My Lords, one word hovers like a spectre over this debate on the fiscal outlook: debt. Two years ago to this very day, your Lordships’ Economic Affairs Committee, which I then chaired, published a report on our national debt, It’s Time for Tough Decisions. It concluded that the UK’s national debt risks becoming unsustainable unless tough decisions are taken in this Parliament to address the major challenges that the UK faces and put debt on a gradual downward path. We found that sustainability depended not just on the level of debt but on having sufficient fiscal buffers to absorb future shocks and on avoiding a trajectory of rising debt service costs.
Two years on, our debt stands at nearly £3 trillion, over 94% of GDP, almost £96 billion higher than a year ago and, relative to the size of our economy, at levels last seen in the early 1960s. My argument today is that our debt remains on an unsustainable path. Our fiscal buffer is dangerously small. The risks facing our public finances have grown and are growing still. All this is thanks in very large part to the actions that this Government have taken.
Some may point to the fact that the debt accumulated during the last Administration, which is correct. I have argued that the last Government made mistakes, but however critical one is of that Government, one must accept that they faced Covid and the energy shock. Others may argue that Britain has carried far higher debts before—notably after the Second World War. That too is correct. However, after 1945, the baby boom, the peace dividend and the opening of world trade all boosted growth, which helped to lower our debts.
Today, Governments here and worldwide face the challenges of the Ds: higher defence spending, the demographic challenge of ageing populations, dependency—large welfare states—and decarbonisation, with the green transition. All these Ds increase demands for higher government spending at a time when Governments are already drowning in debt.
My Lords, it is a privilege to follow the noble Lord, Lord Bridges of Headley, and I congratulate him on securing the debate. The challenges facing this country and many others globally because of the current fiscal outlook have been a consistent focus for him, both during his distinguished stint as Chair of the Economic Affairs Committee and since. I welcome my noble friend Lord Pitt-Watson to the Front Bench, as this is the first time I have spoken in a debate to which he will be responding. I should declare interests, as in the register, as a trustee of LAMDA, an adviser to the family office WFO and a director of Digbeth Loc. Studios.
The survey of the fiscal outlook by the noble Lord, Lord Bridges, could be described, perhaps by Sir Humphrey Appleby, as very grounded, verging on the bleak. There is no denying that globally the challenges are formidable, with economies in a more vulnerable position to future new shocks, by some measures, than before the global financial crisis of 2008. As the noble Lord described, the UK is, unfortunately, not a positive outlier relative to the global picture and in too many respects is at the wrong end of the spectrum.
Before I make my observations on these challenges and some of the responses to them, I begin on a positive note by welcoming the encouraging trend in productivity growth that has emerged in recent weeks. Output per job increased by 1.4% in the 12 months to 30 June and has been consistently above average since late 2024. It is premature to call victory or attribute the improvement to the effects of AI, but productivity is so central to the turnaround of the economy and the balancing of the fiscal books that there seem to be grounds for cautious, tentative optimism. It perhaps supports the argument that my noble friend Lord Eatwell made after the Government’s first Budget: that the increase in employers’ national insurance would drive productivity growth more than hit employment.
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Bridges, has outlined the challenges facing fiscal policy very well. I was a member of the Economic Affairs Committee that he chaired so ably, and he has summarised the conclusions of the report of that committee two years ago. Since then, the OBR too has set out the significant risk that UK debt could become unsustainable unless offsetting action is taken. While the previous Chancellor was successful in stabilising the debt ratio, we now need to make significant progress in reducing it, not just in the forecast but in practice. The need for early action is not removed because the debt ratio of other countries is similar or even worse than that of the UK. Having a shared problem might make it feel less urgent, but the UK debt ratio can be brought on to a sustainable downward path only by our own actions.
The noble Lord also set out the initial source of the problem very clearly. Since 2007 we have engaged in three rounds of exceptional expenditure in response to events. There were good reasons in each case why that was undertaken, even if in some cases it was overdone. In one case, the financial crisis, we were trying to protect savings and maintain a functioning financial system; the Covid crisis required support for people who were suffering in lockdown; and there was a sharp rise in energy prices after the invasion of Ukraine. So some of that was right in principle, but I cannot recall any Government giving much warning that these rounds of fiscal support would eventually have to be paid for, even if not immediately. Nor did Governments warn that the longer the delay, the greater the cost in terms of higher debt interest. Taxes were cut when the opportunities arose, and expenditure control proved to be too difficult politically.
While there is general support for changing the fiscal rules to accommodate public sector investment, less has been said about the debt service costs involved in that, at a time of rising and very high global interest rates. Taking out a mortgage means starting your monthly payments immediately. The same applies to government borrowing and we are, of course, experiencing that.
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to speak after the noble Lord, Lord Burns, who brings so much experience and authority to his comments. They were extremely balanced and will be well received by all sides of the House.
