My Lords, before we move on to the Second Reading of the Health Bill, I want to stress the importance of all noble Lords speaking to be here for the majority of the debate. Equally important is that noble Lords who speak must return at the end of the debate to hear the Front-Bench responses. The advisory speaking time is five minutes.
During this debate, the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell of Surbiton, will address the House using an AI-generated voice. This is a first in a British Parliament. As it is a first, I have advised the Whips that some leeway in the advisory time for the noble Baroness should be allowed as this is the first use of this technology. I am sure the House will agree with me.
My Lords, the NHS matters deeply to people across our country; it profoundly touches all our lives. Every one of us will have our own experience of the National Health Service and our appreciation of the care it provides, and we will all have hopes for its future. As the needs of patients are evolving, so must the National Health Service. Our job is twofold: first, getting the NHS treating patients on time again; and, secondly, reforming the health service so it is fit for the future. These ambitions run throughout the core of the Bill.
Modernisation does not mean change simply for its own sake, but making considered changes that drive real and tangible benefits to patients, who are at the heart of all we do. It means making better use of technology, empowering local leaders to meet patient needs, and taking a clear view of what needs to be done nationally so that more funding and resource reach the front line.
Before turning to the substance of the legislation, I will make a few points of gratitude and note: first, to all Peers who have engaged constructively with the development and scrutiny of the Bill, and who I know will continue to do so. I also want to appreciate the work of my ministerial colleague, the Minister of State for Health, Karin Smyth MP, who led the Bill through the other place, where there was considered debate of more than 400 amendments in Committee, Report and Third Reading. The Bill was approved at both Second and Third Reading without dividing, which is a sign of the broad consensus on its central aims.
On a number of issues, the Government have listened to concerns and amended the Bill. We remain committed to working with both noble Lords and the other place as the Bill continues its passage. I am confident that this House will take a characteristically constructive approach to its important role of scrutinising every line of the Bill. I thank all noble Lords who have already discussed the Bill with me and who attended the information session after First Reading; I look forward to further discussions in the days and weeks ahead.
My Lords, it is a pleasure for me to open our first discussion on this significant Bill, and I thank the Minister for introducing it in her customary clear way. I do not think she would disagree with me if I described the Bill as a landmark measure, proposing as it does a range of major changes to the way healthcare in England is organised, commissioned and delivered.
It is, therefore, I confess, a somewhat surreal feeling for me to lead off this debate for the Opposition, being the person responsible 14 years ago for steering through your Lordships’ House a number of the measures that this Bill now seeks to unwind. For a good many of us here, I suspect, the difficult parliamentary process that we had to go through in 2011-12 is seared on the memory—notwithstanding the fact that a large element of what we sought to achieve through the underlying policy, let us remind ourselves, commanded widespread support.
What were we seeking to achieve? There were two principal policy aims. One was to bring decision-making around the design of health services much closer to clinical leaders and, simultaneously, to redefine the role of Ministers as that of setting the broad strategic direction for the health service. Empowering clinicians and local managers was seen as a way of bringing to fulfilment the work of the noble Lord, Lord Darzi, when he was a Health Minister, which was to enable the system to commission for quality; in other words, to commission for patient outcomes whose quality could be measured by reference to defined national standards. That was the first policy aim.
My Lords, it is an absolute pleasure and privilege to follow the first two speakers and to directly follow the noble Earl, Lord Howe, a veteran of the 2012 Bill; and I am very much looking forward to no fewer than five maiden speeches.
As we have heard, the Bill introduces significant structural changes to the NHS —although some of them feel contradictory—and of course the development of a single patient record, but these must be viewed within the wider context of the state of health and care in this country. According to the Health Foundation, while we have seen some welcome improvements, the big picture is that health inequalities are widening—particularly the life expectancy of the richest and of the poorest—healthy life expectancy is falling, declining working-age health is costing the economy dear, and waiting times remain unacceptably high.
The big question for me is whether this Bill provides a legislative framework to enable the three “big shifts” set out in the 10-year plan, because there is a clear consensus that we need to move to a more preventive community-based health system. The obvious concern is that these structural reforms will simply serve as a distraction from much-needed improvements in patient care, service design, workforce planning and productivity gains. I will touch briefly on four key issues. Other very important issues, including structures, a single patient record and patient safety, will be covered by my noble friend.
