My Lords, I thank colleagues from across the House for the privilege of working with them over the last 16 years in this Chamber on Bills, on Select Committees and on the general work of this House. Having reached the age of 80, I have decided that the time has come to have a retirement. I thank all the staff of the House for their advice, efficiency and constant good humour. I thank my own Whips’ Office for its loyalty, help and command of its role. I thank my immediate colleagues—my friends—in the Liberal Democrat group, who have been such a support over the years, for their friendship, which I know will continue in the years ahead. I thank my wife and all my family for their support in my time here; it is so appreciated. I thank all the speakers who are going to speak in this debate. I look forward to the maiden speech of my noble friend Lord McCobb, who brings a wealth of experience from his many years in local government.
In this debate I want to praise the Government for their commitment to devolving power out of Westminster and Whitehall into England, a country of 56 million people, and for their commitment to electoral reform, at least at a parliamentary level. There are, however, huge questions as to what all this means in practice for citizen participation and democratic accountability. The new Government have announced that they will strengthen accountability to balance the greater funding freedom for mayors. I thank the Library for its briefing on what the new Government have announced. Chief executives of mayoral strategic authorities will become local accounting officers; there will be a stronger role for the local audit office; there will be streamlining of the outcomes framework for mayoral strategic authorities; and there will be reforms to support the financial sustainability of local authorities, including retention of business rates and reforms to the highest cost services—social care, homelessness and special educational needs and disabilities. I welcome all those things.
My Lords, as someone who watches most proceedings in the House, albeit remotely, I personally pay tribute to the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, as he leaves the House, for his great service—and I mean great service—particularly in the handling of legislation. He will be surprised to know how often I have agreed with his comments during his interventions over the years. I wish him well, as will the whole House.
I wish to concentrate my remarks on democratic accountability and the benefits of electoral reform. The comments of the Prime Minister at the party conference debate are welcome.
In 1989, during a number of rather heated discussions over dinner in the Commons among four former MP colleagues, Brian Sedgemore, Ann Clwyd, Roland Boyes—all now sadly deceased—and me, I argued the case for electoral reform. In the absence of any agreement, I offered to go away and design a new electoral system which offered an element of greater proportionality. Over the following 12 months, I designed that new system and named it the supplementary vote. The original research papers are now archived in my son’s office in the House of Commons.
The system was subsequently adopted by the Nolan commission in 1997 and was introduced in both mayoral and police commissioner elections shortly after. To give the system academic credibility, I was able to secure support for the work from an eminent former LSE academic, Professor Patrick Dunleavy, whose substantial reputation gave the work academic credibility. He monitored the work, as my researcher, James Mahon, and Commons Library researchers carried the work forward.
I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, on securing this debate on crucial issues. I wish him a long and happy retirement; like the rest of the House, I am grateful for all that he has done here.
To the noble Lord, Lord Campbell-Savours, I am in complete disagreement that we need to change the method of election to the House of Commons. He is right that the single-member constituency and the constituency link is fundamental. I remember when I went to Brussels all too often as a negotiating Minister, and met Ministers there chosen or elected by other means, that one of the big gaps between us was that I was constantly saying that a new law could not make any sense for my constituents I was meeting tomorrow in my surgery. Their response was, “Well, why do you bother?” They did not have to, because they did not have that single constituency link.
It is also easiest and fairest to say that the person with the most votes wins. As soon as you become the Member of Parliament, you have to represent everybody to the best of your ability, and you need support from your constituents. So, it makes sense to give the job to the person who already commands the most votes of the group who came forward in election, and it is obviously much easier if you win more than half the votes, as I often had the good fortune to do when I was a Member of Parliament. You need to build support and represent people, so the single-member constituency is the least bad way of electing the House of Commons.
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, for securing this debate and for the considerable experience he has brought to your Lordships’ House from his time in local government. He was a former leader of Newcastle City Council, and I pay tribute to him for that. He leaves this House with, from these Benches, our warmest thanks and every good wish for the future.
It is an honour to follow the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. I also congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, and look forward to his maiden speech.
As Bishop of Newcastle, I serve communities across the city and Northumberland. The questions are consistent: who listens to us, who decides, and what can we do when those decisions fail us? These are questions about dignity, belonging and trust. My firm conviction is that every person has worth and something to contribute to our common life. Democratic institutions should give practical expression to that conviction.
