That this House takes note of the Report from the Economic Affairs Committee Preparing for an Ageing Society (2nd Report, HL Paper 236, Session 2024–26).
My Lords, before we start, I want to make a short statement. As set out on Today’s Lists, speeches in all three debates should be limited to three minutes, with the exception of those of the movers, winders and Ministers. I know from experience that if everyone goes over by just a few seconds, those seconds mount up. I am sure I speak on behalf of Members across the House when I say that I would be grateful if Members could stick to the advisory speaking time to ensure that the Ministers have adequate time to respond to the points raised in each of the debates today.
My Lords, it is a great privilege and pleasure to introduce this report on behalf of the Economic Affairs Select Committee of the House in place of our former chair, my noble friend Lord Wood of Anfield. He has, as the Salvationists would say in the 19th century on the death of one of their senior members, been promoted to glory, which in his case is ministerial office as one of Ed Miliband’s Foreign Office Ministers.
I have known Stewart for more than two decades. He demonstrated a very high level of intellect by his appointment as a fellow of Magdalen at a young age. When I was in No. 10, he was a member of Gordon Brown’s council of economic advisers. Although we did not agree on every aspect of government policy, we were both committed European social democrats and were fascinated by the lessons for Britain of post-war Germany. He has been a great chair of our Select Committee to work under, and we owe him a lot.
No report is ever produced without the contribution of the clerks, the expert advisers, our technical and administrative support, and our witnesses. This whole operation was brilliantly orchestrated by our committee clerk, Matthew Manning, to whom I also pay tribute.
We learned a lot from many excellent witnesses. To pick on one is unfair, but I will take the liberty of breaching that rule by paying tribute to Charles Goodhart, the former Bank of England economist. His brother William was a distinguished Member of this House, whose contribution at the age of 89 lost nothing in its clarity and pungency. He is a great exemplar of why we should not be pessimistic about the possibilities of an ageing society. I also pay tribute to other members of the committee, including those rotated off before this debate.
My Lords, I begin by thanking the noble Lord, Lord Wood, for his outstanding chairmanship. I have already paid tribute to him at Question Time, and I do so very happily again today, because his job was brilliantly done. It is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Liddle, who has summarised our report very comprehensively; he has not left much for anyone to say, even within three minutes.
For me, the most important paragraph in the report was one referred to by the noble Lord, Lord Liddle. It is paragraph two, which refers to the OBR stating, as the noble Lord, Lord Liddle, emphasised, in its Fiscal Risks and Sustainability Report, an annual publication about ageing, that without a change in policy, government spending pressures will push up debt to
“above 270% of GDP by the early 2070s”.
Those are very alarming figures. Of course, many people will say that this will never happen, but it will not happen only if we take steps to prevent it happening.
According to the OBR, age-related public spending will increase total spending by 10% of GDP by 2074. When you add debt interest on top of that, it will raise total government spending from 44.5% of GDP to 60% of GDP by 2073. Taxes are already at an all-time high. What would they be if spending were to reach 60% of GDP? What policies are there that can mitigate the apparent need for deep spending cuts or increases in taxation? The usual answer from a Government, of course, is growth, but alas, growth does not always happen and has not always happened in response to the exhortations of government.
My Lords, I would also like to thank the noble Lord, Lord Liddle, for outlining the conclusions of the committee’s report so well, and thank the noble Lord, Lord Wood of Anfield, for chairing the committee during this investigation. He has now gone on to greater things and I hope he will have the opportunity to continue to deploy his considerable economic skills in that role as well.
There is nothing new or recent about the phenomenon of an ageing population. This been going on throughout my working life, but it is now a major factor in the conduct of economic policy. In the mid-1960s, when I started work, there were fewer than 7 million people aged 65 or over. Today, that number is approaching 14 million and by 2050 it is forecast to reach almost 19 million. The increase in those over 85 is even more impressive. Over the same period, their number has gone from fewer than 500,000 in the mid-1960s to almost 2 million today. It is now forecast to reach 4 million by 2050. This is something to celebrate; it was one of the things we had to keep reminding ourselves of in the committee. It has been a remarkable measure of the progress that has been going on. But it does have consequences for fiscal policy.
Our concern is that, despite this success, the proportion of people aged between 50 and 65—this was mentioned by the noble Lord, Liddle—either working or looking for work drops off considerably compared with the cohort just before them: the 35 to 50 age group. There has been some noticeable increase in the participation rate of those over 65, but it remains quite modest. It was these figures and the starkness of this that formed the basis for our report. It is clear that, unless working lives are extended, our successors will have to fund many more years of retirement than in the past. The report also emphasises the need to rethink our approach to lifelong financial planning for individuals; this is not just a matter for government but for individuals as well.
