That the Grand Committee takes note of the Report from the Industry and Regulators Committee Time is Money: How Regulators can Support Growth (3rd Report, HL Paper 301, Session 2024–26).
My Lords, in addressing our report I pay tribute to our committee staff, Rhiannon Williams and Dominic Cooper, together with invaluable support from an NAO secondment, Sarah Pearcey, and committee members, including the noble Baronesses, Lady Harding and Lady Valentine, and the noble Lords, Lord Fuller and Lord Udny-Lister, from whom your Lordships will hear today, along with my noble friend Lady Carberry and the noble Lord, Lord Camoys, who are also on the committee and from whom we might hear today. We will also hear from my noble friend Lord Chandos, who was in at the start of the process, although he then escaped for good behaviour.
I start with an apology to my noble friend Lord Smith of Ranmoor for misnaming his former organisation, the FSA—obviously it is the agency, not the authority—in the table on page 11. I have to confess that it was he who spotted that, not me.
I also thank the then relevant Ministers, my noble friend Lord Livermore and Blair McDougall MP— notably and significantly from both the Treasury and the Business Department—for appearing in front of the committee, as did the noble Lord, Lord Willetts, who was of enormous assistance to our work.
The report examines the Government’s attempt to help boost their growth objective via their action plan for regulators—an objective that I am sure the Committee shares. Writing in the Times on Saturday, however, the Chancellor admitted that
“growth cannot be commanded from Whitehall”,
but that it could be helped by removing the barriers that hold back investment and by bringing down costs and bureaucracy, which Ministers judge includes regulation. That led to the question that we asked as to the impact that regulation can have in encouraging or facilitating growth and whether the Government’s action plan will help regulators to achieve this objective.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, on chairing the committee, which has produced this excellent report, giving a lot of practical advice on how we can ensure that the regulatory regime is improved. I declare an interest: I chair the Regulatory Innovation Office, in which capacity I gave evidence to the committee. Our task is to ensure that regulation does not stand in the way of desirable innovation and new technologies, and we operate under the scrutiny of the noble Baroness, Lady Lloyd of Effra.
I want to pick up on three points from the report. First, there is the growth duty, what it means and how one can promote growth. My view is that it is absolutely right to try to be as explicit as possible about the growth duty, and it is also then legitimate for Ministers, within that legal framework, to specify in letters and communications to regulators how they think the regulators can promote growth within their overall statutory responsibilities. All too often, under successive Governments, we have seen communications from government to regulators which are long lists of desirable things but do not give a sense of priority and are not sufficiently granular to provide action or “political cover”, as the noble Baroness called it, for officials in those regulators. So the more specific those guidelines and letters drawing on the growth duty are, the better. As an example, they should clearly focus on timeliness. Pace is indeed an issue, especially if you are a start-up. If you are trying to do something different and have limited resource or an impatient venture capital fund behind you, you need to get on with things, while the big, moneyed incumbents are much less focused on getting things done quickly. So dealing with things quickly helps new entrants. That is one area that can be looked at.
Regulators inevitably tend to focus on the “day job” and on what they are already familiar with. Getting them to think to about the innovative people coming in from the side who have thought of a different way of doing things and have the staff to engage with them is important. One thing we tried to do at RIO was shift the priorities in a regulator to ensure that innovative technologies coming over the horizon are properly understood and the companies delivering them are engaged with. That is another thing that is clearly pro-growth. There is then the frustration that companies have of concluding with one regulator to be told finally, “And now we’re passing you on to the next regulator”. The more that these processes can be simultaneous and parallel rather than sequential, the better.
I am delighted to follow the noble Lord, Lord Willetts. We did indeed hear some interesting examples about successful sandboxes in our evidence. However, the lessons from those sandboxes did not seem to spread into the wider regulator and its behaviour.
