I note several entries in the register of interests in relation to work I have done recently for the World Bank, the CHD and Conciliation Resources, my position as a ministerial adviser on soft power and my attendance at more than a couple of conferences on mediation and conflict prevention over the past year.
I thank all noble Lords who have volunteered to speak in this debate. I am very grateful for their participation and particularly for the Minister stepping up to address this important topic in his closing response. I am also grateful for this opportunity to address the escalation in violent conflict that we have seen across the globe in recent years and to speak a little about the hope that exists in the efforts that are escalating to prevent violent conflict and what we here in the UK can do to contribute.
Across the globe today we face the highest number of states involved in violent conflict that the world has seen since 1946. A recent report, Peace Works, by 11 international NGOs based here in the UK, showed that the cost to the world of this conflict is about 10% of global GDP—approximately £16 trillion. Nearly 120 million people across the world are displaced today, approximately half of them children. Over 200 million people face humanitarian need as a result of the impact of conflict. Tens of thousands of children are impacted directly by violent conflict every year. Sexual violence is increasing as a weapon of war after many years when it was enthusiastically tackled. Just under a quarter of a million people, combatants and civilians, were killed in 2025 as a result of violent conflict. In the UK we face the impact of that. We see increased division, distrust, the impact of displacement in different parts of the world and disruption, most of all to our energy supplies.
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, for introducing this debate. There is no more important topic; the world would be a much better place if there could be peace in places today torn by war, with the damage, destruction, and the violence that brings. I agree with a lot of what the noble Lord said about the opportunities for the United Kingdom with our great diplomatic skills, the reach of our diplomatic service, the experience we have gained over many decades and centuries of intervening around the world and, where we could, trying to find resolution of conflict, and with our own experiences bringing peace out of the very difficult situation in Northern Ireland. But, as the noble Lord referred to at the end, one of the reasons the United Kingdom does have a role in the world and is taken seriously is that we have serious and important defence forces. It is most important that they are used with a view to promoting peace where we are intervening, or to right wrongs that can be righted relatively easily by the judicious use of force. That has not always been true in the interventions that we and our NATO allies have made in recent decades in different parts of the world.
I hope the Government, as they go through a rather long defence review and discussion about how best to spend the money that is clearly needed, will have at the forefront of their mind how those forces can be used to deter violence and the outbreak of new conflicts, and how they can be used for expeditionary forces that can make timely interventions where necessary, particularly where those interventions can help create a peace, or where they are needed to police a peace which has been brought about by diplomatic process.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, on securing this debate and thank him for introducing it so well. I declare a non-pecuniary interest as chair of Inter Mediate, the charity founded by Jonathan Powell and inspired by the Northern Ireland peace process. Inter Mediate has been engaged for almost 15 years in dialogue with Heads of State and armed groups in attempts to resolve some of the most dangerous and intractable conflicts of our time. Some of its successes, such as Colombia and Mozambique, are matters of public record; the great majority of its work is not, and for good reason. Suffice it to say that I am more proud of the achievements of our remarkable staff, led by Claire Hajaj and Mockbul Ali, than I am of anything else apart from my own family.
When this House amended the National Security (State Threats) Bill this summer to avoid penalising or chilling dialogue between good faith conflict resolution organisations and designated foreign bodies, it was acknowledging that states do not have a monopoly in conflict resolution. Indeed, some of the principles identified by Jonathan Powell in his book Talking to Terrorists may be more usefully performed by non-state entities than by Governments: dialogue with actively hostile groups, the establishment of back channels and the taking of calculated risks to build trust.
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord for securing this timely debate, though I confess I speak with some trepidation given the considerable expertise in this Chamber. But as a refugee who arrived in this country from Iran as a young girl because of political violence and religious persecution, and as someone who has stayed abreast of developments in Iran and across the wider Middle East, this is a subject close to my heart.
I have spoken previously on why I think the joint US-Israel attack on Iran in February was an act of strategic folly, the consequences of which we continue to live with. The prospect of a renewed assault on Iran, soon after the mid-term elections in America and the recent elections in Israel, fills me with dread and illustrates all too well that our collective ability to mediate and prevent conflict is diminishing.
Although our assessments of the 1945 global order as broken, bruised or in the process of being bolstered may diverge, surely those who care about human flourishing and the conditions that support it cannot be content with the current era of disorder and unpeace. From a faith perspective, I certainly find this state of affairs deeply troubling. The apostle Paul wrote in 1 Corinthians, chapter 14, verse 33, that God is not a God of disorder, tumult or dissension but of peace, order, harmony and shalom.
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the right reverend Prelate, who brings unique experience to this conversation. I point her in the direction of the emerging markets and developing economies taskforce that the Church of England pension trustees are participating in. If successful, that project will achieve and deliver investment at a far greater scale than any development assistance from any country ever could and will unlock the real gains that are needed in developing countries, which will see more stability. That relates directly to the topic of today’s debate.
I am very grateful to my noble friend Lord McConnell for securing this debate. Occasions such as these often allow this Chamber to be at its best. So far, the contributions this afternoon have proved that to be the case.
