My Lords, I open this debate with both a sense of history and a sense of urgency. For generations, across parties and across social classes, the desire to own one’s own home has been one of the most powerful and consistent aspirations in our national life. It has shaped communities, underpinned family stability and helped to create the social and economic resilience on which a civilised society depends. It is not a narrow economic goal, but a means for profound social good. Yet today, for too many people, especially the young and those on modest incomes, home ownership feels less like a realistic ambition and more like a distant dream. I want this afternoon to remind the House why this aspiration matters so deeply and to highlight how recent government policies, sometimes by design and sometimes by neglect, are undermining it. I hope to suggest how we might adopt a more hopeful and practical approach.
Home ownership is not simply about bricks and mortar; it is about roots, belonging, agency and responsibility. Families who own their own homes are more likely to invest in their neighbourhoods, voluntary groups and civic life. Children enjoy greater stability with deeper ties to schools, friendship networks and community support. People are better protected against economic shocks and the insecurity of short-term tenancies and sudden rent increases. We know from decades of experience that home ownership can be a ladder of opportunity, enabling families of modest means to build an asset over time, support retirement, help the next generation and weather life’s storms.
However, the wider context is deeply troubling. Home ownership in England now stands at 65%, broadly unchanged for over a decade but well below the peak of 71% in 2003. Affordability has deteriorated dramatically. The average home now costs 7.6 times average earnings, compared with around four times average earnings at the turn of the millennium. In London the ratio is over 10:1. For young people, the picture is even starker. The average deposit for a first-time buyer is now £78,000, with the median still an eye-watering £36,500. Deposits have grown to the point where they are worth more than a year’s salary for many. The average age of a first-time buyer has risen from 31 to 34, and the proportion of under-25s entering the market has collapsed from 25% in the 1990s to just 6% today. More than half of first-time buyers now need two incomes to purchase a home. Surveys show that while 75% of renters aspire to own, around 60% believe they will never be able to afford to do so. That is not aspiration; it is despair.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Eaton, on securing this debate because for a generation across Britain the dream of owning a home has felt entirely out of reach. It is not because they lack ambition but because they have been trapped in an adversarial stop-start system designed to benefit speculators rather than communities.
Having led housing organisations providing both social housing and homes for sale right here in London, I know first-hand the delicate balance needed to make a city liveable. I know that a healthy city needs mixed-tenure communities where social rent, private sale and affordable home ownership co-exist seamlessly. Our mission must be to structurally rewrite the rules of British housing to enable those families and others who want to transition out of renting permanently to do so.
To understand how this Government are addressing this, look at how buyers were locked out. First, there was the deposit wall. Lenders routinely pulled high loan-to-value options during economic dips, meaning a young couple could work hard and save diligently only to find the goalposts moved overnight under the previous Government. I welcome that this Government solved this by launching the Freedom to Buy scheme, transforming a temporary set-up into a permanent government-backed guarantee. By removing the risk for high-street banks, we changed lending behaviour. Lenders now confidently offer 95% mortgages through all market cycles, meaning that if you can afford the monthly payments, a 5% deposit is permanently enough to secure your foundation.
My Lords, I am delighted to speak in this debate, and I congratulate my noble friend on securing it and on setting a good tone of hope and practicality, as she said, where we can talk about the type of country that we want to be. There are three things I wish to raise. The first is a more general point. I am always struck by how many people in this country care passionately about all aspects of housing and growth. We should surely acknowledge that as a healthy sign. For those of us who want growth, we should, however, look at doing things differently, and articulate a clearer vision that faces the facts and comes up with solutions. In these debates—and you may hear it today—I sometimes get exasperated when hearing the terms “nimby” or “yimby” being thrown around. Too often, it belittles the debate and oversimplifies views.
Broadly speaking, people want development. Last year, polling from Public First showed that 55% of the population are in favour of development in their area and, for many who do have concerns, that does not translate automatically into a total rejection of new housing. We greenies should not instantly object to growth and development, because you can do both. Last year, I visited a development in Aylesbury where they are delivering some 2,500 homes, yet biodiversity has flourished simply by planning to put nature and development together from the outset.