I shall declare some interests. I work as director of place for Business in the Community in cities such as Blackpool, Bradford and Sheffield, and I am chair of Heathrow Southern Railway, which plans to build a railway south from Heathrow to connect with lines to Woking and Waterloo. In both those capacities, the interface with government is fundamental to growth. For instance, Blackpool has just been shortlisted for City of Culture, which would turbocharge its tourism industry, and, post HS2’s northern demise, Bradford needs better rail connectivity to Manchester.
In all the places where I work, youth unemployment is endemic. The Department for Education, the DWP, the business department, local authorities and the Careers & Enterprise Company all have a role, which too often leads to confusion and inaction. For Heathrow Southern Railway, imagine having to make sense of the different ambitions and boundary conditions involving the politics, policy and regulations around the expansion of Heathrow. You have the CAA, as was referred to earlier, the ORR, the DfT, GBR, the Transport Select Committee and the Treasury, to name but a few.
I was delighted to contribute to the committee’s Time is Money report, and I shall focus my remarks today on a few practical examples. Let me start with overlapping regulatory responsibilities. I mentioned the difficulty of getting good careers advice to the young unemployed. Sheffield, however, has created a one-stop shop called See It Be It for schools and businesses involving all the relevant intermediaries, with the result that there are tens of thousands of helpful interventions. One-stop shops are simply a matter of will and good practice. Unfortunately, in our evidence sessions, we heard examples of departments and regulators asking for overlapping but different information or providing conflicting policy advice. Anglian Water told us that in one year it had provided 30 reports on storm overflows to Ofwat, the department for the environment and the Drinking Water Inspectorate. The department for the environment is trialling having a lead regulator, but it does not go as far as sorting out agreed policy and it does not work across to other departments’ regulators. Another positive example is the department for business’s provision of dedicated concierge and front door services for financial services inward investors.
I am very grateful to my noble friend Lady Hayter of Kentish Town for her incisive introduction to today’s debate and for her leadership of the Industry and Regulators Committee, which has produced this excellent report. As she said, I was a member of the committee for the first few weeks of its inquiry and much regret not overlapping with my noble friend, who has brought a lifetime of focus on consumer interests to her new role. I declare my interests as disclosed in the register, as the director of RSMB, the Theseus Agency and Digbeth Loc. Studios, and as an adviser to the family office, WFO Services.
I welcome and endorse the analysis and conclusions of the report, which shines a light into what it correctly describes as the “mixed picture” of regulators’ roles in encouraging and stimulating economic growth. Successive recent Governments have placed great emphasis on regulators ensuring that they take proper account of growth as an objective. At the risk of being pedantic, I do not think it is right for regulators baldly to “prioritise growth”, which risks a mistaken direction of the industry or the products and services concerned, as well as raising unrealistic expectations for what the regulator can achieve. Language matters.
I wholeheartedly support a direction to regulators to seek, particularly in the light of the rapid innovation which the noble Lord, Lord Willetts, oversees, a better balance between consumer protection and the promotion of growth on the part of the producers of the goods and services being regulated, and hence of the economy as a whole. But that is very different from the rhetoric of prioritising growth. The report accurately identifies the complexity of this issue and the need to make trade-offs between fostering growth and other factors, such as consumer protection and environmental standards. I am not convinced by the Government’s response, shortly before the change of Prime Minister, that the proposed regulating for growth Bill will bring the strategic clarity that is needed to enable widely differing regulators to balance the conflicting objectives that they are having to juggle. I join my noble friend Lady Hayter in asking my noble friend the Minister to indicate the timing of the Bill’s introduction and her current thinking about how to define the judgments and trade-offs that are needed.
My Lords, I declare my interest as an employee of Marsh. I warmly welcome this report and congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, and her committee on what is an extremely useful piece of work looking at the cost of regulation. It gets to the heart of the debate we have returned to many times in this House and does so with commendable clarity. This debate has been running for some time. I want to suggest that a clear consensus is emerging around three core pillars. What strikes me about the committee’s report is how powerfully it supports that framework.