The noble Lord, Lord Anderson, referred to Inter-Mediate. I thank him for the work that he has led with it alongside Jonathan Powell. They have done tremendous work, almost all of it invisible by necessity. I have had some involvement with some of its work at various points along the way, and I have had some amazing advice from Jonathan about the necessity of patience, discretion and building trust. In today’s world of what is too often reactive diplomacy, where everything needs to be said publicly and responded to instantly, the work that Inter-Mediate does just proves what can be achieved by taking a slightly different approach.
My Lords, I join in the congratulations to the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, not just on his luck in the ballot but also on his continuing zeal and determination in trying to focus our minds on these vastly important, indeed giant, world issues. Mediation, conflict prevention, peacebuilding and our role in it all are very big issues indeed, covering enormous areas. At least half our home Troubles, which sometimes seem just local matters, are in fact issues that, in a world in which what the Chancellor calls “global economic storms” are coming along, have their roots in precisely the areas that we are discussing today. They require strong and respected international and multilateral institutions to handle and calm them down.
Probably most important of all in the calming down process that is so badly needed are the multilateral agencies and respected fora, which are where our global decisions can be reached and the frameworks, design and rules must be established. Trusted and respected multilateral bodies must be rebuilt, as they were in 1945. People forget that, in 1945, after the rubble of the Second World War, we created from nothing—Americans and British in the lead, but many others as well—an entirely new structure of international co-operation. Yet all those post-war institutions, which served us quite well for decades in the 20th century, are now in deep trouble. They are the rule-makers, or are meant to be, and the referees, but they must have respect and some trust if their writ is to run.
My Lords, I have spent 47 years in Westminster. I have supported conflicts worldwide, most notably in the Middle East and eastern Europe, but some recent conflicts have caused me to reflect and have cost me dearly. Friendships have been fractured. My view that we have sometimes questionably intervened in matters overseas has been unpopular. Today’s debate is about global mediation and conflict prevention, and I shall concentrate my remarks on Ukraine and Russia.
In 1992, as a Labour shadow Agriculture Minister, I visited Moscow to investigate our beef export trade. That eye-opening visit gave me an early opportunity post Gorbachev—Yeltsin was president—to look at developments in Russia. I visited the Duma, NGOs and institutions. The Russian economy was in free fall. Its proud people, the spirit of Stalingrad, were being humiliated before the civilised world. Its administration was often riddled with corruption, with many former Soviet apparatchiks openly exploiting the system to survive, their actions often underpinned by reckless acts of officials who sanctioned violence.
I particularly recall the poverty. I witnessed a respectable, well-clad woman in effect begging over a small stall in the street with her meagre offerings—a bunch of vegetables, a tin or two and some vodka—to raise money to survive on little pension. She was one among many whom I witnessed. The currency was in free fall. My hotel rate was $150 for foreigners; it was $5 for locals. Black marketeers were touring the hotels dealing in currency. Russia was in a state of total humiliation and collapse, and the political response was suspicion of the West.
My Lords, I begin my remarks with a simple reflection: the true test of diplomacy now is not how eloquently we respond to conflict but how effectively we prevent it. I draw Members’ attention to my registered interests with the World Humanitarian Forum and the International Communities Organisation, and as a member of the International Relations and Defence Committee. The issue of conflict prevention is very close to my heart. I thank the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, for tabling this debate. Over many years as a Minister, I saw his passionate advocacy for both conflict resolution and humanitarian affairs.
Today, as we confront a world marked by more than 65 conflicts, depending on how you define a conflict or a war, deepening geopolitical divisions and immense humanitarian suffering, the responsibility on all of us, and the United Kingdom in particular, has never been greater. Behind every statistic of a life lost—and we heard harrowing statistics from the noble Lord, Lord McConnell—there is a human story: a family displaced, a child deprived of education, a woman subjected to violence, or a community whose hopes for a peaceful future have been shattered.
Having served in government, represented the UK internationally, and worked extensively through the United Nations, I have seen both the potential and success of diplomacy but also, tragically, the consequences that come when you act too late. The UK was part of the conflict resolution between Azerbaijan and Armenia. Perhaps we do not get the credit we deserve. I remember shuttling between Foreign Ministers. But that was the true sense of British diplomacy: discreet and understated. I have learned that peace is not achieved through declarations alone. It requires, as the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, said, sustained political engagement, conversations, crucial and trusted partnerships, and, above all, the courage to keep working when progress seems elusive. Prevention, mediation and peacebuilding are not separate stages of our international responsibility; they are interconnected parts of the same endeavour.
1:21 pm
20 of 42 shown
Unfortunately, over the last decade the UK has stepped back rather than stepping up into this challenge. We used to lead the world in global thinking, global action on conflict prevention and peacebuilding. Between 2005 and 2015, successive Governments took the action that was required at home and abroad, and in the multilateral organisations, to make a real difference to combating global conflict, bringing about peaceful resolution and supporting those trying to implement peace agreements. But there has been no refreshing or updating of the conflict prevention strategy of the United Kingdom since the 2016 building stability overseas strategy. Over that decade, we have reduced our capacity for working in the multilateral organisations and, perhaps more importantly, on the ground in local peacebuilding initiatives. Our spend on conflict prevention reduced from £296 million in 2017 to £118 million in 2023; the figures for the next three years have not yet been published.