The Bill transfers to the Secretary of State a duty to consider inequalities in access to health services and outcomes achieved. Although welcome, that is not nearly strong enough. The Bill should place a clear duty on the Secretary of State to act to reduce health inequalities, a call supported by many external organisations. This needs to be accompanied by co-ordinated action across government to tackle the wider social determinants of health, along with transparent reporting on progress. There is a golden opportunity in this Bill to put tackling health inequalities on a statutory footing, and I look forward to working with other noble Peers to get the Bill substantially strengthened.
My Lords, before I contribute to this debate, I would like to thank the Procedure Committee for allowing me to bring my AI-generated voice into the Chamber, and the technical department and the other members of the House of Lords staff who have made this possible. This is cutting-edge technology that will enable me to contribute to debates in my own, once-clear voice before it begins to deteriorate due to my disability. I hope that your Lordships will agree with me that this is an exciting development for the House of Lords, showcasing to the world inclusion in democracy at its best. With that, may I introduce noble Lords to Baroness Campbell mark 2?
I welcome the Bill and share much of its vision. The Government’s commitment to integrated, personalised care and support is long overdue. If implemented correctly, it could transform thousands of lives. However, I also feel compelled to deliver a warning against the potential re-emergence of an institutional medical model. For decades, the disabled people’s Independent Living Movement has fought clinical paternalism, which defines us by our medical condition. We are individuals with the right to control our lives, choosing what we do and who supports us.
NHS personal health budgets—PHBs—were designed to give individuals support to lead ordinary lives on their own terms, however complex their medical needs. The 2019 guidance promised greater choice and control and enhanced independent living. Direct payments enable people to employ personal assistants, or PAs, and to decide how and when they are supported, so I am nervous when I hear the Prime Minister speaking of healthcare and social care staff as one workforce. We must not replace personal control with a one-size-fits-all service. Notional personal health budgets in a national care service could squeeze out direct payments in favour of standardised care packages. Where a PHB is a direct payment, individuals have greater control over NHS funding, and it offers better value, with average savings of 12% to 16% compared with conventional services.
My Lords, it is an honour to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell of Surbiton. I note the historic nature of her excellent speech. I congratulate noble Lords who are making their maiden speeches and welcome the wisdom and experience that they will bring to your Lordships’ House.
I welcome this Bill’s ambition to improve care and make better use of resources. I want to highlight three interlinked issues: trust, health inequalities and the relationships on which good care depends.
First, trust matters between government and the workforce, between national and local institutions, and between communities and those providing care. Transferring NHS England’s responsibilities must bring clear accountability while sustaining local decision-making. Restructuring must support staff and protect their capacity to deliver care. The proposed abolition of Healthwatch sharpens these concerns. Independent local organisations give people somewhere trusted and accessible to speak, including where services have failed them. Their independence enables them to challenge decisions and bring forward experiences that might otherwise remain unheard. I therefore welcome the Government’s commitment to reconsider these provisions. Whatever arrangements emerge, independent scrutiny and established local relationships should be protected. Patient voice should influence decisions, particularly where people struggle to navigate the system. Trust takes time to build and can be quickly lost, as we have heard from other noble Lords.
Secondly, reform must narrow health inequalities. In the north-east, healthy life expectancy is around 57 years for both men and women, the lowest of any English region. Behind that figure are people whose working lives, family responsibilities and opportunities are constrained by illness, often alongside poverty and insecurity. In Newcastle and across Northumberland, access to care is shaped by transport, distance and available support. Greater patient choice means little if someone cannot afford the journey. Digital access and a single patient record offer opportunities, but those without connectivity, competence or someone to help must benefit too. Faith communities and voluntary organisations bring trusted relationships and local knowledge. They should be partners in shaping services.
My Lords, I am very grateful to the right reverend Prelate for supporting amendments around the rights of carers. We look forward to debating that in Committee.
Overall, I welcome the Bill. I see it as removing the last vestiges of the 2012 changes introduced by the noble Lord, Lord Lansley; it places Ministers at the heart of decision-making and improves patient outcomes through the single patient record.
