My Lords, it is a huge privilege to open this debate. Food security is incredibly complex. Addressing it has also never been more pressing. We now face multiple global threats that could create profound food shocks—shocks that will fall unequally on our population. The question is how we can best prepare as a nation and make our food system more resilient.
Planning effective interventions on food security requires us to think systemically across silos—from farming and the environment to foreign and defence policy, international trade, public health, local government, planning regulations, business logistics, behavioural science and much more besides. I am certainly no expert in all these areas, but one thing I have learnt as a new Member is that breadth of expertise is something this House has in spades. I suggested this title for debate because this kind of urgent, vital and knotty challenge plays to the strengths of the House. I am grateful to noble Lords who have given their time and experience to participate, and I look forward to hearing what they have to say.
As the topic is huge, I want to focus my remarks on three areas: first, the threats to our food system and our national response; secondly, efforts to build resilience for the longer term; and thirdly, the need to involve the whole of society in the effort.
My Lords, I congratulate noble Baroness, Lady Teather, on securing this debate. I look forward to working with her and colleagues across your Lordships’ House on this vital issue. I declare an interest as the chairman of Cranswick plc, a large food processing and farming company.
The United Kingdom cannot have genuine food security without profitable domestic farming, resilient supply chains and a thriving food manufacturing sector. Our ambition must be clear: sustainable, affordable, healthy food produced in a system that is fair for all. Our retailers understand that good-quality UK produce matters to their customers, but consumer demand alone cannot secure our food supply. That requires productive capacity, investment, infrastructure and consistent government policy.
Food security is national security, and we should treat it accordingly. It is one of those issues we tend to notice only when something goes wrong. By then, the consequences are already felt in our farms, food businesses, supermarkets and, above all, household budgets. We cannot simply stop consuming food when supplies become scarce or prices rise, yet our food system is exposed to conflict, extreme weather, volatile energy, fertiliser costs, cyber attacks, trade disruptions and pressure on domestic production. The real test of food security, therefore, is not whether food is available when conditions are favourable; it is whether we can continue to produce, source, process and distribute it when they are not.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, on calling this timely and important debate and for her very comprehensive speech. The Prime Minister stated recently that national security must not come before social security, but the tone of this debate already indicates that, without food security, there can be no security at all. Indeed, the noble Lord, Lord Smith, set that out in his very knowledgeable contribution.
Our farmers produce 60% of our food. With government support, over the years they have worked to protect the sustainability of our land so that we can continue to have a reliable food supply in what is now, as we all know, an increasingly volatile geopolitical situation that threatens already fragile international supply chains. Global fuel shortages affect our food production, just as they do all industry. We have real and accelerating climate change deeply affecting—if anybody needs an example—this year’s harvest.
As has already been mentioned, in 2025 the National Preparedness Commission reported on the resilience of our food system. Professor Tim Lang, who has already been quoted, said that, while we continue to import food, our current food system is not sufficiently prepared to withstand inevitable future crises. If there is to be a defence readiness Bill, it must include a long-term plan for a strong and stable food supply system.
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, on organising this debate. That was a terrific speech. Many of the things I would like to say she has already said, as indeed have the noble Lord, Lord Smith, and the noble Baroness, Lady Shephard.
I agree with the point that the food system is not tested until things go wrong. To offer an anecdotal example, when the ghastly 7/7 attacks happened in London, there was no food because, rightly, the city was locked down. All the commuters who had arrived by train and by Tube were stuck inside London and there was not enough food. The only policy was apparently to ring the head of Marks & Spencer to ask for every single sandwich in the UK to be brought to London. Indeed, that is what happened and every sandwich was eaten and the following day everyone went home. That is an illustration that things can happen and we are not prepared.
The noble Baroness, Lady Teather, briefly mentioned freezers. I hope everyone here has been reading about the cyber attack on French refrigerators in supermarkets. I was trying to look it up this afternoon, but they still have not said quite how much real, proper food has been destroyed in this way. In a way, we should not even be having a debate about whether we need more food security; we should be having a debate only about how we achieve that.
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, for bringing this important debate before your Lordships’ House. It is an honour to follow that excellent speech by my friend, the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott. I declare my interest as president of the Rural Coalition.
It was from the noble Baroness, Lady Batters, when she was president of the National Farmers’ Union that I first heard food security discussed in terms that brought home its significance. Her clarity helped me understand that the ability to feed ourselves deserves sustained attention at the heart of His Majesty’s Government. Food security connects the farmer looking anxiously at the weather forecast with the parent looking anxiously at the supermarket receipt. Both need a food system they can depend on.
The threats are growing and interconnected, as noble Lords have already mentioned: extreme weather, conflict, volatile energy and fertiliser costs, animal disease and disruption to transport and distribution. Other noble Lords have referred to the NPC’s 2025 report. The National Audit Office report last month also found that the Government have done too little to prepare for potentially catastrophic disruptions to food supply. It highlighted the limited involvement of food businesses in national preparedness exercises. We cannot assume that, because food reached our shelves yesterday, it will necessarily do so tomorrow.
It is a great pleasure to follow the right reverend Prelate. I understand that this is her third speech of the day, so I congratulate her stickability.
I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, for bringing this incredibly important issue to the Floor of the House. We have heard that food security is national security and, as such, it should be treated as a permanent strategic priority rather than something which is focused on only when there is a crisis. There is no doubt, however, that recent geopolitical instability has demonstrated how quickly international disruption can feed through to the cost of producing food. Of course, agriculture is particularly exposed through energy and fuel security issues of supply and cost, and fertiliser’s availability and cost. From a Northern Ireland point of view, the carbon border adjustment mechanism—coming in at the start of next year—will have an impact on the availability and the cost of fertiliser. Again for Northern Ireland, transport and logistics can be an issue in and around the Windsor Framework, as well as all the international changes in relation to commodities.