The first pillar is sophistication in design and efficiency in implementation. Regulation that is blunt, where it should be precise, or rigid where it should be adaptive, does not merely inconvenience firms; it actively distorts markets and harms the very consumers and stakeholders it was designed to protect. Good regulation is not light regulation but intelligent regulation. The two are not the same, and we should resist any conflation of them. The committee is right to call for regulators to provide clear guidance early and ensure their requirements are unambiguous from the outset. That is not a procedural nicety; it is a prerequisite for any regime that wishes to be taken seriously.
The second pillar is the recognition and removal of fragmentation. The committee identifies directly that additional complications arise from companies where their projects are overseen by multiple regulators. This is, in my view, one of the most underappreciated structural failures in our current regime. When multiple regulators operate across overlapping domains without adequate co-ordination, the result is not merely duplication; it is the creation of blind spots. Firms fall between the gaps, risks go unmonitored and the cumulative compliance burden on those caught across multiple regimes becomes, in practice, prohibitive. I hope that the Government will treat this not as a long-term aspiration but as an immediate operational priority.
My Lords, I, too, warmly congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, and her committee on this exceptional report. Having worked across the public, private, corporate and not-for-profit sectors, I entirely concur with its central premise: time is money. In my experience, unlocking growth is not about a lawless race to the bottom or having less regulation; it is about achieving consistency, interoperability and efficiency, with a confident, not defensive, approach from the regulators. Global investors look for speed and predictability, but, right now, bureaucratic silos and delays are costing the UK lost opportunities.
For me, two specific proposals in the committee’s report highly resonate. The first is the call for a single front door for multiregulator projects. Breakthroughs such as AI medical tools or autonomous delivery drones do not fit into historical boxes. A single portal for concurrent assessment would instantly slash time to the market. The second is the focus on improving the pace of decision-making via fast lanes. If a business has already cleared rigorous regulatory hurdles in a trusted jurisdiction, such as Japan or the European Union, we should offer passported compliance. Reinventing the wheel simply drives innovators overseas. I therefore welcome the draft proposals being discussed presently between the European Union and the UK on agriproducts, which will eliminate lengthy checks at ports. Trade and growth are not just about tariffs but trust and speedy flow of goods. That will lead to growth.
My Lords, like others, I warmly welcome this report from the Industry and Regulators Committee. I pay special tribute to the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, for her exemplary leadership in this area. As I know from other issues on which she and I work, she is a doughty campaigner and we are lucky that she has brought her skills to bear in this vital area of regulation.
The title of the committee’s report, Time is Money, is spot on. Nowhere is this truer than in digital markets, which the noble Baroness just mentioned, where delay and inaction are not neutral. Every day that the unaccountable big tech platforms go unchecked is another day in which they entrench their monopolies further and, frankly, pile up profits on the back of other people’s labours.
The recent issue surrounding Meta, which was raised in our Oral Questions last week, is an excellent case in point. Last month, it told every business with a Facebook or Instagram account that its new terms and conditions would allow it to scrape their websites with impunity. That was a huge threat to news publishers; it was almost existential—I declare my interest as deputy chairman of the Telegraph Media Group. Its message was: “You pay to produce the news, and we’ll harvest it for free”. The CMA deserves real credit for opening an investigation into this under the Competition Act 1998, but the truth is that it should not have to resort to a tool that can take many months to extract binding commitments or—if Meta does not accept that it is in the wrong and offer solutions—years to reach a remedy. As the report says and the noble Baroness powerfully underlined, speed is essential for effective regulation.
The CMA has called Meta a potential candidate for strategic market status designation under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act, which would allow it to publish tailored, focused, ex ante requirements. However, “potential” is the problem word there. As far back as 2020, the CMA itself concluded that Facebook’s market power warranted this regime, yet Meta is still not designated. Had it been, I doubt it would have attempted anything so brazen as it did last month.