My Lords, I am grateful for the opportunity to speak on this important issue, and I thank the Economic Affairs Committee for its thorough and timely report. As we consider the prospect of a society where the people of older age vastly outnumber younger people, it is vital that we avoid framing our discussion primarily around the burden of the old to the young. We must continue to emphasise that the value of a person cannot be reduced to their fiscal contribution to the state, although I very much understand the pressures. As the report rightly notes, increased life expectancy is a welcome gift and one of the considerable achievements of modern society. I note that, when I began ordained ministry in 1997, I regularly conducted funerals for people in their 60s and 70s; decades on, they were much more frequently for people in their 80s and 90s.
I wish to emphasise the way in which other cultures can teach us the value of older age from their perspective. For example, on a trip to Kenya in recent years, I was privileged to share in the birthday celebrations of an 80 year-old matriarch of a village, and I was bestowed the honour of a ceremonial feeding of the first taste of her enormous cake. I will never forget her jubilation, which was felt across the entire community present. Her life, in its longevity, intrinsic value and social contribution, was remarkable, and nobody there took that for granted. Sadly, here in the UK, we often speak of and treat older people as an inconvenience to be mitigated, rather than cherishing the wisdom and life experience they bring. As a young priest, I was trained to visit my congregation in their own homes—a practice continued throughout my parochial ministry to this day. What started as a visit for a cuppa ended with accounts of careers and achievements, such as the invention of the contact lens, expeditions to the summit of Everest, and a most memorable and gorgeous afternoon with an original character from “Call the Midwife”.
My Lords, the report we are discussing was completed before I joined the Economic Affairs Committee. Therefore, I need feel no embarrassment in congratulating the committee on its work. It is prescient, timely and, to put it bluntly, a stark warning to this and future Governments that they will ignore at their peril. The noble Lord, Lord Liddle, summarised it very well. The UK is ageing rapidly—a sign of success. Longer life expectancy is a success, but falling birth rates mean that older people will form a larger share of the population. This will cause critical problems. This is on top of the problems of exponential growth of public expenditure and welfare that we already have.
The noble Lords, Lord Liddle and Lord Lamont, pointed to a crucial paragraph. I will not repeat the statistics, but it illustrated just how far we will have to go to meet the challenges by 2074—roughly the next 50 years. If we do not meet those challenges, we will be in a crisis long before that. I believe this is a challenge, laid out in this report, that no responsible Government can refuse to recognise.
There is another warning. As the noble Lord, Lord Liddle, said, simply increasing the state pension age will not cut the mustard; it will not provide the means to address the challenge the committee outlined. A greater priority should be helping people in their 50s and 60s remain in or return to employment, but this in turn requires better health and social care, flexible working, reduced age discrimination—something to bear in mind next week when we discuss the report from the Retirement and Participation Committee—and opportunities for lifelong learning and retraining. All these are outlined in this report, and I urge the Government to take them most seriously.
My Lords, before we move on to the next speaker, I again insist that we keep to the three minutes, because every second is extending the time of the debate. We need to keep within the three minutes.
My Lords, I shall do my best. I also warmly congratulate the committee. Many of the speeches already made have set out the situation, demography and all the rest of it. The United Nations has described population ageing as
“a defining global trend of our time”.
The changes taking place here and across the world will transform our workforce, public services, pensions and families. It is worth remembering that when the Queen came to the Throne in 1952, she used to send a telegram to everybody reaching 100. How many did she send in 1952? Some 300. That is the scale of the change. Sending that many telegrams now would be difficult, to say the least. We have to act now. The greatest improvement to our fiscal outlook will come not from simply increasing the state pension age but, as has rightly been said, from enabling more people in their mid-50s and 60s to remain in work.
Healthy life expectancy in the UK has fallen by more than two years in the past decade. As the ONS figures show, it is at its lowest level since the present series began—a watershed moment.
I will refer to Sir Charlie Mayfield’s Keep Britain Working review. We are growing older and living longer but getting sick sooner. This is not just a problem for the NHS; it is a problem for the economy. He identifies a profession that gets far too little recognition and understanding. It is mentioned in the report and the government response. It is the occupational health profession. As the report says:
My Lords, as a member of the committee which produced this report, I join others in congratulating the noble Lord, Lord Wood, putting on record my thanks for his outstanding chairing and my thanks to the committee staff.