The issue, therefore, is not simply whether food can be imported today. The Government really need to consider how resilient our supply chains would be during a sustained international crisis. We need to move away from responding to individual crises with short-term measures and towards long-term contingency planning for food.
As noble Lords would expect, I want to bring a Northern Ireland flavour to the debate. The Ulster Farmers Union has supplied me with some contemporary figures, and I wanted to bring them to the House. Fertiliser prices were at least 25.9% higher in June 2026 than a year earlier. Energy costs were 20% higher. At the same time, the agricultural output price index was 4.3% lower year on year. In Northern Ireland in 2025, expenditure on fertiliser and lime increased 32% to £133 million. That all matters in relation to food security.
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lady Teather on her excellent speech; it was completely comprehensive in going through all the areas that she said she would cover—areas on which we would all love to be experts.
One thing to say is that the UK is no stranger to food crises. When I was born—I will not say exactly when—we still had rationing from the Second World War. The rationing of sweets, chocolate and sugar ended in 1953, while the rationing of meat, poultry and, I think, fish products finally ended in 1954. I am pleased to say that I do not remember that time at all, though I was alive and it is within living memory of people in this country.
I was also present—much more so—at the point the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, mentioned: the explosion of just-in-time. During the 1980s, I operated under contract fleets for Sainsbury’s and other major contractors. I dealt with a company called Crazy Prices—a brilliant food retailer in Northern Ireland that has since been taken over by Tesco. At that time, the fast-moving consumer goods industry in groceries moved from around a few hundred lines to between 4,000 and 11,000 in a typical supermarket or superstore. As a nation, we were in a situation where we had an amazing variety of foods from across the globe and across the country that we could enjoy, and we made the most of it and took it totally for granted. Just-in-time, for which I take some responsibility, did exactly what the noble Baroness said: it took stocks completely out of the system, which was very profitable for those retailers. That system, with the help of further computerisation and automation, still exists. I may come back to that later.
My Lords, I wonder whether the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle—we have both done a stretch today—is as fed up as I am with Ministers saying that national security is food security, when at every step, whether by tax, regulation, ignorance or prejudice, obstacles are put in the way of those who put bread on our tables.
We have never imported more of our food than at present, either by weight or by value. Last week, the Food and Drink Federation told us that overall imports rose by 0.9% to £33.1 billion in the first half of the year, the highest since records began in 2000. That £33 billion is twice the entire farm gate gross domestic product of all the farmers in our nation. By a ratio of 2:1, we are importing more than we are producing. That is not healthy. In the hierarchy of needs, food in your belly ranks above a roof over your head. We have heard about public money for public goods: there is no public good more important than feeding the nation.
We have the most productive broadacre agriculture in the world, and some of the best dairy and livestock ground, all of which enhance our natural landscapes. Nowadays, one man can do 2,000 acres. It is astonishing. The old days when a 500-acre family farm could support three generations are well and truly over. I know this more than most because I have a first-class degree in agriculture; I am a director of a large farming business, and I have built a career in the fertiliser industry, which is the foundation of the entire food chain. Hugely complex, technical and market-driven upstream supply chains drive world-leading innovations in plant nutrition, seed production, and crop protection. Not only that but those firms—mostly privately owned—take the big financial and logistical risks so that, when spring comes and crops start growing, farmers have the critical input they need to ensure that their crops meet their full potential.
5:20 pm
20 of 34 shown
Multiple reports in recent years have warned that the UK is dangerously unprepared for potentially catastrophic shocks to our food system. Professor Tim Lang’s impressive report for the National Preparedness Commission last year paints a comprehensive picture of current vulnerabilities. The National Audit Office warned last month that the sector’s ability to withstand events has not been tested. Farmers tell us that climate change is already a reality, creating huge unpredictability. Crops this year have been affected by drought, flooding, excessive rain and extreme heat, which of course has sometimes made it too hot to harvest. While some yields have held up, we have seen the worst cereal harvest on record, and with a supercharged El Niño, it is only likely to get worse. The Joint Intelligence Committee has given stark warnings about the potential for the collapse of ecosystems within five years and the threat to national security and food supply.
In addition, there are new crises emerging. Attacks on international shipping in the Strait of Hormuz have sharply increased the cost of diesel and fertiliser for UK farmers, and threaten critical shortages in Africa and Asia, from which we import. Of course, Hormuz is not the only international choke point we should worry about. We have seen cyber attacks on supermarkets and distributors. This week, the director-general of MI5 warned about the risk of AI-enabled drone attacks on UK soil, a real concern when almost 95% of retail food moves through just 131 distribution centres.
In this new reality, it is naive to assume that private sector switching of supply chains alone will be enough to keep food flowing. It is certainly the case that supermarkets responded with impressive speed to maintain supplies during Covid, but Covid also exposed structural failings in our system, which we have not yet addressed. First, adequate food supply does not equate to all the people being fed. The Food Foundation estimates that one in eight households are already food insecure. I saw during Covid, while I was running a charity for people facing destitution, that global food shocks fall unequally and can have devastating health impacts. Secondly, none of the national food security assessments considers how the public might actually behave in a food shock scenario. The flipside of highly optimised, just-in-time logistics is that very small changes in consumer behaviour can quickly empty shelves. Thirdly, the same efficient logistics have all but eliminated the need for storage. We could have just a few days of food available in the face of a catastrophic interruption to supply.