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter of Kentish Town, and the members of the Industry and Regulators Committee for its report. I declare my interests as the director of AI and AI policy companies.
The report makes a compelling point: good regulation can encourage investment and innovation, but unnecessary complexity, uncertainty and delay can hold back economic growth. I want to focus particularly on artificial intelligence, because the committee heard direct evidence of how regulatory barriers can affect innovation in this sector. The committee heard from MyCardium AI, a company developing AI technology to improve heart scans. Its representative explained that the company’s pilots were taking place overseas because establishing an initial pilot or equivalent regulatory sandbox was more difficult in the UK. Importantly, the same company emphasised that clinical safety must remain paramount and welcomed rigorous regulatory scrutiny. This example captures the challenge before us. We should not have to choose between innovation and public protection; we need a regulatory system that delivers both.
Britain has world-class research and considerable technological talent, but scientific breakthroughs must be translated into products and services that improve people’s lives and contribute to economic growth. The committee rightly recommends clearer regulatory guidance, faster decision-making, early engagement with businesses and greater use of regulatory sandboxes. These recommendations are particularly relevant to AI, where technology can develop faster than traditional regulatory processes. The committee also recognises the values of principles-based and outcomes-focused regulation, which can provide certainty while allowing flexibility for innovation. I welcome the Government’s proposal to introduce statutory sandbox powers through the forthcoming regulating for growth Bill, but sandboxes must provide practical results and not simply opportunities for experimentation. They should help regulators to understand new technologies and give businesses clear guidance about the requirements they must meet.
4:38 pm
20 of 40 shown
Done well, regulation can boost consumer confidence, can provide a level playing field that helps competition and can help provide certainty to businesses and investors, whether from here or abroad. Done badly, particularly if it is slow, regulation can cause uncertainty, costs and delays to new products, services and infrastructure and it can harm the economy and disadvantage consumers by denying them cheaper, improved or new products.
While our committee welcomed the intention of the Government’s action plan, it was not always apparent what this meant for individual regulators, whose responsibilities can differ greatly. The Food Standards Agency, for example, wants there to be more nimble and accessible new technologies, but could that conflict with improved agricultural trade with the EU? Other regulators have vital objectives for safety, health and the environment, as well as for consumer protection, so they need to weigh up whether any relaxation on their focus on those important issues could leave workers, shoppers or road users more exposed and carrying more risk themselves. We therefore ask Ministers to provide individual regulators with a more granular picture of what their growth agenda actually meant in practice.
The Government’s response was that they had issued more specific goals to key regulators, although these largely related to specific activities, rather than clarifying how a focus on growth should be balanced with their core objectives. However, just as the Government need to be clearer about their expectation of regulators, so regulators should be clearer as to how businesses should comply with their various demands. We heard from witnesses that too often a lack of early engagement and dialogue and an absence of guidance led to duplication and delay of approvals, which brings us to the question of speed—or pace, as seems to be the in word these days.
Our recommendations here are important for the Government’s agenda but have a resonance beyond this. All regulators should work quicker and smarter than they often do. They are dealing with services and manufacturers, developers, entrepreneurs or innovators in the real world. As the title of our report suggests, time is money. Time can sometimes save lives, when new safety devices, drugs or health breakthroughs could be approved with due checks but without unnecessary red tape. It seems that red tape is indeed the issue sometimes.
Regulators have two tasks: to enforce their actual regulation but also to run an assurance scheme that checks on compliance. We had one question: is the Government’s 25% desired cut on admin the most important measure, or is it the cost to manufacturers of making the adjustment in what they are producing to comply with the rules? The example that we heard was whether it was more expensive for a fridge manufacturer to make sure that the fridge was built to comply with rules or whether it was the paperwork to show the regulator that they had complied with the rules. The Government replied that they had identified £2 billion in admin costs, a third of the £5.6 billion target, although they said that they would also address broader regulation costs to ensure that businesses benefit from reforms. We urge the Government to focus on the wider issue of regulatory compliance, not just red tape, especially as this has lessons for the future.