It was noted, in an independent report this time last year to commemorate the 25th anniversary of Resolution 1325 at the United Nations on women, peace and security, that there was an increasing gap between policy and rhetoric—all very positive, not just about women, peace and security but about peacebuilding and conflict prevention generally—and action and delivery by the UK. Globally, we face enormous challenges, not just because of the scale of the conflict but because a United Nations that was designed for approximately 50 member states in 1946 is increasingly unfit for purpose for nearly 200 states in 2026.
There is good news amid all this misery and violence. We have countries around the world stepping into the area of conflict prevention and mediation. Turkey, for example, joined with Finland in 2010 to establish the Group of Friends of Mediation at the United Nations. It also co-chairs the friends of mediation in the OIC and in the OSCE. Over these last 16 years it has been involved in helping to resolve disputes between Ethiopia and Somalia and in supporting the peace process in the Philippines. Of course, closer to home it has also regularly engaged with a number of conflicts in its own neighbourhood.
In Japan, just this year the new Prime Minister established the international peace mediation unit in its foreign service to take a “more proactive role” in peacefully settling disputes in other places. That is particularly significant in south-east Asia, given some of the challenges that we are seeing.
Qatar has become both a location and a voice for mediation and conflict prevention since 2004. It has been involved in several ceasefires, the return of hostages, the establishment of peace agreements and support for them afterwards, not least recently in Gaza but also in the DRC and on an issue close to my heart—helping to secure the return of some of the Ukrainian children stolen by Russia, many thousands of whom still lie behind Russian lines. The UK established a partnership with Qatar just 12 months ago to take forward this work on mediation and conflict prevention. I would be interested to hear an update from the Minister on the progress of that partnership and the actions that have been or could yet be taken.
There is a common thread running through this international action, which is supplemented by the historic and important work of the Scandinavian states, the Swiss, more recently the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and others. That thread is that every mediation, every sincere effort at conflict prevention, has three key elements. It has to have sincere dialogue; it has to have a sustained, patient and consistent approach to the mediation itself; and increasingly it has to have regional ownership. In the neighbourhood, people understand the historical, cultural and identity issues that will drive many of these conflicts, and which local leaders could bring about an end to the conflict and sustain the peace.
I have seen this for myself, working with the FCDO, with a number of NGOs, with the Philippine Government and with the former Moro Islamic Liberation Front in the Bangsamoro region of the Philippines. Centuries of division between the Catholic and Muslim populations of the Philippines and decades of armed conflicts in Muslim Mindanao led to a quarter of a million people dying between 1968 and the early part of the 21st century. But in 2014 the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro, supported by the United Kingdom and the international community but led locally and chaired by the first-ever woman to sign a peace agreement anywhere in the world as the chief negotiator, was signed. I have spoken about this process in your Lordships’ House before, but I am delighted to report that in September, just two months ago, the Bangsamoro region held its first elections to the democratically elected autonomous parliament that was promised in the peace agreement. Those elections have been relatively peaceful. The new chief minister will be elected by the new parliament tomorrow in Cotabato. The UK has been a partner in that process, just as we were a partner in Colombia and a driver for the peace process in Somalia. I hope that we will continue to help build peace in the Philippines and elsewhere in south-east Asia. Perhaps the Minister could reflect on that too.
The UK has significant assets that we can contribute to conflict prevention and to mediation and peacebuilding across the world. We have the honour and the responsibility of a permanent seat on the UN Security Council. Our other networks include NATO, the Commonwealth, partnership with the European Union and our considerable diplomatic assets—still one of the best and most respected diplomatic networks in the world, despite some of the cutbacks of recent years.
Here in the UK, we have the expertise and the trust not just in government but outside government that so many people feel that they can, or at least have been able to, rely on. We must use those soft power assets that we have to be engaged more in the years to come in trying to reverse this increase in violent conflict and support those who are seeking peace.
That same report, Peace Works, that was published just last month and launched here in Parliament by the All-Party Group on Conflict Prevention, Conflict Resolution and Peacebuilding, had five key priorities that the UK could follow. The first—this is a statement of purpose that might seem very obvious, but it is not yet up front in the Government’s international strategy— would be to prioritise prevention, and to say that quite clearly and embody it in the work that we do on an everyday basis.
The second would be to energise coalitions. We have discussed this on many occasions. In fact, I think my last contribution in your Lordships’ House was on the coalition of the willing to support Ukraine in this time of desperate conflict against the Russian invasion. But we should be energising other coalitions for peace and supporting and participating where we can. The third would be to harness the capabilities that exist here in the UK, in and outside government, and use them in the way that can be most helpful. The fourth would be, at the same time, to champion local peacebuilders, because ultimately, without local ownership of peacebuilding processes, those processes cannot be sustained. Finally, in a world where technology is increasingly changing the nature of violent conflict, we need also to spearhead technology for peace. We can use many of these new technologies to help support peace rather than just dealing with war.
In securing this debate today, I ask whether the Minister can perhaps clarify for us the current state of funding and the plans for support from the Government for conflict prevention, not just this year but in the next three years. Can the Minister say whether that funding will be maintained in this difficult financial climate or whether there is even a possibility that it might be increased? Will we commit to being a reliable, engaged, long-term partner for not just those international partner countries that we can work with on mediation, conflict prevention and peacebuilding but those trying to build peace on the ground and within countries trying to recover from conflict, to ensure that future generations have a better future? Will we, ultimately, refresh the strategy from 2016 and ensure that we use our assets for the best purposes and the maximum impact as we intervene and take our responsibilities seriously around the world?