My noble friend Lord Bridges set out his case with his customary clarity. The figures he gave speak for themselves. The rest of the world is now catching up with the warnings two years ago of our own Economic Affairs Committee. Not a day goes past at the moment without more evidence of the stresses and strains, not just in the bond markets but in the wider world of geopolitics, that are adding to the pressures and bringing closer some kind of reckoning.
Although I agree with my noble friend that the decisions the Government have chosen to take over the last two years—ducking cuts to the welfare budget and increasing taxes on business and employment—have made the problem worse, we on this side have to acknowledge that this is a problem that has been a long time in the making. Whereas in 1997, the Conservatives left office with a surplus—I repeat, a surplus—in 2024, the fiscal signs were already flashing red.
That brings me to the main point I would like to make today. It may seem slightly to one side, but I want to bring it to the discussion. Our fiscal and economic problems are a consequence of structural political problems, and we will not be able to address them unless we also address the whole way in which our political system operates and our political classes have come to behave.
When I started working in government back in the 1980s, the basic operating model for politicians was something like this: the leadership worked out their overall vision and values, and then developed policies that were coherent with that vision. The job of politicians was to make an argument in favour of that vision and seek to persuade as many people as possible of the wisdom of a particular course of action. I am not arguing that this was universally applied, nor that there were not sometimes contradictions, but I do argue that the Government and Parliament were fundamentally transmission mechanisms and that their core job was to make an argument that was as coherent as possible.
My Lords, I also welcome this debate. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Bridges, for bringing it and welcome the noble Lord, Lord Pitt-Watson, to his place. As for the tone of the debate, it is inevitable that the conference season, immediately before the Budget, is a time when all parties lay out their stall, although I have been particularly encouraged by the contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Burns, and the contribution that we have just heard from the noble Lord, Lord Hill, about some of the thoughtful longer-term structural issues with which we are contending as a nation.
The nation’s fiscal challenges are self-evident, and my party in government faces understandable public anxiety. As the noble Lord, Lord Hill, just noted, the party opposite is also contending with some public scepticism about their record in government. As for what that does to our politics, it brings to the forefront the populists: those who peddle easy solutions to these structural challenges and who are determined to convince the country that the answer to our fiscal challenges is to blow up the system. It is not made any easier by the markets being spooked by a US President who, on social media last week, was telling the Federal Reserve in capital letters to lower the rate and who today promised a “cash bung” to those who voted the right way.
That creates a challenge for all of us, but, as the noble Lord, Lord Bridges, recognised, the real rocket fuel for populism and difficult politics is low growth. Low growth is the root of our fiscal pressures. It is a result of the financial crisis, as we have heard, which was exacerbated in Britain by Brexit and then a series of global shocks: the pandemic, the war on our continent, the rising energy prices and the Iran conflict. There is common ground here that on top of those pressures come spending pressures of an ageing population and the need to raise defence spending. All that requires a Government willing to face up to those headwinds, and I believe that is what we are seeing.
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lord Bridges on bringing forward this debate—he probably had to do a bit of pushing and shoving—and for his crystal-clear demonstration, which will be hard to challenge, that with our national debt interest we are on a path to unsustainability and no one has a clear idea what to do about it, including the present Chancellor. Fair enough, this is not new, as the noble Lords, Lord Hill and Lord Burns, with their enormous experience, have said. This is an old problem which has its seeds in the past. I can go back further than the late 1970s to 1970, when we talked about a new style of Government and Ted Heath slightly unexpectedly became Prime Minister. We urged that we should start unravelling the almost entirely socialised public sector inherited from the war years and begin to regain some balance between private enterprise and the market economy on the one hand and the necessary government framework of laws, guidance and support on the other. As I say, it is not new, and anyone who says it is all the fault either of the present Government or the past Government makes an interesting comment but it is completely irrelevant to what on earth we do about it now.
I declare my interests, given that energy is often at the root of all these problems. I am a chairman of the Windsor Energy Group and I advise Crystol Energy, both without pay. I also advise the Kuwait Investment Office, which is an enormous sovereign wealth fund that longs to invest, as do others, in the British economy but finds great difficulty in doing so and has vastly reduced its commitment in the British economy rather as the pension fund has been vastly reduced. When I was young, pension funds with their surpluses put 60% of their money in the British economy and mostly in British equities. Now the figure is 3.8%. What on earth has gone wrong? No wonder there is a shortage of resources for investment if our main investors, at home and overseas, are quietly packing their bags and going elsewhere.
My Lords, I, too, salute the noble Lord, Lord Bridges of Headley, for securing this critical, timely debate and for his compelling opening remarks. It was a pleasure to sit on the Economic Affairs Committee under his astute chairmanship, especially during our inquiry into the sustainability of our national debt. Some noble Lords will remember that we debated the title National Debt: It’s Time for Tough Decisions for some time, as many of us, me included, had little confidence that Governments of any colour would make those tough decisions. So it proved with Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves, as I fear it will with Prime Minister Burnham and Chancellor Healey—more on that in a moment.
