16: After Clause 12, insert the following new Clause—
“Claims management services: Northern Ireland(1) The Treasury may by regulations made by statutory instrument make provision for claims management services provided in, from or into Northern Ireland to be regulated under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 on a basis equivalent to claims management services provided in, from or into Great Britain.(2) Regulations under this section may amend primary legislation, assimilated direct principal EU legislation or subordinate legislation, including—(a) the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000,(b) the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Regulated Activities) Order 2001, and(c) Part 2 of the Financial Guidance and Claims Act 2018.(3) Regulations under this section may make consequential, supplementary, incidental, transitional, transitory or saving provision.(4) Before making regulations under this section, the Treasury must consult—(a) the Financial Conduct Authority,(b) the scheme operator of the ombudsman scheme under Part 16 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000,(c) the Department of Finance in Northern Ireland, and(d) such other persons as the Treasury considers appropriate.(5) A statutory instrument containing regulations under this section may not be made unless a draft of the instrument has been laid before and approved by a resolution of each House of Parliament.(6) In this section, “claims management services” has the meaning given by section 419A of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.”
16: After Clause 12, insert the following new Clause—
“Claims management services: Northern Ireland(1) The Treasury may by regulations made by statutory instrument make provision for claims management services provided in, from or into Northern Ireland to be regulated under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 on a basis equivalent to claims management services provided in, from or into Great Britain.(2) Regulations under this section may amend primary legislation, assimilated direct principal EU legislation or subordinate legislation, including—(a) the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000,(b) the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Regulated Activities) Order 2001, and(c) Part 2 of the Financial Guidance and Claims Act 2018.(3) Regulations under this section may make consequential, supplementary, incidental, transitional, transitory or saving provision.(4) Before making regulations under this section, the Treasury must consult—(a) the Financial Conduct Authority,(b) the scheme operator of the ombudsman scheme under Part 16 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000,(c) the Department of Finance in Northern Ireland, and(d) such other persons as the Treasury considers appropriate.(5) A statutory instrument containing regulations under this section may not be made unless a draft of the instrument has been laid before and approved by a resolution of each House of Parliament.(6) In this section, “claims management services” has the meaning given by section 419A of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.”
My Lords, this amendment follows on from the amendment tabled in Committee by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral. I am bringing the House’s attention to a growing and deeply concerning problem in Northern Ireland’s insurance market. The market is shrinking in insurer capacity, it is becoming less competitive, and it is leaving consumers and businesses facing higher premiums and fewer choices. It is an issue that the British Insurance Brokers’ Association has been highlighting for some time, and about which it has been getting in touch with noble Lords and Members in the other place.
The evidence suggests that the root cause is claims inflation driven by various factors that are within the power of government and regulators to address. Let me be clear to noble Lords, especially to the Minister: I am not calling for a new, immediate regulatory regime without proper consultation. Rather, the amendment would provide the Treasury with a targeted enabling power, subject to consultation and affirmative parliamentary approval, to extend FCA regulation of claims management companies to Northern Ireland. They are, of course, currently regulated in Great Britain by the FCA.
I will give a brief backdrop to the amendment, which paints a very stark picture. In home insurance, brokers in Northern Ireland now have access to just six markets, down from 11 in 2020. In motor insurance, the number of available providers has fallen from more than 15 to just eight over the same period. As competition has reduced, premiums in Northern Ireland have continued to rise, even as prices in Great Britain have begun to stabilise or fall. In motor insurance, Northern Ireland consumers are being affected by premiums increasing year on year, and they are already paying much higher premiums compared with the rest of the UK. Of course, as noble Lords will know, access to public transport in Northern Ireland’s extensive rural areas is very limited.
My Lords, I support the amendment in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey. It is well thought through, balanced and modest. The House will be relieved that, for once, neither I nor the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, are even mentioning the Northern Ireland protocol or the Windsor Framework as part of this, albeit that that may be to our shame. The amendment is about trying to tackle a genuine problem for consumers. It is very much within the keeping of the Bill. Part of the purpose of the Bill is not necessarily to increase regulation but to have better and smarter regulation. This proposal very much fits in with that.
The amendment is cautious in its nature, because it would not compel the Government to take immediate action. It would give the power to the Treasury. Indeed, before any next steps could be taken there would need to be consultation, discussion and agreement with the devolved institutions and the respective departments. It would not be acted on by government but would have to be brought forward through the affirmative procedure. The amendment would take this in a sensible approach, one step at a time.
Ultimately, the amendment is to deal with a very real problem. Any of us who has been involved politically in Northern Ireland know that, during canvassing for every election, people will raise the issue of the higher rates of insurance. I am sure there will be agreement across the Chamber about this. Even as recently as the last general election, a number of candidates from different parties said that that was something that had to be tackled.
The fundamental point is that we have here an opportunity to help with the cost of living. As brokers are advising, insurers and market-makers are withdrawing from the Province because the economics of the claim system do not pay. An insurance company, like any other business, has to make a profit, but claims may be exorbitant and the management of them expensive. Quite often, claims through these companies result in the amount of time that the vehicle is on the road expanding, with the car hire charges expanding in parallel. That is a source of very significant profit. They have their own garages in some cases, and obviously their own hire cars. That all goes on the bill of the insurer—and then ends up with the consumer.