While I am always delighted to see them, I am particularly glad to see my Chief Whip and leader on the Front Bench today. I never tire of thanking them for giving me the privilege of chairing the Built Environment Select Committee here in your Lordships’ House. Most recently, as the Minister knows all too well, we have been talking about new towns. This great endeavour has bedevilled many a Government, but the Minister knows better than many that, if done properly, they can create a lasting positive legacy.
Our committee’s second report on new towns focused on making sure we can create strong communities. Some will say that we just need to build homes, but what those homes look like matters—they need to become places and communities where people want to live and that they want to take care of. To be fair, I would say developers want to build homes that people love and that will stand the test of time. We did a recent report about how to get the views of younger people embedded in the whole process, from education through to employment and through consultations. If we begin to combine this with doing other things differently—such as better ways of engaging, and ensuring people see the uplift locally by making sure Section 106 and CIL payments are being delivered, and looking at why on earth major infrastructure projects like HS2 take so long and cost so much—then I think we can begin to make a difference and change the tone of the debate. Optimism or “cakeism” alone is not enough, and you cannot satisfy everyone. There must be some trade-off, and of course there are challenges. But it is our job as politicians to take them on, to fix the issues we face and own this agenda.
My Lords, in this short contribution, I will stress just one point. But first, I congratulate my noble friend Lady Eaton on procuring this debate. I take the opportunity to thank her for her copious contributions to the House and for the many years of service she has given to local government.
I grew up with my mother and brother in my grandmother’s house. Ours was not possible to live in due to bomb activity during the war, so when I married, you can imagine the thrill of my husband and me about owning our own home. Early in our marriage, many years ago, we had a painter and decorator named Mr Brown—who was always called “Mr Brown”. He was a rather testy figure, particularly where his young assistant was concerned. One day, he told me that no one in his family had ever owned their home, and he was nervous about doing so. I suggested he talk to my husband, a solicitor, after which he took the plunge. Ever after that, he repeatedly told me that my husband had given him the best advice he had ever had. He was a proud owner and certainly made his home his castle. It mattered to him, as he felt he had a stake in society.
Home ownership is always popular with the public. I remember the excitement when the right to buy was introduced, giving those who rented from local authorities the right to buy their council houses. It was remarkable how soon those houses looked different, as the owners cared for them and brightened them up. Some 65% of people now own their homes, but I hope we can find ways to increase that level of ownership. I hope the Government will realise the damage that has been done by their attitude to stamp duty. The value of properties today means that the deposits needed have increased dramatically, making the chance of owning your own home seem almost impossible. I believe it is a noble ambition to try to give future generations an opportunity to buy their own homes, and we have a responsibility to make it happen.
My Lords, before I start, I remind the House of my interests in this area, as a partner in Quoin Partners and as the chair of H4Life. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Eaton, for bringing this debate, because it has prompted me to really think about the philosophical question of why we truly value home ownership. I commend her and all those who have made contributions so far.
As a child of the Thatcher era, I suppose I grew up thinking that the gold standard for one’s housing was home ownership. Over the past 40 years, we have also seen housing become an increasingly prudent investment vehicle: the equity in your house is your wealth. I have been a beneficiary of this thinking, seeing my £72,000 first home, a one-bedroom flat in Bermondsey, as the financial foundation for my current, fortunately mortgage-free, home. Home ownership has historically provided both housing security and financial security for those fortunate enough to have been part of that generation buying their homes since the 1980s. However, of those two, it must be right that we focus our attention on housing security. Now it seems that the era of ever-upwards house price inflation is on pause, so we have to look at pensions, savings and investments to act as the financial growth vehicles which recently we tended to look to our homes to provide.
If the most vital importance of home ownership is housing security, how can we as a society best replicate that security outside of ownership? How can we ensure that people who do not own their own homes still feel invested in and part of their communities? I should add that one of the drivers of Mrs Thatcher’s policy of right to buy, which has been discussed today, was the belief that people would take greater pride in, and care of, their homes if they owned them. Initially, that seemed to be true. However, as a consequence of the right to buy, we have seen some instances of the fracturing of those communities, such as in my experience in Southwark, as some of the first-generation right to buyers moved on and their properties became buy-to-let housing. The point I am making is that home ownership has not always demonstrated itself as the only way to achieve housing security in settled and safe communities.