We have that responsibility. We have a historic responsibility—a very current responsibility in our role at the United Nations—but we also have an opportunity to use the skills, talents, capabilities and passions of people here in the United Kingdom. Will we use that responsibility and opportunity to not just resist and defend from violent aggression and prepare for that properly, which I fully support, but to contribute to peacebuilding and prevent conflict in a way that will ensure that future generations can live more safely and maximise the opportunities that they deserve?
There has been a bit of debate over the last 18 months within and outside the Government, and perhaps even elsewhere in the world too, about the competition between hard and soft power. Many countries, not least the UK, among the developed democracies of the world, have had to step up, rightly, and improve their hard power capabilities. However, I submit to your Lordships’ House that that cannot be at the expense of soft power. We need to not make this a choice between hard and soft power; we need to use smart power. It will be smart power that will not just allow us to prevent and deter violent conflict against ourselves or our allies but allow us to make a difference around the world and ensure that people are able to live in peace. With that hopefully positive potential outcome to all this, I move the Motion standing in my name.
I am sure all of us agree that talking and diplomatic compromise are usually better than conflict extending into aggressive war, and that we would all agree that you only get a war when diplomacy and politics have failed. We all here believe that politics, particularly democratic politics, should be a benign force channelling the conflicts and disagreements into words and arguments and resolving them by compromise or votes. But that will not always be possible in different parts of the world, and that is why we need to choose to spend our money on defence wisely, and to see how we can best help the world through those places where we have power: through the United Nations, through our senior membership of NATO and through the Commonwealth and all the associations that brings.
Looking at defence priorities, it is most important that the Government do not forget that the main priority is to be able to defend these islands and to show that these islands are so well defended that they would be a very hostile environment should any external force wish to intervene. That must mean strengthening our sea forces and our ability to respond to drone and missile attack, and to know how to police our waters when we see possible hostile powers looking enviously at our cables and pipes that are such an important part of our economic progress. So, will the Government please make sure that that is all beefed up and the best modern technology adopted?
When it comes to expeditionary force, we have in the past shown that we have that expeditionary capability, and at times it has been very successful. The Falklands are only free today, and the people of the Falklands are only safe in their wish to be British, because we had enough expeditionary force on our own to drive out the Argentinian invader and restore order. It is most important that we now keep enough force available in case anybody has changed their minds in Argentina about what they might wish to do to try to gain control of islands that are clearly British. British forces were also very successful alongside the American allies leading the operation when Kuwait was liberated, which was a very good example of a sharp use of overwhelming force to right a very obvious wrong where a country had been badly invaded.
Today we have two very big conflicts, which are damaging in themselves—particularly damaging for those involved with them, with too many deaths and too much destruction of property—but also very damaging to the rest of us economically, and because we are morally offended by how they originated. Those are the conflicts in Ukraine and in the Middle East.
We need to hear from the Government a bit more about how they wish to proceed. If we take the case of Ukraine, the war has dragged on for so long and we keep Prime Ministers for such little time that there have now been five United Kingdom Prime Ministers who have had to respond to the difficult situation in Ukraine. They have shown complete unity of understanding and purpose, they have all condemned the Russian invasion and the atrocities that have resulted and they have all wished to offer sensible support to the very brave Ukrainians defending their country. But they have all been very clear that we are not going to declare war on Russia, commit British forces or drag NATO into a conflict with Russia. That would greatly worsen the position and is much against everybody’s interests, including those of the Ukrainians, because it would intensify the exchange of barbarity with all the extra firepower it would bring to the conflict.
That means that we in the West have a dilemma: we are not going to offer a military coalition to beat the Russians, and the Ukrainians, fighting very bravely, have not yet been able to evict the Russians from their territory. I would be interested to know what the latest government thinking is about when and if there is going to be any chance for talking to replace war-fighting and for the two belligerents to be brought to the table in a way that might produce some kind of diplomatic answer. It is not obvious how you do it. President Trump has been much criticised for trying to do it; people thought he was being too kind to Russia, which is not something that people want. It would be interesting to know what the United Kingdom and the European Union position on all this is, and whether there is any way through. I think we all feel that five years of war is excessive and that the awful problems it is creating for the Ukrainian people are unacceptable, difficult though it is to see a way out.
In the case of the Middle East, the United Kingdom does not have a big role to play because it appears that we do not really have serious forces to offer to try to police the sea-lanes and to deal with some of the attacks on our allies in the Gulf. America has the near monopoly of power that can be committed to that, and in that sense it is America’s war. We all rest upon what happens in the exchanges between the President of the United States of America and those now leading Iran.
I would be interested to know whether the Government feel there is anything we can do by way of helping our allies in the Gulf, and whether they can see any way forward, which is more likely to be led by local interests there, as the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, very sensibly said. We too are friends of the UAE, Qatar and so forth—the places most likely to be able to help. It would be good if we could get our defence forces into a shape where we could play a more significant role in trying to help the restoration of normal shipping in the Gulf and Red Sea area. Clearly, energy prices, interest rates and other things globally have been driven up by the extent of that conflict and by the interruptions to trade. In a world that should have plenty of oil and is in transition to using less of it, we find ourselves short of it because of a very nasty war.
