My Lords, at its heart, this is a simple and modest Bill. It asks the Government to do something that they have already promised to do: to consult on proposals for replacing the House of Lords with an alternative second Chamber and then report transparently on what they have heard. But it does something else that is just as important. It requires the Government not just to consult but to respond. It requires Ministers to tell Parliament and the public what they intend to do next, because the purpose of the Bill is not to produce another report destined for a shelf in Whitehall. We have plenty of those already. The purpose is to make sure a process begins, and, crucially, that it keeps going. The ball must keep moving.
The future of this House has been debated for longer than most of us can remember. Every political party has, at one point or another, argued that the House of Lords should be reformed, replaced or abolished altogether. We have never been short of ideas, and we have never been short of debate, but we have been short of action. That is why this Bill matters. The Government were elected on a manifesto commitment to replace the House of Lords with an alternative second Chamber that better represents the nations and regions of the UK, and to consult on proposals for achieving that aim. This Bill simply seeks to give effect to that commitment.
I congratulate the noble Baroness on the draw and on presenting her first ever Private Member’s Bill. In the 37 years I have been in Parliament, I have never presented a Private Member’s Bill, so I particularly congratulate her both on this opportunity and on the, as ever, passionate and articulate speech that she just delivered. It does not mean that I think that she is right, but I think that she is correct in bringing this forward, which I suspect is why that those of us who are here to debate it this morning have forgone the dangers of not being able to reach the regions and nations of Britain, because of the weather, in order to contribute to an important debate.
Like the noble Baroness, I am very pleased that students are with us in the Gallery. When I presented the ideas on reform of the upper Chamber to students at the University of Sheffield, we always started off with the presumption that they wanted democracy in the form of election of some sort or another. By the time we concluded the debate, they were not so sure, because this is a very complex and difficult issue. If it were not then what the noble Baroness described as the equivocation over a century would not have taken place. It is precisely because no one could actually come to a conclusion on what the legitimate alternative might be that we are here today.
Like the noble Baroness, I am from a deeply working-class community—we have to say it, don’t we: from a council estate—in my case, in the north of Sheffield. Yes, people used to look bewildered at the ermine. By the way, in those days—because I am old, and I am getting older, like the rest of us—there were no life Peers. When I looked at the hereditary situation in the House of Lords, no wonder I was bewildered and thought, “God, I’ll never get there, and if I do, I’ll probably want to abolish it”. Well, I am here and I do not want to abolish it, but I do want to reform it.
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, who is, if I may say so, a living embodiment of why it is a good idea that we move forward and reform the House of Lords rather than abolish it. It is similarly a great pleasure to follow the noble Baroness who introduced this legislation. I applaud her courage massively and recognise the passion and the articulation with which she spoke and presented her case. I have looked very closely at the draft legislation that she proposed and her case is to abolish the House of Lords, not to reform it. This is where I part company with her most materially.
The noble Baroness presented her case with articulation. She spoke of reform as being a process and not an event. I agree very much with that; it is true and that is why I cannot go along with the thesis that it is a good idea to abolish the House of Lords and to present a blank sheet of paper and say, “What do we do next?” This is essentially what the noble Baroness is proposing.
I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, that reform is necessary, and the noble Baroness is to be congratulated, perhaps, on presenting us with a precipice as to what happens if we do not reform. There will be a growing clamour for abolition, and that would be a mistake. There are people in the public who think we are here every day in our ermine. I meet them and they say, “Have you been in your ermine today”? I have been in my ermine three times: once on joining here, once for a presentation of the Queen’s Speech, as it was then, and once when a noble friend was introduced to the Lords. No more than that. There is a misunderstanding of what we do.
My Lords, it is always a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Bourne of Aberystwyth; his calm, measured tones are always difficult to follow. I also welcome the introduction of the Bill by the noble Baroness, Lady Smith. She was very clear and put forward a very powerful argument for why the consultation is needed.
Noble Lords will notice I am slightly croaky today—I am not the noble Lord croaker—but I will endeavour to get through this. It was also great to hear the interjection by the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. The noble Lord and I have known each other through Sheffield politics for well over 20 years. I have been rather worried recently because we have agreed more than we have disagreed, but I am now going back to our normal knocking 10 bells out of each other, as we do in Sheffield politically.
I should own up: I am on the traditional liberal wing of the Liberal Democrats, and we have been waiting for rather a long time for this kind of debate and for reform of the House of Lords. It was the Parliament Act 1911 that promised a second Chamber on a popular, rather than hereditary, basis. That was 115 years ago. I would guess it is probably the longest-running temporary arrangement in British public life. I welcome the progress so far in this Parliament: the hereditaries have gone, but some have returned quite rightly on their own merit, and the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, will be speaking later.
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Llanfaes, for the opportunity to discuss House of Lords reform again. I enjoyed her introductory remarks and agree that this is a very good opportunity to begin to discuss some issues that go beyond the particulars that some of the committees have looked at.