We import around 40% of our food and more than 80% of our fruit. It is vital that we increase the proportion of food that we grow in the UK, but this is only part of the story. Food ingredients are often passed along lengthy, tortuous supply chains before they end up on the plate, with processing, manufacturing and distribution happening in different locations. Disruptions anywhere can cascade and amplify along the route. Given this context, our national assessment of risk looks dangerously complacent. The national risk register, for example, has very little on the food system and, where it does consider food, the focus is on risk of contamination rather than interruptions to supply or access.
So, what is needed? First, the Cabinet Office frankly needs to up its game and update the way in which we assess and think about food security in the light of the new threats. We need a special national risk register study that includes consideration of public reactions and dynamics. Secondly, the Government’s post-implementation review of the Civil Contingencies Act provides an opportunity to integrate food resilience and to think about the kinds of structures that we need at local and regional level to co-ordinate efforts. Local areas need plans to get food to the vulnerable and an understanding of community assets and networks that could help. We also need a more grown-up conversation with the public than a website telling people to stock up on tins. Thirdly, while there are legal duties to ensure that food is safe, there are no duties to ensure that everyone gets fed. It really is not clear who would hold responsibility for this in a crisis. Finally, we need a rapid assessment of what storage is available at national, regional and local levels and a plan to improve it. This is not an easy fix. Can the Government convene a cross-sector taskforce, for example, to wrestle with it? Other countries, everywhere from Switzerland to China, have national stores and many European nations are developing plans to store food.
A key theme from Professor Lang’s report for the National Preparedness Commission was the need to move our peacetime food system to a more distributed and diverse model, to boost domestic production and to enhance regional food systems. The UK is unusual in having an underdeveloped regional food system compared with, say, France or Italy.
Long-term sustainability in our food system depends on protecting the natural resources that farming depends on—soil health and biodiversity—and transitioning from reliance on globally imported fertiliser. Yesterday, the Government published a new Organic Action Plan for England, to boost the share of food farmed organically. My first reading of it suggests that there is much in it that is welcome, including backing organic farming to boost resilience to climate change. We have to support farmers to transition to new ways of farming. That means backing those willing to experiment with organic and regenerative farming models that focus on soil health and are not tied to inorganic fertilisers. We must fund rigorous scientific research into crop yields, soil, nature and profitability and share those lessons widely.
However, the new organic plan also leaves lots of questions. There has been exasperation from farmers at the chaos of the sustainable farming incentive scheme. Small growers told me that, even if the scheme had been well managed, it left them out by design. They are a critical component of a regional food system and often already farming in sustainable ways. For example, Vallis Veg in Somerset, an established small farm, told me that the economics of the food system currently relies on farmers in effect exploiting themselves. Its owners are deeply committed to agroecological farming but do not have the resources to certify as organic, which the organic action plan acknowledges is a problem. Vallis Veg’s commitment to the cause extends to supporting new entrants. It provides a small plot of land for free to a local grower to run a market garden, who is allowed to live on site for below-market rent, but even with all that generosity he struggles to make a living. According to a recent McCain Foods survey, one in four farmers made a loss or barely broke even in the past year, and two in five considered quitting farming altogether. We know that those financial pressures are particularly acute for small farmers. Those who make it work often rely on additional funding streams.
The inspirational Prospects Trust on the Cambridge-Suffolk border includes an accessible nature reserve, organic farm, shop and retail outlet and provides placements for people with learning disabilities or autism, funded through social care. It employs 51 local people part time and grows delicious fruit and veg. Over decades, it has built trusted relationships with a local organic wholesaler and a Cambridge college chef willing to cook veg that it cannot sell elsewhere, reducing food waste. It told me that relationships are key to its ability to adapt to shifting weather, because constant communication allows it to agree with the customer on what it can crop. It is a remarkable success story, but there was frustration that it could not access the agricultural water resilience grant to replace its leaky irrigation system because it could not quickly raise the 50% capital contribution needed. Can the Minister say what the Government will do to support small farms such as these?
Incidentally, Cambridge is an example of a city with a vibrant local food partnership, much enthusiasm and fertile arable land. But without capital investment in the missing middle of infrastructure on storage and distribution, it is difficult to turn ambition into a functioning regional food system. The founder of the fledgling Cambridge Food Hub has been trying to secure investment for that missing middle for 13 years. He illustrated the problem that he is seeking to fix by explaining that, even though one of the largest strawberry farmers in the country is based just outside the city, local businesses must buy their produce from New Covent Garden Market. That means that fruit grown six miles away must travel 120 miles—Cambridge to London and then back to Cambridge—in a refrigerated lorry. That is madness.
It is worth contrasting that with the success of the Welsh Veg in Schools initiative. With Welsh Government backing, Food Sense Wales to broker deals and local infrastructure donated by Castell Howell, local growers have been able to co-ordinate what they grow. More veg is being grown and local farms now supply over half of Wales’s councils.
The new organic action plan restates the Government’s ambitions to use public sector procurement to support domestic growing and it references Sustain’s Bridging the Gap programme, but it is short on detail about how the Government will invest in the so-called missing middle infrastructure to make regional food systems fly. Will the Minister tell me what plans her department has to make good on Labour’s 2024 manifesto pledge to boost local food procurement?
The final theme that I want to touch on is how we can ensure that our efforts on food security involve the whole of society. We have a long-standing problem with food inequality and it is getting worse. The Government announced small pots of funding for the Good Food Neighbourhoods programme to tackle fruit and veg deserts, but what is missing is a coherent national strategy with teeth that draws together public health, planning policy, housing strategies, local government, agricultural policy and public attitudes.