My Lords, I too thank my noble friend Lady Eaton for introducing this debate so ably. I declare my interest as a director of a company that has carried out a very small development—and as a home owner.
As we have heard, home is more than an investment or a place; it is one’s sanctuary. A home is more than bricks and mortar. It encompasses general surroundings, community and neighbourhood. Where we live has an effect on our mental well-being and health. As the old adage goes, an Englishman’s home is his castle. As we have heard, home ownership has been a long-held aspiration in this country, more so than for our colleagues on the continent, who have a tendency towards a rental culture. Much of the recent home ownership debate has centred on numbers of houses, but it is much more than this. Most of us value a home by what it looks like, where it is and other factors.
You so often hear how housebuilding has fallen behind in recent years, so I was really interested to read in the briefing notes that we were given by the House that housebuilding kept up with the population until 2021. While current ownership data suggests that home ownership here is at a fairly constant level, it has never been easy for first-time buyers to get on the ladder, and it has got progressively more difficult. House prices are rising, and the average ratio of prices to earnings of 7.63 is higher than the five times average affordability benchmark used by the ONS.
I think we all agree that we need to do more to help younger people get on to the housing ladder, and that means we need to build more houses. However, just applying a sticking plaster of mass building is not the answer. We should also address the causes. Some is due to the huge influx of people into this country. Also, for many years we have allowed people from all over the world to buy properties in central London, pushing prices beyond affordability for most British people—thus doughnutting our capital city of its settled population. Do the Government have figures on this? How will they enable more British people to buy in their own capital city? The effect of this is rippling out around the surrounding counties.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Eaton, on securing this debate. She set out very eloquently the benefits of home ownership, and I do not need to dwell on them again. We know what they are, and I am sure most of us agree with them: the stability it gives and the stake in society and in your local area that it provides—we all saw the socially transformative effects of the council house sales programme in the 1980s.
We can all agree on that. The problem is: how do you deliver home ownership in modern conditions? We need to achieve it. We need an effectively functioning housing market that is capable of providing housing where people want to live, at affordable prices. At the moment we simply do not have that in this country, and we have not had it for quite a long time.
Much government policy over the last 20, 40 or even 70 years—it depends where you start—has been going in the opposite direction. Obviously, this all began with the Town and Country Planning Act and the green-belt policy that first came in in the 1950s and has expanded since then. But a lot of the real damage was done in the 1990s and afterwards, with the huge rise in stamp duty that has persisted, and the constant green and environmental restrictions on what can be built, how it can be built, where you can build, the style in which you can build, and so on and so forth. To mitigate all this, successive Governments have engaged in price manipulation, such as the so-called affordable housing scheme—subsidised housing, really. Of course, we have had the latest wave of restrictions on tall buildings, specifically in London, that has brought housebuilding almost to zero. We have had the war on renters across successive Governments that has also destroyed rental stock.
This has taken us to a position in which we have a planning process where there are simply too many blockers in the process to get the job done. We have the absurd situation that the green belt now is actually bigger than the developed area of the country. It is quite an unusual belt that is bigger than the area it is trying to constrain, and it is certainly constraining the growth of our cities and towns pretty effectively. Prices are of course super high as a result of all this.
My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lady Eaton for giving us the opportunity to debate the issue of home ownership and the Government’s record on housing delivery. I will focus on one or two areas. One is about family housing, the other is about the current housing crisis and supply and demand, and a few practical solutions to the current malaise.
I will not rehearse the comments I made at Second Reading of the Social Housing Bill on 1 June. Suffice it to say that there is little evidence that the Government understand the need to support more home ownership for families and have failed to address, via regulatory policy or legislative changes, the economic and social impact of falling birth rates. What we saw in that Bill was a spiteful ideological assault on right to buy, which will be all but scrapped by raising the required tenancy length and eligibility and reducing the discount to 5%, which will lock 600,000 potential householders out of the scheme. A future Government will and should reverse this pernicious and incoherent policy.