Over the past decade, I have consistently made the case for reform. I have argued for a limit on the size of the House, a balance of new party appointments which reflect the most recent general elections and 15-year term limits for new Peers. Sadly, we have seen no progress on these proposals. As the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, said, there has been a shortage of action. Despite the removal of the hereditary Peers, the House is roughly the same size as it was 10 years ago, when we started work on the Lord Speaker’s committee. The Prime Minister of the day continues to determine the total number of appointments and their allocation by party. New Peers are being appointed at an age that could see them being Members of this House for 40 years, even with a retirement age of 80. No one outside Westminster can begin to understand how these arrangements make sense for a legislative Chamber.
I understand the complexity of the issue, but I am disappointed that successive Prime Ministers have shown little interest in reform of these elements of our system. Instead, the Government have a manifesto commitment to replace the House of Lords with an alternative second Chamber that is more representative of the nations and regions. They have said that they will consult on proposals, and, rather cleverly, today the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, has taken on that job for them and brought forward this commitment to a consultation in her Bill. Personally, I remain committed to the proposals from the Lord Speaker’s committee and hope they will be considered, among other options.
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the very thoughtful contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Burns, and I commend the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, on bringing forward this Private Member’s Bill.
I am the first to acknowledge that Governments—and, more to the point, the public—face challenges that may feel a good deal more pressing than constitutional reform, not least the cost of living. But it would be wrong to assume that there is no popular interest in our constitutional arrangements. On the contrary, people hold clear views on Lords reform, and it is fair to say that the majority believe there is some room for improvement.
The gap between how the public perceive this House and how the House sometimes regards itself is striking. Opinion poll after opinion poll shows staunch support for change. Labour’s manifesto reflected this imperative. It set out commitments first for incremental reforms, including the removal of seats for hereditary Peers, a mandatory retirement age, participation requirements and ways to make it quicker and easier to remove disgraced Peers. The public believe that such changes are long overdue, but progress still feels painfully slow. Labour’s manifesto reflected mainstream public opinion when it asserted that the right to inherit a seat in the Lords was “indefensible”. Yet we spent many long, late hours in this place while some tried to do just that.
Labour’s manifesto also committed to substantive reform. It commits to
“replacing the House of Lords with an alternative second chamber that is more representative of the regions and nations”
and to consulting the public on proposals. This is not about changing this House’s core function—a reformed second Chamber would continue to play its vital role in scrutinising the Government and improving the quality of legislation—nor about undermining the primacy of the House of Commons. However, to protect that primacy it does not automatically follow that this House should remain wholly unelected; rather, we need to ask why the UK is alone in having the only second Chamber in Europe that has no part democratically elected, whether directly or indirectly.
My Lords, I am delighted to follow the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, and I agree very much with most of her points. I am grateful to her for her forthright views. I am also grateful to the noble Lords, Lord Blunkett, Lord Bourne, Lord Scriven and Lord Burns, for their constructive contributions and look forward to other colleagues addressing this House.
I am glad to speak in support of this Bill and congratulate my colleague, the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Llanfaes, on her good fortune in coming out of the ballot, on her choice of topic on which to introduce a Bill, and on her truly excellent Second Reading speech this morning. In proposing what some noble Lords may regard as a radical step, the noble Baroness has presented an opportunity for the Chamber to consider a matter that should be of concern to all of us as democrats. She has done so in a modest and reasonable manner, to which no one might take offence, and she has avoided being overtly party political, so it probably remains for me to clarify some of Plaid Cymru’s views on these matters.
Clearly, this Bill may not appeal very much those who believe that our second Chamber is perfect beyond question. But I suspect that, in their hearts, an overwhelming majority of Peers and the general public accept that, in a modern democracy, it is impossible to justify a Chamber composed of Members who have been chosen by the Prime Minister of the day when they took their seats, with a complete absence of geographic balance. The fact that we have finally done away with the hereditary principle in no way validates the composition of this Chamber.
My Lords, it is always a pleasure to follow the mellifluous contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Wigley, although invariably we disagree. I begin by congratulating the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Llanfaes, on bringing this Bill forward. She is above all consistent and principled. She came into this House pledging to work for the abolition of the House of Lords, and she is as good as her word. It takes some principle to support something that is against your own fiduciary interest, so I commend her for that, but I have to say that this Bill is a missed opportunity. It is a legislative vacuum, because it really does not address the key issues in this half of our bicameral legislature. We could be debating many other important issues for reform: the NHS, social care, the prison system or welfare, not constitutional reform, notwithstanding the remarks of the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady.
The Bill presupposes the answer from the outset, the answer being abolition, and it gives quite wide-ranging, sweeping powers to Ministers to set up a process with little detail or vision. One has only to look at Clause 1(2)(e) and (3)(a) to see that. As others have said, including the typically astute noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, we already have a people’s assembly and it is called the House of Commons.