I want to emphasise one of the major conclusions, which the noble Lord, Lord Liddle, and others have highlighted and which I think was for many of us the major new insight: that we must concentrate on raising the participation levels of people in their mid-50s. This is really important. The UK has done pretty well at raising the state pension age, but just putting it up further is not a panacea, as others have explained. Doing that is very unlikely to increase employment levels among the pre-retirement cohort, where many have already dropped out of the labour market. Conversely, raising participation among these 55 to 65 year-olds would make a major difference to our economy, to the public finances and, in many cases, to people’s physical and mental well-being. As our witnesses confirmed time and again, working is really good for people, and being unemployed and economically inactive really is not.
This country had a good record over the last few decades of providing jobs and keeping formal unemployment down, and there is now concern, rightly, over the impact of government policy, in both taxes and employment legislation, on employers’ willingness to hire and especially to hire the young. PAYE data shows a fall of 86,000 payrolled employees in April to June 2026, while workforce data shows a fall of 97,000 in the year to March 2026.
10:45 am
20 of 60 shown
The UK is a rapidly ageing society. The numbers are striking. The Office for Budget Responsibility’s projections say that the old age dependency ratio—that is, the number of people above the state pension age relative to the number of working people—will rise from approximately 31% now to 38% in 2050 and 47% in 2074. Indeed, in the years of the Conservative Governments from 2010 to 2024, the population aged over 65 rose from something like 16.5% to 19%.
The decline in fertility rates is even more striking. In 1964, a peak fertility rate of 2.93 children per woman was achieved. This has fallen precipitously. In 2023, it had reached a new low of 1.44 in England and Wales and 1.25 in Scotland. The long-term replacement rate is 2.08, so we can see the basis of the demographic crisis.
We heard from our witnesses that the prospects for raising the fertility rate are dim and that policy attempts elsewhere to do this have failed. That was a great disappointment to me, because when I worked for the President of the European Commission two decades ago, we had confidence that the adoption of Nordic-style family-friendly policies—subsidised childcare, gender equality and more equally shared responsibility for bringing up children between men and women—would help sustain an adequate fertility rate. Sadly, that has not proved to be the case.
Immigration is likewise not the panacea that in some quarters it is made out to be. It might help if immigration were circular—that is, immigrants returning home as their countries become more prosperous, which to some extent has happened with eastern European immigration. The problem with the immigration from further afield that Britain has experienced since 2019 is that families are more likely to settle here permanently, adding in the short term to public spending costs but not adding to demographic sustainability in the longer term, as second-generation birth rates tend to adjust to UK norms.
Among our witnesses, people were optimistic that the change in profile of the population is manageable. However, the rate at which it is occurring could pose substantial challenges, though it is worth highlighting that some of that is the result of a great success story. Rising life expectancy is something to be celebrated—for girls born today, life expectancy is 90, while for boys it is 86.7—but there is a worrying gap between life expectancy and healthy life expectancy. Healthy life expectancy has actually fallen in the last couple of years. There is already a huge north-south gap emerging; for instance, the gap in healthy life expectancy between London and the north-east is seven years. These are very worrying trends.
The fiscal picture is also stark. In its Fiscal Risks and Sustainability 2025 report, the Office for Budget Responsibility—for which I have great regard, unlike some other people—says that by the early 2070s, on current policy settings, borrowing will be pushed up to a clearly unsustainable 20% a year, and debt will rise to over 270%, which again is clearly unsustainable.
We are not alone in facing this challenge, but that is no source of comfort. The fact that others will be grappling with the same issues could increase competition between nations over a dwindling workforce, at the same time as our economy will be struggling.
This is about more than just the current elderly. The current young population will become the older generation of the future; indeed, thanks to the increases in life expectancy, they will be older for longer.
Yet demography is not destiny. One key conclusion we reached is that the Government need to focus on the older economically inactive who are below state pension age, and I think these facts are not particularly well known. Discussion of raising the state pension age to deal with this problem is, in our view, misplaced. Those still working at the point of state pension age are entitled to claim it but are in fact highly likely to continue working beyond it. The focus has to be on those who exit the workforce before reaching the state pension age.
This is the scale of the problem: at the age of 50, 80% of the age group are still in work, but at the age of 65 the participation rate has fallen to 25% to 30%. That catastrophic fall in the participation rate is the public policy challenge that we feel needs to be addressed. Simply to raise the state pension age would plunge a significant number of people in that late-60s bracket into poverty, as happened when the pension age was raised from 65.