Now is the moment for a good food Bill—something that covers the full arc of the food system, allowing co-ordinated decision-making at national and local levels. It would allow us to set targets on childhood obesity, food security and domestic production and would provide certainty about the direction of travel for farmers, businesses, investors and consumers. It would also kick-start a consultation about what we mean when we talk about a healthy nutritious sustainable diet. What would a reference diet look like? What implications would it have for our agricultural strategy? What needs to shift in public attitudes if we are to consume more of the foods that we can grow here, such as beans and pulses? A consensus on these elements would guide policy-making priorities in peacetime, but it would also be critical in an emergency.
Joined-up policy-making would also give more creative projects a chance, such as peri-urban growing and land for community gardens and allotments. No one is arguing that community growing projects will fill the gap in domestic production, but what it can do is build solidarity, narrow the distance between farmers and urban populations, build knowledge and shape attitudes to what we eat and cook. In the end, in an emergency, it is only communities acting together that can provide civil resilience. Everything we do now to invest in conditions for deeper community bonds will reap dividends.
The need to address Britain’s food security cannot wait. I look forward to the Minister’s response and the debate. I beg to move.
Nor is a full supermarket shelf proof that a country is food secure. Food may be available but unaffordable. Imports may keep prices down in the short term while concealing an excessive dependence on overseas suppliers. We therefore need to consider four questions: do we have enough food? Can we maintain supplies when production of trade is disrupted? Can households afford what they need? Can people access the food that supports good health? They are not separate challenges. They are interconnected tests of whether our food system is genuinely resilient. Professor Lang, in his report, touches on most of those topics.
A resilient food system begins with a productive domestic agriculture sector. If farming is not profitable, it is not sustainable, and if it is not sustainable, our food security is at risk. Farmers need the returns that allow them to invest in equipment, livestock, technology, soil health and infrastructure. They need confidence that government policy will remain sufficiently stable for long-term investment to make sense. That trust matters. We cannot expect farmers to invest for the next generation if they cannot predict the conditions under which they will operate over the next few years.
Farms are strategic national assets, underpinning domestic production, traceability, food standards and our own capacity to respond to disruption. How well do we understand the productive infrastructure on which our food supply operates? Do we know where our crucial dairies, critical bakeries, protein processing facilities and cold stores are located? Where were the bananas that you ate today ripened? Do we understand the consequences if a major facility closes or an essential input becomes unavailable, and do we have credible contingency plans? Those questions are not considered optional in relation to energy or other critical infrastructure, so why should food be treated differently?
Domestic production alone cannot guarantee food security. International trade remains essential. The answer is to strengthen our own productive capacity while diversifying the overseas sources on which we depend. Imports can supplement domestic resilience, but they cannot be a substitute for it. A country may have productive farms but remain vulnerable if it lacks the processing capacity to turn its output into food on supermarket shelves. Food manufacturing and distribution is not a secondary consideration but an integral part of our national food infrastructure.
Yet we risk undermining that capacity through the very policies and constraints that prevent domestic businesses expanding. Consider chicken production. Demand has grown around 4.5% a year in the last three years but planning constraints have made it difficult to build the additional domestic capacity that is needed to satisfy that need. The result is that more of that demand is met by imports, including from Poland, the Netherlands, Brazil and Thailand. Those overseas imports have doubled since 2020, so we should ask why it has proved so difficult to secure investment in additional British production and resilience. There are investors who are ready to commit capital, there are plans, but there are other barriers preventing domestic capacity growing. There is a fundamental contradiction in making food security a policy priority while we obstruct the investment that is needed to deliver it.
We cannot secure tomorrow’s food supply by exhausting the natural resources on which that supply depends. Climate change presents direct risks to agricultural productivity. Healthy soils, reliable water, biodiversity and effective land management are not simply environmental aspirations; they are the foundations of long-term productive capacity. We should reject the false choice between food production and environmental protection—neither can be secured sustainably by disregarding the other. Nor can we ignore the trade-offs involved in land use. Decisions about food production, nature recovery, energy generation and development have consequences. Those consequences must be understood and assessed together. Farmers need a coherent, long-term framework that rewards environmental stewardship while allowing viable agricultural businesses to produce food and invest in their future. Otherwise, we risk weakening domestic production in pursuit of objectives that depend, in turn, on a resilient domestic economy.
One final important test, the one that matters most to families, is whether people can afford to eat well. Food security cannot be measured simply by national production figures, import volumes or the availability of calories. It must be measured also by whether households can afford a healthy diet. When food prices rise and household budgets come under pressure, the consequences extend well beyond the weekly shopping bill. They affect children’s development, health inequalities, productivity and long-term demands placed on the NHS. This is why food security must connect agricultural policy with public health, household incomes, food prices, public procurement and access to nutritious food. We must not create a false choice between affordable food and healthy food—or between improving nutrition and maintaining viable food businesses.
Defra and my noble friend the Minister cannot deliver food security alone. This agenda crosses departmental boundaries, involving health, business, trade, energy, transport, education and local government. It also requires a close partnership between government and the businesses that produce, process and distribute our food.
The country needs profitable farms, resilient food manufacturing, diversified international supply chains, a natural environment that sustains production and a food system capable of delivering affordable, healthy food to every household.
Food security should not be an aspiration that we rediscover every time a crisis exposes our weaknesses. It must be a permanent test of how we make policy. The true measure of our food security is not whether the system works when everything is going well but whether it continues to work when things go wrong.