We all know that the same old people will be mounting their hobby horses in this campaign: Unlock Democracy, the Electoral Reform Society, the Fawcett Society and, of course, the Guardian. The House of Lords is way down the list of voter salience and voter concern. We have already experienced the unedifying chaos of piecemeal reform with the removal of the hereditary Peers, which would make a Central American banana republic blush as dozens of new Labour Peers have been ennobled while long-standing, experienced hereditary Peers—mainly Conservative ones—have been kicked out. In fact, I sometimes think that there is not a member of the constituency Labour Party in Islington or Camden who is not a Member of your Lordships’ House.
11:11 am
20 of 39 shown
One promise remains outstanding, and no clear plan has been put out for delivering it: the commitment to consult on the future of the second Chamber itself. If the Government remain committed to that pledge, why should consultation be delayed indefinitely? If it was important enough to place in the manifesto to the electorate, why should Parliament hesitate to begin delivering it?
I come to this debate from a rather different perspective from many who have spoken on these issues over the years. I am the youngest Member of your Lordships’ House and I come from a working-class background in Wales, which is not traditionally the route by which people arrive here. This is also my first Private Member’s Bill. My own views on the constitutional future of Wales are no secret. Some may find it curious that someone who supports Welsh independence has chosen to bring forward a Bill about reforming a Chamber within the UK Parliament, but I see no contradiction. Whatever constitutional future we each believe in, we should all want the institutions that exist today to command public confidence.
Like many people from communities across Wales and beyond, my route into public life was anything but conventional. A lot of my politics is shaped by my experience of growing up as an unpaid carer for my father, and my focus was—and continues to be—how we improve people’s lives. The way decisions are made and who makes them plays a big part in that. Westminster was not part of my everyday conversations growing up. It felt distant—something that happened somewhere else. I suspect many people still feel exactly the same today. Experiences like that shape the way that you see public institutions. They make you ask who is represented, whose voices are heard and who feels left out altogether.
For me, that is what this Bill is really about. Growing up on Ynys Môn, this place could not have felt further away. In fact, my noble friend Lord Wigley was the first Member of your Lordships’ House I had ever met, and what a formidable advocate he is for Cymru. Having now spent more than two years here, I have a far greater appreciation of the work the House does and the contributions made by Members from all sides and none. But I still think that many members of the public have perfectly reasonable questions about how this House is put together.
Being appointed by former Prime Ministers is not a process that most people would immediately recognise as a modern form of democratic accountability—neither are Bishops, specifically from the Church of England, having 26 reserved spaces in a place that scrutinises new laws for us all to live under. We should not be surprised when people ask questions about an institution with more than 800 Members carrying titles such as Lords and Baronesses. We can explain the work that we do here and rightly point to its value, but we should also understand why some people look at this place and think it belongs to another age. I suspect that, for some people, the only Lords and Baronesses they have encountered are the ones they have seen in “Bridgerton”.
Public institutions are strongest when people feel that they have helped shape them. They are weakest when people feel that decisions are being made for them rather than with them. As a Welsh Member of this House, I am conscious that debates such as this can sometimes sound like Westminster talking to itself. But they are not. These questions matter in Holyhead and the Highlands, in Cardiff and Carlisle, and in Belfast and Birmingham, because they are ultimately questions about who has a voice, who feels represented and who feels heard.
The Wales I grew up in is the Wales that voted for devolution. A previous Secretary of State for Wales, Ron Davies, famously described devolution as a “process, not an event”. That is a helpful quote to consider when we look to make change here, too. Our communities have changed and expectations have changed, yet when it comes to the second Chamber the debate often feels stuck in the same place. Whether one supports independence, federalism, further devolution or the union in its present form, there is a legitimate question about whether Parliament’s institutions properly reflect the nations and regions they are intended to serve. That is not a question that should be answered exclusively here within the walls of Westminster.
Some may reasonably ask why we need another consultation when this issue has already been examined by countless commissions, committees and reviews. That is a fair challenge, but the answer is simple. Too often, Lords reform follows a pattern, which we are all quite familiar with. A report is written, conclusions are reached and then everything quietly grinds to a halt. The Bill seeks to break this cycle. It requires the Government not only to listen but to come back and explain what happens next. In short, it seeks to keep the ball moving.
We saw evidence of how strongly people feel about these questions when the Bill received its First Reading earlier this year. Some noble Lords took the unusual step of voicing opposition to what is normally a procedural stage. I mention that not as a criticism but as an illustration. People care deeply about the future of this House and, where there is disagreement, my instinct is not to narrow the conversation but to widen it.
Noble Lords will hold very different views about the future of this House. Those disagreements are fair, but this Bill does not ask anybody to abandon their convictions. It asks a much simpler question: should the public have a voice in determining the future shape of Parliament? If we cannot agree on the answer, surely we can agree on that as a question. That is why the Bill provides for wider public engagement, including citizens’ assemblies and other deliberative approaches. Change should not be something done to people; it should be something done with them.