The Government are beginning to think hard about how to promote workforce participation at the other end of the age spectrum, among young people, with the brilliant Milburn review, which is greatly to be welcomed as an outstanding contribution to public policy. However, we hear nothing, or very little, about the scale of what is required to prepare an ageing workforce for those in their mid-50s to mid-60s. The Government’s response is their mid-life MOT programme and targeted jobcentre support for older job seekers. All that is welcome but it hardly seems an ambitious enough response to this crisis, and that is a crucial conclusion of our report.
There are a number of reasons for people to leave the workforce at older ages, which present policy does little to address. Some are benign. People want to stop working if they have the financial resources to do so. Unfortunately for the Treasury, these are often those who contribute the most in taxes, and the Government need to find ways of incentivising these people to remain in or return to work. However, we also heard about those who want to work but are unable to do so because of caring responsibilities, either to ageing parents or to dependants. We recognise that this is a priority for the Government and we are looking forward to the recommendations of the commission that the noble Baroness, Lady Casey of Blackstock, is working on. But you cannot help noting that a number of these grand reviews have been held in the past, with very little action taken. Let us profoundly hope that the Casey review will be the last before concrete policies are announced and enacted.
There has obviously been some focus in discussion on reforming the triple lock. This has proved an expensive driver of real-terms increases in the state pension, due to the recurring volatility of both inflation and earnings, which have led to real-terms increases. Linking pensions to earnings—that is, to the living standards of the working population—is estimated to save some £15.5 billion. That is a significant sum of money. It would take the defence budget up by over 0.5% of GDP. But in our report, rather than focus on that, we have chosen to focus on the much longer-term issue of raising labour force participation among those over 50. The continued yearly focus on the Budget, and the Government’s fiscal headroom and all that, means that there is a danger that we lose sight of the far more serious long-term issues. I am afraid that nothing in what the Government had to say reassured us in this regard.
The Cameron Government, to their credit, made the ageing population one of the subjects of their foresight studies, but this was lost in the aftermath— I would say “chaos”—of Brexit. The present Government, in response to our recommendation that they publish an overarching strategy statement setting out how they plan to address the challenges of an ageing society in a cohesive way, said that an “integrated approach” was
“preferable to a single standalone strategy”.
I do not know quite what that means. They went on to say that they were taking
“a strategic and cross-cutting approach to issues relating to an ageing society”.
Well, without some clear statement of what the strategy that underpins the purported integrated approach is, I find this answer devoid of significant and substantial content.
The lack of any published strategy on ageing is a worrying indication that the Government would prefer not to face up to these challenges as an immediate question, and that the UK is therefore woefully unprepared for the future. This is a harsh conclusion, but the point of having Select Committees is to point out difficult conclusions that our politics is failing to address. On that basis, and with that reason, I beg to move.
According to the OBR, immigration on any likely acceptable scale will not be sufficient to improve the debt dynamic. According to our witnesses, efforts to increase fertility rates in other countries have largely failed. Raising the pension age, which the Government intend to do, does save money but does not, as the noble Lord, Lord Liddle, emphasised, increase participation rates or promote longer working lives.
One alternative, which is recommended in our report and accepted by the Government, is to increase labour force participation among those aged between 50 and pension age. Finding a solution to the problem of social care—which is an urgent problem in its own right, not just a financial problem—would help many of those in their mid-50s and 60s to remain at work. But a national care service modelled on the NHS, as suggested by the Prime Minister, could cost no less than up to £19 billion a year in 10 years’ time, so that will not help our fiscal problems.
If we do not increase the proportion of older people at work, output per capita and the overall size of the economy will be lower, with fewer workers and higher pension payments. We have to improve productivity per worker and, at the same time, get more of the old to remain at work. It is not impossible. Over the past 100 years, the old age dependency ratio tripled, but it has not been a factor in holding back growth. In the past, we have adapted.
Our report only scratches the surface of what is a huge subject. The ageing of society is transformational and will reach into every department, but the impact is felt only gradually, almost imperceptibly. We need a longer-term framework to allow well-informed development of policy to prepare for these profound changes. If we do not face reality, reality is going to face us.
As has been noted, the committee concluded that, from a fiscal point of view, the best response would be to encourage and incentivise those in their mid-50s to mid-60s to remain active in the workforce, but this would also require greater recognition of the valuable contribution that experienced people can make to the workplace.