In this House, as those who have been here a long time will know, we often jib at allowing ministers too much power under secondary legislation, which Parliament therefore cannot influence. But in this report we found that sometimes over-prescriptive rules in primary legislation mean that outdated requirements cannot be quickly altered, even when a regulator wants to do that—so there are lessons for future legislation. Indeed, since this report, our committee has now heard particular examples of legal regulations. The example that we give, looking at the defence industry, is the requirement in law for life jackets on boats. That requirement becomes a little bit meaningless when we are talking about uncrewed vehicles. The regulation cannot be dumped because it is in primary legislation, yet the whole nature of warfare changes as we use autonomous vehicles. That is a lesson for future legislation.
There is another aspect of regulators’ behaviour that is alleged to get in the way, the tendency to risk aversion—and that is easy to understand. When they do something right, nobody notices that the regulators even exist, but one fault, one accident or serious injury, or damage, and the press and Parliament are down on them like a ton of bricks. If the Government want regulators to be bolder in decision-making and less risk-averse, and allow them to see the upsides as well as downsides of new developments, the Government are going to have to provide some political cover for regulators. Each sponsoring Secretary of State must make it clear to their particular regulator that they will honour that.
Indeed, the leadership of regulators is vital in mitigating, rather than avoiding, risk. The appointment of the chair, and often the board, is in the hands of Ministers, as are discussions on their annual reports. Ministers must make their expectations clear and their own tolerance for risk understandable to the regulators, along with the degree to which they are willing to allow consumers to bear any resulting risk if exact regulations are not nailed down and enforced. Ministers are calling for a culture change among regulators, but it will be achieved only if they understand that the level of acceptable risk is a political decision and should be decided by Government, and that they must set out their own risk appetite for regulators and give a clear steer as to when that could be sacrificed to help promote, or at least not stifle, growth. The Government are going to strengthen the growth duty in the regulation for growth Bill and issue steers to guide regulators in applying the new duty, so can my noble friend the Minister let us know when we might expect the Bill?
There is clearly significant room for regulators to improve how they work, especially on the pace of decision-making. Delays increase the cost of borrowing and can make the UK less attractive for investment. Time is money, and speed was the main ask we heard from businesses. While the action plan floated the idea of paid-for fast lanes for approvals, we concluded that allowing some companies to pay for quicker decisions could reduce public trust, disadvantage small or innovative new entrants and remove the incentive for the regulator to speed up all of its processes. All companies need speed, not just the rich ones.
The issue of pace came through strongly, and therefore while we acknowledge the idea of looking for paid-for regulators, it seemed to us that there were other ways to improve things, whether by digitisation, AI, regular and earlier dialogue or a more proportional approach. There are some areas in which companies have to deal with more than one regulator, leading to a government pilot which we welcomed, with a lead environmental regulator. However, that initiative applies only to regulators within the same department, whereas many companies have to deal with more than one department. It also does not allow decision-making to move to the lead body. Can the Minister update us on the work and thinking in that regard?
The committee agrees that the Government are right to turn their attention to the role of regulators, which could make a useful, though not decisive, contribution to the growth objective. Regulators can deter but not actually create growth, but they can certainly facilitate it. However, the Government must take some strategic decisions to fill their scope in this regard. Ministers will have to provide political cover if they want regulators to be less risk-averse, and they must use their role as sponsoring Ministers to ensure regulators up their game in their processes, speed of decision-making and openness to dialogue with the regulated community. Every regulator must maintain a solid focus on their core function, whether that is financial stability, health and safety, consumer protection or fair competition. I commend the Government for their work in this area, and I look forward to seeing the outcome of their action plan in due course. I beg to move.