Before I conclude, I thank those who have helped to inform my thinking as I have brought forward my first Private Member’s Bill. In particular, I am grateful to the Electoral Reform Society for its continued advocacy and campaigning on people’s democratic rights. I am also grateful to my fellow officers on the APG on House of Lords Reform, who include Members in the other place representing Labour, Conservatives, Liberal Democrats and the Greens. I also wish to thank the students of the politics lab at Edge Hill University, some of whom are here today. Their involvement is a reminder that conversations about the future of our democracy should belong not exclusively to politicians and constitutional experts but to the people who will inherit that future too.
I do not stand here today claiming to have all the answers—I have my own views about the future and other noble Lords will have theirs—but surely the future shape of Parliament is not a question that Parliament should answer alone. The Government promised to consult on that future; this Bill simply asks them to honour that commitment. But it also asks for something more: it asks that consultation be followed by actual action. The people we serve deserve a voice in that conversation, and they deserve to know that, once they have been heard, something will happen as a result. As someone who grew up on a council estate in Ynys Môn, who never imagined that I would one day be standing here introducing a Private Member’s Bill in this House, I find it very difficult to argue against giving people a greater say in decisions about the institutions that govern them. This Bill asks for no more than that—not a conclusion, not a blueprint, just a conversation, and a commitment that once this conversation has taken place it will be followed by a clear statement of what comes next. If we cannot agree on the answer, surely we can agree on the question. After decades of debate, that hardly seems too much to ask for. I beg to move.
My noble friend Lady Taylor of Bolton, who is speaking later, was the chair of the Retirement and Participation Committee, and I served under her. We looked at some of these broader issues. We did not have a Bishop on our committee—as a Methodist, I have no intention of going into the issue of the abolition of the hereditary principle of the Church of England having representatives here—but, apart from that particular grouping, we were well represented across the House.
It was interesting to have that debate. I say to the noble Baroness, Lady Smith: by all means let us set up a constitutional commission. Let us have the open debate about what we would replace this House with. If, as my friend the former Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, proposed in the commission that he led four years ago, it focuses on the regions and nations, which the noble Baroness mentioned, and would therefore be much more a constitutional Chamber, I have a very simple message: there is a House that is entirely representative—minutely representative—of the regions and nations of the United Kingdom. It is the House of Commons. It represents, in relation to geography and population, the nations and regions, and it speaks for them.
It is true that we could be more representative in this House. It is true that Prime Ministers of all persuasions, when they say that they are going to widen the scope of the representation of English regions, of Wales, of Scotland and of Northern Ireland, should do it. I am relieved, despite the fact that we have moved in the opposite direction in the past two years, that those who have entered this House from London and the south-east are of the highest possible quality. Good job—otherwise I would be deeply offended by the way we have ignored the Labour manifesto of 2024. But there we go; there are other bits of it that I do not agree with as well.
This morning, let us agree perhaps that there is a dialogue to be had and that we could, through a constitutional commission, examine the impact of changing fundamentally the representation of this House on the workings of the House of Commons, on devolved regional strategic authorities in England and on our relationship with Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. That would be sensible, not least because the House of Commons would have to change dramatically. In the last Session before the general election, 2,400 amendments were moved by the Government to improve and alter Bills that had been partly scrutinised but were mostly nodded through the House of Commons. Having spent 28 years there, I know its strengths and its weaknesses.
I never made a pledge from the council estate or when I was in the House of Commons that I would not enter this place, so I feel fairly secure in saying: let us try to get it right for the future, not simply by having a list system—which is what it would be if we had direct election—in which the political parties would determine who was at the top of the list and who arrived here.
I looked at the evidence closely and recently attended a talk by constitutional expert Ian Dunt, who is very much on the left of politics, not the right. I anticipated that he would lambast the Lords and say that it should be scrapped, but he did not. He said that if there is one part of the constitution that should be reformed and essentially left more or less as it is, it is the House of Lords. He said that because, successively, we have acted as a bastion for opinion when the House of Commons has got it wrong; we have done that over a succession of issues where opinion runs high, such as student fees, Brexit and Rwanda. This House gives a chance to represent a different view from the elected Chamber, and that is important.
The work we do not just in the House but in Committee is important, as the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, has said, with thousands of practical amendments to improve legislation. That role of scrutiny is vital in everything that is done in this House. But tackling the great growth of subordinate legislation is something that we do, too. These things are worth retaining.
That does not mean that we should not be reforming the House of Lords. I will say a bit about some of the strands that that represents, if I may. I recognise the work that the noble Baroness, Lady Taylor of Bolton, has done on this, which was the total opposite of self-serving. The work was not to her advantage or that of the people on the committee; they did it based on what is best moving forward for this House. I strongly support the work that they have been doing—it is to be applauded.
That should be joined with something on appointments. I recognise that that was not part of the brief that the committee had on attendance and retirement, but we need to look very closely at what is happening on appointments. More people have joined than have left the Lords in this Session, although we have lost the remaining hereditary Peers. There have been more appointments made and we need to look at the role of HOLAC and put it on a statutory footing. We should alter the way that appointments are made, and I agree that probably the way forward is a commission to look at appointments. That should come with some urgency.