The committee’s two subsequent inquiries raised further concerns about our fiscal outlook: one was on preparing for an ageing society, which, in short, we are not doing; and earlier this year we looked at our fiscal architecture and asked the key question of whether the fiscal framework is fit for purpose. In short, it is not. Our track record, as the noble Lord, Lord Bridges, has pointed out, is disturbing to say the least. Debt is at £3 trillion. It has tripled in size over the past 20 years, and yet we have so little to show for it—witness our anaemic growth rates. The annual interest bill now stands at £110 billion, almost double our defence budget, and our budget deficits continue to run well north of £100 billion a year, financed by yet more borrowing despite our overall tax burden rising above 36% of GDP and heading, I fear, for 40%. The OBR copped a lot of flak for its projection that debt would climb to 270% of GDP in 50 years’ time, but given our economy’s vulnerability to global shocks, let alone our baseline trends, that forecast strikes me as conservative.
That is enough fiscal hammering from me, as I want to focus on the outlook and the need for turnaround. Here I draw on lessons learned from my private sector experience in rebooting companies that have lost their great momentum and become overly dependent on outside financing. Turnaround always involves taking tough, unpopular decisions on costs in the interest of financial sustainability; the triple lock is a classic example. However, far more important than cost controls, turnaround depends on sustained revenue growth. What areas do you need to protect and nurture to accelerate growth? That is the only way out of our fiscal trap, yet Government after Government have failed to address this. Rachel Reeves’s first Budget was a classic example, trumpeting economic growth as the number one mission yet hitting the supply side, our businesses and employers, with an extra £25 billion on NICs, doing huge damage to jobs, growth and investment. I have seen the impact first hand across SMEs that I chair, invest in and advise, and I should declare my interests as set out in the register.
My Lords, the Conservative Government were swept from power, first because they did not deliver on immigration control in the way that they promised but, secondly, because they presided over a very major surge in inflation in the early 2020s, which had been brought about by excessive spending, excessive borrowing, the deliberate repression of interest rates and the artificial creation of very large sums of money by the Bank of England. Like many, I supported the first very substantial injections into the economy when lockdown was first announced. Lockdown took a lot of activity and income out of the economy and a very major offset was needed. However, I became increasingly critical and impatient in the recovery period because the Government and the Bank of England did not seem to understand that we were into recovery and carried on with excessive borrowing, excessive spending and excessive money creation. I and others told them that it was bound to be inflationary, but much of the great British economic establishment was slow to see that and the result was a nasty cost of living crunch that did damage to the electorate and drove the Conservatives from power in a perfectly understandable way.
By 2024, however, the Conservative Government had got much better control of the economy and, for the first six months of 2024, under Conservative direction, the inflation rate came back down to the 2% target. For those six months, it was the fastest-growing economy of the G7. The Government set out a five-year plan in their 2024 Spring Budget, as always, which had entirely credible figures to show the deficit and therefore the borrowings coming down year by year to reassure bond markets. Under the Conservatives, of course, it was considerably cheaper than it is today for the Government to borrow because there was a bit more credibility in the medium-term prospects for controlling borrowing than there is today.
I think the fairest thing to do to try and analyse where we are, because I want the Government to succeed and I think they need to consider very carefully where they are when framing their next Budget, is to compare the plans of the outgoing Conservative Government in the 2024 Budget for 2027-28 with those of this Government. Let us concentrate on 2027-28 because that is when the new Prime Minister and his new Chancellor can make any changes they like. They have inherited the current year and have chosen not to make many changes, just a few incidental, very small increases in spending. They have basically lived with the Reeves/Starmer construction of this year, but let us hope they think carefully about what they want to do for 2027-28.
1:08 pm
20 of 44 shown
Across the advanced economies, government debt rose from around 70% of GDP on the eve of the financial crisis to around 110% today. That debt explosion took place during an era of low inflation, ultra-low interest rates and unprecedented quantitative easing, and in a world that is largely at peace. That world has gone, but government debt remains at record levels and is growing. The OECD expects Governments to borrow around $18 trillion this year. Almost four-fifths of that is simply to refinance debt coming due. Advanced economies spent more than $2 trillion on debt servicing alone last year. Dozens of nations, including the USA, now spend more on debt servicing than defence. In this rising tide of red ink, the price that each Government pays on their debt—ours included—is ultimately determined by investors, by their judgment on the health of a nation’s economy. To coin the Prime Minister’s phrase, it is that thing of being in hock to the bond market.