Another area where RIO, working with Ministers, tries to make process is in convening groups of regulators to confront them as a group with some new technology, just to work out exactly who is responsible for what and how that can be communicated to innovative companies and the technology community. So there are practical things that can be done on growth.
The second point is on risk aversion. Speaking as a former Member of Parliament who used to face real constituents, I can understand the difficulties of standing in front of one’s voters and saying, “We’ve got this great idea: you’re going to take more risk”. It is not always a palatable message. My view is that we can make a lot of progress by looking at what we mean by risk. Often, the real problem is that the definition of risk is very narrow; it is what encompasses the specific responsibilities of the regulation, and it means that wider benefits are not taken into account. I shall give an example—which is not invidious and it is slightly simplified. There are lots of uses of drones. The CAA, with which we have a good, constructive dialogue, is worried about drones flying beyond line of sight and carrying heavy equipment, particularly electrical equipment, so its instinct is to say, “Our job is airspace and protecting airspace, and these types of drones are potentially risky”.
However, there are wider benefits. If the electrical equipment that the drone is carrying is a defibrillator—this issue was raised by the Welsh Ambulance Service—drones flying defibrillators to help people with heart attacks, which is what happens in Switzerland, is a good overall reduction in risk for British citizens. So we are not saying to British citizens, “You have to take more risks because we’re going to going to regulate drones more lightly”. We are actually saying, “When you’re looking at the risks of that bit of electrical equipment landing on someone because a drone crashes, also bear in mind the wider angle of it being used for a medical purpose”. Often, that wider perspective is not one in the minds of the regulators, but we can put it in the minds of the regulators. In other words, benefit aversion is the problem, not risk aversion.
My third and final point is that there is an important section of the report on the difficulties of overspecific regulation. We see that all the time. There is a great example in the report of the FSA requiring chilled foods to be chilled in storage, not allowing for the fact that the transport itself can be chilling now. There is an awful lot of that. The more we can have broad regulation and then use standards and trusted bodies such as the BSI, the better. Let us face it: this House is sometimes one of the worst culprits in adding detail to regulation. If one message that went out from our debate today to our colleagues was, “Lay off a bit”, that itself would be significant progress.
The plethora of regulators and departments around Thames Tideway offers a parallel to Heathrow Southern Railway. The super-sewer was designed to prevent London reaching European pollution limits. The department for the environment and Ofwat were concerned to minimise costs to the consumer, and there was the usual toing and froing about whether this would be on or off the balance sheet. The eventual breakthrough was a senior reference group involving all relevant government parties which established a clear investable pathway and the long-term certainty that investors needed to commit capital. Now that the tunnel is open, I am delighted to say that the Thames has improved from being biologically dead in 1957 to harbouring millions of fish and 4,000 seals.
But this example throws up two common challenges. The first is the tension between keeping prices down for today’s consumer versus investing in the future, and the second is the Treasury. In the 1990s, I had regular conversations about funding London’s transport with three bright young things in the Treasury, namely Ed Balls, Ed Miliband and Shriti Vadera—now the noble Baroness, Lady Vadera. Their view about being on or off balance sheet was that the primary concern was whether the investment was good for UK plc and whether the Government made a good return on any contribution that they made. The simplicity of this view gets lost in worries about ONS classification. Looked at from the perspective of a lowly regulator, on the one hand one has the Treasury saying, “Be less risk averse and more open to innovation”, but on the other, if your project is novel and contentious, the Treasury’s approach will be scepticism and mistrust. These seem like mixed messages.
Where I have less sympathy with the regulators is on efficiency. It should be a given that all regulators are continuously improving their processes and their transparency about timeframes and stages of decision-making. I am delighted that in two of our investigations, into the Building Safety Regulator and the defence industry, timeframes for decision and procurement respectively are being improved, in each case with new leadership. As the title of the report says, time is money.
I finish with two pleas. First, set every regulator a key performance metric on efficiency as one of a small number of priorities. Secondly, advocate “one-stop shop” arrangements to improve user-friendliness and provide clear investable pathways for investors.