There seems to be an idea—I would welcome enlightenment from the Minister later—that the Government have suggested that local authorities might be given the task of providing food stores, as part of a food security plan. I really hope either that I am mistaken or that whoever said it was not speaking with authority, because all of us would agree that local government, being in total flux at the moment due to reorganisation, could not be entrusted with something as complex as a new system of food storage. I remind the House, although it does not need reminding, that we know almost nothing about the structure, functions and, above all, imminence of local government reform right now. If local government is to be given this vital task, those who produce our food should know what form it is likely to take. I apologise to the Minister, who may not be able to answer this—she can; great stuff! This should not need saying but, before we discuss food storage, should we not try to ensure that those who actually produce the food are given as much support and certainty as possible, so that they can continue that food production?
We know that farmers, by definition—people have already mentioned this—are accustomed to working with uncertainty, such as climate conditions and world events that affect supplies and prices. They plan not just for the following year but for several seasons ahead. But they need to be able to invest confidently and for the long term in land improvement, irrigation, water storage and livestock. This is not at all what the present Government have delivered so far for this the very core of our national security—our land, environment and food supply. What the Government have delivered is a series of shocks and policy changes, some of them literally at the last minute, driving farmers from the land and thereby threatening not only our food security but our rural communities. There has been a heavy price from this ill-thought-out policy. Last year saw the closure of more than 6,000 agricultural, forestry and fishing businesses.
A recent survey by the CLA, which has already been mentioned, has revealed what we knew would happen: namely, that the Government’s introduction of the inheritance tax changes on farmers has had a devastating effect on their confidence to invest. The same survey found that almost nine in 10 farmers have paused investment in order to avoid triggering the tax. Many have cancelled the creation of income-earning projects, such as the provision of holiday homes, farm shops and cafés—all of this cutting jobs in rural communities. Others are having to delay vital machinery purchases, irrigation and drainage schemes, farm-building repairs, and renewing animal stocks, resulting in the attrition of farming and our rural areas. I am sorry to say that every aspect of the rural economy, which is the staple of our food security and of the protection of our environment, has been affected by what is perceived in rural communities to be a Government which farmers feel are hostile to them.
This is not the way to improve our national security. That any Government should talk about plans for national security while threatening the livelihoods of those responsible for its main component, food security, is almost beyond belief. These are harsh words, and I know that the Minister has much understanding of the problems that the Government seem to have inflicted on rural communities. I know also that there have been some helpful changes, many of which have been mentioned, but I hope the Minister will be able to persuade her ministerial colleagues that, if they are serious about our national security, they will have to accept that without food security and what that means, they cannot claim to be protecting our nation.
We are very dependent. Some 80% of fruit, 47% of vegetables and 18 of our top 20 suppliers come from areas that are vulnerable. Just this spring, Sicily, Spain and Morocco were flooded, affecting enormous quantities of imports. These are foods that we have become very lazy about, with the attitude: “If we cannot grow it, someone else can. We can always shop”. Amazon makes it worse with a sense that everything is available to us all the time. But the answer is that it is not. We have to find ways to be more resilient. I am not arguing against trade; I am just arguing for resilience and for a food system that takes food back into communities, back to farmers, and makes decent wages for them.
There are reports—these come again from Tim Lang, whom I think we will all quote, and with whom I have worked very closely over the last 20 years—that some parts of East Anglia have 15 or even just 10 harvests left because we have overworked the very precious stuff on which we all depend, and that is the soil. Actually, we have no food, if we do not have the soil—I think James Dyson has an answer about strawberries, but I do not know enough about that except to mention it.
I do not think that growing food hydroponically in factories is an answer, either. What I want to advocate for is that the whole of our farming system tips towards regenerative agriculture. Indeed, I have put in a pitch to have a special inquiry on how this could be achieved. While I very much welcome the Government’s support of organic, the thing about regen is that it is not quite as tough as organic and, frankly, many people can get it.
What does it mean to farm regeneratively? It means that you no longer go on completely digging the soil one-foot deep. One way of thinking about it is that, if you understand soil, you understand that it is a living community with millions of different interactions going on every second. It is truly magical. It is like being bombed every night. It is like the soil lives in the Blitz: you build your house and we smash it down. Somehow, it keeps on recovering, but only because of the addition of fertilisers, which are—thankfully, I sometimes think—currently stuck in the Strait of Hormuz.
One of the things I do is that I am involved with the Groundswell regenerative agriculture festival. When it took place in June this year, when the first impacts were being felt, a number of farmers came to say, “How can I transition my farm? How can I go from this very high level of inputs to a place where I can get the soil and get nature to do the job for me?” Which is, in effect, what we are saying. The answer is that they need help.
In that context, I would like to go back to when the Environment Act was going through under the previous Government and there was a big fight in this Chamber about what would be categorised as ELMS, the environmental land management scheme that was put in to replace the common agricultural policy, which, for all its ills and all the things it messed up, was basically a support for farmers for just owning the land. Now, if you get on to the ELMS, you get the SFI, which is soil, pests and biodiversity, you get the Countryside Stewardship scheme, and you get the Landscape Recovery scheme, which you can claim for. But if you just want to get money for growing food, the argument back then was, “You can’t do that because food makes money”. But citing Tim Lang again, the farmer gets roughly 8p in every £1 that you spend on food. It is no wonder that they are, as the noble Baroness, Lady Shephard, said, setting up weddings in their barns and renting out cottages. I have nothing against that, but we should pay for the food we have.
Food at its best goes back to communities, and one of the other things that is very bad about the subsidy systems is that you cannot support the small farms. Small farms, intensively grown, can produce both good salaries and a lot of food. I was at Jersey’s regenerative agriculture conference the other day, where I met the nut farmer of Glastonbury. He has only five acres and had enough family money to tide himself over for seven years. He is now supporting four workers and his family on a few acres of production. It is a great story and a replicable story as well.