I will highlight three priorities: accountable devolution, meaningful participation and fair representation. Beginning with the first, I note that the North East Mayoral Strategic Authority offers an opportunity to bring decisions about transport, housing and skills closer to the communities they serve. Newcastle and Northumberland have connected economies but distinct circumstances. Transport policy must serve both someone crossing Newcastle to work and someone in rural Northumberland whose opportunities depend on whether a bus runs at all. The recent bus franchising consultation makes this concrete. Decisions about routes, timetables and fares determine whether people can reach work, college, healthcare and one another. Greater control brings greater responsibility: the mayor’s mandate must be accompanied by effective council scrutiny, accessible spending information and clear responsibility for delivery.
My Lords, I agree strongly with the right reverend Prelate on community participation being fundamental to democracy.
I shall miss my noble friend Lord Shipley, but he is entirely right to retire. I am strongly in favour of retirement from this House as a principle, and I shall follow him next year. It is correct that the House is close to an agreement on a retirement age.
On electoral reform, I simply say to the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, that he probably missed the magnificent Liberal Democrat victory in a by-election in Cornwall some months ago, in which the Liberal Democrats won 18.9% of the vote in an election in which six candidates got more than 10% and one of the mayors elected as chair got one-quarter of the vote. When we are in that sort of situation, the question of the acceptability of that sort of democratic representation is one that we must all take on board. That is why it is entirely correct now to open a national conversation on where we go from here and not argue, as Dominic Cummings in the 2011 referendum did, that having more elections is a dreadful, additional cost that we should avoid if possible.
I want to talk about democracy. Democracy, in a minimalist sense, means elections every five years and referendums every now and again. The rest of the time, those who have the money and campaigned the most effectively get on and do things. The Liberal Democrat version of democracy is active citizenship, with government at all levels trying to explain to an educated electorate what the difficult choices are and engaging the citizens as far as possible in public life. The noble Lord, Lord Redwood, believes that we should not have too many layers of government, but we have fewer layers of government in England than there are in almost any other established democratic country. I have lived in the United States, and I have worked in Germany and France.
My Lords, I, too, will miss the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, in the Chamber. I thank him for his commitment and long service to local government; it has been a pleasure to work with him. I declare an interest as a vice-president of the Local Government Association.
Amid local government reorganisation and the ever-changing decisions and guidance issued by Government Ministers, local authorities across England continue to operate in a state of flux, uncertainty and instability. My noble friend Lord Redwood will be pleased to hear a positive note: it should be recognised that this year’s local elections saw one of the highest turnouts in recent years, with the Electoral Commission confirming a turnout of 45.2% for county council elections and 41.2% for metropolitan, London borough, unitary and district elections.
In the context of local government reorganisation, and on the matter of democratic accountability, the Government need to provide urgent clarity to the more than 20 local authorities that currently operate under a committee-based model. As the Minister will no doubt be aware, the English devolution Act requires local authorities to move to a leader and executive model by June 2027. However, where structural change orders exist in those areas, this deadline can be extended by the Secretary of State to June 2028. Given the uncertainty caused by the Government’s decision to review LGR, can the Minister provide some clarity in her contribution for the approximately 20 local authorities in this situation?
My Lords, it is a privilege to address this House for the first time. I have been touched by the welcome that I have received from noble Lords on all sides of the House. I am particularly grateful to my noble friends who introduced me: my noble friend Lady Pinnock, of Cleckheaton—a fellow citizen of Yorkshire, whose decades of local government experience we will hear of later in this debate—and my noble friend Lady Leaman, of Chipping Sodbury. She has been a friend and comrade through at least four general elections and is one of Britain’s sharpest political minds.
I am grateful too to Black Rod’s team, the doorkeepers, the clerks and the attendants. However, I must warn them that despite over 24 years as a city councillor in Hull, I never quite learned to tell one side of the ground floor of Hull’s Guildhall from the other, so I ask for their patience if they occasionally find me lost in the even more labyrinthine layout of this place.
I give thanks to the Liberal Democrat Whips’ Office, whose support and advice I have relied on since coming here and in my working life. To declare one interest, I remain the Liberal Democrats’ campaigns and elections director and, to declare another, I recently became a trustee of the Kingston upon Hull William Wilberforce Lecture Trust, a small charity that seeks to keep alive the legacy of one of my home city’s most famous representatives.
My Lords, it is a delight and privilege to follow my noble friend Lord McCobb’s eloquent maiden speech—the first of what I am sure will be many thoughtful contributions to our House and certainly the first of many times that we will hear him talking up the wonders of Hull. Those who know us both will perhaps not be surprised that his first email to me many years ago, after starting work for our party, was to seek some very detailed electoral statistics that he thought I might have; but that interest in using evidence and rigorously scrutinising assumptions will, I am sure, be of great benefit to this House in our scrutiny work.