That brings us to the question that bond traders and all of us here today are asking: just how resilient are the UK’s finances? On Monday, the Chancellor told us that Britain is turning a corner. If so, surely debt should be on a steady downward path—but no, it is not. Debt will be higher at the end of this Parliament than at the start, before falling only slightly to around 95% of GDP by 2030-31. Even that fall is questionable. As the OBR notes:
“Plans to reduce borrowing and stabilise debt have been a common feature of forecasts since the pandemic, but have not yet materialised in outturn”,
or, as St Augustine might have put it, “Lord, make me fiscally responsible, just not yet”.
Indeed, the OBR concluded in July that Britain’s public finances were
“in a challenging position relative to history and to other similar countries, with … debt having increased by one of the largest shares of GDP of any advanced economy over the past two decades”.
It is the structure of our debt that makes us unusually vulnerable. QE shortens its effective maturity, while Britain has a particularly large stock of index-linked debt, so when borrowing costs rise, we feel the effects very quickly. Even before the economic impact of the Gulf war, the OBR was forecasting that debt servicing would cost us £110 billion in 2025-26. That is 3.5% of our national income, which is more than we have spent on education and approaching twice what we spend on defence. By 2030-31, that figure is expected to hit £137 billion.
The bond market is beginning to reflect investors’ anxiety about all this. Britain may not be an outlier in the amount it owes, but it is becoming an outlier in what it costs us to borrow. Our 10-year borrowing costs are now the highest in the G7 and the fourth highest in the advanced world. On Tuesday, Britain paid the highest borrowing cost on a sale of 30-year debt in almost three decades, and that rising interest bill is eating into the Government’s fiscal buffer. At the spring forecast, that buffer was around £24 billion. Against £3 trillion of national debt and £1 trillion of annual spending, that is not a buffer; that is a wafer, and some estimates suggest it has already shrunk to just £5 billion.
The Chancellor’s optimism cannot camouflage the facts: debt is high and still rising, its structure leaves us unusually exposed to shocks, our fiscal buffer is wafer thin and shrinking, and investors are demanding an increasingly high price to lend to us. In that sense, though, the Chancellor may be correct: we are turning a corner. Ken Rogoff, the former chief economist of the IMF, now puts the chances of a major UK debt crisis by 2030 at more than 50:50.
This brings us to a central question: what would convince investors that Britain has a credible plan to stabilise its debt? The answer, I would argue, lies not so much in economic theory as in political choices. A central conclusion of the Economic Affairs Committee two years ago was:
“If we wish to maintain the level and quality of public services and benefits that we have come to expect, we face a choice: taxes will need to rise or the state will need to do less. Addressing this will demand clarity as to the responsibilities and the role of the individual versus that of the state. Muddling through is not an option. If this choice is ducked in this Parliament, the UK risks being on a path to unsustainable debt”.
Two years on, my argument is not that the Government have failed to take tough decisions: it has, but it has taken the wrong tough decisions. Labour decisions have weakened growth, dug us deeper into the debt hole and increased our fiscal vulnerability. What is needed is a plan to control spending and strengthen the underlying budget so we live within our means, bear down on inflation and the cost of our debt, and, above all, get the economy growing faster. But the Government’s actions have produced the reverse of all that.
Let us look at spending. I was intrigued to hear the Chancellor say on Monday:
“Staying true to our values means being honest about the need to control government spending”.
For a moment, I thought I was listening to fake news. By the end of this Parliament, the Government will be spending around £260 billion more a year than at the start. Public spending will absorb more than 44% of national income. That is a level we have not seen on a sustained basis, outside shocks and their aftermath, since the 1970s. Let us look where that increase is going. Welfare spending is set to rise by some £75 billion a year over this Parliament, to £390 billion. Within that, spending on health and disability benefits is forecast to hit £104 billion, an increase of more than a third.
Instead of taking the tough decisions needed to control spending, the Government have chosen higher spending, financed by higher taxes. Working hard, investing, setting up a business, employing more people—the very activities that drive growth and generate the revenue needed to stabilise our debt—are being taxed more heavily. To give one example, the rise in employers’ national insurance alone means an employer now pays around £900 more a year for every worker on median earnings, and the tax burden is set to rise still further, to the highest level on record.
Then there is inflation. I fully concede that the war in the Gulf has made the fight against inflation more difficult, but that is all the more reason for the Government to double down on measures to cut costs on business. I welcome the Government’s promise to take an axe to the bureaucracy holding back private investment, but why are they stopping there? If regulation is holding back investment and growth, the Government should take an axe to the burdens they have themselves imposed on business and employers, such as their energy policies and the Employment Rights Act—an Act that will impose direct costs on business of around £1 billion a year.