This House has totally changed over 80 years. The noble Lord mentioned the Life Peerages Act 1958. Until then, all appointments to this House were hereditary. That is only 80 years ago. Now, all appointments to this House are life peerages. Effectively, the hereditary principle was abolished in 1999, although we retained—I think this was a mistake—the hereditary by-elections. I say this with due respect; I know that the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, is speaking later, so there is nothing personal in this. I recognise that many of those who have joined through that route are worthy of their appointments, but it was very much a Gilbert and Sullivan or Heath Robinson sort of construct, in a very British way. If we had not had the hereditary by-elections, we would have seen the remaining hereditaries wither on the vine, and that would have been a way forward. Anyway, that is history.
What is important is to look at the principle of appointment to see whether we should do something for the nations and regions in terms of appointments: they are underrepresented in this House, that is quite true, and that would be a way of putting it right. I personally agree with the Bishops and the Archbishops, though I think we can extend that to other religious leaders; I think that would strengthen our House, constitution and country. That is something worth looking at.
I have struggled with the principle of an elected House of Lords. It is difficult to deny the importance of elections. We have elections for the other place. However, I recognise—and it is strengthened by my participation in this House—that there are loads of Peers, many of whom are here today, who would not dream of standing in elections, and they probably would not be returned if they did. But they strengthen this House immeasurably. We risk losing that very valuable element, especially on the Cross Benches, which includes many lawyers, retired diplomats, trade union leaders and so on. They are people who would probably not stand in an election. Do we want to risk that? It is something that needs to be looked at on balance as to whether we have an elected element but retain appointments so that we are able to play to the strength of a House of Lords with all the expertise that conjures up.
I am grateful to the noble Baroness for bringing forward this legislation. It is an important piece of legislation, at least to focus our minds. I do not think the way forward is to abolish the House of Lords and ask what we do next, which is essentially throwing all the pieces up in the air. That is not the way to go about it; we do not need revolution, but we certainly need evolution—and quickly, in my humble opinion.
However, that is only tinkering. We have swapped the accident of birth for the accident of who you know and left the Prime Minister’s patronage exactly where it was. A promise to consult without a date attached is the constitutional equivalent of “The cheque is in the post”. The Liberal Democrat position is long-standing: a fully elected second Chamber, chosen by proportional representation, speaking for the nations and regions of the United Kingdom; the primacy of the Commons will be preserved. But this Bill asks only for a consultation. After 115 years, that is hardly a leap in the dark.
Why an elected Chamber? As a matter of principle in a democracy, I believe the right to make law comes from the people. Not one of the Members of this House, no matter how eminent or detailed we are in legislation, has been chosen by the public to sit here. Not one of us can be held to account or removed by them. That is why this House defers to the elected Commons. It knows it has no mandate. An elected second Chamber would be stronger, not weaker, and it would scrutinise with authority and not, as sometimes we do, with an apology.
I am from Sheffield, like the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. When the Electoral Reform Society last analysed this House by region, just under 6% of Peers lived in Yorkshire and the Humber, whereas 24% lived in London and 21% in the south-east. For the poor north-east, it was 3%; for Wales it was 4%, Scotland 7% and Northern Ireland 2.5%. A Chamber meant to speak for the whole country looks more like a London dinner party, and Yorkshire rarely gets invited.
I want to be fair, though, to the Cross-Benchers. Their Members are recommended by the House of Lords Appointments Commission through an open, merit-based process and many are people of real distinction who add to your Lordships’ House. But look how thin this safeguard is: the commission is asked to find just two non-party Peers a year, it has no veto and no say over numbers, and the Prime Minister can still nominate Cross-Benchers directly. In 2020, the Prime Minister overruled the commission’s advice. In other democracies, expertise advises; it does not hold a lifelong right to legislate.
On the party Benches, it is starker. The commission checks propriety, not merit, and suitability is left to the party. In July, with the previous Prime Minister preparing to leave, 26 new life Peers were announced in one of his final acts. Five of these places went to my own party, so we claim no clean hands, but while this system exists every party uses it, and that is exactly why it must go. A panel that can improve patronage is not one that can supply a mandate. We elect our councillors, our mayors and our devolved Parliaments as a matter of principle. Only at the top of the system do we hand out seats by appointment, which is unusual in any other bicameral system in the world, bar one.
Like the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, I will skip along now to the Bishops’ Benches; people would be very surprised if I did not. In 26 cases, some of our Members are here by job title. Again, they contribute to the work of the House, but, as a matter of principle, nobody voted for these 26 Bishops. They are here because of the posts they hold in the only institution in the whole country that is guaranteed places in Parliament. The 2021 census found that 46% of people in England and Wales described themselves as Christian and over 30% said they had no religion at all. The Church’s own figures put average Sunday attendance in 2024 at just under 1% of the population of England, so 1% attend the Church, but 26 seats are guaranteed automatically in the UK Parliament.