There is no doubt that the Government’s housing record is lamentable. Nationally, housebuilding starts are at a 12-year low. There were 261,000 housing starts in the last 18 months, compared to the implied target in the Labour Party manifesto of 525,000. Bloomberg predicts a shortfall of between 90,000 and 100,000 starts each year between 2026 and 2029.
The situation under Mayor Khan in London is even worse—indeed, it is dire. In quarter 1 of 2026, 6,325 homes were started, just 7% of the mayor’s target. Some 22,000 homes are unsold or under construction. There is no way that the Government’s annual target, which is broadly supported on both sides, will be achieved to meet their 1.5 million homes aspiration. Are we surprised, given the Government’s mishandling of the economy? We have the highest energy costs in Europe, and there are labour shortages and increased inflationary pressures on materials. Higher national insurance contributions, a higher minimum wage, rising taxes, increased borrowing and mortgage rates have all contributed to and exacerbated what Savills has described as a “particularly gloomy” outlook for the housing sector.
20 of 43 shown
These pressures are compounded by the Government’s economic decisions. Youth unemployment has reached 16%—higher than during the pandemic—and rental reforms have reduced supply, driving rents upwards. High rents make saving for a deposit harder, trapping families who could afford a mortgage but cannot reach the starting line. Under the previous Conservative Government, 800,000 people bought their first home through Help to Buy and stamp duty relief, yet since Help to Buy ended major developers have reported a nearly 50% fall in first-time buyers. This is simply not sustainable or a fair model for a country that believes in social mobility.
The supply side tells a similar story. The Government pledged 1.5 million homes in this Parliament, yet in their first year they delivered just 208,600 net additional dwellings, a fall from the previous year and far short of what is required. On current trends, they will miss their target by 400,000 homes. Worse still, the new mandatory housing targets shift responsibility away from cities and on to our rural communities, cutting housing numbers in London, Birmingham and Coventry while imposing huge increases on rural authorities. This is not a serious plan for meeting demand. It is a political redistribution of targets.
Taxation policy is also central to this debate. Stamp duty has become a significant barrier to home ownership. Conservative Governments recognised its distorting effect and acted to limit the damage, including during the pandemic, but the current Government have cut first-time buyer stamp duty relief and now preside over a system that slows the market, penalises mobility and reduces affordability. The housing Select Committee concluded earlier this year:
“Stamp Duty Land Tax … puts barriers in front of people seeking to buy a new home … and … damages the economy”.
It is simply an unfair tax and yet another hurdle for individuals trying to get on the housing ladder.
Meanwhile, Labour’s Social Housing Bill downgrades right to buy, one of the most successful Conservative policies of the past half century that brought more than two million people into ownership and delivered measurable social benefits. Labour’s reforms raise the minimum tenancy period to 10 years, exclude new homes for 35 years and slash discounts. These changes do not expand opportunity, but restrict it.
For those who have managed to buy, the leasehold system remains fraught with unfair charges. Progress on reform has been slow and partial, leaving families trapped in unsaleable homes and undermining confidence in new-build flats.
Taken together, these trends paint a deeply discouraging picture. Home ownership is becoming simply a distant prospect for too many. If we are to honour the aspiration of home ownership, we need a coherent, long-term strategy, stable planning, fair taxation, well-designed support schemes and robust leasehold reform. Above all, we need a clear statement of principle that home ownership is a public good that we actively wish to promote.
When we debate home ownership, we debate the kind of country we wish to be: a country where a young couple with steady jobs can reasonably expect to buy a home or a country where they find themselves permanently locked out, paying ever-higher rents with little prospect of ownership. Government policies either support that aspiration or undermine it. Too often in recent years they have done the latter. We must renew a balanced housing system in which the aspiration to own is respected, supported and attainable. If we fail, we erode not just economic opportunity, but a key element of our national story: the belief that through work, saving and contribution, a secure home can be achieved.