Although the noble Lord is perhaps best known to many for his formidable campaigning experience, he also, as we have heard, brings considerable historical knowledge and local government experience to our deliberations: years of dealing, on the front line, with the practical realities and consequences of decisions we make here in Parliament. The breadth of that expertise, accumulated in roles that have been very challenging and time-consuming at times, has—as for so many—been possible only due to the support and forbearance of the noble Lord’s wife and son. It was therefore such a pleasure to see them wearing two of the broadest smiles I have ever seen on the day of the noble Lord’s introduction.
One of the reasons why our decisions here are so relevant to local government is that so much power has been and continues to be centralised in Westminster. That undermines local democratic accountability and puts people off local participation. When we considered the recent devolution Bill, for example, I particularly highlighted the continued central control over cattle-grids—a small but telling example of just how deep-set that centralising micromanagement culture can be at times. Aficionados of cattle-grid regulation had our hopes raised when the Government’s White Paper promised devolution of these powers; alas, by the time we got to legislation, the centralisers had won out, deciding that not even strategic authority mayors can be trusted with full bovine autonomy.
1:57 pm
20 of 37 shown
I see this debate as an opportunity for all noble Lords to contribute at this important time to government thinking and to thinking at all levels of local government about how we should proceed now that the mayoral structure and strategic authorities are being put in place. I want to talk about three issues. First, too often, devolution is seen as being about just the location of power. But that is only part of it. Actually, it is about the effective use of power and responsibilities, and whether the resources and capacity are there to deliver those responsibilities.
Secondly, we, together with government, have to define far better than we previously have what we expect mayors to do in each of their areas. My view is that mayors have responsibilities which are much too broad. They need to devolve as much as they can to local authorities, and those local authorities, in turn, need to devolve as much as they can to neighbourhoods and to town and parish councils. Too often, people think of devolution as being about power to themselves from somebody else. But true devolution comes from giving up power and transferring that power to others. Indeed, at the Local Government Association annual conference in July, the then Secretary of State said:
“Residents can feel just as shut out by the town hall as by Whitehall”.
I agree. It is very important that, if the Government are going to reach every postcode, citizens should have more involvement in matters affecting their everyday life.
My third point is that we live in a representative democracy, and that means that votes cast should ideally have equal weight. That system worked pretty well when we had a two-party system. But in local government in England now there are effectively six major groupings, and the time has come for a more proportional voting system to reflect citizens’ views adequately. However, it is also my view that we must ensure that there is a connection between councillors and the people they represent, particularly in rural areas.
The new Government want to rewire the state, with all parts of England having a strategic authority. I commend their commitment to transfer powers over such matters as schools, employment support, transport, housing and innovation. I strongly welcome the likely announcement in the Budget—much trailed—that a share of income tax, perhaps £21.5 billion, will be devolved as part of a new road map towards greater fiscal devolution. We should note that this will not be new money, but it will focus minds on what it is spent on, and funding will be more predictable for local government. However, as the Local Government Association emphasised recently, a timetable is now necessary to clarify how devolution will be delivered, as currently there are no plans for the whole of England to be covered by strategic authority proposals. We need to see the “whole of England” part of the devolution process, and anything further the Minister can say about that would be helpful.
We should note that most parts of England receive more in public spending than they raise in taxation; only London and the south-east generate more from taxation than they spend. There is a huge fiscal reliance in England on London and the south-east. This is why growth in areas outside London matters so much, and why mayors and strategic authorities must help achieve that as their primary aim. However, resources are a problem. We have just been talking about the triple lock and social care. It is the case now that there is a local authority in which social care can take 92% of its core funding. It used to be two-thirds, but since 2015 there have been cuts in public services as social care has been loaded more and more on to council tax. There is a very serious financial problem in local government, which is the result of the failure over so many years to find solutions to growing demands for social care. This needs urgent resolution, otherwise we will continue to see heavy cuts in other services.
This is all about partnership working between mayors, strategic authorities, Whitehall and every level of local government. It is about effective joint working between councils at all levels, including parish and town councils, and there has to be a willingness to deliver that partnership. Place-based policy-making matters. The British Chamber of Commerce has said that business should be at the heart of devolution, and it needs to be. You cannot solve the problem of youth unemployment and too many young people not in education, employment or training unless business is at the heart of that. If that does not happen, the Government will not reach every postcode as they have promised to do.
I mentioned earlier the capacity of mayors. Mayors have a huge range of responsibilities, from police and fire to strategic planning, inward investment, culture, skills and transport, and now I see proposals that mayors may have a role in holding water companies to account. The basic question is this: how on earth does one person do all these things? I used to serve on the north-east regional development agency, One North East. I was there for seven years. It had a lot of staff and there was a government office, to bring Whitehall together in one place. Unfortunately, it is the case that, in many parts of England, there are just not enough people to do some of the jobs that the Government rightly think need to be done.