I listened with great interest to the noble Earl, Lord Howe. We have been debating NHS structures for far too long. He looked back of course to the 2011 debates that we had on that Bill. In your Lordships’ House in October 2011, we had two days of Second Reading debate with over 100 speakers, such was the concern about the Bill. My noble friend Lady Thornton played a leading role in that. The noble Earl said that the upheaval then was a price worth paying, but I put to him that it was a hugely unpopular, hugely expensive and damaging restructuring. I looked at his Second Reading speech then, and he anticipated that to an extent. But he argued, in essence, and he said it today, that the aim of the proposals from the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, whom we will hear from very soon on this, was to make the service patient-centred and to give greater autonomy to clinicians. But that did not really end well, did it? Because the reality was anything but.
In essence, GPs were not prepared to take on the task of commissioning services; NHS England never established full independence; and Ministers refused to take responsibility for large aspects of the running of the service. What is so tragic, looking back, is that the coalition Government inherited the NHS in the best condition it had ever been. Waiting lists had been virtually eradicated with the 18-week wait for elective surgery and the four-hour wait in A&E; 100 new hospitals had been built or were in the process of being built; and there were new services such as NHS Direct, which was far better than the current service that we have, because qualified nurses were the people who took the calls.
My Lords, I am glad to have the opportunity to contribute, not least coming straight after the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath. Having listened to my noble friend Earl Howe on the Front Bench, noble Lords will be aware of how lucky I always was to have him on the health team and speaking on behalf of the team in this House. It means I do not have to revisit all those issues; I thought he explained perfectly well what the intentions of the 2012 Act were.
I will add just a single point: the 2012 Act was not implemented. Clinical leadership on the part of general practitioners was stifled, pretty much at birth, by the way in which the management systems in the NHS told them they could live with the deficits or they could have autonomy; they could not have both. And NHS England was not created by the 2012 Act; it was the accretion of subsequent responsibilities. What was created was the NHS Commissioning Board, and the focus on commissioning and clinical leadership is what we should continue to have at the forefront of our mind. If there was duplication with the department, it was largely because the department never let go. Ministers did not understand that they had to let go; they had to give the NHS autonomy, otherwise inevitably there would be confusion and duplication.
I read the Bill looking for the positive purpose, and all I find is abolition: abolition of NHS England, abolition of Healthwatch, abolition of the HSSIB, and abolition of foundation trusts. What I wanted to find in the Bill was positive purpose. I follow not least the noble Baronesses, Lady Tyler of Enfield and Lady Campbell of Surbiton, in saying there is much we can do now to deliver on a government manifesto commitment. None of these things in the Bill are manifesto commitments. What there is, is a commitment to a national care service. We should use this Bill and the debates around it to help to fashion that by, as the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell, said, strengthening the existing statutory provisions for personal budgets that combine health and social entitlements; by strengthening joint commissioning between ICBs and local authorities through devolution; by implementing the cap on care costs in the Care Act 2014, which has been in legislation for 12 years and no subsequent executive has seen fit to implement Parliament’s intentions.
20 of 164 shown
I am sure noble Lords would also want me to congratulate no fewer than five noble Lords—which I understand is a most unusual number, in a good way—on the occasion of their maiden speeches. I thank them for choosing this Bill in which to make their own introduction to this House. I look forward to hearing from them and I warmly welcome them to your Lordships’ House. As the Chief Whip said, we have a world-first today. I am most grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Campbell, for making this happen, and for making AI help her make her speech. I am grateful not just to the noble Baroness for choosing this Bill in which to do this, but to the parliamentary authorities for making this possible and ensuring that accessibility prevails in this House.
I turn first to what I believe is one of the most important reforms in the Bill: the single patient record. For many years, patients, carers, clinicians and campaigners have spoken to the shortcomings of fragmented information systems. Too often, information follows institutions rather than individuals; too often, patients and carers repeat the same story over and over again to different professionals; and all too often, healthcare staff make decisions without a complete picture of a patient’s needs. When records are incomplete or inaccessible, opportunities for mistakes increase and continuity of care can be compromised; at worst, these consequences can be deadly. A report on maternal deaths published in 2025 found that failures to share critical information between providers were a significant factor in nearly half of the cases examined; this could have been avoided.
