely a failure of prison management; it is a failure of public policy. Of course, overcrowding is a major cause, but it is not the whole explanation. We identified longer sentences, which have already been mentioned, excessive use of custody, bureaucracy restricting governors’ autonomy, inadequate recruitment and training of staff, poor assessment of prisoner needs, a backlog of repairs and, frankly, complacency within the MoJ and HMPPS.
For each of those problems, the committee made recommendations to release capacity for work on reducing reoffending and public protection. Yet, little more than a year later, the picture remains deeply troubling. Charlie Taylor, the Chief Inspector of Prisons, in a newspaper article only this weekend described the system as awash with drugs, with organised criminals operating with impunity, serious violence going unpunished and prisons struggling to control, let alone rehabilitate, those in their care. A prison system which cannot maintain order cannot properly rehabilitate prisoners. One which fails to rehabilitate stores up more crime for the future.
The impact of all this on staff is equally serious. In the last 12 months to July, prison officer numbers fell by the equivalent of seven officers per prison and sickness absence rose to 12.4 days per officer per year, compared with a national average of 4.4 days for all other workers. We cannot expect officers to deliver rehabilitation in an unsafe, understaffed and demoralising environment.
Overcrowding will not disappear quickly. Recalls are adding substantially to the pressure. Ten years ago, one person was recalled for every three or four released. In the first quarter of this year, for the first time ever since records were kept, more people were recalled to prison than released. Recalled prisoners now account for approximately one-seventh of the prison population, at a cost according to Nacro of £750 million a year. These figures raise all sorts of questions about whether the system is operating intelligently or just recycling people through custody at enormous cost. I urge the Minister to revisit the committee’s recommendations with much greater urgency than there has been so far.
I have just a few quick suggestions in the time that remains. We must reduce the number of people sent to prison unnecessarily. We know that well-run, probation-led community sentences cost less and can produce lower reoffending. I welcome the replacement of short prison sentences with community sentences, but I believe we can go much further, which means doing other things. The noble Lord, Lord Brooke, referred to the issue of gambling disorder. It is a ridiculous situation that the courts can currently make changes to the sentence they give to people with drug and alcohol problems by linking treatment orders to a non-custodial sentence, but there are no similar treatment orders in relation to gambling disorder. I urge the Minister to look at that issue.
I hope we will also look at the way in which we are funding and developing our Probation Service. We will hear all sorts of fine words from the Minister about the Government’s £700 million, but I point to the simple fact that, since the day our report was released to July of this year, the total increase in the number of probation staff has been 11. The Government are now using an ad agency to try to find additional people, at a cost of £150 million. I hope the Minister will tell us whether that is true and whether he believes it is good value for money—and, in particular, whether that is coming out of the £700 million, which would be a very expensive way of filling staffing gaps. We also know that the huge pressure on probation officers is one of the key causes of the recall of prisoners, because it is so much easier if there is a licence infringement to send people back to prison rather than taking up more time to deal with them.
I hope the Government will also look at our recommendation about the importance of prison education. They accepted our recommendation and said that prison education was vitally important, yet since our report was produced the budget for education in prisons has been reduced by at least 25%, which has meant that some 300 people who deliver that service have now lost their jobs. We can do other things, too, by looking at the way we help prisoners when they leave prison. I urge the Minister as a final point to look at the work being done at HMP Doncaster, where Nacro is bringing together all sorts of different agencies to help prisoners from the day they walk out of prison.
There is a lot that needs to be done. Only today, the unions have written to the Prime Minister about the piecemeal approach to dealing with the multiple problems in the justice system. They urge a more joined-up approach. I hope the Minister will look at that letter; it gives a lot of good advice as to how we could move forward, with the Government working more effectively together on these issues.
One might ask: who on earth would want to be a prison officer? We have heard not only from me but earlier from other noble Lords what happens to them. The need for rehabilitation of prisoners is obvious, for their sake and the sake of the public. If we just bang people up—mainly men, as we largely do—they are obviously more likely to offend and fill the prisons again. It seems a vicious circle.