One of the Government’s solutions—we saw it in the passing of the English devolution Bill at Easter—is to appoint commissioners. The commissioners are not elected; they are appointed by the mayors, though there will be scrutiny of the appointments. But I have come to the conclusion that we need more shared staffing between existing local authorities and these strategic authorities and that strategic authorities need to have the resources to do the job the Government expect of them. I add to this my conclusion that we need direct elections to mayoral strategic authorities. If the mayor is directly elected then the members of the strategic authority need to be directly elected, through a form of proportional representation.
That takes me briefly to electoral reform. The national commission is welcome. It is wise to press ahead. It does not yet include local government, and it should. I do not want to get involved with all the different systems you could have, but it is wrong that one party, under first past the post, can win control of a council with a substantial minority of votes. It is vital that voting systems keep up with changes in levels of voter support for different parties. I hope the Government will be willing to look at that.
I am drawing towards a conclusion. I want to comment on the overnight visitor levy. I have many times in your Lordships’ House talked about the importance of a tourist tax. It is called an overnight visitor levy, and I am strongly in favour of it. However, some of the mood music that I am hearing is not terribly helpful. There is a real worry that the tourist areas that are short of social housing because there are so many second homes are not being guaranteed the resources to build the social housing that is required in their areas. They are frightened that the mayors are going to have big projects which will not be in their areas. There needs to be clarity on this. It is a good example of the problem we have with devolution but also of the opportunity. Who decides what would be raised by the levy and where it would be spent? There are many examples: in Manchester, a voluntary tourist tax has been hugely successful.
Mayors have to be set targets and assessed against them. For example, mayors should be made responsible for reductions in the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training. It is not only the Government or the private sector that do these things—let us make the mayors accountable for some of these things. Further, mayors should be measured on their ability to promote local procurement in every postcode. That is the objective. I hope the Government will see the importance of doing these things. Mayors must be assessed on their success in growth. I hope that they will be assessed against their ability to run an authority in which budgets are properly constructed and costs properly controlled, so that the mayoral strategic authority does not then end up blaming the Government of the day for everything that goes wrong.
This is about sharing a great deal more. I would like to think that all MPs in the mayoral strategic authority area would have the right to be part of a select committee structure to talk to the mayor on the basis of an annual report produced by that mayor. We have to think much more about doing things like that.
I am really keen on what the Government are doing. I congratulate the Minister and all her colleagues on the ambition that they have set. There is a danger that mayors and strategic authorities will end up being strong on strategy but short on delivery. We have to do far better than that, for that is what the general public expect us to do. I beg to move.
The supplementary vote, not to be confused with the contingent vote, survived two decades, until Prime Minister Johnson decided to abolish it, believing mistakenly it damaged the Conservative vote—a big mistake, as Conservative electoral number crunchers have increasingly realised. Added to that have been the widely held concerns of PR enthusiasts over alternative forms of PR which destroy the constituency link.
Recently, the Prime Minister announced his wish to reopen the discussion on electoral reform, and, as I understand it, he has proposed that a working group be established to consider various options for reform. For obvious reasons, I would like to be considered as a member of that committee, but my disability—working remotely—rules me out. However, I would like to think that the supplementary vote would be on that agenda and would now in the light of experience perhaps go further with possible future amendment.
In a bid to secure even greater proportionality, there is an argument that supplementary vote should be subject to a limited element of top-up off a list—SV plus. I have been giving such an arrangement considerable thought over recent weeks. A list member could be elected as an additional member on a regional basis to a group of perhaps 10 directly elected MPs. That would give us a Commons of approximately 590 directly elected, and 60 from the list. The list could be regional or national.
There are however dangers, primarily that of list members using their positions to displace individual directly elected members. This would arise where list members in multimember constituencies concentrate their efforts on targeting an individual constituency, their motive being to replace an existing directly elected member in a subsequent election. The answer is to introduce a restriction on movement from list membership to directly elected membership of the House. I would like to see at least a five-year block on movement. That would kill the incentive to play the system and undermine directly elected constituency members.
However, there is a problem with that as a solution. It may raise questions of rights. I recognise that such a system is not challenging the right to stand for Parliament. However, it is applying a restriction on that right. It is to that issue that I am having to give more thought, and on which I am looking for further advice.