I have chaired Feeding Britain and put together Capital Growth in this city. We have 200 acres of London that were nothing and now produce food. We produce something like 200,000 tonnes of food per year. That is probably an exaggeration, but it really works.
I want to see the Government revisit the way in which we subsidise and help people transition across from very traditional farming. I go back to Groundswell as an example. The farm is run by two brothers and it is a great story. It is like a parable. One brother does completely regen and the other brother still does traditional. You can walk from one farm to the other. Over this year, in the drought, the one who did regen farming still had water and crops and had spent no money on his input. His yield was not massive but, on the other hand, the spend on his balance sheet was almost zero. On the other side of the fence, there was drought and there were crops dying. With regenerative, you use animals and everything at your disposal and you do mob grazing, which honestly could be done by a robot, with cattle moving across the land, eating only the top inch of grass so you never wear it out completely. It is revolutionary, because at the same time you get insects, biodiversity and extraordinary food.
I have one minute left and anyone who knows me well knows that I constantly bang on about ultra-processed food. We must change the way we eat, localise it and put more abattoirs and local networks in. Someone was talking about how you get access to the City and the lunacy of having to come into Covent Garden. When I chaired the London Food Board, we tried hard to set up hubs mirroring what they do in New York, which has a fantastic centre at the top of New York City that takes produce from all over New York State and distributes it around the city. It is fantastic. It means that farmers get 40p in the pound rather than 8p in the pound.
We can do all this stuff with a bit of government thinking, changing the way that we use the money. The point is that everyone benefits. You benefit the kids, you benefit the people, you benefit health and, ultimately, you benefit the soil. The soil doing its stuff is the best carbon sink in the world; there is nothing to beat it for just absorbing carbon and keeping us on a net-zero track. So it seems to me that it is a win-win and the other way is a lose-lose.
I shall highlight three dimensions of our response. First, food security requires viable farming businesses. In many of the communities in my diocese across Northumberland, from the Cheviots to the arable land nearer the coast, farming sustains communities as well as producing food. Businesses make decisions about planting livestock, borrowing and succession over timescales much longer than a parliamentary term. When confidence weakens, investment is postponed. When businesses disappear, skills and productive capacity cannot simply be switched back on.
The farming profitability review by the noble Baroness, Lady Batters, published at the end of last year, offered recommendations on finance, planning, supply chains and infrastructure, and I welcome His Majesty’s Government’s response. The test will be whether the commitments enable farmers to plan, invest and earn a fair return. Public purchasing by schools, hospitals and other institutions should create realistic opportunities for smaller producers to supply nutritious food, strengthening local markets and connections between producers and consumers.
Newcastle University’s research helps us understand whose enterprise sustains these businesses. Professor Sally Shortall, professor of rural economy at Duke of Northumberland, together with Dr Hannah Budge and Dr Margaret Adesugba, has examined women’s contributions to farm diversification and sustainable agriculture. Their research for Defra shows how women’s businesses and income from employment beyond the farm can underpin farm viability. It also identifies barriers to training, business support and recognition. The policy implication is clear: support must reach everyone whose work sustains production. Advice, finance and networks should recognise women as farmers, entrepreneurs and decision-makers. Overlooking their contribution means overlooking part of our capacity to adapt.
Secondly, food security requires a healthy environment and dependable infrastructure. Healthy soils—as my noble friend has just pointed out—reliable water supplies, pollinators, and functioning ecosystems underpin food production. Supporting farmers to protect these resources is an investment in future harvests.
Newcastle University’s work on regenerative agriculture highlights opportunities to reduce reliance on external inputs and strengthen resilience, but change requires investment and advice suited to different farms. Policy must recognise the distinct circumstances, for example, of Northumberland’s upland livestock and lowland arable businesses.
Having lived and worked in New Zealand’s Waikato region, I bring another agricultural context to these questions. Circumstances differ, but the connections between farming, local livelihoods and community confidence are familiar. New Zealand also offers a warning. In 2023, Cyclone Gabrielle flooded farms and orchards, damaged roads and electricity supplies and isolated rural communities. A single event disrupted several parts of the food system simultaneously. For Northumberland, and my area, the lesson is practical. Resilience planning must include the roads, power supplies and communications connecting farms to processes and markets. A productive farm still needs a functioning route from field to fork. Imports offer diversity of supply, but they also connect us to environmental and geopolitical pressures elsewhere. They must sit alongside a resilient domestic farming sector.
Thirdly, we must care for those who feed us and those struggling to be fed. This year’s Oxford Farming Conference took “growing resilience” as its theme. Its chair, Jude McCann, also leads the Farming Community Network. Agriculture’s resilience depends on the resilience of its people. The network supports families and farmers through business difficulties and personal pressures. New Zealand’s rural support trusts likewise demonstrate the value of trusted local relationships when rural communities face diversity.
Further research by Professor Shortall and Dr Budge offers an important caution. Their study of farming during the pandemic found that its effects differed within farm families, with women experiencing increased domestic responsibilities and emotional burdens. Their conclusion was that crises affect the whole farm family and its members differently. Our response must therefore look beyond the person formally identified as the farmer. Caring responsibilities, well-being and access to support belong within our understanding of food resilience. Rural churches and community organisations can sustain supportive relationships; they need accessible public services alongside them.
Equally, national food security must reach the household. Food on a shelf offers little security to someone unable to afford it. In Newcastle and rural Northumberland, nutritious food is a matter of health, dignity and opportunity. Can the Minister explain how His Majesty’s Government will turn their farming commitments and the National Audit Office’s findings into a co-ordinated, tested programme of food resilience, involving producers and communities, with clear responsibilities and reporting to Parliament? Our daily bread depends on land, labour and relationships. We owe those who produce it and everyone who needs it a system capable of sustaining all three.