Many years ago, as a judge, I visited Exeter Prison. I saw an absolutely splendid workshop training prisoners how to make and repair furniture. I went back about three years later and asked about the workshop. It was closed. I asked why. The present officer said that they were so busy taking people to the courts that they did not have time to look after the workshop—oh dear.
In the present circumstances, with overcrowded prisons and a lack of resources, it seems difficult to resolve rehabilitation, but the prevention of reoffending and some training of those inside is crucial for the benefit of prisoners and, much more importantly, the public. In the past, there have been some very successful drug and alcohol magistrates’ courts working on addict offenders. Surely, there should also be more residential units for drink and drug offenders under probation orders. If the offender did not finish the course, he would go to prison, but at least some might not reoffend.
The female prison population is, as we all know, very much smaller. Many, if not most, women who offend have been victims of abuse. I am not suggesting that no woman should go to prison, but many would be better off out of prison with appropriate probation orders and, of course, support and help to live in the future. The 2007 Corston report gave very good advice on women offenders. I do not know how far her recommendations have been implemented, but she recommended, among other things, that there should be a woman-centred approach in the judicial system, early diversion and efforts to identify and address the root cause of offending. There are excellent initiatives dealing with women, and they should be encouraged and increased.
Another problem, of course, is how to deal with prisoners upon release, which has already been referred to. I gather that the early releases are leaving prisoners without the help to prepare for time out of prison. There seems little point in release if there is insufficient help both inside and when they are outside. There are too many offenders who commit offences on release in order to go back to prison—because, where else can they go? Of course, we also have a serious lack of housing. What I do not know is where the overwhelming need to improve the prison estate should start, so I shall listen with great interest to the Minister as to how something, at least, can be done. Both the prisoners and the public require it.
The noble Lord, Lord Farmer, raised the issue of the deletion of parental responsibility in a coming Bill. That, as I understand it, would require a judicial decision. I would hope that judges would not remove parental responsibility as a matter of course, but only if the person in prison is unsuited to exercising it. The noble Lord perhaps is worrying too much about that particular proposal.
Clearly, the present situation also greatly complicates the management of prisoners within the prison system. As already mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Foster, it is costing the prison service around £750 million a year—surely money better spent on supporting prisoners on licence in the community. But the most devastating effect recall can have is on the prisoner concerned, including perhaps the loss of employment, loss of accommodation and, most importantly, destruction of any progress there may have been towards rehabilitation. This total interruption of the process of rehabilitation was rightly emphasised by the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, and by all noble Lords who have so far spoken.
Those of us who have been around for a while will remember that 20 or 30 years ago, in admittedly very different circumstances, the culture of the Probation Service was that recall was a last resort. Indeed, it could be regarded as a sign of professional failure to have to recall someone who was under one’s own supervision. Today, for whatever reason, the culture seems to have swung 180 degrees in the other direction: recall has become the first resort, not the last.
I fully accept that the problem is very difficult, but there are only three possibilities. The first is that the prisoner was not properly prepared for release, was not properly looked after once released, or that post-release support was inadequate. An important case in point is if the prisoner is recalled because of homelessness, a point already raised by noble Lords. That seems to be a major factor. According to Nacro, as mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Foster of Bath, last year 15,000 released prisoners were homeless on the day of release. What hope have we got? What hope do they have of remaining out of the prison sphere? So, lack of preparation or lack of support for prisoners in the community is the first thing.
The second possibility is that the licence conditions are too tough, inappropriate or not tailored to the needs of the prisoner concerned. Are we holding prisoners to licence conditions they are not capable of achieving—that are too heavy, that are not properly designed—given the lack of support, the mental health problems and the drug problems? These were emphasised by the noble Lord, Lord Brooke. In all these circumstances, the Chief Inspector of Probation has criticised “excessive licence conditions”, imposing on people obligations they cannot meet. Both those points amount to setting prisoners up to fail. What chance have they got if they are not properly prepared and the licence conditions are too onerous?