The issue of the growing number of people requiring health support and social care has been mentioned. As others have noted, the unsatisfactory arrangements for adult social care have been recognised for years, but no policy proposal has received the necessary support. Fundamental questions remain about service provision, our lifetime contributions, how we share costs between the state and the individual, and the potential role for insurance. Let us hope that the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, can unlock this puzzle.
Finally, there is the testing question of pensioner incomes. The old system of indexing pensions solely to prices meant that pensioners did not automatically benefit from economic growth. However, the triple lock guarantees that the level of pensions will increase faster than earnings over time, but in an arbitrary and random way. This is a problem that must be fixed.
Clearly, the flourishing of our civil society continues to depend on the time, generosity and commitment of older people, many of whom serve as volunteers, carers, mentors, trustees and community leaders in retirement. Without this, many organisations would struggle to survive and function. It is vital that local communities continue to have the support to provide the network of friendship and stimulation that helps older people remain connected and appropriately valued as they grow older. Examples across the country of excellent dementia cafés and bereavement and other support groups are a lifeline for many. I visited the church-run Memory Lane Café in Henley-in-Arden, where the lunch on Christmas Day is oversubscribed, with 100 people attending, who were very keen to let me know that it is a much-loved annual event.
Finally, as the report explores, an ageing population requires a reframed understanding of retirement. The Church of England depends on an active workforce—as a Bishop, I am hugely grateful for their commitment. As we consider the extension of the working life, it is vital that we maintain the safeguards that protect sustainable patterns of work. That said, the challenges facing public finance, health services and social care are acute and must be addressed. I again thank the Economic Affairs Committee for its work. I urge the Government to ensure that, within this work, the value of older-aged people is not lost. As we prepare for an ageing society, we must not forget that such people are not merely recipients of care; they remain bearers of gifts, contributors to the common good and people of immeasurable worth.
If I have one disappointment, it is that the report did not more forthrightly consider and challenge the triple lock. I believe that is essential. Absent that analysis in the report, we have to rely on the good services of the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, who has been forthright on it. I agree entirely with him. That issue would undoubtedly have to be part of the deliberations of the recommended Cabinet sub-committee and overarching strategy.
Overall, the message is simple: the UK needs to prepare now. It is already later than it should be to start preparations. We need to treat longer lives as an opportunity rather than a burden. In the months and years to come, the Government cannot say that they were not warned.
“In 2024 only 45% of workers had access to OH support … this falls to just 18% among small employers”.
If we want to keep more people working through ill health, or returning afterwards, they are a critical group, helping people manage conditions, make adjustments, return after illness and avoid leaving employment altogether. The Centre for Ageing Better, which I applaud, estimates in its report on the looming retirement crisis that more than 900,000 people between 50 and state pension age are out of work but would like to be working.
I must quickly shoot forward to the triple lock, because the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, as has rightly been said, has been forthright—saying that it is “completely bonkers” and “very unfair” to younger generations—and we heard more from him this week. Sir Leigh Lewis, the distinguished former Perm Sec at the Department for Work and Pensions, wrote this in a letter to the Times recently:
“Of all the policies for which I had some responsibility during my time in government, this was by far the worst. Left unchanged, it will bankrupt our children and grandchildren”.
His conclusion was equally clear: politicians of all parties have a duty to admit that the triple lock policy is “unaffordable” and “has to change”.
The other area in which I look to for courage is social care. The Prime Minister, with his people-pleasing approach, has said warm words about social care, but this is an incredibly costly programme. Healthcare has always been free at the point of use, but social care has always had an assessment of means. It is essential that there is a proper expectation of what the reality of a social care programme will involve. I hope somebody will produce coherence in this programme. I commend the report.
Although we are very focused on the immediate problems, our participation rates over a longer period do not actually look that wonderful. At a time of lengthening life expectancy, it is true that total employment is up, but that is because of the size of the population. Overall employment rates have been pretty static this century: down a bit for men and up a little bit for women. Meanwhile, unemployment rates are down because of people simply dropping out of the labour market. Again, we know and heard from witnesses that, if you drop out in mid- to later mid-life, you are very unlikely to return. Meanwhile, part-time employment, which is especially attractive to older workers and those with caring responsibilities, has started to fall sharply.
This is a major challenge for the Government, and I think that people have not really been aware of it. We asked them to set out their policies and to look at tax and other incentives but, as the noble Lord, Lord Liddle, said, the focus at the moment is very much on the young. The young really matter but, in our ageing society, people in their 50s and 60s matter too.