These policies have undermined growth, which is the all-important ingredient to bring down our debt. The Government will rightly point out that there was stronger growth in the first half of this year, but two good quarters do not solve the structural problem. The OBR still puts our potential growth rate at only 1.5% and forecasts GDP per head to grow by just 1.1% a year over the rest of the decade. That is roughly half its pre-financial crisis rate. For debt sustainability, it is that underlying rate of growth—year on year, not a couple of strong quarters—that matters.
Let us put this together. What lies around the corner? A higher-spending Government, extracting ever more tax from a weak, debt-laden economy. There is clearly a debate to be had about the role that the fiscal rules play in all this. My view is that today’s fiscal rules, like their predecessors, can be too easily gamed, and we can debate how to address that, but let us not lose sight of the main point. What matters is whether the underlying fiscal trajectory is credible, and that trajectory is shaped by political choices and political belief. Do you believe the state should be the driving force of growth, or do you trust people and the markets? Should the state encourage people to take greater control of and more responsibility for their lives, or should the state assume ever more responsibility for itself? The answers to these questions will shape our fiscal trajectory and the decisions in next month’s Budget.
The Minister obviously cannot prejudge that Budget, but, that said, there are some simple questions he should be able to answer. First, does he think British business can afford to pay still higher taxes without damaging growth—yes or no? Secondly, the Prime Minister has said he will use “flexibility” within the existing fiscal rules. Can the Minister define what “flexibility” means? Thirdly, what did the Prime Minister mean exactly when he said:
“We’ve got to get beyond this thing of being in hock to the bond markets”?
Finally, what does the Minister think about the current trajectory of our national debt? Is it sustainable—yes or no?
My answer to that question is a firm no. We may not face a debt crisis today, but the horizon is darkening, with weak growth, a record tax burden, sticky inflation, rising welfare dependency and more of our national income consumed by servicing the debts of the past. I do not see this as turning a corner. I see it as proof that, after two years of Labour, with its massive majority, we are on the wrong path and going in a very dangerous direction. We need to change course now, before that thing called the bond market forces us to change, and in a way that will be more painful and more costly.
Let me end by taking us back 50 years to September 1976. Britain had just turned to the IMF for a loan. A few days later, standing at that Dispatch Box, Lord Carrington said something which echoes down the generations. He said that
“you cannot go on spending vast sums of money which you have not got. You cannot go on improving your own standard of life on other people’s money because, sooner or later, they will not lend you any more. … Whether we like it or not—and we do not—and the sooner the better, we are going to have to cut our public expenditure. Of course, it is not going to be nice. Of course, we are all going to be hurt by it, and of course, we shall all have to cut the things we would much rather not cut. Of course, we will dislike it very much. But what other alternatives are there?”—[Official Report, 4/10/1976; col. 953.]
But for all that, there are powerful headwinds to contend with. The Financial Times this week described the issue of national debt service globally as “a $2tn monster”. The US, France and the UK are all having to pay more debt interest than they spend on defence. This not only poses real challenges in setting steady state spending plans but, as I have already noted, gives less leeway to respond to future financial crises. The OBR, in its long-term forecasting, assumes a financial crisis every nine years. In this week’s announcement by the Dutch central bank that it was moving the physical custody of 14% of its gold from New York and Ottawa to London—an eloquent demonstration, perhaps, of the damage that the Trump Administration are doing to international confidence—it made a strikingly blunt assertion:
“This ensures that DNB is … prepared for severe crises”.
As my right honourable friend the Chancellor prepares his Budget, he is undoubtedly constrained by the commitment in the Labour manifesto not to increase the three most significant personal tax rates. Taxation policy has always been part of the political debate, but perhaps most acutely since the Conservative Party’s campaign—fake news—“Labour’s Tax Bombshell”, which can credibly be seen as having swung the 1992 general election result. It is understandable why the party, scarred by that, has sought to avoid a repeat. But, to be frank, it is not conducive to the best management of the economy in inevitably changing circumstances.
Those changing circumstances include, most importantly, the effects of the war in Iran. The NIESR has estimated that every 10% increase in the oil price reduces GDP by 0.12%. So the rise of 40% or more since the US’s misconceived attack on Iran is likely to have reduced GDP by 0.5%, with the IMF having concluded that prior to this the UK economy was on a positive, improving trend.
I will end on one or two more positive notes. The fiscal devolution started by the last Chancellor and turbocharged by the new Prime Minister has the potential to have disproportionately beneficial effects on growth, employment and housing, as I am already seeing in the work I am doing in the West Midlands. My right honourable friend Gordon Brown made a compelling analysis in the Financial Times of the role of innovation in driving growth and the UK’s world-leading strength in science and technology. I hope my noble friend the Minister can reassure the House of the Government’s understanding of the need to address the fragile state of the higher education sector.