The third possibility, however, is risk aversion in the Probation Service. It is right to bear in mind that the service has, over the years, lost many experienced staff, is understaffed and is managing huge caseloads in very difficult conditions. Some 73% of recalls are for breach of licence conditions. There is widespread concern that those recalls are often triggered by minor or trivial breaches of licence conditions. Recalls should be primarily for reasons of public safety and not for minor breaches of licence conditions. There should be stronger rules and clearer guidance on this point. I ask the Minister: is the dramatic increase in recalls in recent years a matter of concern for the Government? What are the reasons for that increase, and what are the Government doing to tackle those underlying causes?
Finally, I add my own welcome to the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson of Liverpool, to whose maiden speech we are much looking forward.
Let me start with the number of remand prisoners in custody. On 30 June 2026, of the 85,858 in custody, 10,242 were untried and 5,144 were convicted but not sentenced. For those awaiting trial, presumed innocent, their lives are on hold; for those awaiting sentence, they cannot start to engage with a sentence plan; many may wait months, if not years, for a co-defendant to be tried so that all convicted can be sentenced together.
What of those who have been sentenced? Rehabilitation is identified as a requirement of Section 57(2) of the Sentencing Act 2020 for adults and is mandated by Section 37 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 as the principal aim of sentencing for those under 18. These are core requirements getting lost as prison and probation officers seek to contain and provide such support as they can to the unsustainable number of people with whom they have to deal in custody and in the community.
There have been far too many reports into prison conditions. I still possess a copy of the Woolf report, which followed the prison disturbances in HMP Manchester in April 1990. I was then responsible for the prosecution of prisoners for conspiracy to riot and other offences. The average prison population that year was about 45,000, and on 1 June 1990 there were 20,785 prison officers and 994 auxiliaries. On 7 September 2026, the prison population was 86,868, of which 67,652 were in public sector prisons which, as of 30 June, now employ 22,001 full-time equivalent prison officers and 5,661 operational staff. For just under 1,300 extra prison officers, there are roughly 50% more prisoners. I quote from the overview by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Woolf:
“members of the Prison Service as a whole, against heavy odds, have managed over a number of years to contain an almost impossible situation by showing immense dedication, courage and professionalism”.
With over twice as many in custody, that is even more so today.
As for activity in prison, the recent annual report of the Chief Inspector of Prisons identifies that, in many prisons, services have been cut—his word was “brutally”—with many teachers, as we have heard, made redundant. With few exceptions,
“Attendance in education, training and work is often appalling”
and insufficiently prioritised, with short working days. Similarly, the annual report of the Chief Inspector of Probation speaks of
“an organisation grappling with serious systemic challenges, an increasingly large and complex caseload … and an increasing proportion of the caseload … in the community”.
In short, he says there are
“too few staff, with too little experience, managing too many cases”.
The report of the Justice and Home Affairs Committee, Better Prisons: Less Crime identifies that reoffending represents around 80% of offending. It is therefore important to examine the challenges facing those who are serving sentences, the vast majority of whom will rejoin the community, whether sooner or later.
Your Lordships may be familiar with the figures but, with thanks to the Howard League for Penal Reform, I shall summarise. In 2024-25, assessment in England identified 57% of adult prisoners as having a learning difficulty or disability. More than half of men and almost three-quarters of women identify with mental health problems and, as your Lordships have heard, in 2021, Dame Carol Black published an independent review which identified one-third of prisoners as having a serious drug addiction. In a survey undertaken by the chief inspector, 41% referred to the ease with which illicit drugs could be obtained in prison; in category B training prisons, it was 57%.
In large part, that is the cohort which society has to address. Education, along with support and treatment for mental health and drug issues together with training to allow those released to be able to aspire to obtaining work are all critical if we are to prevent the revolving door of repeated offending. I agree with and fully endorse the observations of the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, in which he emphasised the importance of maintaining family relationships. As your Lordships have heard, the recent Nacro report revealed that more than 15,000 people were homeless on their first night out of prison.
In short, it all requires a move away from simple containment in prison to active measures to assist those in custody to find a bed and work towards living a useful life in the community. A plan is essential. Of course, there will be some who are so dangerous that this is not an option, but they are not the bulk of those in custody. Support both while in prison and then in the community is critical, and the Prison and Probation Service must be equipped with the personnel and resources to do so. That will be expensive, but nothing like as expensive as receiving them back into prison or keeping them there.