The Bill establishes the legal foundations for the single patient record to create a single, secure and authoritative account of patient information. It will bring together health and social care records so that those providing care can access the information that they need, when they need it. It will empower patients to make informed decisions about their health, while supporting clinicians to provide safer, more joined-up care.
Public support, I am glad to say, is strong. Independent public deliberations show that 76% of participants supported the principle of a single patient record. The benefits are real, including every year: 20,000 fewer A&E attendances, 6,000 fewer hospital admissions, more than £20 million in medicines savings and the release of around half a million hours of doctors’ time. This surely is a prize worth having.
I am grateful to noble Lords who attended the single patient record round table. I recognise the concerns that were expressed about privacy, confidentiality and public trust, so I can assure your Lordships’ House that the single patient record will operate with strict safeguards, strong cybersecurity measures, clear controls over access, robust oversight arrangements and full compliance with existing legal protections. The Bill is about safer care, not weaker protections. It is about empowering patients; it is not about diminishing their rights.
I turn to the abolition of NHS England and the guiding principle of the democratic accountability of our health system. Since NHS England was established, the number of staff working across NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care has increased substantially. I have experienced the overlapping responsibilities and convoluted processes that slow up decision-making and divert attention away from patient care—something that I know none of us wants. This Bill will return the functions of NHS England to government and the wider NHS system where appropriate. In doing so, it will provide greater clarity for the system. It will restore democratic accountability and free up resources to be reinvested on the front line, where we want to see them. There will also be greater clarity about where responsibility lies, ensuring that Ministers are accountable for national decisions while devolving more power to local NHS organisations.
On that point, let me turn to the matter of devolution and local leadership. This Government believe that a more devolved NHS will be a more effective NHS. Those closest to patients are best placed to understand their needs. That is why the Bill devolves decision-making, empowers integrated care boards, strengthens strategic commissioning and provides greater flexibility for local leaders. Having said all that, I also recognise concerns around local representation and expertise. We listened carefully to those concerns during the passage of the Bill in the other place. As a result, the Government amended the Bill to restore the requirement that every ICB includes a local authority member, jointly nominated by relevant upper-tier local authorities. I believe that this amendment strengthens the Bill. It ensures that important expertise on social care and public health continues to inform decision-making and helps to lay the ground for future social care reform.
Looking ahead, integrated care boards will act increasingly as strategic commissioners of local health services, with responsibility for a broader range of services and resources, while holding that responsibility in their own right rather than as duties delegated to them by others. We want decisions to be made as close to communities as is feasible, with the ICBs providing strategic leadership while working closely with local authorities and other local partners. Neighbourhood health will be at the very heart of this approach.
I know that patient safety is a concern shared by noble Lords across the House. Before turning to that issue, I extend my congratulations to the noble Baroness, Lady Neuberger, on her appointment as chair of the Care Quality Commission. I look forward to working with her and I am sure we all wish her well.
No Government should ever pretend that things do not go wrong in the NHS. When they do, patients, families and the public must have confidence that lessons will be learned and acted upon. The independent review, led by Dr Penny Dash, identified a patient safety landscape that has become cluttered and confusing. The sheer number of recommendations to health bodies in this landscape—over 1,400 in the last 30 years—can make it very difficult for them to focus on doing the right thing. The Bill streamlines that landscape. It transfers the functions of the Health Services Safety Investigations Body to the Care Quality Commission, helping to create a clearer connection between learning from failures and improving care. At the same time, we will ensure that vital safe space protections remain in place.
The Government also recognise the importance of ensuring that the CQC is ready to take on these functions, and that is why we are taking a carefully managed approach to implementation and have been working closely with the CQC to monitor its operational readiness. This transfer will happen only when the CQC is ready. I want to assure your Lordships’ House how seriously we take consideration of patient safety. We will listen to noble Lords’ concerns and keep them updated on any and all progress in this important area.
The Dash review also spelled out how to simplify the arrangements for the patient voice. The Bill abolishes Healthwatch England and local Healthwatch, placing responsibility for listening and responding to patients and the public with the organisations that plan and commission services: ICBs and local authorities. Again, I recognise that noble Lords have raised concerns about these reforms, and I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Hunt for meeting me to discuss them. I look forward to continuing discussions with noble Lords as part of our review of these measures.