It is not merely about higher costs. Persistent pressure on margins affects a willingness to invest. The replacement of machinery and infrastructure is pushed back, as are decisions about future production. It affects productivity, succession and the next generation, and our capacity to deal with environmental requirements. Ultimately, it is also about the amount of food that we are capable of producing in the UK.
On succession planning, the noble Baroness, Lady Shephard, already mentioned the inheritance tax changes. It might interest the Minister to know that, in a recent survey carried out by the Ulster Farmers Union of its members, 88.6% of respondents indicated that the inheritance tax changes had increased family stress and worry. The economic health of primary agriculture is an early warning indicator on food security, and we need to acknowledge that.
The good news is that, notwithstanding the pressure on family farms, Northern Ireland should be regarded as strategically important in relation to food production for the UK. It has productive family farms and established livestock, dairy, poultry, egg, arable and horticultural sectors. It has an experienced agricultural workforce and, of course, a significant downstream food and drink industry. Maintaining that capacity is important, not only for us in Northern Ireland but for the wider UK food system. The Government should think strategically about agricultural productive capacity, rather than viewing agriculture purely through the lens of annual support budgets. The question should be not simply how we support agriculture but what agricultural capacity the UK believes it needs to remain resilient.
In that regard, have the Minister and the Government given any thought to a food production duty on our farmers, given the importance of food security to the nation? We have all sorts of duties on welfare, the environment and the health of our produce but, given the seriousness of food security, perhaps we should think about a food production duty. That would give farmers the certainty that they need.
We should view this not just as domestic production increasing versus lessening our imports; that is a false choice. Imports are, and will remain, an essential part of our food security. Equally, becoming overly dependent on imports from a small number of countries or vulnerable supply routes carries obvious risks. We need a resilient UK food system with a strong domestic production and diverse international trade. It is not an argument for isolation or complete self-sufficiency. Having said that, our ability to produce food domestically is a strategic national asset and one that we should absolutely celebrate.
As I think the noble Lord, Lord Smith, said, food security must start at the farm gate. Farmers cannot be expected to continually absorb increasing input costs, maintain high production standards, improve productivity, invest in new technology, improve environmental performance, respond to climate change and continue providing affordable food without receiving a sustainable return from the market. We need a fair, competitive and functioning supply chain with greater transparency; that is so important. Food security ultimately begins with the primary producer. If farmers cannot make an adequate return then they cannot invest, maintain production or respond to the shocks we have seen over the past months. I would like to see food security embedded in government decision-making as a long-term strategic objective.
My last point is that food security and environmental policy must work together. We must avoid portraying food production and the environment as competing objectives. Northern Ireland farmers are already doing significant work around soil health, which has been mentioned, as well as genetics, carbon footprinting, nutrient efficiency, biodiversity and environmental management. The objective should be sustainable production, rather than simply less production. There is little food security benefit in reducing UK production if consumption remains unchanged and production is simply displaced overseas. My message to the Minister is that environmental resilience and food security should be designed together and not pursued in separate policy silos.
I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response, in particular on the idea of a duty on food production, which could change the dynamics around our food security.
There are so many things that I could talk about, and my noble friend has mentioned a number of them: the challenges of nature-friendly farming, biodiversity, pollinators and invasive species—which we have not talked about, but which is key. But I want to talk about the other 70% of the planet: our oceans and seas, which I do not think have been mentioned today. They provide something like only 6% of total global protein, but in many countries it is far higher, up to 50%. In the UK, it is higher as well, with our tradition of fish and chips, although we export 80% of our fish and import 80% of what we consume.
Two reports have come out this week on the state of our oceans and fishing stocks globally and nationally. In the UK, the MSC seafood report has highlighted that 29 categories of fish have gone from green or amber to red, or from green to amber. That is clearly not good. There is some good news for North Sea herring and bluefin tuna, which I have been privileged to see from Land’s End, down in Cornwall, near where I live—a fantastic spectacle if Members have the opportunity to see them. There is a little positivity but, despite all our management, our fish stocks are not in a good position. Internationally, in comparison with 1970, global fish stocks are down something like 59%. That is a truly worrying figure for the future of biodiversity in our oceans and, particularly, the artisanal fisheries in the developing world that rely on those fish stocks.
Will the Minister say whether, nationally, we are pursuing hard enough the illegal, unregistered and unreported fisheries? Are we doing enough? I feel that we still are not. It is a difficult issue, but one that we need to address. Are we pushing the International Maritime Organization on those fishing vessels and huge trawlers that go across the high seas, unflagged or flagged with nations of convenience that take no control over their actions? Are we doing something on that? Something I know the Minister feels strongly about and has worked on with us all in this House is the treaty on biodiversity beyond natural jurisdictions. Now that the UK has ratified the treaty, it gives us the opportunity to get together with other like-minded nations to have some influence and control over piracy on the high seas outside EEZs. I would be interested to hear from the Minister what we are doing on that. Are we pushing that important agenda forward? That is national and international, but I want to come back to the national aspect.
One important area of understanding scientifically what is happening in our seas is equipping our fishing vessels with remote electronic monitoring. The Government have said that they want to do this, and I am absolutely sure that they do, but, at the moment, I think we have only one vessel that has remote electronic monitoring and can analyse exactly what has been caught and give such depth of scientific information. Scotland has moved ahead on this: its pelagic fleet has to be equipped in that way. When will we do that in England? Because of our agreement with the EU, if we do that in English waters, it means that foreign vessels in our waters will also need to have similar technical equipment and do exactly the same. This would not only solve the issue for British waters but would, I hope, have a contagious effect on European fisheries. Those are the areas that I would like to see accelerated, as they are so important in saving our oceans and seas.