But fixing finance does nothing if buyers are left competing for non-existent supply. For a decade, the “why” behind the lack of houses was local political paralysis. Councils routinely bowed to pressure and scrapped housebuilding targets, choking the market. We broke that logjam by immediately reinstating mandatory housing targets and aggressively streamlining the planning rulebook through the updated National Planning Policy Framework. By introducing brownfield passports and opening underused grey belt land, we have removed the bureaucratic vetoes to clear the path for 1.5 million new homes.
This Government are addressing the supply issue too. We have changed who gets new housing by establishing local priority windows. We have blocked overseas investors from buying up entire developments off-plan, ensuring that those new keys go to local families first. This is especially critical for our key workers—the nurses, teachers and first responders who keep our country running but are routinely priced out of communities they serve. For many of them, shared ownership was supposed to be the safety net but let us be honest about what has happened to it: high interest rates and volatile service charges have left many shared owners struggling.
In response to this, the Government have injected new protections through the social and affordable homes programme. We have tightened regulations around optional fees, enforcing greater transparency on costs and backing the new Shared Ownership Code to protect buyers from financial hardship. We are also reforming the model so that it serves as a sustainable staircase to 100% ownership, not a dead end.
Yet solving this crisis is not just about pouring new concrete or tweaking intermediate tenures; it is about better utilising all the homes that we already have. Right now, there are thousands of older citizens living alone in large multi-bedroom family houses who want to move closer to their children, grandchildren or wider family. They want a home that is easier to manage, but the heavy financial friction of moving stops them.
I urge the Minister to look at targeted initiatives that the Government can prepare to help older home owners to right-size. There is data—from the Radix Big Tent housing commission’s landmark ResizingRightsizing report—that indicates that nearly half of those over the age of 65 find the current stamp duty rates an active barrier to moving. This effectively locks up an estimated 870,000 underused homes across the UK. If we want to bring family-sized properties back into the active supply chain for the next generation, without laying a single brick, I ask the Minister to consider a tailored scheme that will help them to unlock a massive hidden housing supply.
Secondly, I was in Downing Street under Prime Minister Johnson; we accomplished some great things on supply-side reforms, and in my view we should have carried on. I confess that, while I still have reservations about the Planning Act and how it will work, I think that the new NPPF, as the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, was just mentioning, should be welcomed. To give confidence and clarity, it would still be good to hear more detail about where exactly these well-connected stations are.
If we look at the market right now, we have about 1.4 million homes sitting with approval yet waiting for work to commence. That is not to say we should reverse the policy to unlock land, but the debate should move on to the demand side. The Minister will perhaps say later that the Government will not set out the detail now, but I hope that, in the upcoming Autumn Statement, there will be a lot more on helping first-time buyers to get on to the housing ladder, which will hopefully kick-start the wider housing market beyond first-time buyers. If we look at what previous Governments have done, this area is a rare opportunity for government to step in and have a positive impact. What we did with Help to Buy, for example, when we were in government, had a net benefit to the Treasury, fired up the sector and helped get more than 300,000 first-time buyers over the line.
Finally, I will briefly comment on the capital. I briefly worked in City Hall, and sometimes when I speak in these debates it feels a bit like a reunion—particularly when I see my noble friend Lady O’Neill, a good friend, on the Front Bench and the noble Lord, Lord John, opposite. I worked in City Hall for a few years after the crash, and I came to make London my home. As a northerner who made it his home, I can say that Samuel Johnson remains right: if you are tired of London, you are tired of life—it does have everything. However, there are challenges, and they are stark. There is the tragedy of families and children in temporary accommodation, and there are issues relating to the cost of rent, lack of social housing and supply not meeting demand, which are driving those less able to afford the costs out of the city. A fascinating yet sobering recent report from the Centre for London sets out the scale of the problem, as well as measures to tackle the plethora of issues at play that are:
“Touching the lives of almost every Londoner”.
In that vein, given that this is not a single issue but one requiring a much broader response, do the Government recognise this complexity? Is work taking place to develop a different and more comprehensive package of solutions? This is a vital debate beyond simply building homes. It is not something that has gone awry overnight, but there is a huge opportunity here to not just increase home ownership but create jobs and growth, do things differently and get people more involved in society.