Let me take a moment to remind the House of the additional amendments that the Government have made during the passage of the Bill thus far. They relate to pharmacy regulations, visiting in health and care settings and reforms relating to medicines and medical devices. Together, these changes support patient well-being and access to high-quality care and innovation.
In bringing my remarks to a close, I wish to highlight one further commitment relating to a statutory maternity and neonatal commissioner. The Government accepted the recommendation of my noble friend Lady Amos, and I thank her and her team for all their hard work in delivering the national maternity and neonatal investigation. The Secretary of State has made it a priority to bring forward an amendment to establish a statutory maternity and neonatal commissioner to provide independent leadership, oversight and accountability for maternity and neonatal care in England. This is an important opportunity to strengthen accountability and champion the interests of women, babies and families throughout the system. I thank noble Lords for the questions and points they have raised about the role, and I look forward to working with them on this important development.
The Bill will not solve every challenge facing the NHS, but it will be a significant and necessary step towards a modern, accountable and patient-centred health service. It will help information to follow patients rather than institutions. It will reduce bureaucracy and strengthen accountability. It will give local leaders greater freedom to deliver for their communities, and it will place the patient voice closer to decision-making. I, for one, welcome all of that, and I beg to move.
The other main aim was to give public health a place at the table that it had not had for many years. With the creation of Public Health England as a discrete body within the National Health Service, Government Ministers were made directly and unambiguously responsible for population-based health policy and delivery. In the round, therefore, the intention was to make the system more responsive to people’s needs and, in so doing, to improve patient care and better protect the health of the nation. The upheaval arising from the reorganisation of NHS structures—I do not deny that it was an upheaval—was the price that we thought worth paying to achieve those desired ends.
My point in recalling all this is not to rehearse the Health and Social Care Act 2012; it is simply to point out that there was a purpose behind the Act that reflected an explicit intention and desire to benefit patients. The White Paper published by the Government in advance of that Bill was called Liberating the NHS,and the creation of NHS England as the national body accountable to Ministers for the delivery of NHS services was one of the principal measures designed to achieve that liberation.
The Bill before us proposes a step that is, I suggest, every bit as momentous, complex and time-consuming as the creation of NHS England: it is to take NHS England apart and abolish it. I do not doubt that Ministers are convinced of the need to take such a step, despite what will undoubtedly be a painful process for many committed and skilled men and women in the NHS who have lost or face losing their jobs. Let us not forget them and, equally, let us not forget NHS patients. The labyrinthine process of reabsorbing roles and responsibilities into the Department of Health and Social Care and parcelling out other roles and responsibilities to ICBs—bodies that are themselves undergoing restructuring—will, as sure as night follows day, eat up large slices of leadership capacity that would otherwise be devoted to service improvement.
That dilution of leadership bandwidth, with all the costs associated with it, is a big price. For that reason, I strongly suggest that we need to hear rather more from the Minister than we have hitherto about how she believes the abolition of NHS England will benefit those whom the NHS is there to serve—not how it will benefit the system, not how it will benefit the spending review, but how it will benefit patients, for that is surely the prime test against which the entire Bill should be judged.
As regards patients, the Government have repeatedly stated that their intention is to devolve greater responsibility to integrated care boards to allow decisions to be taken closer to the communities whose needs those boards are intended to understand. The Bill accordingly places a much greater proportion of commissioning responsibility directly with ICBs, including formal responsibility for primary care and other services which they currently commission under delegated arrangements.
However, at the same time, the Bill transfers to the Secretary of State extensive powers of oversight and direction. It creates a new general power to direct ICBs as to the exercise of their functions; it allows the Secretary of State to require ICBs to exercise health service functions on his or her behalf; and it transfers to the Secretary of State NHS England’s existing responsibilities for ICB resource allocation, financial directions, appointments and oversight.
The forces created by the Bill therefore pull in two opposing directions: one which devolves responsibility for commissioning and the other which centralises significant powers over the way that that responsibility is exercised. That is not merely a source of tension; it promises to be a source of confusion. If NHS England is to cease to exist, the arrangements that replace it, to be effective, must make authority and accountability completely clear.