The challenges in each regulated industry or sector vary significantly: in financial services, overseen by the Industry and Regulators Committee’s sister committee, there is clear evidence of clumsy and onerous regulation holding back growth in this vital and world-leading service sector without commensurate improvement in consumer protection. In the water industry, under the Conservative Government, short-term and politically influenced focus on holding down consumer prices and lax supervision of corporate behaviour led to serious detriment to the long-term interest of consumers, as well as the undermining of the industry’s financial resilience. The legal services industry is undergoing fundamental changes in ownership and operation as outside capital is introduced through private equity in the stock market, akin to the “big bang” in financial services 40 years ago. The regulation of legal services is currently diffuse, incestuous—dare I say it—and questionably fit for purpose, as these developments change the motivation and behaviour of firms. Can my noble friend the Minister say whether she believes that the regulation of legal services provision strikes the right balance between independence, growth and consumer protection?
The report makes only passing reference to generative AI and AGI, as the committee’s remit was very much focused on existing regulators, but this area poses the starkest challenge in balancing growth and consumer— and, indeed, human—protection at a time when leading companies in this field acknowledge in their initial public offering documentation the non-trivial possibility of devastating systemic harm to mankind. Can my noble friend provide any update on the Government’s intentions for the overarching regulation of AI?
I will end by unashamedly asserting the primacy of consumer protection in regulation, reflecting the asymmetry in power in most cases between consumers and producers and providers. As the report argues, stable, fair consumer protection is a necessary condition for producers and providers’ growth anyway. The most efficient and streamlined application of well-designed regulation is a complementary factor in stimulating that growth. This report gives a compelling summary of the challenges facing the Government in achieving this balance and therefore deserves the closest possible attention and action.
The third pillar is transparent decision-making. This is where I really want to linger, because I think that it is the main point; the committee’s call for clear guidance connects directly to it. If regulators must provide clarity early, the logical consequence is that they must also be transparent about how they will respond when things are unclear, contested or novel. Industry can absorb almost anything if it can plan for it; what it cannot absorb is uncertainty and the inability to anticipate how a regulator will behave. When firms face uncertainty, they do not take risks. They over-comply, over-report and over-resource.
The waste embedded in that precautionary behaviour is vast and almost entirely invisible to those who design the system, but—this is the point I do not want us to lose sight of—transparent decision-making cannot be achieved by regulators alone. It requires government to do its part. Regulators cannot be transparent about how they will resolve conflicts between objectives if government has never told them how those conflicts should be prioritised. That is a political responsibility. The strategic guidance and political cover that government provides, or fails to provide, is the foundation on which regulatory transparency either stands or collapses. The committee calls on the Government to play that role, and I believe that that call deserves to be heard very clearly.
I also commend the committee on drawing a distinction that previous reforms have consistently missed: the difference between the cost of paperwork and the cost of compliance. Reducing the administrative burden of form-filling is welcome, but it is a fraction of the real cost that firms bear when the system changes, with the structural adaptations and ongoing operational adjustments that regulation demands. If we focus on paperwork, we are, to use a familiar phrase, looking for our keys under the lamp-post. The committee has pointed us towards where the keys actually are.
I look forward with great interest to hearing from the Minister about how the Government intend to respond. The committee has done its work with rigour and purpose; I commend it on that again. The question now is whether the response will match the ambition of the diagnosis.
However, to truly support growth in a fast-moving economy, we must also address the compounding weight of legacy rules. I recognise that automated sunset clauses are politically controversial, but I am absolutely not suggesting a blanket eradication of laws. Instead, we should tie sunset clauses directly to digitalisation. As technology evolves, the administrative processes used to enforce regulation become rapidly obsolete. The Government should mandate that digital compliance frameworks and administrative reporting requirements placed on businesses automatically expire after a certain time—maybe five years. This would force the regulators continually to modernise their systems, strip away analogue red tape and transition to leaner, data-driven oversight.