I have to confess that, over the years, I, too, have flirted with wider systems of proportional representation, in particular, multimember constituencies, but they have all fallen on the problems of breaking the constituency link and the duplication of unhealthy competition in the representation of constituents. I sense from colleagues across Europe, and now our latest conversations in Scotland, who have experienced multimember constituencies that they are not always conducive to healthy interparty and intermember relationships. I suppose, in truth, I am fearful of any electoral system that breaks the vital link between the identifiable MP and the constituency. Direct, individual MP accountability is critical, and any list system must be very small and built in such a way as to avoid conflict.
That is all I need to say at this stage. This is no doubt the beginning of a long discussion, and I am sure there will be times in the future when I will no doubt wish to intervene as the debate further develops, albeit remotely.
The Liberal Democrats would be wise to remember that when they were in the coalition Government, one of the things they insisted on—and Conservatives agreed to—was, on their choice of system, to have a referendum on whether we should change the voting system. From memory, the public voted 68% against, in favour of keeping the current system—more than two-thirds. I was and am still with the public on that. They were right. I have always found the “democracy” bit in the Lib Dem name a bit odd, because whenever we have a public vote, they always seem to disagree with it, then they want to overturn it, not listening to the views of the people. They do not like the verdict that was given on their preferred system of changing the voting system, and they do not like the outcome of the Brexit vote, when millions came out to say we needed to restore our sovereignty, so that we could have a debate like this to discuss how the powers of self-government should be administered and distributed.
The Liberal Democrats wish that to be taken away from us to a much higher level of government by agreement between parties around a council table, with only the Commission allowed to write the laws and make most of the suggestions. The Lib Dems need to think very carefully about how they see democracy, compared with the way the rest of us see democracy—because we think democracy is about the voice of the people. There is only one thing above the elected House of Commons: the voice of the people in a referendum. The House of Commons would be wise to accept the verdict of a referendum, because otherwise, the people in the House of Commons can be changed at a subsequent general election.
As a former local government Minister, and, as a young man, a county councillor who chaired a committee and was therefore responsible for the conduct of various departments in the county council, I have a great affection for local government. Over my years as a Member of Parliament, I worked very closely with leading councillors in my area, and quite often, the issues that most concerned my constituents were wholly or partially decided by the local council.
What that taught me was that it is very disappointing that turnouts in local government elections are so low and that we do not get a good public debate through local media, and even social media, about the powers, duties and money that the council disperses. If people knew more about what could be done by local government, I think there would be more interest in voting.
However, I am afraid that a lot of Labour and Liberal Democrat councils, as well as councils under no control, put people off. Instead of being proud of their powers and telling people how they will spend their money, all we ever hear from these councils is that they do not have enough money and they do not have any power because everything is already decided by the national Government. People therefore naturally conclude that there is no point in wasting their time with these councillors and councils, because the councillors themselves say, “Well don’t blame me, we can’t do anything; it’s already sorted out by the national Government”.
That of course is not true, but one of the further reasons why people are confused or put off is that we have far too many layers of government and council. It is a huge mistake to introduce regional strategic government in a small, very unified country such as England, and to have that in conflict with what should be truly local government through the local councils. My area moved over from county and district to unitary; I broadly welcomed that, because it removed some of the confusion. It means that, for local matters, we can say, “O unitary authority, it is your problem”, instead of being told that some row is going on between the county and the district and that nobody was really to blame.
That still leaves us with quite a lot of government, although I am very pleased that we have knocked out the European level, because that was a mighty imposition of taxes and laws that we often did not want. I am also glad that we have gone to unitaries, but we still have parish government, and now this Government are trying to intrude regional government on us. It is muddle, confusion and extra cost.
Let us deal with the question about the money. We always hear that most councils do not have enough money, and yet every year the council tax goes up, usually by more than inflation. That is what the public see. Every year government grants go up—yes, under Conservative Governments, as well as Labour Governments, grants usually go up—and councils still say that they are poor. Then when you look at how they are misspending, you can see why: councils that went on a binge buying up commercial property because the debt was cheap, or, as in my local area, a Lib Dem council wasting money on road projects and destroying our road systems for something that people do not want. The answer rests with local government showing its powers and spending its money more wisely.
There is a legitimate concern about cost. As additional layers of representation and governance develop, residents are entitled to ask whether these arrangements represent value for money, avoid duplication and genuinely improve decision-making. Democratic accountability must be clear, not lost between institutions. I recognise the public service of councillors across parties and of independents. Effective scrutiny requires time, resources and access to information.