There are other great benefits of promoting rehabilitation. The prison population crisis is very real. If more can be supported in the community and reoffending minimised, there will be more room for those who should be remanded into custody and those who are dangerous. Remand prisoners will be kept nearer their court of trial. The police will be able to provide greater focus on offences that cause great public concern, including violence against women and girls, other serious sexual and violent offending, phone, petrol and shop theft and more.
It will be clear that, although this debate is about prisons and probation, the crisis is much wider: every aspect of criminal justice requires urgent attention. Some courts are listing trials for 2030. Criminal justice reform could be my “Mastermind” specialist subject, but I would not dream of testing the patience of the House by going through my recent review. It is sufficient to say that there are solutions that I look forward to discussing with and urging upon your Lordships, working with all to address the challenges that it faces.
I end by observing that we must not forget the human beings behind all these issues: the victims, the witnesses and the offenders. The state must facilitate the early identification and detection of crime. It must, within a reasonable time, ensure its prosecution, and it must do all it can to promote the rehabilitation of convicted offenders. If it does not, it is failing in one of its most important responsibilities.
I need have said none of that, because the proof of what he will bring is in all your Lordships’ expectations, which were amply justified but which, modestly of course, he said he was a little worried he might not live up to. His mastery of the criminal law and the criminal justice system is enormous. Indeed, I found over that quarter of a century that I almost always agreed with everything he said. I can take the opportunity of saying so today because I do not wish to add to, and could not possibly improve upon, his analysis of the difficulties facing the criminal justice system.
Like other noble Lords, I am extremely grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, for obtaining this debate and for the many speeches that have been made about what needs to be done. The list is almost endless. I want to address one overarching problem, and that is what we can best do with what money we get.
I recall some years ago that this was exemplified by the first matter we have to address, and that is rigid discipline over money—no doubt noble Lords will fear that I have gone over to the Treasury’s side, or should I say the dark side? But it is important to have discipline. In the last Labour Government in the early 2000s, I remember that when reforms were thought of, you had to prove what effect it would have. This was then checked by the Home Office. There was something called the Home Office model, which showed that if you created an offence, it would need so many more prosecutors, so many more judges, and so many more prison places.
I deeply regret that we do not do the same now on the most important aspect, which is at the heart of today’s debate: the massive increase in prison sentence lengths of which everyone has spoken. The first thing we must do is bring back a fiscal discipline so that we know what money we have, because only with knowing what money we have can we do things properly. The late Lord Judge and I were bitterly critical of the constant increase in sentence lengths without consideration of how this was to be paid for without either putting prisoners into squalid conditions or cutting the really good things that are done in prison—in particular, education. That is the first fundamental question. We need to work out what we can pay for with the money available.
The second fundamental question is then to explain to the public what we are capable of doing. This is a shared endeavour of us all because we cannot go on as we are. It seems to me that we must return to, first, truth in sentencing. If the judge says, “You get five years and you spend half of that in prison and half in the community”, that is what we should deliver, but we have had to go away from that because we have not told the public the truth—that there is only a limited amount of money available and we can do only so much with it. I hope this fundamental question will be grappled with by us all.
I warmly commend the Government on what they have said about IPPs. It has taken huge courage and a sense of justice to do it. The greater task ahead is to adopt the same attitude to explaining to the public that if this is the money available, this is all we can do, prison sentences must come down and we must use prison spaces more effectively, and they will be better for that. That is the next task facing this Government.
I would normally want to use today’s debate to talk in detail about prison reform, because I am passionate especially about improving educational initiatives in prison and I hate the lack of purposeful activity available that has been so well described by other noble Lords—I thought the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, made a magnificent speech—but it is also true that it has become particularly difficult to convince the public that the MoJ should prioritise improving the treatment of prisoners in jail when so many are being released out of jail before they have served their time. Discussing rehabilitation feels meaningless when the very purposes of prisons—at least in the sense of punishment and deprivation of liberty, not cruelty, or of protecting the public, let alone rehabilitation to reduce reoffending—are made a mockery of by successive Governments’ failure to deliver prison expansion and now the makeshift solutions to deal with the fallout.