This Labour Government’s Renters’ Rights Act makes a very positive contribution towards the housing security I have been talking about, with the overdue end of no-fault evictions. I well remember a conversation with a facilities management worker at Southwark about 10 years ago, where he told me that the following week his daughter would be five and that for each of her five years she had lived in a different home. They had had the misfortune that, every year, their landlord would serve an eviction notice and relet the property at a much higher rent which he simply could not afford. He asked me what I could do to help. Sadly, it took the Renters’ Rights Act to provide that help a decade later.
I would not argue that home ownership is not a valuable source of housing security. With that in mind, it is perverse that we live in a world in which someone renting for many years and paying significantly more in rent than they would on a mortgage for the same property, and having demonstrated that ability and reliability to pay over a long period, remains shut out of the home ownership market because their income, even if multiplied by five, does not equate to the purchase price of the home they are living in. Why is that the case? In trying to cure the failures of the subprime market from 2008-09, we allowed a banking and lending system to be created which too often seems to work against the interests of the public and which bears a great deal of responsibility for public disaffection with the system or the establishment. The banks were seen to get away with their failures, and the people who were punished were the Great British public, who found it harder to get a loan and impossible to get a mortgage.
What more can be done to radically rethink the approach that the banks and lenders take to those who could meet a mortgage rather than a rental liability? Essentially, whether we see an increase or decrease in home ownership in coming years—I accept that the factors influencing that are many and varied—we need to ensure that housing security is the gold standard for everyone, not just those fortunate enough to be able to buy.
We are the custodians of this country, with its beautiful old towns and villages and an outstandingly lovely countryside. Yes, we need more housing, but it is important that we do not spoil what we have and that new housing is sensitively done in the small rural towns and villages where small numbers of extra houses are needed. We need beautiful housing built in a way that harmonises with the existing community. We need to encourage and facilitate local builders who will build a few houses and are invested in their neighbourhoods. We should make it easier for people to build just one house or two houses. The report Building Homes Better by the Housing Forum recently highlighted:
“Government policy has prioritised growth in housing delivery”
over quality, and documented “poor-quality workmanship” and falling customer satisfaction levels.
Housing should be a long-term asset. We should be building beautiful, not adding to what Roger Scruton called the uglification of the UK, driven by utilitarian modern architecture, corporate greed and a cultural rejection of traditional beauty. We are seeing this too often in the developments going up around the country—often big, unsightly developments inappropriately tacked on to and spoiling small villages. Have we yet implemented the statutory requirements in the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 for LPAs to prepare design codes? If not, why not?
In discussions about the Planning and Infrastructure Bill last year, it was identified that there were 1.2 million brownfield sites, around half a million planning permissions given and over 300,000 empty neglected houses that could be refurbished. We need to end the practice of development companies land banking planning permissions until prices rise. It is perfectly possible to meet the Government’s target of 1.5 million houses without encroaching on greenfield sites.
The planning Bill also introduced grey belt, citing examples of disused petrol stations and abandoned car parks as sites in the green belt that could be released for development. However, new research from the Campaign to Protect Rural England reveals that the Government’s grey-belt policy is paving the way for large-scale development on England’s unspoilt rural landscape. What are the Government going to do to stop the misuse of this policy and erosion of genuine green belt?
Before I close, I would like to raise an issue that I have spoken about before. Under human rights law, we are entitled to live without our property being interfered with. The party wall Act cuts across this. This can result in damage to adjoining houses and, in some rare cases, houses have collapsed. I declare that I have been a recipient of three party wall notices in the last four years. The noble Lord, Lord Dubs, tried to put forward a Private Member’s Bill in 2016 to address aspects of this. I have tabled some Written Questions about this, and the Government said they would engage with stakeholders and the public to gather insights and explore ways to improve its implementation. During the passage of the planning Bill last year, I tabled some amendments. I understood that the Minister said she would meet further to discuss this, so I hope she will not mind me asking whether we can meet, and not before too long.