Secondly, I turn to meaningful participation. An invitation to participate does not, by itself, make participation possible. Someone working shifts, caring for children or living without reliable internet access may struggle to contribute. In rural Northumberland, an evening meeting is inaccessible if there is no return bus. Public bodies need to go where people already gather: schools, libraries, community centres, churches and other faith communities. Newcastle’s Pride in Place sessions at West End Women and Girls Centre in Elswick and the Wor Hoose Community Project in Walker offer examples of this approach. Town and parish councils connect regional decisions with local knowledge. Young people, too, must help shape decisions that will determine their futures. The noble Lord, Lord Shipley, referred to these points in his speech, and I wholeheartedly agree.
Such participation strengthens community resilience, which is increasingly important amid global instability. When emergencies arise, trusted local relationships matter: knowing who needs help, who can offer it and how reliable information reaches people. Local resilience forums have an important co-ordinating role, but preparedness must draw on the knowledge and networks of communities themselves, particularly in isolated rural areas. Participation is therefore not simply about consultation; it is about building relationships, sharing responsibility and enabling communities to shape their own futures.
Thirdly, I turn to fair representation. Electoral reform should strengthen the relationship between people and those who govern them. There is a serious case for considering proportional representation in English local government, so that councils better reflect the range of views within their communities. However, changing electoral systems alone will not restore trust. At a time when polarisation is increasingly evident, building a culture of consensus and co-operation requires time and intentionality. I remember that dynamic from my time living and working in New Zealand, which operates an MMR system. We need institutions capable of holding differences constructively and representatives willing to work across them. Further devolution and electoral reform must be judged against the same principles: transparency, accountability, accessibility and fairness.
Trust grows when people know their voice matters, can see the difference that participation makes, and are confident that decisions can be challenged and that those entrusted with power remain answerable. That trust strengthens our capacity to face uncertainty together. Ultimately, local democracy is not simply about where power sits but how it is exercised, who participates and whether it serves the common good.
If you want an active democracy, you have to engage the public in it, and that starts at the local level. In the last 40 years, we have seen local democracy in Britain shrink in a number of ways. Mrs Thatcher deeply mistrusted local government and weakened it where she could. Central funding has become more and more important. Local taxation has shrunk to an unreformed council tax. Living as I have for the last 40 years both in Wandsworth and Bradford, under our system I usually pay more council tax on our house in Saltaire than I do on our house in Wandsworth, which is a crazy situation. Council tax is part of what needs to be reformed.
We have also moved away from the local. The idea that the most efficient way to have local government is to have at least half a million people in every council area is crazy. I see my noble friend Lady Eaton—I do regard her as a friend—shake her head. The noble Baroness is a neighbour of mine in Yorkshire, and I have long admired her position not only as a former leader of the council but as someone who represents a very large rural ward, previously a rural district council, with five substantial villages within it. That is a really difficult task for the councillor concerned, and it is a difficult task for those who live in the villages to get to know or even to remember the name of their councillor. We need to re-establish the idea of local government, and that clearly involves establishing parish and town councils wherever we have them.
Across Yorkshire, wealthy areas—middle class areas and areas with lots of graduates—have active parish councils. Former council house areas and areas where there are a lot of unemployed people tend not to have parish councils. That means that they are disengaged from politics. As council services shrink, many people hardly ever have any contact with government as such. That is the situation in which conspiracy theories grow and mistrust of government festers, which is very bad for democracy. So part of what I hope this Government will do, as they push through the previous Conservative Government’s insistence on single-tier local government that is oversized, is to insist or to encourage the extension of town and parish councils all the way across the country and to allow them to have some local powers and local funding so that local people can feel that they are engaged with politics in one form or another.
When I was first involved in politics, the Conservative Party had several million members. As I remember from the small towns in which I lived as a teenager, the local councillors formed the fundamental structure of the local Conservative Party. There was a period in which my own party had 300,000 members. Neither it nor the Conservative Party has 100,000 members now, I am told. That is a setback for democracy. We have a very low level of public trust and public participation.
Last year, the strategic defence review talked about the need to re-engage the public on national security and homeland defence. We have heard a certain amount over the past year or two about the need to rebuild resilience in our society, which means local volunteers, looking after each other and rebuilding local community, local engagement and local leadership. In the way in which local government has shrunk, we have lost the sense that politics, security and community start at the local level. Devolution to mayors on their own is not enough. It works well in metropolitan areas, but it works a great deal less well outside metropolitan areas. I was one of the many in Yorkshire who resisted the Conservative Government’s insistence that we should have a mayor for North Yorkshire and a mayor for East Yorkshire, each now with no more than two subsidiary authorities over which to be strategic. We need, therefore, to rebuild the sense of local democracy.