We are told that the Bishops speak for the nation, as they do on many important issues, and not just for the Church. But the record shows they also speak for the Church: during the passage of the equal marriage Bill, the previous Archbishop of Canterbury welcomed the Church of England’s quadruple lock on marriage and argued to protect it. In 2023, eight Bishops, including one who then sat in this House, signed a submission asking the Government to exempt the confessional from mandatory reporting. Again, that issue has been raised recently.
We have seen a number of occasions when the Bishops have stood up and asked for special privileges in VAT concessions on reforming and doing up churches. When the hereditary Peers Bill came before us, the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Sheffield, who I admire greatly, spoke against the amendments to reduce the number of Lords spiritual. Turkeys, I am told, do not vote for Christmas, and it seems that Bishops do not vote for fewer Bishops. This is no criticism of the faith or the individuals, but nobody should sit in our legislature by virtue of a job in one church.
I support the Bill and urge the Government to give us a firm date for consulting, rather than a vague nod to do so.
The requirement that the House should be more representative of the regions and nations could be added fairly simply. The responsibility for meeting them should be placed on each of the party groups and HOLAC. On its own, this does not require major reform. However, when we looked at this, I was astonished to discover how difficult it is to determine where people come from. Is it where they were born? Is it where they now live? Is it where they were educated? Is it somewhere between all these areas? Nevertheless, it does not require major reform and does not seem to me, on its own, to be an argument for fundamental reform, compared to some of the other issues that we have discussed.
In any consultation with the public about reform—despite what the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, said about his interaction with students—I am confident that the most popular option would be some form of appointment by election. There might be debate about the details, but my reading of public opinion is that it clearly favours the legitimacy of election-based appointments.
Under the terms of the manifesto commitment and this Bill, the Government must publish a document setting out alternatives for consultation. In my remaining remarks, I will suggest some factors that I hope the Government will consider if they get round to setting out these alternatives. First, in any consultation, it is hugely important that the Government should be cautious about any change to the powers and purposes of this House. Experience shows that the Commons is very wary that increased legitimacy for this House could undermine its own primacy. The safest approach is to accept that the present powers and purposes of this House are appropriate and to place emphasis on the experience and independence of Members. Any consultation should clearly state that the primary role of the second Chamber is legislative scrutiny and encouraging the Government to think again on certain issues. Earlier this week, there was a debate in the House of Commons about House of Lords reform and the issue about the primacy of the House of Commons surfaced from a number of the contributors.
My second point is that if elections for Members are included, the system should be as different as possible from the Commons system. Therefore, for a second Chamber, my view is that a proportional representation would be most suitable. I say this in tribute to the noble Baroness, Lady Smith: the recent Welsh Senedd system offers such a model for a limited proportional representation system. It involves regional constituencies with multiple Members where voters choose between the parties and determine the number of seats that each party wins. These seats are then allocated by the parties from a closed list of candidates. Like the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, I am not a fan of closed lists, but essentially this seems to me to be a hybrid system of election and appointment, which may be suitable for this House. The overall numbers would be determined by election rather than by the Prime Minister, but leaving the selection of individuals effectively in the hands of the parties. This would also address the Government’s concern about underrepresented regions and nations in the second Chamber.
The next question is whether separate elections for the two Houses are necessary, or whether they should be held together. I favour simultaneous elections for both Houses because it would be very difficult to generate much interest among the electorate in separate elections for a Chamber with relatively limited powers.
The third major issue that keeps cropping up for me is the mechanism for Members leaving. In an elected system, of course, this would involve term lengths. The straightforward approach would be to have the same term length as the Commons. During a general election, all party members would leave and stand for re-election or retire. However, as the scrutiny role emphasises experience, options could also include longer terms for Members of the second Chamber. Members could serve for two Parliaments, say, with half of the House standing for re-election at each general election. A third option would be to serve for three Parliaments, with a third of the House standing for re-election. The third option is, broadly speaking, my own choice, and would—this is no coincidence—over time deliver a result very close to the proposals of the Lord Speaker’s Committee for the political parties, but with the democratic element.
The fourth major issue is the role and handling of the Cross-Bench Members. I will leave the detail of this for another day, but noble Lords will not be surprised to hear that I hope the Cross-Bench Members remain a significant proportion of the House under any option, with appointments generally being made by HOLAC. I agree with the criticism of what has happened in recent years in the way that Prime Ministers have limited the role of HOLAC and the number of appointments it is allowed to make, taking on the job of making appointments to the Cross Benches themselves.
The focus of my contribution on Lords reform over the past decade has been to try to make the existing arrangements work more effectively, avoiding the relentless underlying increase in the size of the House, and I have not given up hope that we could see significant changes yet. However, if there is no change to the Prime Minister’s power to make appointments and there are no term limits, it will become increasingly likely that more fundamental reform is going to take place.