The scale and severity of the challenges that we face are formidable. These are global challenges, faced by multiple countries and exacerbated overwhelmingly by the policies of the US Administration. The noble Lord, Lord Bridges, is wrong to attribute the causes of that challenge to this Government. In fact, in contrast, I am totally confident that the Labour Government—governing, unlike its predecessors, in the national interest—are best placed to find a successful path through these challenging times.
Both the Economic Affairs Committee and the OBR have set out the significant headwinds we are facing, and they are very tough. They include an ageing society, increased defence spending and rebuilding our energy grid to make the best use of renewable energy.
Dealing with these matters will not be easy. In my view, it means a combination of increased taxes, restraint on increases to benefits and improved public sector productivity. As far as possible, this should involve reducing the array of exemptions and tax credits that are characteristic of our tax and benefits systems, and we need closer scrutiny of claims for benefits. The goal should be a wider tax base and a narrower welfare base, and we should be doing our best to avoid the high marginal tax rates or damaging cliff-edge withdrawal rates that are also very evident now.
Faster growth could improve the situation, but we need to be cautious. The OBR has pointed out that if faster growth is simply translated into proportionate growth in the provision of public services, growth on its own will not be sufficient to solve the problem.
Here lies a fundamental challenge. Demand for the major public services tends to increase more than proportionately in a growing economy. We see this with health, social care, education and some aspects of welfare. So, it is not surprising that costs rise more rapidly than the growth rate itself. Indeed, in the case of the triple lock the arrangements mean that pensions will grow faster than earnings. It was designed to produce that effect. This explains why growth alone will not solve this problem.
In an earlier phase of my career, I had close experience of three difficult periods for fiscal policy: 1976, 1981 and 1993. I was an academic and commentator during the first, and a Treasury official during the second and third. In each case, decisive action was taken, even though it involved difficult and often unpopular decisions, as the noble Lord, Lord Lamont, will remember in the case of the 1993 event. But eventually, we saw an improvement in the balance of the economy and improved market confidence.
If coping with excessive debt becomes the priority for a Government, it tends to crowd out discussion of longer-term structural policy and issues such as tax reform, which are so necessary. Once debt is clearly on a downward trajectory, life becomes much calmer, leaving more time for dealing with the longer-term issues that really deserve scrutiny. Above all, if we could get on to a path of a falling debt ratio, we might spend less time discussing the fiscal rules and whether they are a sufficient buffer for the next Budget—and I suspect we would all welcome that.
We did not obsess over opinion polls. We did not carry out endless focus groups and taxpayer-funded market research. We did not, at bottom, think our job was to split the difference between competing interest groups. Contrast that with what we see today: incoherent and contradictory policy positions to please different lobby groups. For example, there is a drive on deregulation, on which I believe the Government are to be congratulated, but it sits alongside higher taxes on business, employment taxes on non-doms and laws to make it less attractive to hire workers. One set of measures is pro-investment but another is anti-investment. The result is incoherence.
In essence, we have moved the Government and Parliament from a transmission mechanism into one that is always on receive and sits on top of a giant lobbying system, where the plaudits go to the politician who can negotiate the next 24 hours most skilfully or take most plausibly some ludicrous line—ideally, while wearing a high-vis jacket or hard hat. So is it a surprise that our fiscal problems have compounded as our political system has become ever more performative? I remember my noble friend Lord Lamont once saying, “To govern is to choose”. More recently, we have had a Prime Minister who said, “I’m pro-cake and pro-eating it”.
Fortunately, we face a test that will show whether we have a political system that is indeed capable of being serious once again. What are we going to do about the pension triple lock? It is already clear that, in the circumstances we face, it is indefensible economically. But if, as a society, we believe in some kind of intergenerational fairness, it is clearly also indefensible morally. A policy that locks in the transmission of money from a declining number of young people to a growing number of relatively well-off older people—or, if you like, from our children to us—is not the path to a strong, balanced society.
I hope we can rise to this challenge, which applies to my Benches as much as it does to the Benches opposite. As my noble friend Lord Bridges said, we can either take steps ourselves to start sorting out the mess or wait to have change forced on us. I know which I prefer and which I believe is better for our democracy, but honesty about our fiscal situation requires honesty in our politics. To restore seriousness to our fiscal position, we first need to restore seriousness to our politics.
Our times demand serious responses. We have heard from the noble Viscount, Lord Chandos, about Gordon Brown and I am going to come to that, but I took inspiration this week from the noble Lord, Lord Hague, who wrote:
“The old Conservative philosophy … is no longer a convincing governing programme. That is because circumstances have changed. We now face ageing populations, housing scarcity, energy insecurity, technological competition with the US and China, Russian aggression, weak productivity, strained public services and increasingly expensive welfare states”.