That clarity matters on three levels. Those working within the health service need to know who is empowered to take a decision; patients and the public need to know who is responsible for what; and Parliament needs to know whom it should hold to account when services improve, and crucially, when they do not. We surely cannot have a situation in which, let us say, services at a local level deteriorate, and fingers of blame are then pointed in multiple directions. As a bare minimum, what we should be looking for with ministerial powers of direction is transparency in their use, what the reasons are for using them and what their financial and practical consequences are expected to be. More importantly, perhaps, we will need to examine at later stages whether the broad powers of direction granted to the Secretary of State should be circumscribed in order to ensure that NHS organisations enjoy sufficient autonomy, both to innovate and to be accountable for their own performance to the communities they serve.
What matters to those communities is the health service in their local area. As we speak, the NHS is undergoing upheaval and change. At a time when powers and roles are being shifted to the centre, and ICBs are being told to reorganise themselves on to different footprints, the risk of service disruption becomes that much greater. In a situation of this kind, it is surely all the more important that we have systems in place that can sound the alarm should any risks to service quality appear to be emerging. Yet, Clauses 70 and 71 of the Bill, together with Schedules 10 and 11, would abolish both Healthwatch England and all local Healthwatch arrangements—the very organisations that are there to meet that need.
I state here and now my grave concerns about this proposal. The value of Healthwatch is not simply the feedback it sends to commissioners and providers: it is a route independent of the wider system through which patients and service users can gain a voice. It is a way for them to highlight inequalities of access or of outcomes, and in doing so help to eliminate them. It is a means by which any worrying patterns of service provision can be identified in a timely fashion. The insights provided by Healthwatch are often very local and so not ones that necessarily become visible through published performance data. If we are to abolish these arrangements, we need to put something equally effective, equally accessible and equally trusted in their place. However, what this Bill proposes as a substitute for Healthwatch is not, in my view, likely to tick any of those boxes. My noble friend Lord Kamall will say more on this subject when he comes to speak later on. Healthwatch recommends itself as a model for patients and public involvement because it is trusted by the ordinary citizen. We risk squandering that trust at our peril.
It was put to me recently that trust is a commodity that arrives on a tortoise and leaves on the back of a racehorse. The same maxim can be applied to the proposals for HSSIB, the Health Services Safety Investigations Body, which, under the Bill, as the noble Baroness explained, is to be abolished as a separate organisation, its functions being transferred to the CQC. I have not yet heard a convincing argument in favour of that idea. The CQC is a regulator and inspector. HSSIB performs a deliberately different function. Its purpose is to investigate systemic patient safety failures in order to understand what went wrong, and for that reason it relies on people being willing to speak frankly about a serious safety event with a guarantee of anonymity. Whatever Chinese walls may be put in place within the CQC to keep the two functions separate, it is the way it looks. Once contributors fear or suspect that the information they supply is going to be fed through to a regulatory body, their confidence to speak up will evaporate.
Where does all this leave us? The Government’s case for abolishing NHS England rests in significant part on the proposition that doing so will remove duplication between NHS England and the department, reduce bureaucracy and release resources for frontline care. Ministers have said that the reforms are intended to save about £1 billion a year by the end of the Parliament. Against that, the Government now estimate that paid exits and redundancies across the department, NHS England, ICBs and commissioning support units will cost approximately £1 billion to £1.3 billion. On top of that, there is the cost of establishing the new commissioning arrangements. It would therefore be most helpful if the Minister could tell the House what assessment the Government have made of the net financial effect of the reorganisation. When does the department expect the cumulative savings generated by the new structure to exceed the costs of implementing it? What mechanisms will Parliament have to assess whether those savings have actually been realised?
There is a legitimate case for asking whether the present architecture of the NHS is too complex, whether responsibilities are sufficiently clear and whether resources currently devoted to bureaucracy could be used more effectively elsewhere. But any reform should make things better. Responsibilities should be clear. Accountability should be identifiable. Savings should be demonstrable, rather than assumed. Operational risks should be understood before functions are transferred, and reforms intended to simplify the system should not, in practice, create new ambiguity elsewhere. Above all, patients and the ordinary citizen should not be forgotten.
The NHS review of the noble Lord, Lord Darzi, which was commissioned by the Government in 2024, contained conclusions and recommendations which were warmly welcomed by Ministers. But the noble Lord ended up saying that
“a top-down reorganisation of NHS England and Integrated Care Boards is neither necessary nor desirable … Constant reorganisations are costly and distracting”.