I would hope that the defence review would come up with good answers on that combination of defending the home base, which needs more defence, and the appropriate expeditionary force for policing commerce and sea-lanes and going to the aid of allies. It would be very useful to know from the Minister how the Government can extend the skills and the experiences we have had diplomatically and in governing places that are subject to these conflicts. The world desperately needs peace, particularly in those two centres of warfare at the moment, and we would all be better off if that could be brought about.
Unlike some noble Lords present today, my experience of international conflict resolution is largely second hand. I am not out there cutting deals with national leaders or armed insurgents—just sitting in London checking the kidnap insurance and signing off on the accounts—so I shall not detain your Lordships for long. I venture to make three points that have struck me with particular force during my eight years with Inter Mediate.
First, we in the United Kingdom have a very good name for this sort of activity. I am regularly impressed by the regard in which our diplomats and third-sector peacemakers are held for their influence, their convening power, their trustworthiness and their moral leadership, even—perhaps especially—in those parts of the world where we were once the coloniser. In a 2026 Conciliation Resources survey, 65% of those polled expressed support for UK investment in peacebuilding around the world. They were backing a British success story that, with the right support, has the potential for more success still.
Secondly, conflict resolution is not some wishy-washy nice-to-have. Here I go perhaps a little further than the noble Lord, Lord McConnell: it is an essential ingredient of our hard power. Conflict, weak governance and institutional collapse can create opportunities for terrorist recruitment, regeneration and expansion, and can provide hostile actors with opportunities to undermine UK interests. Integrating early warning, intelligence, local partnerships and institutional resilience into security planning enables us to anticipate threats and head them off. If our counterterrorism or containment strategy begins only when a threat becomes operational, we have already surrendered the advantage. Enhanced military power is certainly necessary, as the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, said—a year on the Armed Forces Parliamentary Scheme has left me in no doubt about that—but it can be strategically effective only when accompanied by work at every level to develop relationships, forge compromises, make agreements and see that they are implemented.
Thirdly, money spent in this field offers remarkable value. Public investment in civilian peacebuilding, conflict prevention and mediation is minuscule as a proportion of overseas development aid, and barely noticeable by comparison with defence spending. The annual budget of Inter Mediate would barely stretch to the purchase of a single fixed-wing attack drone or a Patriot missile. If we are serious about boosting our security, our self-reliance and our ability to respond to and shape international events, planning for a serious investment in mediation and peacebuilding needs to be a long-term priority, both in our world-class capacities here at home and in local partners who are essential for reach and for delivery. This means more than simply increasing budget allocations, although after years of the brutal cuts that have been referred to, that would be a good start. We need funding vehicles that are flexible and responsible, partnerships across government and with peacemaking organisations and, returning to where I started, a political and legal environment that supports the risks necessary to make peace.
Some will argue that, if you want peace, you must prepare for war. That logic is evident in last year’s strategic defence review and in subsequent conversations about how we fund Britain’s military commitments. I do not deny the utility of military deterrence, and I am immensely grateful and indebted to our Armed Forces, who risk danger to protect us. At the same time, I fear that the practice of some countries in recent years suggests we are now moving towards a new formulation altogether—namely, that if you want peace, you must first wage war.
That is a dangerous path to tread. It invites a new global arms race, renewed wars of conquest, shrinking trade and prosperity, and the collapse of the co-operation needed to confront shared global threats. It is a dystopian path that threatens our God-given human dignity and the very integrity of God’s creation. I worry that the preparation for war and the act of war itself become our principal ways of imagining the road to peace. We need instead, as the Lutheran archbishop of Estonia has suggested, to take an alternative pathway—namely, if you want peace, prepare for peace and invest in the instruments necessary to uphold it.
The 2025 strategic defence review was necessary, but where is the strategic peacebuilding review to complement it? At a time of heightened insecurity, we need a focused assessment of whether the UK has the policies, institutions, capabilities and partnerships needed to prevent violent conflict and strengthen the conditions for sustainable peace. At a time when considerable attention is rightly being given to defence, deterrence and national resilience, we also need to examine the other side of the security equation: how Britain prevents conflict, addresses the conditions in which violence and instability develop, and strengthens social cohesion and supports peace before, during and after crises. A strategic peacekeeping review could bring together the domestic and international dimensions of peacebuilding and consider the contribution of government, civil society, faith communities, business and international partners.
None of this is to belittle steps that have been taken in recent years. The creation of a 16-person peace process and mediation team at the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office is a welcome step, but how might this capability be strengthened and embedded across government, rather than remaining primarily as an FCDO-led operational function? Rather than undertaking such a strategic peace review and investing in peacebuilding mechanisms, we seem intent on financing our rearmament by salami-slicing the development budget and, in so doing, diminishing our ability to tackle the drivers of conflict in many parts of the world. This is a false economy and feels self-defeating. Instead, we should invest in peacebuilding, with fresh funding and a more joined-up national conversation than we have had to date.
