To ask His Majesty’s Government what independent safeguards they intend to put in place at the Havant Thicket Reservoir to ensure contaminants such as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, nano plastics and other emerging pollutants do not present an unacceptable risk.
My Lords, before the noble Baroness asks her Question, I remind the House that the first supplementary question should take no more than 45 seconds, remaining questions should each take no more than 30 seconds and responses should be of similar length.
My Lords, I do not think that the Chief Whip’s comments were personally meant.
Reservoir operations must comply with water framework directive objectives. Water companies are required to follow the drinking water safety planning approach and must assess risks to drinking water from the water source that it is taken from until it reaches consumers at the taps. The planned raw water sources to supply the Havant Thicket reservoir have been monitored and mitigations have been proposed where required, including for emerging substances.
I thank the Minister for her Answer, but I am deeply unsatisfied with it, because I assume that it is Southern Water itself that has monitored and checked the sewage effluent that is going to be put into Havant Thicket reservoir. We need a reservoir. We desperately need more water sources, but we cannot trust Southern Water to audit its own discharges. Can the Government do what is being done in countries such as Singapore and create an expert panel to audit exactly what is going into that water supply? The forever chemicals that I have referred to are highly poisonous and pernicious.
The noble Baroness mentioned Singapore. It is important to say that water recycling is used widely around the world, not just in Singapore but in Australia, the USA and in Belgium. Southern Water is one of the companies that are developing water recycling plants for the future. It is also important to say that the project is going to use highly treated recycled water that has been through a series of very strict treatment and quality checks before it would enter the Havant Thicket reservoir. Water stored in the reservoir would then go through further treatment and testing before being supplied as drinking water. I am happy for the noble Baroness to raise with me specific concerns around Southern Water after this Question.
Following Michael Sheen’s documentary showing that polychlorinated biphenyls are dumped at 14 sites across the UK, some of which are near Newport and Cardiff, what action are the Government taking to detect high levels of contamination both in drinking water and in farm produce?
The Environment Agency works closely with a range of UK and international bodies to understand the different sources, because it is important that we understand where PFAS are coming from so we can have a proper risk-based approach to assessing and managing risks. That work is helping to inform the design requirements for additional water treatment schemes such as the one that we are discussing. Defra has made a commitment to protect public health and the environment while supporting innovation and economic growth. This is part of how we are going to work together to manage PFAS contamination.
My Lords, not only should reservoirs be clean but they should ideally be full. Last week, on Friday, Yorkshire officially entered a drought status due to low water levels in reservoirs and rivers. I know the noble Baroness believes that there should be more reservoirs, particularly more smaller reservoirs, so what can she and her department do to remove the barriers to more smaller reservoirs being built?
The noble Baroness makes a really important point, and this year’s drought has demonstrated that we need better ways in which we can hold water, particularly on farm, so that we can manage resilience of food security. Defra is very cognisant of this. We are working hard with the farmers’ union, for example, around what we can do to increase food security. Obviously, holding water on farm is part of that.
My Lords, does the Minister accept that some of the underlying issues in this Oral Question are precisely why we need the long-promised clean water Bill, or whatever it is now going to be called, including urgent statutory protection for chalk streams? What immediate safeguards will apply before that legislation arrives? She expressed a lot of urgency about that previously. And when will the Bill be published?
I cannot give the noble Baroness a date for when the Bill is coming, but it is something that we are working on very hard at the moment, because it is important that we bring it forward. We know there is a lot of anticipation around it, but it is also a very important Bill. The noble Baroness mentioned chalk streams. Building reservoirs is an important part of how we protect chalk streams. We need to stop the amount of abstraction that is taking place. Reservoir building is important if we are to reduce the need to take water from very sensitive environments.
My Lords, is it not the case that farmers and golfers use a lot of water inefficiently? Do we not need to do more to encourage them to be more effective?
One of the really difficult questions around drought is who has access to water. Golf courses use an enormous amount of water, and there were some issues with some water companies and golf courses earlier this year. It is really an issue for the water companies and industry to sort among themselves, but, clearly, if there is a particular issue, government will step in.
Will the Minister accept that if our system for supporting agriculture was adjusted so that there was a proper biodiversity margin between agricultural land and rivers, we would significantly reduce the amount of effluent flowing from that land into rivers and improve river quality?
I totally agree with the noble Lord, because that is something I have done myself through a catchment-sensitive farming grant. You can get grants like that. We fenced off our river to stop the cattle going down to it, to stop that kind of pollution going in, and we planted alongside it to, again, stop that pollution. You can get catchment-sensitive grants to look at things like that, and it is important that we encourage people to apply for them.
My Lords, that is a sticking plaster for as long as we are mixing industrial waste into sewage waste so that the PFAS are still coming through into the water in the runoff from the fields. What would the Minister say to that?