Opinion polls show strong opposition across the board to a House of Lords selected primarily through patronage. There is roughly equal support, in the polls I have seen, for some form of elected membership and the appointment of Members who are genuinely independent. Of course, it is perfectly possible to design a system that provides for both. In his first major speech on the workings of the House of Lords in July, the Lord Speaker, the noble Lord, Lord Forsyth, counselled caution, saying that Labour’s case for substantive reform should be considered carefully. That is good advice, but the Lord Speaker went on to warn that rewiring the system risked blowing “a constitutional fuse”. However, as any decent fire officer will tell you, the consequences of not upgrading an ageing, outdated system are far more serious than just blowing a fuse. That is true for the Lords both metaphorically and quite literally.
This week I attended the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly, where we heard the long view from Professor Alvin Jackson of Christ’s College, Cambridge. Drawing on examples from across Europe, he presented a historical analysis of why some union states endure while others fall apart. Key factors include whether there is a willingness to engage with modernisation and constitutional reform; whether bigger partners are ready, and generous enough, to share power across the union; whether there are sustained efforts to build a shared vision and identity that can bind diverse populations together; and, critically, whether institutions are fit for purpose to support that shared endeavour. No doubt there are different views on the future of the union and on whether Gordon Brown’s specific proposal to replace the Lords with a senate is the right one, but Labour is committed to better representation of the nations and regions. Perhaps we could take the opportunity to consult on how to deliver much fairer representation of women and Black and ethnic-minority communities too.
This Bill proposes a framework and timetable for consultation, including with devolved Governments and constitutional experts and potentially through citizens’ assemblies. Of course, not all expertise, wisdom and practical experience resides in this place. It would be quite wrong for unelected Peers to mark our own homework or effectively wield a veto. It is not the job of the Lords to obstruct, delay or dodge its own reform. We cannot be sure what conclusions the proposed consultation would reach, but we do know that the public want parliamentary institutions that better represent their interests and are more accountable to them, because at the heart of this debate is the need to rebuild trust in democracy. The definition of democracy is that authority rests with the people, so it is high time to ask the British public how politics can best serve them.
The usual justification of the present system is that it brings to the legislative process individuals of great and wide-ranging experience who would not put themselves forward for election. I wholly accept that there are Members here with immense experience in the world of academia, the law, science, industry, agriculture, the arts, the Armed Forces, diplomacy, government and much more. But many of these highly respected cohorts of experts will admit, if pressed, that their expertise may indeed have been substantial at the height of their careers, but that may have been a decade, or two or three, ago. It will not have passed unnoticed that it is the youngest Member of this House who has brought forward this Bill today.
There is also a geographic imbalance that must cause concern to those who believe that Westminster’s system of government should be acceptable to all parts of the United Kingdom. No comprehensive figures are available for the geographic parts of the UK that Members of this Chamber regard as home, but based on limited data the Library’s brief suggests that about half of all Peers live in London and south-east England, making it grossly geographically distorted.
This brings me to the party-political dimension. My party, Plaid Cymru, is the governing party in Wales’s Senedd. Up until 2006, Plaid refused to nominate representatives for consideration to this Chamber because of the non-democratic nature of the House of Lords. The party changed its mind when the Government of Wales Act 2006, in granting primary lawmaking powers to the then National Assembly, wrote in a proviso that every single application for the use of those powers on devolved subjects such as education or housing would have to be approved by order by both the House of Commons and the House of Lords. In other words, the undemocratic second Chamber at Westminster could veto the wishes of our democratically elected National Assembly on devolved matters that solely and exclusively related to Wales.
We were told by the then Labour Chief Whip that, if we agreed to nominate suitable people for the second Chamber, we could expect to be allocated three Members. On that basis of assurance, the party, after a lot of heart-searching, agreed to make nominations and held an internal party election in which three Members—former council leader Janet Davies, industrialist Dr Eurfyl ap Gwilym, and me—were duly nominated. We were led to believe that we would be ratified quickly and that the three of us would take our seats here. But, lo and behold, by then there had been a change in Labour’s leadership: Tony Blair had stepped down and Gordon Brown had replaced him, and no way was he going to appoint any nationalist to this Chamber. He was as good as his word, and none of us were appointed.
It was only after David Cameron became Prime Minister that I was offered a place here. My two colleagues were left in suspended animation. It was March 2024 before we were allowed a second Member, and my noble friend Lady Smith of Llanfaes was elected by Plaid Cymru’s National Council to join me here. We now have a Plaid Cymru Government in Wales, with 44 Members of our Senedd elected last May, but are still denied reasonable representation in this Chamber.
Let me make it clear: while the ultimate objective of Plaid Cymru as a party is an independent Wales, which at that point would cease sending Members to either the House of Commons or the House of Lords, Plaid accepts that in the interim, Wales should have the strongest possible voice in any Chamber whose decisions affect the well-being of the people of Wales. We believe that this Chamber, while it has a legislative function over government portfolios relevant to Wales, should have a statutory number of seats from Wales, with Members democratically elected from within Wales to occupy those seats.