This is an agenda that the Church takes seriously. The commitment to peacebuilding is part of our very DNA. We are willing to work together with government and others in creating the conditions in which war and conflict no longer feel like the logical choice or the inevitable outcome. Only last year, the Church of England Pensions Board established the Global Centre for Peacebuilding and Business to respond to the growing global demand for minerals and energy; the expansion of extractive industries into fragile and conflict-affected contexts; the risks that flow from this; and the extraordinary presence and reach of the Church in many of those places.
In South Sudan, a country where, for ordinary people, the situation is getting worse and nothing seems to be getting through to the political inner circle, the Church continues to be the most trusted and far-reaching national institution, engaged in peacebuilding, humanitarian responses, education and healthcare. This role is replicated in other fragile and conflict-ridden countries and underscores the Church’s commitment to being a force for reconciliation and peace.
All this is by way of saying that, in today’s age of disorder, peacebuilding should be understood not merely as a humanitarian endeavour but as a strategic imperative to national security, economic resilience and long-term stability. In a world increasingly focused on preparing for conflict, it is important that we continue making the case for peace and peacebuilding with all due seriousness. Committing to a strategic peace review, to sit alongside the strategic defence review, would be an important but long-overdue step in this direction.
Last night, I had the pleasure of attending an event here to mark 10 years since the signing of the peace agreement in Colombia. Former President Santos spoke about the painstaking work, the political risk, the essential role of the international community, and the commitment that is needed to this day to protect and secure that agreement.
When asked how the UK had helped, former President Santos said, “The most significant change happened when we instructed the Colombian armed forces to stop killing the FARC”. President Santos explained that, when the army began to capture fighters to demobilise and reintegrate them into society, the armed forces were no longer seen as devils by the fighters. He said that real progress was achieved when the enemy became viewed as people, not to be destroyed but rather to be defeated, because you need them to negotiate with in order to bring about a stable peace.
There are obviously lessons that can be learned from the Colombian experience, just as there are from other fragile and all-too-rare lasting peace agreements, such as the Good Friday agreement and Dayton, which are incredibly fragile and which we must protect at every opportunity. But there is a warning about trying to learn lessons and apply them directly in different contexts. It is tempting to search for a template—a set of principles to deploy that will guarantee success in other contexts—but, as we all know, each conflict is unique. The motivations, relationships, history and political space, the involvement of neighbouring states, which we see more and more, the approach of more distant but powerful nations, the presence of hard power, the deployment of technology and the character of the protagonists are all different.
Instead of the hard work of innovation—coming up with creative new approaches, combining our defence, diplomacy and development work, working alongside the multilateral development banks and multilateral systems—too often I see the international community’s response is to look to the tools that it used last time to ask itself which of those it ought to deploy. This is fine, important and can lead to some success—UN resolutions, increasingly outraged statements of condemnation, which I have given myself, sanctions, demands for accountability, side meetings and symbolism. These are all important and have their place, but issues and places are too often picked up and put down by the multilateral system and by nations. Look at Haiti, and even Sudan. There are so many examples. Who is holding it close? Who is really taking responsibility for what is happening and saying, “We’re the penholder: we have the job of making this better, however long it takes”. In an era when countries can trade off their relationships, not just with their neighbours, but with the US, China, Russia and Europe, protagonists can and do ignore the standard toolkit responses.
When agreements work, they are the result of deep understanding and, often, local leadership. This is especially true in Africa, where one year since the fall of El Fasher we continue to see widespread massacres and atrocities. While high-intensity wars in Ukraine and Gaza generate so much news, attention and, it is true, a massive share of the casualties, it is Sudan and, indeed, Africa as a whole that is the deadliest continent for deliberate non-combat violence, directed deliberately and specifically at civilians, with women paying a particularly high price. We see non-state armed groups, private armies, Russian mercenaries, extremist terrorist groups, weak states and communities desperately trying to survive despite it all.
This debate is about what the UK can and should do. If the UK and our partners want to help, as I believe we do, we must supplement the statement making with statecraft. We, by which I mean the international community, need less reliance on shaky deals between warlords and more time given to building long-term, resilient, civilian relationships that form the foundation of any lasting peace. We saw Kagame and Tshisekedi summoned by the White House to sign a deal. That did not bring about peace to eastern DRC, which is now ravaged by Ebola and lacks the community trust or state apparatus to do what is needed.
Last night, when I asked President Santos what his experience told him would help in Sudan, he gave an answer that I agree with completely. He said that the UK should give its time and attention to the supporters of the warring parties in neighbouring countries and further afield and that we should work hard to support civil society and local civilian leadership. It is low-key, unglamorous and time-consuming, but it is vital. Trade, transactional approaches and saying that we will bestow or withdraw development assistance or other such gestures will always fail. They have always failed. There is no example of where that approach, so often advocated for, has succeeded.
The UK, as others have said, has credibility in building and sustaining peace alongside others, notably Qatar and Norway. We must use this well and do so urgently, especially in places where the ordinariness of earning a living, raising your children and seeing out your days in peace is far too often denied. It should never ever be taken for granted.
Obviously, we need a new Bretton Woods to shape the financial regulations of an entirely different world from that of 80 years ago. We plainly need new trade rules in a far more complicated trade and investment world of supply chains. We need entirely new maritime controls, both subsea and surface. We need overhauled international courts, new insurance systems and so on and so forth. Where are the visionaries today? Where are the equivalents of Truman, Marshall, Maynard Keynes and Dexter White, for instance—although I am told that he had other interests as well. They were supported by a dazzling cast of American and British economists, officials and financiers.