Those are wise words indeed, and they echo what we have heard in this Chamber today. However, there was also an honest acknowledgement of the new fiscal challenges and an invocation to us all to not be tempted by easy populist solutions. His remedy was growth, particularly innovation and entrepreneurship. Gordon Brown, who wrote 24 hours later in the Financial Times, also urged a focus on growth and innovation, both men arguing for a Budget as an economic event as much as a fiscal one. Encouragingly, the new Chancellor’s inaugural speech on Monday focused on growth and innovation and scaling start-ups in the north.
I will put the case for the Government. Despite the headwinds, the Starmer Government delivered the economic stability that we promised. Growth is the best in the G7. I stress that we are cutting the deficit faster than others in any other G7 economy, although I accept that a sustainable long-term path is something we have to find. Productivity is up, wages are up, business investment is rising, with planning delays, judicial reviews and the Green Book all being tackled and young people put back to work. Meanwhile, the Chancellor has reaffirmed the Government’s commitment to fiscal discipline and respect for manifesto commitments, and wisely has made no false promises on tax. I say to the party opposite, we await what the new shadow Chancellor’s prospectus is.
The last shadow Chancellor told us that his strategy was not to focus on innovation—indeed, he was proposing cuts to the British Business Bank—but for a rather implausible £23 billion to come from welfare. Welfare spending outside of pensions has hovered around 5% of our national wealth for the last 40 years, so there is scant evidence of where the axe would fall. We have been told that half a million children would be pushed back into poverty by restoring the child benefit cap. That, along with raising VAT on disabled drivers and cutting housing benefits, is not the totality of the solution. Nor is cutting overseas aid. That ship has sailed. We are told asylum hotels will be cut—another ship that has sailed. Legal and illegal immigration are both decisively down. Cutting back on some of the extra 150,000 civil servants employed in the last decade and a half is perhaps wise. My point is that the luxury of opposition should not involve aping the populists, because that is not a governing strategy.
We have heard from the noble Lord, Lord Burns, that the way forward may be to look at tax. We have heard from others, including the noble Lord, Lord Hill, that we should perhaps look at the triple lock. There are legitimate differences around where and how spending might be addressed and where the axe should fall, but I simply say in conclusion that we know from the Chancellor that this Budget will be one that sticks to the fiscal rules, restores the fiscal headroom, as it must, and reinforces the Government’s commitment to growth with a 10-year plan to follow which signals where change is coming on devolution, social care and defence. I believe these are the priorities that resonate with the country.
I will put four points on the question the noble Lord, Lord Hill, has rightly raised: what to do about it. The roots are deep and the problems will require an enormous change of attitude in the digital age, which will be difficult for a lot of people to face, including a lot of politicians.
First, around the world there are a lot of methods of merging or matching private finance and enterprise with public and state frameworks for basic needs—in particular, longer-term public infrastructure projects which simply cannot be delivered without a Government pump-priming and underpinning but for which there is no state cash left. There is no money. There is no more room to borrow, or if there is, the borrowing cost of interest cancels out what one was trying to borrow. And there is no room to tax, because if you tax beyond a certain point, as we know from Arthur Laffer and many others—although there are exceptions to this—you end up with less revenue, not more. So, the ceiling is being bumped against and there is no way out of that.
Secondly, these new methods that I mentioned, which we invented here under the name of PFI 25 or 30 years ago and which are now called PPP, are being developed and used in several countries. They are not just experiments or hopes for the future, but what is actually going on at the moment. We dropped the idea back in 2018, but a whole range of countries, which I will come to if I have time, are adopting varieties of this method of harnessing private enterprise to public needs. Compatibility between state and private investment can be reached through risk analysis, insurance developments and careful phasing of projects. The whole resources of private enterprise can be brought in, easing the bond markets’ tensions, worries and consequent increases in interest rates for lending us their money. There are opportunities opening, certainly not for any more bogus financial headroom and that sort of thing but definitely for carrying forward some of the projects we need, from potholes to power stations, without burdening the bond markets or government accounting. These are being followed in a number of countries.
Finally, these are immensely powerful new insights that I hope we can pursue and share, aside from the politics. We on this side think that the wrong Government are in office and that they are bound always to bow to the state. That is a statement of fact and raises all sorts of other issues. There is no point in bemoaning it. At this time, we have a role in opposition to try to state some constructive ideas. If the Government borrow them, that is fine—at least we are making progress.
I hope that we can unlock a great deal of progress. A lot of this lies in the great energy transition and providing 24/7 reliable, affordable clean energy in the quantities that are going to be needed if we can ever get growth going. The experts planning our energy future have persistently underestimated the amount of clean, green energy we will need and the amount of investment we will need to achieve that—certainly for our modern growing economy and, even more certainly, to cover the enormous requirements of the data centres we will need to keep up with the world, which are very thirsty indeed. At present, our plans are proving totally inadequate for meeting their needs.
