Further considered in Committee (Progress reported, 19 October)
[2nd Allocated Day]
[Relevant documents: Third Report of the Joint Committee on Human Rights, Legislative Scrutiny: Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, HC 162; Second Report of the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee of Session 2024-26, The Government’s new approach to addressing the legacy of the past in Northern Ireland, HC 586, and the Government response, HC 1716; and Correspondence from the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee, on the Government’s amendments to the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, reported to the House 12 October.]
Further considered in Committee (Progress reported, 19 October)
[Relevant documents: Third Report of the Joint Committee on Human Rights, Legislative Scrutiny: Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, HC 162; Second Report of the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee of Session 2024-26, The Government’s new approach to addressing the legacy of the past in Northern Ireland, HC 586, and the Government response, HC 1716; and Correspondence from the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee, on the Government’s amendments to the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill, reported to the House 12 October.]
Order. I remind Members that in Committee they should not address the Chair as “Deputy Speaker”. Instead, please use our names—Ms Ghani—or “Madam Chair”, which is also acceptable.
Clause 72
The Independent Commission on Information Retrieval
Question proposed, That the clause stand part of the Bill.
With this it will be convenient to consider the following:
Clauses 73 to 76 stand part.
Government amendment 232.
Clause 77 stand part.
Clauses 78 to 81 stand part.
Amendment 74, in clause 82, page 64, line 39, after “ICIR” insert “, and
(h) analysis of the ICIR’s engagement with non-state actors”.
Clause 82 stand part.
Government amendments 233 to 235.
Clause 83 stand part.
Amendment 51, in clause 84, page 66, line 6, at end insert—
“(1A) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (3), no inquest may be resumed in relation to the deaths resulting from Operation Judy in Loughgall in 1987.”
Amendment 109, page 66, line 18, leave out paragraph (b) and insert—
“(ab) for subsection (2) substitute—
‘(2) The Presiding coroner has the power to allocate a coroner to resume and conduct such inquests.’
(ac) Omit subsection (3).’”
This amendment would require all inquests arising from the Northern Ireland Troubles to be subject to a coroner-led process.
Government amendments 236 and 237.
Amendment 20, page 67, line 3, at end insert—
“(5) If during the course of an inquest it appears to the coroner that the death may have resulted from a criminal offence, he shall stop the inquest and refer the matter of potential criminality to the Director of Public Prosecutions.”
Today we are debating parts 6 to 9 of the Bill. Part 6 sets up on a pilot basis the Independent Commission on Information Retrieval, as originally proposed in the Stormont House agreement. The commission will be an international body established jointly with the Irish Government to give families an additional means to retrieve information about troubles-related deaths. Part 7 covers the restoration of a limited number of troubles-related inquests. Part 8 covers further provisions, including the lifting of the prohibition set out in the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 on investigations by the police of other troubles-related offences, including sexual offences, ensuring that there is no bar to investigating crimes based on when they took place. It also covers the provisions regarding interim custody orders.
I will turn first to inquests. I understand the strength of feeling across the House in respect of inquests, as evidenced by the large number of amendments that have been tabled by right hon. and hon. Members. The Bill does not establish any new inquests. However, when the legacy Act abruptly halted a number of inquests on 1 May 2024, we committed in opposition to restoring some of them, as we knew the hurt and anxiety it caused many families in both Northern Ireland and Great Britain. As we said at that time, it marked a very painful day for families of troubles victims, who felt that 1 May marked a door being shut in their faces, in particular for those who had been involved in inquests.
The truth is that many families have received answers through inquests, and only through inquests. I rather agreed with my right hon. Friend the Member for Leeds South (Hilary Benn) when he said yesterday that he had been brought up to expect an inquest whenever there was a suspicious death.
That matter is particularly pertinent when it comes to consideration of the Omagh bombing. Given the material that we are discussing today, what indication has the Secretary of State had from the Irish Government that they will withdraw their inter-state case against the United Kingdom at the European Court of Human Rights? It seems to me that they are very reluctant to act at all.
The right hon. Gentleman makes a good point. By the time we finish considering the Bill today, I cannot see any legitimate reason why the Irish state would continue with its inter-state case at all. I have already made that point robustly to my counterparts in Dublin. I very much hope that they will look again and think again and decide that not only did we win the case in the Dillon judgment, but the legislation that we are advancing today is fully human rights-compliant, and that there is therefore no argument for them maintaining their inter-state case.
The Secretary of State says that he very much hopes that the Dublin Government would move at the conclusion of today’s consideration. Has he had that conversation with them, and have they given him the assurance that that is what they intend to do?
Yes, to the first part. As I have just said, I have said this very robustly to Jim O’Callaghan and Helen McEntee on several occasions. They have kept their own counsel for the moment, but it seems to me inconceivable that, by the time the Bill gets to the House of Lords, there could be an argument for them maintaining the inter-state case, and I therefore hope that they will withdraw it. I am being as clear as I can with the hon. Gentleman. As he knows, he and I agree on many, many things, not least the fact that it is good to have power sharing in Northern Ireland and that I should not be running Northern Ireland.
I think it is important that the Secretary of State has reiterated the point that the commission will have the ability to take information from the Irish Government. However, without revisiting yesterday’s debates, does that not put into stark relief the fact that while information has been available for the last 28 years, it was revealed only last week? There will be many other instances of information that could beneficially have been considered and led to a change. Is the Secretary of State at all concerned that the history that we repeat time and again with the Irish Government, where they are not forthcoming with the full information and they withhold information, should be a cause for concern for this House and how we deal with the legacy of the past?
The right hon. Gentleman makes a decent point. The question then is simply how one addresses that and ensures that one gets the future co-operation that has been promised and committed to by the Irish Government. I am more hopeful than he is, I guess—he may say that is because he has more scars on his back than I have in this regard. I think that between the two of us, with his scepticism and my hope, we might be able to get to a good set of outcomes.
On the Omagh bombing, it is inevitable, I think, that we will end up having some of the same conversations today as we had yesterday, as Members understandably referred then to issues that we are voting on today. However, I would just say to the right hon. Member for South West Wiltshire that with my understanding of the terms of reference of the Omagh inquiry, we slightly disagree on this matter. I think it will be perfectly possible for the Omagh inquiry to come to some fairly firm conclusions. More importantly, however, as I said yesterday, it is really important that the fullest possible co-operation is shown, and, where the chief counsel has already said that they are not happy with that co-operation, it is incumbent on the Irish Government to step up to the plate.
Yes, although this is all on one sentence, and it is the right hon. Gentleman’s second go.
20 of 722 shown
Amendment 111, page 67, leave out from the beginning of line 4 to the end of line 11 on page 68.
Amendment 113, page 67, line 10, leave out from “must” to end of line 12.
This amendment along with Amendments 114 and 115 would require all inquests that were initiated before 1 May 2024, but had not yet been allocated to a coroner, to be directed to the Legacy Commission’s senior judicial panel member for allocation as inquisitorial proceedings.
Government amendment 238.
Amendment 114, page 67, leave out lines 17 to line 6 on page 68.
This amendment is consequential to Amendment 113.
Government amendment 239.
Amendment 115, page 68, leave out line 16.
This amendment is consequential to Amendment 113.
Amendment 129, page 68, line 32, leave out subsection (3) and insert—
“(3) A coroner conducting a resumed inquest must not do anything which duplicates anything previously done in connection with the inquest unless—
(a) a New Evidence Certificate has been issued under section 30 and,
(b) in their view, the duplication is essential.”
This amendment requires a New Evidence Certificate to be issued before resumed inquests may duplicate previous investigative steps.
Amendment 32, page 68, line 34, after “essential” insert
“, if the inquest in question involves a person who has served in His Majesty’s Armed Forces or a former member of the Royal Ulster Constabulary.”
Amendment 33, page 69, line 2, after “A person” insert
“who has served in His Majesty’s Armed Forces or a former member of the Royal Ulster Constabulary and who is”.
Government amendment 240.
Amendment 112, page 69, leave out from the beginning of line 35 to the end of line 16 on page 70.
Government amendments 241 to 243.
Clause 84 stand part.
Amendment 142, in clause 85, page 70, line 39, at end insert—
“(5) A decision under this section is subject to section (Review of certain decisions relating to Veterans) where that section applies.”
Clauses 85 to 87 stand part.
Government amendment 244.
Clause 88 stand part.
Amendment 105, in clause 89, page 73, line 1, leave out subsection (4).
This amendment would remove the retrospective effect of the interim custody order provisions.
Clause 89 stand part.
Amendment 106, in clause 90, page 73, line 7, leave out
“does not affect the quashing of the conviction, but” and insert “shall not be applied retrospectively, and”.
This amendment and Amendment 107 clarify that the quashing of previous convictions on the grounds that the Secretary of State had not personally signed an interim custody order should not be disregarded for the purposes of securing compensation for miscarriages of justice.
Amendment 107, page 73, line 8, after “is” insert “not”.
See the explanatory statement for Amendment 106.
Clause 90 stand part.
Government new clause 49—Guidance about prosecution of Troubles-related offences: Northern Irelandand England and Wales.
Government new clause 50—Consent requirement for prosecution of indictable-only Troubles-related offences.
Government new clause 51—On the run letters.
Government new clause 52—Removal of bars on bringing civil claims relating to the Troubles.
Government new clause 53—Independent reports about effect of certain provisions etc on former members of the security forces.
New clause 7—Annual Reporting on Recruitment and Retention within the Armed Forces—
“(1) The Secretary of State must, within three months of any regulations being made under section 97(4) to commence this Act, appoint a person to act as an independent reviewer of the effect of this legislation on recruitment and retention in the United Kingdom Armed Forces (“the independent reviewer”).
(2) The person appointed under subsection (1) must—
(a) not have previously held elected political office in the United Kingdom;
(b) not be a current member of a political party registered in the United Kingdom;
(c) not be a current employee of a political party registered in the United Kingdom;
(d) not be a current employee of the Northern Ireland Civil Service or of the United Kingdom Civil Service;
(e) not be a current employee of the British Armed Forces.
(3) The process for appointing the independent reviewer shall be conducted by the Commissioner for Public Appointments.
(4) The person appointed as the independent reviewer under subsection (1) shall have a term in office of five years, renewable for a single additional term by the Secretary of State.
(5) The independent reviewer must provide a report to the Secretary of State within six months of their appointment and every twelve months thereafter on the impact of this Act on recruitment and retention in the United Kingdom Armed Forces.
(6) On receiving a report under subsection (5), the Secretary of State must lay a copy of it before Parliament along with the Secretary of State’s response to the report’s findings.
(7) The Secretary of State may pay the expenses of the independent reviewer and may also pay them such allowances as the Secretary of State, with the advice of the Commissioner for Public Appointments, determines.”
New clause 12—Duty to promote reconciliation—
“(1) The Secretary of State must publish a strategy for the promotion of reconciliation in Northern Ireland arising from and in connection with the implementation of this Act.
(2) The strategy must set out how the Secretary of State intends to—
(a) support the transition from the legacy of the Troubles to a stable and shared future;
(b) foster constructive relationships between different communities in Northern Ireland; and
(c) acknowledge the suffering of victims and survivors.
(3) In preparing the strategy, the Secretary of State must consult—
(a) the Legacy Commission;
(b) the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee of the House of Commons;
(c) the Victims and Survivors Advisory Group; and
(d) such other persons as the Secretary of State considers appropriate.
(4) The Secretary of State must lay a copy of the strategy before both Houses of Parliament within six months of the Act coming into force.
(5) In this section, references to the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee shall, if the name of the Committee is changed, be taken to be references to the Committee by whatever name it is for the time called.”
This new clause places a statutory duty on the Secretary of State to produce and publish a strategy for promoting reconciliation in Northern Ireland in connection with the implementation of the Act.
New clause 22—Restriction on repeated investigations without new and compelling evidence—
“(1) The Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (“the ICRIR”) must not begin, continue, or reopen any review or investigation of conduct forming part of the Troubles where—
(a) that conduct has previously been the subject of an investigation, inquest or other legal proceedings, and
(b) no new and compelling evidence has become available.
(2) For the purposes of this section, “new and compelling evidence” means evidence which—
(a) was not available to any previous investigation, inquest or proceedings, and
(b) is reliable, substantial and highly probative such that it gives rise to a realistic prospect of a different outcome.
(3) No review or investigation may be begun, continued or reopened by virtue of subsection (1) unless the Secretary of State has certified that—
(a) the test in subsection (2) is met, and
(b) it is in the interests of justice to proceed.
(4) In deciding whether to issue a certificate under subsection (3), the Secretary of State must have regard to—
(a) the public interest in finality of investigations,
(b) the age, health and welfare of the person concerned, and
(c) the need to ensure fair and proportionate treatment.
(5) The Secretary of State must by regulations make provision for an independent review of decisions made under subsection (3).”
This new clause would prevent the reopening or continuation of Troubles-related investigations or reviews where there is no new and compelling evidence, and introduces a certification requirement whereby the public interest, age and health of persons concerned, and the need for fair and proportionate treatment are considered before a review or investigation may be begun, continued, or re-opened.
New clause 30—Mandatory Compliance with Medical Certificate—
“(1) This section applies where a person (“P”) is required, or has been requested, to give evidence in connection with—
(a) an investigation under Part 3;
(b) inquisitorial proceedings under Part 4; or
(c) a resumed inquest under Part 7.
(2) Where P has provided a certificate issued by a registered medical practitioner stating that P is unfit to give oral evidence, the relevant decision-maker must not require P to give oral evidence unless subsection (3) applies.
(3) Where there are substantial grounds to believe that a medical certificate produced by P has been procured by fraud, or in any other way dishonestly, the relevant decision-maker may require P to disclose their full medical records for the purposes of determining P’s fitness to give evidence.
(4) Where medical records have been requested under subsection (3), P is under no obligation to supply those records to any person other than the relevant decision maker and such records shall not be supplied by the decision maker to any other individual.
(5) Save where the circumstances described in subsection (3) apply, and the decision-maker determines that P is in fact fit to give evidence, no adverse inference may be drawn from any person’s reliance on medical unfitness certification.
(6) For the purpose of this section, “the relevant decision-maker” means—
(a) the relevant Director of Investigations;
(b) the relevant judicial panel member; or
(c) the coroner conducting the resumed inquest (as the case may be).”
New clause 31—Review of certain decisions relating to Veterans—
“(1) This section applies where a decision is made under—
(a) section 28(11) (requests for investigations by certain persons);
(b) section 43 (referral to prosecutors: investigations);
(c) section 61 (referral to prosecutors: inquisitorial proceedings); or
(d) any provision of Part 7 (inquests).
(2) A person to whom the decision relates may, within such period as may be prescribed by regulations made under the affirmative statutory instrument procedure by the Secretary of State, request that the decision be reviewed in accordance with this section.
(3) Where a request is made under subsection (2), the decision must be referred to—
(a) the Attorney General for England and Wales;
(b) a person appointed by the Attorney General for England and Wales who—
(i) holds or has held high judicial office in the courts of England and Wales; and
(ii) does not hold office in Northern Ireland.
(4) A reviewer under subsection (3) may—
(a) confirm the decision;
(b) quash the decision;
(c) remit the decision to the original decision maker for reconsideration, together with directions as to the matters to which regard must be had in reconsidering the decision.”
This new clause provides for the review of certain decisions by the Attorney General, or a serving or former Judge from outside Northern Ireland.
New clause 54—Reconciliation, transparency and memorialisation of the Troubles—
“(1) The Secretary of State must, within six months of this Act receiving Royal Assent, lay before both Houses of Parliament a statement on the implementation of Part 4 of the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 (“the 2023 Act”).
(2) The statement made by the Secretary of State must include, but be not limited to—
(a) details on how the implementation of Part 4 of the 2023 Act will occur in relation to the entry into force of this Act.
(b) a proposed appointment process for selecting “designated persons”, for the purposes of Part 4 of the 2023 Act, that is transparent and guarantees the independence of those persons appointed.
(c) provisions detailing the reconciliation projects that will receive funding from His Majesty’s Government.”
This new clause would require the Government to make a statement on progress in implementing Part 4 of the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023, reflecting recommendations made by the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee in its Second Report of Session 2024–26.
Government amendment 245.
Clause 91 stand part.
Government amendments 267 to 275.