Early release schemes outsource the problem into our communities, literally dumping it on our streets. The public are rightly furious that criminals will not now serve the sentences that the law, which we make here, thinks is appropriate for their crimes. Recent polling shows that 69% of those questioned are against the early release scheme. More troubling, 68% say they have lost faith in all Governments’ handling of criminal justice per se. At the forthcoming annual Battle of Ideas festival organised by the Academy of Ideas, which I run—I declare an interest—one of the panel debates is entitled: “Letting abusers out early: solving the prisons crisis”. It is proving to be an unexpected festival sell-out hit.
When I talk to people, four recurring themes are raised. There is a perception that the early release scheme, alongside the Sentencing Act, has a presumption against prison in favour of community sentences. With the even further reductions in release dates to a third of sentences served, people just feel that sentencing has become a joke and that it is less a pragmatic response to a lack of prison space than an official ideological turn against incarceration as punishment. This is happening without public debate or consent.
There is also a worry that the prison crisis is diminishing the diligence of policing in pursuing certain crimes. What is the point of arresting shoplifters or burglars if they cannot be threatened with the prospect of prison?
A third concern is that early release is a lazy reaction to the crisis. Why are there no other emergency options—perhaps the prison equivalent of NHS Nightingales? Maybe the thousands of empty prison cells currently out of action could be renovated, or even the shocking facts about those kept on remand, which we heard from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, in his brilliant maiden speech, could be tackled. It is a disgrace that this is such a large percentage of the prison community.
A final concern is in response to the Government’s reassurance that early release prisoners are not being released freely but will be under close supervision. Yet probation services admit that they are not equipped to cope. The whole paraphernalia of control and surveillance in the community—curfews, electronic tags, formal restriction zones, the wearing of high-vis vests—can only result in whole swathes of local areas feeling more like open-air prisons for all, rather than a free society.
Possibly the only good thing to have come from the prison crisis is Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s commendable announcement that he will, at last, end the injustice of IPP prisoners. I confess that I got emotional hearing an ex-IPP prisoner, Marc Conway from UNGRIPP, declaring that it was,
“a day that thousands of families have spent years fighting for”.
He also stressed that implementing the decision needed to be swift and transparent, and that is where the euphoria is dampened.
Last week, I received this message from Stacey Clough of the Injustice of IPP campaign. It is worth listening to her words. She said:
“I think it’s great what Andy Burnham has said, but he has left IPP prisoners and their families with a different mental torture by not making it clear what it’s going to look like … and they still have no definite date to count down to. My partner said all the IPPs in Wayland have gone downhill, as the hopes were raised by the announcement, but as there’s no time-frame… they’re all worried it’s false hope. What if there’s an election and Labour are voted out—then back to square one. They have now been left with uncertainty. If the Government don’t end it, there is going to be more suicides”.
I gulped at that. Stacey continued:
“The thing is he could order probation to release the recalled prisoners without any new requirements—and no new legislation is needed because of executive powers created in 2012—powers they’ve never used. They should also be recommending that anyone going up for parole, with no new crimes or charges on a recall, should be granted release and have their licence terminated and give them a supervision order instead”.
My advice to the Minister is to recommend to the MoJ that Stacey is given a job, because she has got it all completely right, as far as I am concerned. There are so many inequities in the way in which IPP prisoners continue to be treated. It is not just that we need to have these things happen more quickly. For example, we hear that, even when IPP prisoners are granted parole, they are often kept in prison for months and months, due to a lack of approved accommodation on the outside. There are things that need to be done fast.
While the Minister defended the principle of recall at Questions this week, the fact that the number of IPP prisoners recalled without any criminal charge has gone up from 70% in 2023 to 77% in 2025 should worry him. I hope that noble Lords have a good recess, but I will be at No. 10 North on Monday, along with anti-IPP protestors—