Finally, we must also recognise that opening up digital markets is itself a powerful pro-growth policy. When we properly resource units, such as the CMA’s digital markets unit, to curb the market power of tech monopolies, we create the predictable level playing field that some smaller domestic innovators desperately need to scale up.
I conclude by asking the Minister an overarching question. Given that the IPPR found that 79% of digital-intensive UK firms view big tech dominance as a primary constraint on growth, will the Government commit to a modernised, enforced strategy that pairs aggressive digital market competition with targeted sunset clauses on legacy administrative reporting, ensuring that our regulatory state moves at the same speed as technological innovation?
The legislation, if applied, really does work. Because Google was designated under the regime as having strategic market status, publishers can now withhold content from AI overviews without vanishing from search results. That is the DMCC Act at its best: flexible, targeted remedies, built firm by firm on the evidence. I believe this is far preferable to the blunt instrument of news prominence proposed in the Government’s media Green Paper. What use is prominence if publishers have to withdraw their content because the price of admission to a platform is having their content used as AI training material for free? That way lies commercial perdition—and, indeed, the end of a free press, which my noble friend Lord Hunt of Wirral believes so strongly in.
Also relevant to this excellent report, we need to ask why the CMA has not designated Meta or other big tech services that extract excess profits from consumers and crowd out UK start-ups. I do not think the fault lies with the CMA itself, which has done really good work under difficult circumstances; I fear the culprit is the Government’s 2025 strategic steer to put inward investment front and centre. The IPPR report, Bottleneck Britain, found that digital-intensive UK businesses rank big tech’s market power as the second biggest constraint on growth, ahead of finance and talent. The Government’s steer has the priorities backwards, and they should urgently change their direction by expressly backing the CMA to use the powers that we in Parliament gave it and resource it to match. A regulator facing the world’s most valuable companies cannot do the job on a shoestring.
The same question matters for the regulating for growth Bill, which the noble Viscount, Lord Chandos raised. What type of growth will it mandate? I hope it will not be the sugar rush of inward investment announcements of the sort that lets big tech off the hook. It should be growth felt by British businesses and citizens, powered by firms that scale and stay here. The growth duty must never override regulators’ core functions. There is little point in a £500 million sovereign AI fund if the CMA cannot regulate monopolists who swallow up potential UK tech champions. That Bill also risks being lopsided. Ministers propose AI growth labs to exempt AI firms from regulation, potentially with sweeping Henry VIII powers to make those relaxations permanent. Yet where a light-touch rule would unlock massive growth for UK firms, they hold back. AI crawlers harvest content anonymously and ignore the wishes of content creators. The Government should put bot transparency provisions into the regulating for growth Bill.
I would like to press the Minister on a number of points. First, will the Government urgently issue a new strategic steer that backs the CMA to take on big tech with the resources that it needs? Secondly, will they ensure that the regulating for growth Bill focuses on growth that will be felt by UK citizens and businesses? Thirdly, will they put bot transparency provisions into the same legislation? Time is indeed money, and British firms, including our world-class content creators, are paying for every day of delay.
We must also ensure that smaller companies benefit. The committee rightly cautions that paid-for fast lanes could disadvantage businesses unable to afford them. Faster and more predictable regulatory decisions should benefit all applicants. I therefore ask my noble friend the Minister two questions. First, how will the Government ensure that smaller AI innovators can access early regulatory guidance and appropriate sandbox opportunities without compromising safety? Secondly, will the Government establish clear, measurable expectations for regulatory decision-making times so that businesses can invest and plan with greater confidence?
Britain’s challenge is not simply to develop the technologies of tomorrow but to ensure that innovations developed here can be tested, adopted and scaled here. Effective regulation should protect the public while giving responsible innovators the certainty and confidence to succeed. That is how regulation can become an enabler of economic growth.