The thrust of my contribution this afternoon will be about ensuring that the process for agreeing structural change orders—in particular, interim warding arrangements—is fair, legal and democratic. To begin with, the Government should provide the legal advice given by officials to the former Secretary of State, Steve Reed MP, as part of his decision-making process when deciding on proposed new local authority boundaries before the Summer Recess. It is important that the sector fully understands the facts that were presented to the former Secretary of State before he made his final decision.
On the subject of interim warding arrangements, we need a far more democratic and fair process to ensure that new warding boundaries remain within tolerance, comply with the principles set out by the Local Government Boundary Commission and are not used by political parties to create questionable boundaries that favour certain groups. As noble friends may be aware, interim warding arrangements for shadow authorities, which are confirmed through the structural change order, must be submitted in advance by the constituent local authorities before being approved by the Government. To be clear, the Local Government Boundary Commission will therefore have no formal role in creating interim warding arrangements.
This is a far cry from the process followed by the previous Conservative Government, where new unitary authorities such as Buckinghamshire had interim warding arrangements based on existing county council boundaries. These boundaries would have been created through a fair process, overseen by the Local Government Boundary Commission. Over recent months we have seen highly questionable submissions, which some may argue are incompatible with the warding principles set out by the Local Government Boundary Commission.
Allow me to provide one example: the City of Lincoln Council submitted its option D proposals, which meant that areas of the city with higher levels of deprivation, according to the Office for National Statistics data, would receive more representation than residents living in more rural parts of the proposed unitary authority. Specifically, under the proposed 65-member model, a resident of Minster ward would be represented by one councillor for every 1,849 electors. By contrast, a resident of Witham Saint Hughs would have one councillor representing 4,354 electors.
My point, and what I hope will be understood as the central thrust of my contribution to this debate, is that I fear that local government reorganisation is providing an excuse for some not to follow the established norms and processes that we have followed for decades when bringing local authority wards together. This undermines the established democratic principles that have been set in stone for decades. I hope that the House will give serious consideration to this issue as local government reorganisation advances.
I particularly welcome today’s debate, tabled by my noble friend Lord Shipley—partly because, like me, he is a citizen of a proud northern port city, but mostly because it is on the power of local government and of my home city and its East Yorkshire surroundings that I wish to speak today. I ask for forgiveness in advance from noble Lords if these are themes to which I return with predictable frequency. My family finds itself in East Yorkshire because nearly 60 years ago, my parents came to Hull University as students, where my father became the head of the German department. As I was growing up, he served on the councils for the borough of Beverley and the East Riding. I feel today a particular sense of sadness that he missed my arrival here by just six months even though, as a good Liberal, he would probably have strongly disapproved of the lack of any election involved in getting me here.
I was born in Beverley and grew up nearby in the East Riding of Yorkshire. It was near Beverley that my wife Elspeth and I got married, but for the last 26 years I have lived in Hull, where our son was born. Like many others who live in this part of the world, my family’s lives run backwards and forwards across the border between Hull and the East Riding. The Yorkshire coast, from Filey to Spurn Point and the Holderness plains, shares a distinctive beauty:
“Here is unfenced existence:
Facing the sun, untalkative, out of reach”,
as Philip Larkin described it.
Hull and East Yorkshire people have a warmth and wit all of their own, with a quirky and occasionally rebellious sense of independence. It is a corner of Britain with a rich and fascinating history. Hull Fair, Europe’s largest travelling funfair, is one of the oldest events of its kind, dating back to 1279 via a royal charter granted by King Edward I. As an aside, the 732nd Hull Fair is taking place this very week, so I would be delighted to offer any noble Lords with a few hours to spare this coming weekend the guided tour.
Speaking of Hull’s history, in 1642 Hull’s governor, Sir John Hotham, turned King Charles I away from the city’s gates, an act of defiance many historians count among the sparks for the civil war. William Wilberforce, to whom I alluded earlier, born in 1759 in Hull and elected as its Member of Parliament in 1780, spent 20 years pursuing the abolition of the slave trade. At the peak of Britain’s maritime power, Hull was its third port. Its shipping line was, for a time, the largest privately owned one in the world and its distant-water trawler fleet remained among the biggest on earth until the 1970s.
Hull has also had its fair share of challenges—some of the heaviest bombing of any British city in the Second World War, with the majority of homes damaged and thousands destroyed. The fishing industry that sustained it for a century collapsed in the 1970s, with a fraction of the national attention and funding that followed similar economic challenges in other parts of the country.
For a city so geographically isolated, connectivity is everything, and here there is much work to be done. Our motorway, the M62, simply ends 15 or so miles short of Hull. Our airport is in Lincolnshire and has no rail link and no bus on a Sunday. Unlike other comparable cities of its size, Hull has no tram or metro system. Noble Lords may be surprised to learn that it is faster to travel by train from London to Paris—twice the distance—than from Hull to Liverpool via so many great cities of the north.
