My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 5 in this group. Structurally, the amendment follows the approach used by my noble friend Lady Bowles in her previous amendment, and I am very grateful to her for the help and support in drafting. My amendment has a simple purpose, which is to bring relief to mortgage prisoners. As many of your Lordships will know, mortgage prisoners are people who are stuck with their existing mortgage holders—who are not active lenders—on very high interest rates and who cannot access a better deal, such as the normal market fixed-rate deals. As a result, mortgage prisoners continue to pay interest at around four percentage points over the normal market fixed-term rates. This costs them hundreds, and even thousands, of pounds extra per year.
According to the UK Mortgage Prisoners action group, there were originally around 195,000 mortgage prisoners. This number is declining slowly due to death, reaching the end of term and repossessions. The largest group of mortgage prisoners are former Northern Rock customers. After nationalisation in 2007, these mortgages were placed in a Government-owned company run by UK Asset Resolution—UKAR. When returning these mortgages to the private sector, the Conservative Government could have sold them to active lenders, which would have offered the prisoners a fair market deal. The Government did not do that. Instead, they sold the mortgages to non-active lenders and vulture funds; the consequences we continue to see.
It is not as though the Government were not warned about the problem this would cause. The risk to customers was clearly identified. In January 2016, the noble Lord, Lord McFall, wrote to the Treasury and UKAR, warning them that:
“Many of … those affected by these sales, will be mortgage prisoners and will be unable to switch lenders”.
He told the Government that the customers affected by the sales should be protected, offered a fair deal and given access to fixed rates. He warned that: