My Lords, this instrument is a necessary part of the wider legal framework that has brought British Steel into public ownership. I will begin by setting out why this legal certainty matters.
Steel is a foundational industry; it supports our national infrastructure, our defence and security, our clean energy ambitions and our wider economic growth. British Steel is a major producer in the United Kingdom, providing products that are essential to the construction, maintenance and operation of critical infrastructure. This led to my right honourable friend the Member for Hove and Portslade, the Secretary of State at the time of the transfer, to conclude, following careful consideration of the public interest test in the Steel Industry (Nationalisation) Act 2026, that it was necessary to bring British Steel into public ownership. That was an exceptional step and it was not taken lightly.
The Government previously used the Steel Industry (Special Measures) Act 2025 to maintain continued and safe steel production. Following unsuccessful negotiations with the owner, and given the risk of serious disruption to domestic steel-making capabilities, the Government determined that public ownership was the only viable route to secure continuity while longer-term options for the business are explored.
4:15 pm
First, the instrument ensures that the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006—TUPE—applied to employees moving on from the old company to the new company. This meant that British Steel employees had certainty about the continuity of their job and the terms and conditions after the transfer.
Secondly, the instrument disapplied the TUPE requirements for the current employer to inform and, where appropriate, to consult elected or trade union employee representatives due to the unusual situation and pace of this legislative transfer of the British Steel business. This is only in the context of this specific transfer.
Thirdly, it rules out the possibilities that Ministers and civil servants count as shadow directors of the company.
Fourthly, the instrument provides that British Steel does not count as a public authority subject to the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and the Procurement Act 2023. This reflects the fact that it operates and competes in the private sector rather than as a traditional public body.
Fifthly, it disapplies rules around the reuse of the company name by a new company when the original company goes into insolvent liquidation. These modifications have enabled, and will continue to enable, the new publicly owned company to function properly while the Government stabilise the business and consult on its longer-term future.
The Government’s objective is to maintain continuity, protect capability and provide stability while the future of British Steel is developed. Public ownership gives the immediate platform from which the company can be stabilised, operations can continue and options for a sustainable long-term future can be considered. That work will require close engagement with management, employees, trade unions, customers, suppliers and other stakeholders.
In summary, this instrument is technical but important. It ensures that the nationalisation of British Steel operates effectively in law. It supports employee certainty, business continuity and the continued operation of a strategically important steel undertaking. It is targeted, necessary and proportionate. For those reasons, I beg that the Committee considers these regulations.
My Lords, I find these instruments very worrying, because they seem to be part of a pattern that the nationalised British Steel will not be properly accountable and will not provide decent information for the taxpayers’ representatives now funding the operation. We all wish every success in saving jobs and maintaining the basic steel-making capacity in this country, but I fear that this vehicle is not going about it in the right way.
We are not learning about what we are actually buying for the huge sums of money that are currently being put into it, with no proper budget line and no proper business plan to explain the expenditure. We learn in the scrutiny committee’s report that, in the first year or so, it was £555 million, so it is eating into the budget line for investment support in new steel-making activities—which is, I think, how it is being funded by the Treasury—when presumably all or most of that has nothing to do with capital spending but has everything to do with operating losses. Much of it is based around the non-competitiveness of UK energy prices and the phenomenal cost of burning fossil fuels in blast furnaces with carbon taxes and the other net-zero impedimenta, which are gradually deindustrialising very large areas of British activity, and would have deindustrialised us completely from basic steel-making if the Government had not stepped in, in this rather clumsy way, to route very large subsidies into a business that cannot conceivably compete at its current cost levels.
My Lords, I welcome these regulations and the Government’s support through their intervention to protect British Steel and safeguard future steel-making in this country. Steel is not simply another industry, as we heard from the Minister; it is a strategic national asset that is essential to our defence, infrastructure, energy security and economic resilience. Without a strong domestic steel industry, we risk becoming dependent on overseas supplies for materials that are fundamental to our national interest.
4:30 pm
For Sheffield and South Yorkshire, where I am from, this issue is particularly important. Steel-making is woven into our history, identity and prosperity for our communities. Generations of families have worked in our steel industry and developed skills and expertise that are recognised around the world. My family is part of that history; as I have previously mentioned, my grandfather, uncle and father all worked in the steel industry in Sheffield. Their experiences reminded me that steel is about much more than production figures and balance sheets. It is about livelihoods, family traditions, skilled employment and pride in what our country can manufacture.
When we allow steel-making capacity to disappear, we do not simply lose factories. We risk losing skilled workers, specialist knowledge, supply chains and the ability to train the next generation. That is why the Government were right to act to prevent the blast furnaces at Scunthorpe going cold. The consequences of allowing that capacity to disappear would have been felt far beyond Lincolnshire, affecting businesses and communities across the country, including in South Yorkshire.
20 of 43 shown
The instrument we are debating did not transfer British Steel into public ownership; that was done by the British Steel Limited Property Transfer Regulations 2026. The purpose of this statutory instrument is narrower but critical to the transfer. Together, the two instruments give practical effect to the transfer. The Modification of the Law (British Steel Limited Property Transfer) Regulations 2026, which are before the Grand Committee, will ensure that the mechanics of the transfer operate effectively and provide for the effective operation of the business post-transfer. In doing so, it will protect the continuity of operations and give legal certainty to employees, customers, suppliers and other parties affected by the transfer.
Noble Lords will, rightly, want assurance that scrutiny has not been bypassed. I therefore welcome the scrutiny today. The instrument was made using the “made affirmative” procedure because it needed to come into force simultaneously with the property transfer regulations, in circumstances that were commercially sensitive and where operational continuity was essential. Notices were provided to the Speakers before the instrument was laid, explaining why it was necessary for it to come into force before being laid. The instrument is now before both Houses for approval, as Parliament intended when it passed the 2026 Act. The modifications are deliberately targeted. They are made under Section 50 of the Steel Industry (Nationalisation) Act 2026, which allows the Secretary of State to modify the law only for the purposes of enabling the transfer of powers in Part 1 of the Act to be used effectively.
This is not a general power to rewrite the law; it is a limited power tied to the effective operation of a particular transfer. This instrument relates specifically to the British Steel transfer. There are five technical areas of the law which require modification to ensure the effectiveness of the transfer of British Steel. This is necessary because a legislative nationalisation at pace was not envisaged when those laws were first drafted.
It would be timely if the Minister could update this Committee, and therefore the wider Parliament, on where we are getting to on the losses to date, as the last figures relate to the summer and the monthly losses were obviously very considerable then. Is there any sign of the monthly losses coming down at all, or are we to assume that it will be £500 million or so a year every year?
It would be very good if the Minister could tell us what the plans are for these two blast furnaces. They are extremely old. I do not know whether they are both steel-producing or what maintenance schedule they have to be on, but, at some point, they will obviously need fundamental maintenance. Will that be put into the budget plans? Alternatively, will the nationalised industry carry on with the plans that the previous Government—and, I think, this Government at the beginning—were trying to negotiate with the Chinese owners: a case of switching over from blast furnace-basic steel-making to an electric arc furnace arrangement for recycled steel? That would clearly come with the loss of a lot of jobs, because they are far less job intensive, and would mean the termination of our country’s ability to make primary steel in the traditional way. Sometimes, you need primary steel to provide the additives and special steels that are more difficult to find in recycled steel. Therefore, Parliament deserves to know more about the long-term plans.
Capital expenditure for an electric arc furnace would be very considerable and would need to have its own budget line, but it would be a more legitimate drawdown of the monies in the current overall budget for steel modernisation, out of which this seems to be funded. The Government wish to drop the idea of quarterly reporting of the financial figures. If a business in the private sector were losing this much money, quarterly reporting would be a bare minimum—you would want it to be monthly. The executives would want weekly reporting because this is a terrifying rate of loss, which implies that it is unsustainable. I would have thought the unions and workforce would be very interested as well, because I cannot see how the current operation represents a way of saving these jobs. At some point, there will be a crisis because of the lack of competitiveness and the very high level of cash burn, which would force the Government into a change of mind.
I am concerned at the wide-ranging and sweeping legal powers that the second statutory instrument wishes to take. There would be many companies trading in the private sector that would love to have friends at court who could suddenly suspend or remove all kinds of legal obligations upon them. Rightly, the Government will probably not do that, so why do they think it is reasonable to suspend important legal obligations on a company because it happens to be nationalised? The idea that you should not consult over TUPE when transferring people’s jobs seems particularly strange, because I would have thought that many employees in the union there would have welcomed the nationalisation. Why do they have to be told that they no longer have the normal rights to consultation on what could be quite important changes to the contracts they are operating under?
More worrying still is the idea that no senior official—doing this as a day job and liaising carefully with the board and the company—and no Minister designing the steel policy should be deemed to be a shadow director. Surely, they would be able to influence, to control or to order the company, because he or she who controls the money controls the business. This business really only has one important customer, which is the British Government, who are supplying these monumental sums of cash to keep the jobs going and to keep the blast furnaces operating, if possible.
Of course, Ministers and senior officials are, in practice, making crucial decisions that will dominate board discussions. If they are determined to suspend company law in relation to those activities, because they are Ministers and senior officials, there should be even more of an obligation on them to come regularly to the Commons and Lords to report on the progress they have been making so that we can apply the kind of scrutiny to them that would otherwise have been applied by company law and in normal board discussions by directors who genuinely have the power to determine the future of their company. The directors who the Government appoint will not determine the future of this company; the big decisions will be taken by the Government. Its very future is entirely dependent on the Government continuing to put very large sums of money into it.
We should also ask why the Freedom of Information Act will not apply. Again, it leads to suspicion that the Government think the results, performance and plans of this company will be so bad that they should not be revealed to the taxpaying public who pay for them. I would be a little more reassured if, in return for taking this big power—removing freedom of information inquiries from this expenditure of money in this very important company—we were told that there would be more regular and frank reporting through Parliament and directly to the public by normal company information. We could then be reassured that the Government are not trying to avoid all kinds of accountability.
It would be good to know from the Minister when the finances of this group will be regularised with a normal budget line, which we can see in the Red Book and Budget Statements. I do not think that they can go on for much longer saying this is just part of a general steel package designed for something else. We need an honest line in the Budgets so that we can see that it is being properly financed and is part of the Budget settlement.
It would also be good to hear something about the cost of energy, because this is a major reason why the losses are so huge. Will they be benefiting from the recycling of government money? The Government take money off businesses through carbon taxes and then give some of it back through the so-called supercharger that we have heard about this afternoon in the Chamber. This is a very unsatisfactory way of doing it. It increases the administrative costs: instead of just taking the tax off, you have to ask to get some of the tax back. Can we know something about how much of the tax they will get back so that can help us form a judgment as to how competitive this might become?
Above all, we need to know from the Minister when there will be a proper government plan—or a proper company plan approved and directed by the Government —that meets the requirements of this legislation to say that they are charged with the duty of making a competitive and sustainable industry. Those two words are very interesting. Does “sustainable” mean that they definitely have to close the blast furnaces on the grounds that they do not meet net-zero standards? “Competitive” implies moving into breaking even, if not into profit. We are so far away from that that it would be extremely good to have a deadline or timetable for the first plan, and the knowledge that the Commons and Lords will have an opportunity to debate that plan, given that very large sums of money are being discussed, that a very important number of jobs are at risk—if the finances are not gripped, those jobs will eventually go—and that it is surely good order for a Government to be open and transparent in their dealings about such an important national industry.