National plans and solutions we have two a penny—they are coming out all the time—but missing is the other half of the story: the global network and new international organisations that are the shield under which our own reforms become possible and relevant. Where are the new levels of co-operation that we need to assume some control over artificial intelligence and superintelligent machines that are beginning to think for themselves and have their own agenda?
All this is ignored or barely reported or discussed in the media or in public policy. The spirit of 1945 and those visionaries is plainly needed all over again, but in an even more ambitious form. Without that, we can carry on attacking one another and attacking the nearest targets as well, but we remain the playthings of past economic fantasy theories, swept along in a rudderless craft in a world without rules, referees or restraints. Amid many uncertainties, the one thing that can be said with absolute certainty is that such a world, without the handrails of accepted standards, is fatal to the prospects of a nation such as Great Britain.
To those who shake their heads and say that the required degree of co-operation is politically impossible today, the answer is not so. Political parties may be harder than ever to keep together, but authors such as the brilliant Adrian Wooldridge, whose book I strongly recommend and who writes about centrists in all parties needing to come together, are pointing a way to a new kind of revolution. The middle ground may sound a quagmire to party warriors from the old ideologicalwars, but the new common ground, which is a very different thing, undoubtedly lies ahead. That is where the real revolution is, and where those with real foresight should be concentrating their views.
This is the political powerplay and style of co-operation in the internet age and beyond. It avoids the traumas of party “betrayal”, which the press loves to play up, but unites the search for common ground. The barrier, of course, is the old left-right battle that grew out of Marxism-Leninism versus laissez-faire capitalism and led to unstable ideological stalemate and worse.
The moderating instincts of balanced international liberalism ought to be the ones driving global financial stability and restoring free trade, which Trumpism has thrown into turmoil. They ought also to be the ones that open the gates to closer co-operation, rather than a standoff between private funding and public need in almost every sphere of public policy.
I end with one final observation: with the binding force of the English language still dominating global trade and holding together a still growing Commonwealth, the largest network in the world and the largest network in history, it may be that a new vehicle of thought, action and hope is about to be born. Let us wait and see.
Of course, it was totally unwarranted, a complete misunderstanding, the truth being that across our political divide there was a hope that their suffering would end and a new Russia committed to democratic values would surface and enter the world of advanced, civilised nations. It was not to be, as within two years of this period of humiliation, Russia signed the 1994 Budapest memorandum. It was a treaty born in duress that was prayed in aid by the noble Lord, Lord Bruce of Bennachie, last week. That memorandum was signed by Russia at its lowest ebb. Russia, in humiliation, never accepted that treaty. It arguably led to the election of Putin in 1998, a former spook with visions of rebuilding Russia which appealed to its humiliated peoples.
That brings me to the Putin years. I well recall that day in October 2001 when my noble friend Lord Robertson of Port Ellen, as NATO Secretary-General, met Vladimir Putin—I think it was in Vienna. My noble friend had proposed that a working group be established to promote a NATO-Russian relationship—all very welcome—but it was to be completely undermined by President Bush’s calls in the same year for NATO expansion into eastern Europe. Those Bush interventions were critical, as they heralded an end to détente and the revival of a militant Russia, where they were seen as acts of hostility. Russia had relied on the maintenance of a string of non-nuclear, non-NATO barrier states stretching from Finland to Georgia. Ever suspicious of the West, it followed up with its desperate but ill-considered attempt to take over Ukraine, and Zelensky was elected on the backlash.
It was about this time that I started following events in Russia more closely, which I do to this day. Talk of détente had gone, and the Robertson/Putin agenda was dead. We now had an inflexible Russia extending political control, grabbing territory—the Crimea—and manipulating populations in Ukraine’s eastern provinces, provoking a fearsome and brutal response from the Azov Brigade with its history of support for Germany in the Second World War, thus the Russian references to the Nazis. When historians reflect on developments in Ukraine during its darkest periods, let us not underestimate the significance of those battalions in Russia’s decision to use them as foil in justification for their invasion of Ukraine.
For me, the issue is how we should respond. We now face a future where a Russian leadership, paranoid and challenged, stands in isolation. I fear for the future of mankind in this period of conflict. A rogue operator in Russia’s nuclear military establishment could act in isolation. I well recall with concern the actions of Yevgeny Prigozhin, the rebel commander of the Wagner brigade, a former confidant of Putin, who died in suspicious circumstances. Putin himself saw the dangers, and it is in that light that the drift into war where Zelensky controls the agenda worries me.
So now how should we proceed? A proud Russia is cornered, and I suspect it seeks a settlement without humiliation. We need an agenda that avoids humiliation for all concerned. We need to settle this dispute. I have called repeatedly for the UK Government to seize the initiative and take on the settlement agenda. In my most recent interventions, I have called for the establishment of protectorate status in eastern Ukraine, for which there are well-established precedents—a settlement to include much of Donetsk and Luhansk, underpinned by guarantees from the major powers, to include the United States, Europe and Russia. I still believe that Russia’s future lies with the West and that Putin, for all his misunderstanding, can be returned to rational discussion. It is the British who should take the lead, but it is an agenda requiring courage, understanding, wise counsel and risk, and an agenda that listens to those of us who take a different view without the name-calling.