To conclude, of course we need to help young people to be able to buy their own homes, but in doing so we must ensure that this is not at the detriment of present home owners and existing communities, and that we continue to preserve our countryside.
It is worth pausing for a moment to contrast the situation in this country with that of other European countries, which are of course our nearest comparators. It is true that the UK is a fairly small and dense country, and England even more so. However, there are European comparators, and the story is not particularly flattering. Belgium is a country I know well. It still has a lot of natural beauty of all kinds and is only slightly less dense in population than England is. Of course, the Netherlands is significantly more dense.
Here in England, we have 430 dwellings for every 1,000 in the population, in the Netherlands there are 490 and in Belgium there are 500. Our dwellings are also the smallest in Europe. If we want to give English people the same housing opportunities as those in Belgium and the Netherlands—and that is a reasonable aim—we will have to build 2.8 million houses just to catch up with just the Dutch, 3.6 million to catch up with the Belgians, and 4.5 million if we aim for the European average. That is simply to catch up, not to deal with any of the social changes or trends that are currently driving the problem.
We have to face up to this reality. Much of the current debate on this question—not just today but generally—is about trying to avoid this reality and the belief that we can somehow have more houses without changing any of these rules: the magical Tardis-like powers of the brownfield in cities that can supposedly accommodate everything we need. We have a policy that appears designed to maintain the economic geography of the 1950s and 1960s and never allow villages to merge or towns to grow. We have the belief that people can be made to live where the houses are, rather than the other way around, and we have an endless circular debate about social, council and affordable housing—we have one of the biggest sectors in Europe, of course—all of which is avoiding the problem.
The Government deserve a bit of credit for the planning Act and for the latest plan, but the solution is not driving the current system to work harder, and still less is it, as some have suggested, to allocate housing to favoured categories of workers. It is not about telling people they need to rightsize and that they are somehow occupying the wrong kind of house. It is about freeing up the system and trying to generate a real housing market with incentives to build, invest and grow, but we are simply not achieving that.
I fear we are heading to a social and economic crisis if we do not look this hard in the face and realise we have to do some things that many of us do not particularly like. We have to give opportunities to our young people to settle and to have houses, as we did. We need to get serious about this.
On the supply side, the Government’s planning reforms are, to be fair, a small step forward in the right direction, but no more than that. I welcome some aspects of the revised NPPF. Under the NPPF changes, faster infrastructure consent was brought into force in August. There was a redesignation of low-quality green belt and a focus on brownfield and transit land sites, but it is simply not enough to overcome the inherent viability squeeze on new building sites. Planning hold-ups, long decision times, biodiversity rules, nutrient and water neutrality conditions, infrastructure levies, tighter building standards and the forthcoming building safety levy—due later this year—all mean that land which is viable and buildable on paper cannot and will not be developed profitably. The Government should address that.
In addition, we have one of the highest levels of affordable housing targets in the western world. It is much higher than most of the developed world. That means that sites are land banked and lie idle and undeveloped. We need to look at this 40% to 50% figure again, because it is not delivering housing that we need.
The Government have also failed to look at demand. Only 27% of tenants in social rented accommodation are in work, so the Government intend to borrow £39 billion for their social and affordable homes programme to build more properties to warehouse welfare—a direct capital transfer from business, working people and pension funds to the workless, who will continue to receive benefits. This is economically insane and unsustainable. Immigration and welfare are integral to better housing policy. We must look again at prioritising working families and young people. It is a badge of shame that in 2021, over 100,000 social lettings in London were held by foreign-born tenants. It is indefensible and offends against fairness, efficient resource allocation and social equity, and it is a breach of the social contract. The figure is 12% across the whole of the UK.
In conclusion, a future Conservative Government—or, indeed, perhaps even a Reform Government—should cut taxes for SME builders, which suffered so grievously in the downturn in 2008-09. We must reduce regulations; establish a sovereign wealth fund to build new houses; give priority to families, married couples, veterans and young working people; restore right-to-buy eligibility post ante; and relaunch the coalition Government’s very successful new homes bonus policy. The present Government’s anaemic policy response will do nothing to tackle this grievous housing crisis and build enough homes. Much more radical change is needed.