Schedule 6 stand part.
Clause 92 stand part.
Amendment 277, in clause 93, page 76, line 10, leave out “, or” and insert “,
(ea) F is a grandparent of D,
(eb) F is an aunt or uncle of D,
(ec) F is a niece or nephew of D,
(ed) F is a grandchild of D, or”.
This amendment would extend the definition of a close family member of a deceased person, as recommended by the Northern Ireland Affairs Committee in its Second Report of Session 2024-26.
Government amendments 246 to 248.
Clause 93 stand part.
Government amendments 249 and 250.
Clause 94 stand part.
Clauses 95 and 96 stand part.
Amendment 45, in clause 97, page 78, line 35, after “(2)” insert
“and subject to the provisions of subsections (3A) and (3B)”.
This amendment is a paving amendment for Amendment 46.
Government amendment 251.
Amendment 46, page 78, line 36, at end insert—
“(3A) No regulations may be made by the Secretary of State under subsection (3) unless the condition in subsection (3B) is met.
(3B) The condition in this subsection is that the Secretary of State must lay before both Houses of Parliament a written statement which outlines the steps undertaken by both the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of Ireland to implement the undertakings made in “The Legacy of the Troubles: A Joint Framework between the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of Ireland” (“the Joint Framework”), including, but not limited to, a report of the Secretary of State’s understanding of progress on—
(a) a cross-border body on information retrieval,
(b) the establishment of a dedicated unit within An Garda Síochána to be a central point of contact for cross-border cooperation on Troubles-related cases and Troubles-related investigations being undertaken by An Garda Síochána,
(c) the investigation by An Garda Síochána of all unresolved Troubles-related incidents within its jurisdiction.”
Clauses 97 and 98 stand part.
That is why the Bill strikes a balance on how to take this issue forward. It enables the resumption of the small number of inquests that were cut off midway on 1 May 2024. We believe that those families deserve to have that process continue, as we have said from the outset. For inquests that have been directed but not started, the Bill requires the Solicitor General to sift whether they would be best handled by the legacy commission or a coroner based on clear criteria, including a statutory presumption in favour of the commission for cases involving sensitive material, owing to the greater powers of the commission to take such material into account in producing reports. This is covered directly in clause 84.
There are understandable concerns about how we ensure that veterans are treated with dignity and respect within the coronial process. That is exactly why we have introduced safeguards to protect veterans from cold calling, to ensure that they do not have to travel to or within Northern Ireland to give evidence, and to ensure that the operational context in which they served is fully recognised. Let me repeat: these also apply to inquests, not just to the legacy commission. The Bill also amends coronial law so that inquests cannot repeat processes that have already been undergone elsewhere unless essential.
Let me turn to the matter of when this process comes to an end, which is something that has been raised with me by many veterans and others. Earlier this year, the right hon. Member for Goole and Pocklington (David Davis) tabled amendment 50, which sought to remove clause 85. I agree with him, so I have added my name to the amendment—it is now a Government amendment. This means that no new legacy inquests can be directed when the commission comes to an end. In practice, it means that we will simply vote for clause 85 not to stand part of the Bill, when we get to that moment. I believe that this will provide a clear end to troubles-related inquests and certainty for all those involved. I am very grateful to the right hon. Gentleman for tabling the amendment, and for his gratitude when I rang him to tell him that I was adding my name to it. I want to make it absolutely clear that this will mean no additional inquests—full stop, punto final.
As several Members pointed out yesterday, addressing the legacy of the troubles is a responsibility for both the UK and Irish Governments. A unilateral approach simply cannot work, as was demonstrated by the legacy Act. As Sir Declan Morgan, the chief commissioner of the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery, has repeatedly made clear to me, my predecessor—my right hon. Friend the Member for Leeds South—and the public, co-operation from the Garda and other Irish authorities will be essential to the commission’s ability to find answers for families. That is why my predecessor negotiated the joint framework, and it is why we are committed to implementing it.
Let us be clear about what that means. Records held by the Irish authorities may well contain crucial information or answers about how UK civilians and service personnel died. I have heard many people make the point that while the British Army kept records, paramilitaries certainly did not. However, we know that the Irish authorities may well have crucial information that is vital to this process.