The United Nations, a clear focus of our debate, was founded on the determination that future generations should be spared the devastation of war. In my view, millions have been failed in this regard. The founding vision remains as relevant today as it was in 1945. The UN, as I saw myself, brings together the international community, provides a framework for collective security, supports peacekeeping, facilitates mediation, and gives a voice to nations that might otherwise be unheard. Yet we must be candid: the UN’s effectiveness in recent years has been diminishing or indeed absent from the negotiating table. As the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, and others have said, we have seen other countries stepping forward—Qatar in the Middle East and beyond—and regional players playing their part to ensure that conflicts can come to an end.
When divisions within the Security Council prevent meaningful action, as I saw myself, the credibility of the international system suffers. Yet my own experience of multilateral diplomacy also reinforced a fundamental lesson. International institutions, whether we talk of the UN, the ICJ or the ICC, are as effective only as the political will that sustains them. We need a more responsible, dynamic and agile United Nations but, importantly, with the right people who can act as advocates. Reform matters, but so does the willingness of member states to use the instruments that already exist.
One of the most important lessons of diplomacy is that conflicts rarely emerge without warning. Political exclusion, discrimination and the erosion of human rights, economic insecurity and the deliberate targeting of communities are often the basis. Yet too often, as a collective, we wait too long. We wait until violence has erupted before mobilising the full weight of international diplomacy. This must fundamentally change. Prevention requires investment in early-warning systems, strong institutions, inclusive governance, and the protection of fundamental freedoms. It also requires listening to communities and faith leaders, as the right reverend Prelate reminded us. I saw directly the importance of sustained relationships and direct engagement with international partners. In diplomacy, trust built before a crisis is essential.
I have a plea that applies to my party as well as the current Government. We must stop the revolving door when it comes to ministerial change on the global stage. Relationships matter and we must invest in those relationships. Without that, the UK loses credibility. We have excellent diplomatic networks and international relationships. We have the experience in this House as well. I say to the Minister: leverage those experiences. We have names who have built security and trust. We need to ensure that we get the optimum benefit for the world as a whole. The most successful act of conflict prevention may be one that the world never notices, precisely because that conflict never happens. Those who have been involved with this have seen it.
My noble friend Lord Redwood also mentioned the importance of diplomacy, but it needs the strength of all our assets, including defence. So I ask the Minister: as the United Kingdom previously has operated, and continues to operate, on issues such as Operation Prosperity Guardian, what is the current support we are extending to ensure that places such as the Bab al-Mandab and the Red Sea continue to be secure, despite the Houthis’ attacks? Mediation also means that we keep the door open. It requires patience and political judgment. When we believe in peace, we must be prepared to do the hard work of pursuing it.
Let me emphasise an important distinction. Engagement does not mean endorsement, and dialogue does not mean abandoning principle, especially when it comes to dealing with conflicts such as Ukraine and Russia. This is where the UK and its regional partners can make a real difference, co-ordinating diplomatic pressure and ensuring that negotiations are accompanied by a realistic pathway to peace. We must also resist the temptation to measure success solely by whether the parties all sat around a table. It is far more than that. The real measure is whether the process produced meaningful progress, peace, and security. A ceasefire can stop the immediate violence. Only sustained political engagement can help prevent its return. Peacebuilding begins long before a peace agreement is signed, and we must emphasise the importance of women peacekeepers. The UK led on the issue of conflict mediators, creating the very networks of women mediators. Yet, with the one exception that the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, pointed out, we have not seen women mediators involved in the current live conflicts that we witness.
I turn to a subject which was very close to my heart. I pay tribute to my noble friends Lord Hague and Lady Helic on the issue of preventing sexual violence in conflict. I spent seven years on that. In terms of listening to voices, of effecting global change, we listened to survivors, not after the event, but we put them at the heart of our strategy planning. I hope the Minister can assure me that we will continue to stand by UK leadership, and I would welcome an update on the international alliance that was created in this respect.
To conclude, the UK’s responsibility is immense. First, I do not subscribe to the view that we are a middle power. We are slightly more enhanced than that. We are not China or the United States, but we are the United Kingdom. We have incredible diplomatic networks, as has been mentioned, and we need to invest in those to sustain our principled diplomats.
Secondly, we need to practise principled, consistent engagement and maintain channels of communication. We must be the champions. It is not woke to stand up for women in mediation; it is simply the right thing to do. We must support peace beyond the negotiating table and build effective coalitions. But, above all, we must maintain consistency between our words and our actions.
Let me conclude with a reflection drawn from my own experience on the international stage. Diplomacy can be frustrating: I served five Prime Ministers and six Foreign Secretaries, so I know that it starts at home. Yet history reminds us that conflicts once considered intractable have found pathways towards resolution when political leadership, international engagement and public determination have come together. We must never confuse the difficulty of achieving peace with the impossibility of achieving it. The UN has a vital role, but it must be revitalised. Let us therefore move from reacting to crises towards preventing them and from managing temporary pauses to political settlements. Let our legacy be measured not simply by the conflicts we helped to resolve but those we helped to prevent, the lives we helped to protect and the generations who were able to grow up in peace.