On this evidence, Hull city region is a strong contender for being one of the worst-connected places of its size in Britain. The devolution deal confirmed in September 2024 committed to integrating Hull into the Northern Powerhouse Rail network; I am determined to see that delivered, because Hull has shown what it can do when given the chance.
In 2017, Hull was the UK City of Culture. Over 5 million visits to Hull and east Yorkshire helped generate a new sense of pride and belonging in the area. As a local councillor, I wholeheartedly backed the sadly unsuccessful first bid for City of Culture status and the subsequent, second, successful one. This helped put this part of Britain on the map for the right reasons. A year ago, National Geographic ranked Hull as one of the top 20 global destinations to visit in its prestigious “best of the world” list. This transformation shows the difference that strong local government leadership with proper backing from national government can make.
For 24 years, I represented the Beverley Road and Newland Avenue areas on Hull City Council, helping constituents on a daily basis. I bring to this House a strong conviction that good local government can enrich people’s lives in ways that Westminster sometimes finds too easy to overlook.
I look forward to making the case for Hull and east Yorkshire in this House, as well as the positive case for the impact of that strong and effective local government with good national government backing to which I referred, and many more worthwhile causes besides. I hope to learn along the way from the wide range of wisdom and experience on offer from noble Lords on all sides of this Chamber, who continue to champion their chosen causes with passion and commitment.
That Bill was my first experience of working with my noble friend Lord Shipley, and I greatly valued the support, advice and mentoring he provided—just one of his many attributes that will be so missed later this year.
To give a different example, the explanatory text that councils in England and Wales put out to explain the business rates system is not written by councils; nor is it a shared text produced for convenience by the LGA or a similar body for different councils to use; nor is it even a helpful draft provided by a civil servant in Whitehall. No: it is specifically controlled and legislated for in detail by, once again, that culture of saying, “We cannot really trust councils to do this themselves”. For all the talk, on other topics, that legislative time is such a precious resource that this thing the Government really want to do, sadly, cannot quite be done yet, in this case, that centralising micromanagement culture runs so deep that time has been found in Parliament every other year, on average, for the last quarter of a century, to legislate time and again on how councils are allowed to describe that business rates system.
We do not set such requirements for other taxes, people or organisations. It is a reflection of how, at times, Whitehall unfortunately seems to treat local government as an untrustworthy or wayward young child. Then there is the problem of legislative time so often not being found for other local government matters that really need it. I will give the House two examples where good ideas have been proposed, consultations carried out and clear and strong consensus found for action, but then action has not followed.
The first example was highlighted by the Ethics and Integrity Commission in its annual letter to the Prime Minister earlier this year. In 2024, there was a consultation and then, in 2025, proposals for a stronger and more accountable standards system for local government—something that the Committee on Standards in Public Life had first called for in 2019, a full seven years ago. Seven years on, we have no legislation and no slot promised in a King’s Speech for future legislation. We have no substantive progress in seven years to secure the benefits that a proper accountable standards system would bring for improving councillor and staff well-being, of public trust in local government, and of more effective local government. Instead, it has just stalled for seven years.
There is a similar tale with remote or proxy participation at council meetings. Both this House and the House of Commons, in our own different ways, allow some degree of remote or proxy participation, as we have seen in this debate. It is a sensible way to deal with illness that does not impair the brain but precludes mobility, for example. It is something that was successfully done during Covid and, since then, in different ways by local government in the UK outside England. But in England, that centralising, controlling, micromanagement hand is at work again, banning councils from daring to decide for themselves how they wish to arrange their affairs. I wonder how we would feel in this House if someone in Whitehall was to say that we cannot decide how we will allow remote participation but have to have someone in Whitehall tell us instead.
To be fair to the Government, there was an extensive consultation in 2025 on changing the rules and it found overwhelming support for change—not a free-for-all abolishing in-person meetings, but for the sort of sensible changes that we have now long since adopted in this House or in the House of Commons. But was legislative time found to implement the results of that consultation? No, it was not. Was the devolution Bill used as an opportunity to implement the results of that consultation? Once again, no it was not. That is the problem: Whitehall is just too busy to find the time to relax that centralising grip, but that is exactly why it needs to step back and trust local government more.
I very much hope, when we hear from the Minister later, that we will hear not just the usual albeit very sincere words about the importance of supporting local government but maybe even a hint of progress on allowing councils to decide for themselves how councillors participate in their business, on putting in place a proper standards regime for local government, and maybe, as Christmas is not that far away now, on finally devolving power over cattle-grids.