While we believe that Wales itself does not need a second Chamber—small countries such as New Zealand or Denmark do perfectly well with a unicameral system, as do almost half the countries in the world—we accept that the workload at Westminster indeed requires two Chambers of Parliament. However, we believe that they should both have democratic answerability. This Chamber should be directly elected on a regional system of proportional representation, and while any part of the governance of Wales is undertaken at Westminster, Wales should have a full voice in both Chambers. A reconstructed second Chamber could still be seen as a revising Chamber, albeit one with greater legitimacy, and the other place could still have primacy, or an appropriate system of resolving conflict between the two Chambers could be established, as happens in other bicameral Parliaments. That is where we stand, but we are totally prepared to participate here for as long as any public policy or legislation affecting Wales is decided here, and we would take a positive stance towards the reconstruction of the House of Lords into a democratic second Chamber and play a constructive role ourselves in that legislative process.
My noble friend Lady Smith of Llanfaes has emphasised, in moving the Second Reading of this Bill, that all she is doing is facilitating the Labour Government to fulfil their election commitment to replace the present Chamber with
“an alternative second chamber that is more representative of the regions and nations”.
If Prime Minister Burnham takes steps to fulfil that election pledge, we will engage positively with him and his Government in that process.
Today’s Bill tries to secure a more democratic system of government at Westminster. The Bill is modest, but potentially far-reaching in its consequences. As such, I congratulate my noble friend Lady Smith of Llanfaes on presenting it, I commend it to the House and I urge noble Lords to give it a Second Reading today.
The Bill fails to address the case for meaningful incremental reform on attendance, on the potential abuse of leave of absence, on the role of the Lords spiritual or on improving the role of this House in, for instance, confirmation hearings for senior civil servants and quango leaders, or the scrutiny and oversight of international agreements and treaties, analogous with foreign jurisdictions and Senates, such as the United States. These are all areas that could be enhanced without reducing the proper, predominant, constitutional role of the elected House of Commons.
The Bill is also silent on powers, composition, election method and our relationship with the other place. I have to say, I think it is virtue signalling in legislative form. We need only look back to 2012 and Nick Clegg’s proposals for a 15-year, one-off, non-negotiable term in a de facto Senate. That did not work; there was no consensus, which is why it fell, and of course the rest is history.
The public do not really care about this issue. There is no real, definitive, empirical evidence that this is a matter about which the public are significantly concerned. It would be a bunfight and a race to the bottom among the perennially angry activist class. An elected House or Senate of the regions will result in a House of compliant placemen from party lists, donors, careerists, cranks and the unemployable, with fewer appointments on meritorious achievement, skills, knowledge and lived experience.
The dirty secret is this: the Commons will never allow the Lords to impinge on its authority via a competing mandate, even if the Lords aspire to be elected. I speak as a sinner who is repenting—I look at the Bishops’ Bench as I say that—and as someone who had a pretty jaundiced view of the Lords as a Member of Parliament but now genuinely appreciates and understands its integral role of making the Commons better: a Commons that frequently fails by poorly and inadequately scrutinising drafted primary and secondary legislation. We need only think of the Northern Ireland Troubles Bill earlier this week: dozens of amendments were put forward but, because of the guillotine, they were not considered. The other place does not have the time to do that.
In this Parliament, the House of Lords has challenged the over-mighty and arrogant Executive where the Commons has had to acquiesce on, say, Chagos, the then Employment Rights Bill, the social media ban for under-16s, and the Financial Services and Markets Bill. There were—the Whips will probably wince at this—208 defeats in the 2024 to 2026 Session. The alternative is a House of apparatchiks with some kind of a mandate that will set it at permanent war with the Commons. That is a recipe for gridlock and a constitutional impasse. We would not invent the present Chamber as it now is, but it works to meet its constitutional obligations. The Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949, the Blairite settlement of 1999, the Life Peerages Act 1958—all have acted to establish the proper and well-understood conventions and constitutional proprieties.
One only has to look at the superb work that has been undertaken in the past two years on the terminally ill adults Bill. Whatever your view on that, the House of Lords came into its own as the finest example of a proper scrutiny and oversight Chamber in pointing out the very evident and egregious flaws in that Bill—and we know what happened thereafter.
The Puritan zealots abolished your Lordships’ House during the Cromwellian interregnum, but even they brought it back with Charles II: a legislature that was at the heart of the Glorious Revolution and the publication of the Bill of Rights, the abolition of the slave trade and, more recently, the blocking of 42-day detention for pre-charged terror suspects. Such a body should not be slowly killed off by a consultation portal peopled by angry misfits and anarchists in their parents’ bedroom. This Bill could have been a catalyst for an interesting and important national debate. Regrettably, it feels like a tick-box exercise hiding the blushes of an already over-powerful Government, and yet another of their broken manifesto promises.