The nations moving this way are the Netherlands, Ireland, France, Germany, Norway, Sweden, Finland, Canada, Australia, South Africa and some provinces and states in Canada and Australia. The province of Ontario is launching a huge new nuclear programme that is much quicker than ours, much more efficient and much more reliable, with the help of the Japanese and without going to its Government. There are many other examples, some of which might well bring down the cost of borrowing, which for this country is too much and too expensive, and we must call a halt. There is a third way of a sort. It does not let the Government or politicians off the hook, but we should realise that the private enterprise pattern for public expenditure of this kind is vital for the projects of the future and is attainable if we think clearly and wisely about it.
It is deeply disappointing to hear Andy Burnham repeat Keir Starmer’s pledge not to touch income tax, employee national insurance or VAT, because that points to raising taxes on businesses and wealth creators. This Government appear to be hanging their growth strategy on the peg of devolution, “Good growth in every postcode”. It is a mission that may come back to haunt them, because such ambitions will generate pain before gain—if, indeed, we get the gain. It will mean increased spending on reallocating resources and power, recruitment, training, management and execution, and that is before we even address infrastructure. It is a long-term strategy which in parts of this country has some merit, but it requires financing up front and will disrupt output and productivity, adding even more fiscal pressure that will not go unnoticed by the bond markets.
Economic growth is the only way out of our fiscal hole, but we need to address this head on and with realism, so let me conclude by suggesting a pathway. We need a plan and a coherent strategy that delivers a minimum of 2.5% real GDP growth from 2027 to 2032, compared to our current rate of 1% to 1.5%. This would be achieved not by shifting resources around the country or building high-speed railway networks but by addressing the core productivity issues within our workforce of 34 million, in both the public and private sectors.
I am talking about performance: management and leadership, the way we pay and incentivise our workers, recruitment and retention, training and adoption of technology, especially AI. Above all, we need to target productivity gains and reward performance—an enterprise culture, in other words. I contend there are very few organisations or companies out there that cannot achieve a 2% annual improvement in productivity if that is their prime focus.
What would this do fiscally? By adding just one percentage point of real GDP growth in each the next five years, we would see £60 billion to £70 billion a year of additional tax revenues by the end of that period without increasing tax rates. Of even greater benefit would be the impact on interest rates because debt sustainability turns on the gap between the interest rate the Government pay and the growth rate of the economy or “r minus g”. Right now, that gap is unfavourable: gilt yields are sitting at 5.2% to 5.9% against nominal growth—real growth plus inflation—currently running closer to 3.5%. We have to close this credibility gap otherwise our economy will remain chronically dependent on borrowing at unfavourable and unsustainable interest rates while our miserable GDP growth rates continue.
What have they inherited from Reeves and Starmer? Well, in two Budgets, Reeves and Starmer increased taxes by £66 billion by policy changes—there is also, of course, a much bigger increase in taxes from fiscal drag and inflation—and for 2027-28 they suggested that they wanted to borrow £97 billion more than the outgoing Conservative Government had planned to do. The Conservatives were planning to borrow £50 billion in 2027-28, and the current Government inherits £147 billion. There is then the level of spending: the Reeves/Starmer Government added £145 billion extra spending for 2027-28 compared with the £97 billion that the Conservatives were planning for that year. The total package is to borrow a lot more, tax a lot more and spend a great deal more.
Looking at the economic performance of the last two years, we see that this has not been a benign policy mixture for the economy. Unemployment has gone up and inflation has gone up, not entirely because of world events in the Middle East, but also driven by public sector costs where there has been a very big increase in public sector wages. I have no problem with paying people in the public sector more, but there should be productivity gains to help pay for it, and those have been sadly lacking. We have seen the Government stumbling to maintain tax revenues at the more elevated levels because they have triggered what in the 1970s was called a brain drain. A lot of talented people and a lot of people with wealth have decided that they want to make their lives or to make their investments elsewhere, which is a considerable concern. I have no problem with wanting to tax the rich more than everybody else, because they have the money to tax, but if you overdo it they do not stay to pay the money you wish to raise from them and then everybody else has to pay rather more, because you have lost those easier amounts you can get if you tax the rich in a sensible and internationally competitive way.
As has been made very clear by my noble friend Lord Bridges, the Government have to take action on spending. I do not think higher taxation is going to help get the Government out of this, given that they have ruled out the main taxes on most people. They would have to target the wealthy, the energetic, the people who work harder rather more than anybody else. More of that would do damage to growth and would mean less revenue rather than more, so they have to find public expenditure reductions that can start to bring the budget into a proper shape.
I do not share the view of those who think we should pick on the pensioners or the disabled to make particular sacrifices at this juncture. Those who are genuinely disabled need our proper financial support and I think both parties were right to promise the triple lock in the election and should keep to their word. There are many easier targets, which I have often mentioned, but which time does not permit me to handle today, but my party has set out a very good set of cuts for the benefits bill to start us off.