Was the noble Lord right or was he wrong? I hope and trust that our further debates will come up with the answer.
On patient voice, in the debate on the King’s Speech I expressed my serious concerns about the proposal to abolish Healthwatch England and local Healthwatch. At Report in the other place, following strong concerns about removing trusted and independent channels for people to make their voices heard, the Government committed to review the Healthwatch provisions. I welcome this and very much hope that the Government will think again.
The Bill as drafted unhelpfully separates public voice functions concerning the NHS from those related to social care and public health. It does not put an equivalent independent national and local patient voice function on a statutory footing. I know that many noble Lords, like me, want the Government’s review to deliver a system which both preserves independence and has sufficient authority to secure action when concerns are raised. At the risk of stating the obvious, the most cost-effective route would be to stick with the current arrangements, particularly the trusted local relationships built up by local Healthwatch over 13 years. So I ask the Minister: what is the scope of and timescale for this review, and who will be consulted?
I now turn to unpaid carers. I pay tribute to the 4.7 million unpaid carers in England, whose contribution is vital to our health and care system. The value of the care they provide is estimated at £152 billion a year in England—roughly equivalent to the NHS budget—and unpaid carers outnumber NHS staff by around 3:1. Despite this, carers can too often feel invisible and unsupported by the NHS. This Bill provides an important opportunity to ensure that carers are recognised by the NHS and can rely on support such as respite breaks actually being available. So I intend to bring forward an amendment to introduce a new duty on ICBs to identify unpaid carers and to match what already happens within local authorities, along with an amendment to strengthen provision for breaks for unpaid carers.
I want to talk briefly about what I call the forgotten areas. Adult social care is largely absent from the Bill. That is a real missed opportunity for integration. The Prime Minister has brought forward the publication of the Casey commission’s final report to next summer and has committed to setting out plans for a national care service before the next general election, but I do not think that we can wait that long. Significant challenges remain in the short term. Pressure on providers, workforce shortages and unmet need continue to pose major challenges to both social care and the NHS, meaning that urgent action to stabilise the sector is vital while longer-term reforms are developed.
There are other things that I would like to have said on children’s and young people’s health and mental health services, but time prevents me doing so. In my view, those areas are very much overlooked in the Bill, so I intend to return to them in Committee. I would very much welcome further discussion with the Minister and her team on the issues that I have raised. I look forward to working with her, along with other noble Lords on all Benches.
Some ICBs are showing creeping rigidity over the use of PHBs. As I recently highlighted in the Guardian, individuals have been prevented using budgets to enable their PA/carer to support them when they are away from home. Lucinda Ritchie was forced into residential care from hospital against her will, rather than returning to her adapted bungalow and her experienced PA team. Only after we raised the alarm and involved the BBC did her ICB change its mind. This will not do.
In July, the Minister and I discussed my proposal for an inquiry into ICB practices to address these issues. Perhaps she could update me on this, and on whether the Government remain committed to PHBs for 1 million people by 2030 and for anyone who would benefit from them by 2035. Sadly, evidence from the Coalition for Personalised Care tells a different story. Since the restructure, hardly any ICBs have a named lead for PHB expansion. Without the dedicated NHS England team, PHBs have declined from 188,489 in 2023-24.
An NHS-funded PA/carer provides essential support for people with complex needs. I am here today contributing equally with your Lordships as a result of a PHB. I am fortunate. Denying portability effectively institutionalises a person at home. When systems dictate that people cannot travel or place rigid rules around support, they treat the home like a hospital ward, flying in the face of Article 19 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, ratified by the UK in 2009. I will therefore be scrutinising the Bill to ensure that integration and devolution to ICBs does not weaken PHB protections and freedoms. Choice must be safeguarded through stronger guidance, including a right to portability and flexibility. ICBs must not use residential care or budget withdrawal to coerce individuals.
Let us ensure that the medical model does not swallow decades of progress on disability rights and independent living. I am not a medical diagnosis but a wife, grandparent and working member of the House of Lords. ICBs would do well to reflect on that.
Thirdly, integration must strengthen the relationships that sustain care. Social care must be a full partner in neighbourhood services and shared records, with safeguards for privacy. Duties to commission palliative care must translate into dependable access, wherever people live.
