To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the impact of industrial electricity prices on the international competitiveness of British manufacturing.
My Lords, we recognise that high industrial electricity prices can affect the international competitiveness of British manufacturing. That is why from 2027 more than 10,000 businesses will be eligible for the British industrial competitiveness scheme, up from the 7,000 originally announced, to save up to 25% on their electricity bills. That is a total package of £600 million a year. Recognising the immediate challenges, we are also providing an additional payment for eligible firms, which will be delivered next year.
My Lords, China produces 31% of all global CO2 emissions, the USA 13%, India 8%, Russia 5% and the United Kingdom 0.7%. In the immortal words of that great Labour idol, Tony Blair, the Minister is a pretty straight sort of guy, so will he admit from the Dispatch Box now that Dieter Helm is right and that the Government’s fanatical drive for net zero is decarbonising British industry out of existence with the highest electricity prices in the developed world? How many more factories must close and how many more jobs will be lost before the Government accept that their energy policy is making British industry totally uncompetitive without reducing global carbon emissions one iota but reducing thousands of British jobs?
My Lords, that is precisely the reason why we are supporting businesses. Alongside BICS, we are providing targeted support to reduce electricity bills through the British industrial supercharger, saving British businesses more than £1 billion a year. In the longer term, accelerating renewable generation is the fastest way to break the link between gas and electricity prices and to protect consumers from energy crisis. Our transition to clean power will strengthen energy security and reduce exposure to volatile fossil fuel markets, helping bring down electricity prices.
My Lords, it is scandalous that the UK lacks essential electricity transmission and storage systems and that the Government pay billions each year to solar and wind turbine farms to switch off during periods of high sunshine and winds. The cost of the switch-off to the public purse is likely to hit £8 billion a year by 2030, while National Grid pays dividends. What are the Government doing to check this failure to invest?
I am sorry, but I totally disagree with my noble friend. First, we need to look at domestic gas production. It can reduce our imports, but it does not guarantee British consumers a discount as gas is traded in connected international markets, nor would it remove electricity network costs or the need to replace ageing infrastructure. We are tackling costs directly through industrial relief while investing in clean power and reforming electricity pricing.
My Lords, does the Minister accept that the horticultural sector is particularly hard hit by these matters? It is not currently recognised as an energy-intensive industry and therefore is not eligible for the network charging compensation schemes. Can he please have a look at this to ensure that this important industry does not go under because of these high prices?
I thank the noble Lord for bringing that to my attention. First, we intend to review eligibility for the supercharger and the energy-intensive industries compensation scheme later this year, ensuring that support remains targeted, effective and proportionate. The supercharger targets sectors most exposed to high electricity costs and international competition where production is at greatest risk of moving overseas. As I mentioned earlier, from 2027, BICS will extend support to many manufacturers currently outside these schemes, helping to strengthen competitiveness and sustain skilled jobs.
My Lords, unlike the Official Opposition, we believe in our green future, and we support the rollout of renewables. However, the cost of electricity remains too high, so I take this opportunity to ask the Minister what further action this Government are taking in the Budget and beyond to fundamentally reform our energy markets so that we can improve our productivity and reduce poverty.
The noble Earl tempts me to comment on the Budget, which obviously I cannot—that is very much left to the Chancellor. However, that said, a successful transition must keep manufacturing investment and skilled jobs in Britain. We have to be mindful of that, and BICS, which I mentioned earlier, and the enhanced supercharger support this goal, while our efforts on clean power and electricity pricing address a fundamental system issue.
My Lords, it is pretty clear that the vision for our green future is right, but international situations have changed since that vision. We still need to get there, but in the transition, must we not keep jobs for young people here and ensure that we have substantial security in gas provision, which anybody listening to the Today programme this morning will realise is under serious threat? Are the Government carefully considering these situations?
As I mentioned earlier, we have to keep everything under review. We have the BIC scheme that is currently open to more than 10,000 businesses and we have a supercharger scheme in place. We are constantly listening to businesses, and we will support them as much as we can. We want to keep businesses in this country and deter them from going overseas, and we are supporting them in every way we can.
My Lords, I have just returned from No. 10, where I had a meeting, in my capacity as chairman of Make UK, with the Prime Minister about energy costs. I am sorry that I am sometimes guilty of harassing the Minister—I hope, in a nice way—but I am going to ask him the same question as I asked the Prime Minister. Our energy costs are 60% more than those in our competing countries. This is because of policy costs. It is because Governments have decided that instead of taxpayers paying for whatever might be very good policies, they are paid for by manufacturing industry. I am afraid that the BIC scheme is two years too late, and it lasts only for two years. I ask the Minister to answer the question, which is: how can we be sure that we are going to reindustrialise when, long-term, we are at a big competitive disadvantage to France, Germany and other countries?