Finally, we talk about food imports, but we do not often talk about food exports. We export some 14% of our agricultural production, mainly fish, meat and drink—which I will come back to later. I would be interested to hear the Government’s view of how that affects strategy. How should we look at that? I am not suggesting a Trump-style diesel export ban, but perhaps there are some possibilities there that would make us more secure.
I mentioned at the beginning of my speech that we had rationing. That was state imposed. These days, we have family-imposed rationing. We have at least 2,800 food stations in this country, and the Trussell Trust alone put out some 2.5 million parcels of food last year. We need to change that. We have moved from state rationing to family rationing, and that cannot be right in our advanced society.
The problem is that our yeoman farmers have the Government on their backs. The National Audit Office has in recent weeks called on the Government to make our food system more resilient, but they have stopped investment in our farming future stone dead with the family farm tax. However, not only do they attack those farms, handed down in trust over generations, but they harm that wider economic private ecosystem that supports them. Somebody mentioned Warburtons earlier—a private business; all are under threat, alongside machinery dealers who are on their knees and a network of fencers, ditchers, drain workers and groundworkers who now have no incentive whatever to invest in their or our future.
By some delusion, the Chief Secretary breezily tells them not to worry about inheritance tax—dear oh dear. The Government’s stand is incomprehensible because their land use framework—which is a shoddy piece of work that would shame a sixth-form geography project with its suggestion that Norfolk, breadbasket of our nation, should be forested— requires a 20% improvement in agricultural productivity by 2050. I ask the Minister: where does she think this 20% productivity gain is going to come from when yield improvements have flatlined over a decade, when new investment has been made irrational or where our best land is carpeted with solar panels?
I was grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Smith, for an important and telling contribution when, for the first time to my knowledge in this House, he raised the risks that are faced in the cold store business. Cold store and cool chain are extraordinarily vulnerable pieces of national infrastructure that ensure food arrives in our stores safely and nutritiously. I am grateful to him for raising that threat to our food security.
We heard last week that there is one civil servant for every five farmers. What have these people been doing? They have been designing an SFI system, which launched mid-morning during the best drilling conditions of the year; it was exhausted after five and a half hours and resulted in only 50 upland farmers in the most fragile environments—of which the Minister knows best—being accepted. Three-quarters of eligible farmers missed out because they did not employ armies of land agents and have now been forced to rip up the environmental improvements, lovingly cherished for years, and instead go hell for leather on intensification. That is a failure.
It is this Government who have driven the wedge between economic security and environmental benefits. They have forced farmers to plough up as much land as they can. No wonder they have all gone to the pub for a pint of warm beer; their black Labrador has a better idea of what is going on than the Government we pay to sort this out. It is a battle of survival now, while real ale dulls the drone of the sanctimonious Defra press releases pretending SFI was a success while treating the callus-handed farmers with contempt. I am sorry for the farmers who thought they could put 75% of their farms into regenerative approaches, which is only really fit for rooks and crows. They were suckered.
Those who remain wonder how they are going to get cash flow from the crops they are meant to be putting into the ground after three bad harvests. First, it was too wet, then too cold, and lately too hot. Could the economic security of these farms get any worse? Well, yes. Say what you like about Brexit, but we now have effective blackgrass control for the winter wheat that millers and bakers use to bake our bread. I attempt to pronounce the product name, but it is a miracle which could be traded away in a late-night session on 20 November alongside that other miracle, precision breeding.
I have met the people using CRISPR technology to breed more nutritious tomatoes, longer-life strawberries that halve food waste, and faster-flowering, healthier purple broccoli, and the Norfolk company protecting the Cavendish banana in Africa and Latin America from disastrous fungal attack without the need for chemicals. All this is at risk from an SPS deal that asks for alignment rather than mutual recognition. The EU has seen us coming.
It is not just the EU; the US has done a CO deal which rewards French farmers with a £1 million subsidy per day over our own. It was needed only because the former Prime Minister recklessly decimated our clean biofuels industry when he negligently surrendered 1.4 billion litres of tariffed product—which just happened to be the market—in another one of those late-night phone calls with the US President.
This week, the other place rubber-stamped new taxes on fertilisers, the thing that drives productivity the greatest, which will be added to a farmer’s most expensive input. That will do nothing to reduce carbon emissions, because this Government’s energy policies make domestic production impossible. All it will do is incentivise the importation, at huge cost, of the most polluting fertilisers and drive up the cost of food in an inflationary spiral that affects the poorest the worst.
We have a Minister who faints at the sight of blood while a former Agriculture Minister says the Government do not understand these issues. We know this because Defra has entered into a contract to send its civil servants to see what farms look like. It is unbelievable.
I want to be helpful to the Minister. This litany of failure is bad politics for the Labour Party. It has a majority in the other place of some 160, but 80 of those MPs are in rural or semi-rural seats. They are the Government’s majority.
The Government say they want to reset relations with the countryside. On all these issues, they are going to have to square away the farmers and those who form part of that wider £160 billion GVA in the food, drink and agriculture industry, or they will be done. Labour have estranged themselves from the countryside, and now they need to make an existential choice between putting food on Britain’s table or pursuing a class war fantasy grounded in a world they say never existed. Dogs, warm beer and roaring fires do exist. The only delusion is a hard-left fantasy, blind to the reality that a nation that cannot feed itself in a dangerous world is no nation at all.
For the Prime Minister and Chancellor, it is “make your mind up” time: stop the war on the countryside, the farmers and family businesses or face the music. It is as simple as that. The choice is theirs.