John’s Campaign, with which I have had a long-standing connection, expresses the importance of relationships powerfully. Founded following the experience of John Gerrard, who had dementia, it champions people’s needs to have someone they trust alongside them whenever they receive care. For someone with dementia, a familiar person may help them communicate, eat, understand what is happening and feel safe. They may recognise pain or distress that would otherwise go unnoticed. Their presence is integral to safe and compassionate care. With that, I welcome the Bill’s provisions for promoting visiting and accompaniment. Essential personal support must, however, be distinguished from general visiting, and I will seek to support amendments that will be tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, who follows me, on recognising and protecting that distinction.
Children’s needs also need attention. I support ensuring that adopted children’s health records remain safely connected, with confidentiality protected, so that fragmented information does not compromise care. I note that children’s distinct needs receive too little explicit attention in this Bill.
Structural reform must strengthen human relationships, protect patient voice and improve access for those whose needs are greatest. These are the principles against which I will continue to consider the Bill as it proceeds.
In 2010, the British Social Attitude Survey showed public satisfaction with the NHS at an all-time high of 70%: by 2024 it had fallen to 20%. During the years following those changes, there has been a continuous stripping away of that blueprint, but the framework lingered and undoubtedly contributed to NHS performance deterioration. That is why I welcome direct ministerial control and the resulting enhanced accountability to Parliament.
My noble friend stressed devolved decision-making. I agree with that. What I would say to her is that it has to be balanced out by strengthening mechanisms of local accountability and scrutiny as well. That is why I very much welcome the review in relation to Healthwatch. My hope is that a strong, independent public voice at local level will be maintained. I also hope and urge my noble friend to re-look at the proposals to abolish councils of governors for foundation trusts. They play a really effective role. Local people get involved in the running of their hospital by electing governors. The governors hold the board to account. They are a vital safeguard, being the eyes and ears of local people in their local institutions. They can broaden the trust connection with local communities. Numerous visits to patient areas provide valuable feedback. The National Lead Governors’ Association has shown in its briefings to us that it can be a statutory, independent warning system, escalating front-line safety concerns to non-executive directors. So, I hope the Government will look again at these proposals.
My noble friend rightly pinpointed the single patient record as the most important aspect of this Bill. I agree with her. She will be asked questions about the confidentiality of patient information. She will have seen, I think, the recent HSJ and Sky News survey that showed most NHS trusts are ill prepared to protect patient information. She will have seen the prosecution of staff in some cases, and certainly disciplinary action against staff who have looked inappropriately at patient records. Clearly, that will be a matter for debate. Overall, I very much welcome this Bill and look forward to our debates in Committee.
I listened with interest and approval to what the Prime Minister said about the difficulty of people with severe dementia not accessing NHS Continuing Care in circumstances where somebody with cancer would. We can deal with that and I will bring forward an amendment that should, if it works, enable more people with severe dementia to access NHS Continuing Care. We can do positive things with this Bill and I hope we shall.
When it comes to abolishing NHS England, I just say to the Minister that she should be careful what she wishes for because every issue will land on the Minister’s desk. At the moment, Ministers are still wandering around saying they have cut the waiting list by half a million. Good grief, when I left the department, the waiting list was 2.64 million; it is now 7.37 million. The numbers have been going up, not going down, in the past three months. She says that patients should be treated on time. When I left, 162,000 patients were waiting more than 18 weeks; it is now two and a quarter million. There is a very long way to go. If she thinks running everything from the Department of Health is going to solve the problems, she might like to talk to her former colleagues in Cardiff, because running things from Cardiff did not sort the problems of the NHS in Wales. I think she might like to think again about whether this will solve her problems.
I do not need to repeat what my noble friend said from the Front Bench about the importance of the independence of the HSSIB in relation to its investigations and the patient voice through Healthwatch, and I hope this House will be robust in defending them. I hope that the single patient record will work. I am scarred from trying to manage the results of introducing new technology in the NHS, but I think this time we have to crack it. It is important to have the statutory provision and the implementation very firmly in our debates. Finally, I will just say this: my noble friend was right that commissioning and clinical leadership in the NHS are exactly where we should focus our efforts and make sure that we give clinical leaders in the NHS the autonomy to make that happen.