My Lords, taking up the last point from the noble Lord, Lord Weir, the Prime Minister, on his recent visits and tour of the UK, has emphasised that the primary focus of the Government is to help people with the cost of living. Because our population in Northern Ireland is spread out more than it is in Great Britain, there is much heavier reliance on motor vehicles to get around. This has a huge impact not only on farmers but on people who are resident in rural areas.
At one point a number of years ago, as Minister for Enterprise, I had responsibility for consumer protection. I have no recollection that financial matters of this nature were incorporated in the devolution settlement, so I believe that the Treasury has a key role to play. It seems odd that we in Northern Ireland have a sector that is unregulated. It is the only part of the United Kingdom where it is unregulated. People need to grasp that there is a different legal framework for dealing with claims for damages under insurance. For instance, the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, referred to a list of settlements that should be reached, whereas we have a thing called the green book, which allows for much greater flexibility and has resulted in much higher claims.
The noble Baroness quoted one example, for soft tissue injury, but that is only one. It does spread out, and of course that is not the only potential claim. There could be other mental health claims arising from the situation. So the Minister should perhaps reflect on this. If he is not content with this amendment, cautious though it might be, he could table something at Third Reading.
8:30 pm
The fundamental point is that we have here an opportunity to help with the cost of living. As brokers are advising, insurers and market-makers are withdrawing from the Province because the economics of the claim system do not pay. An insurance company, like any other business, has to make a profit, but claims may be exorbitant and the management of them expensive. Quite often, claims through these companies result in the amount of time that the vehicle is on the road expanding, with the car hire charges expanding in parallel. That is a source of very significant profit. They have their own garages in some cases, and obviously their own hire cars. That all goes on the bill of the insurer—and then ends up with the consumer.
The Government have an opportunity to take a practical step forward to help people with the cost of living by extending a regulatory regime that exists in other parts of the United Kingdom. There are no legal or other risks attached. There is no cost to the Government—quite the opposite. I therefore urge the Minister to seriously consider the points that have been made. I would like to think that he could bring forward some proposals by Third Reading.
I support the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, and the noble Lords, Lord Weir of Ballyholme and Lord Empey. In doing so, I declare my interest as past chairman of the British Insurance Brokers’ Association and a practising solicitor in the City of London.
We have campaigned within the broking community for proper regulation of claims management companies for a very long time. Therefore, BIBA was particularly disappointed that this Bill did not address the problem, which is urgent. Average motor claims costs in Northern Ireland have tracked more than 30% higher than in England and Wales since 2021. The figures given by the noble Baroness bear that out. There is a need to do something about this problem. I agree with noble Lords who have spoken that this is a great opportunity for the Government to put right the anomaly. Claims management companies add between 15% and 30% to a total claim by taking a percentage out of compensation that does not reach the claimant. We must keep reminding ourselves of that.
This amendment would be a practical, targeted correction alongside the Bill’s wider focus on consumer protection, redress and better regulation.
My Lords, notwithstanding the anomalies that have been discussed—there are significant anomalies in insurance in England as well—we have some concerns about this amendment. It would hand the Treasury very extensive powers to act through secondary legislation, including the ability to amend primary legislation. We have raised concerns consistently in Committee and on Report about the use of broad, delegated powers of this kind. The same concerns apply here. Regulations being subject to the affirmative procedure provides a degree of parliamentary scrutiny. However, it does not alter the fundamental point that Parliament will be delegating significant legislative discretion to the Treasury before the detailed regime on any transitional arrangements has been set out.
My Lords, Amendment 16 would give the Treasury the power to extend regulation of claims management activity to Northern Ireland through secondary legislation. I am aware of the concerns relating to high insurance costs across the UK and would be supportive of action to tackle these where we can, but we should not rush to regulate without clear evidence.
The Government’s Motor Insurance Taskforce has examined the drivers of motor insurance costs, including claims-related costs and market practices. This work has not identified clear evidence that claims management companies are a primary driver of higher premiums in Northern Ireland. Moreover, any proposal in this area would also need careful engagement with the Department of Finance in Northern Ireland and proper consideration of the devolution implications. I therefore ask the noble Baroness to withdraw Amendment 16.
My Lords, there I was thinking that we had a Minister who was going to be much more reassuring, but, in fact, that was a very negative response. All the things he said have already happened and could be happening in more detail if the Government were to move forward with this. It really is a missed opportunity for the Government and it is not going to go away; it will have to come back in a different form.
I had not realised until recently—probably like many people here tonight—how appalling this situation is. I do not know where the Minister got his facts and figures; perhaps from the Treasury, but certainly not from the people who know what is going on in Northern Ireland. There is obviously no point putting this to a vote tonight, but I hope that, following this, the Minister will meet a group of us who understand this a bit more and will make it clear to him that perhaps, sometimes, he might be given the wrong advice. I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment 16 withdrawn.
Amendment 17
20 of 125 shown
Therefore, there is no regulation of claims management companies in Northern Ireland. This has led to many of them exercising poor practices, which in turn leads to inflated claims settlements and therefore higher premiums for consumers and businesses. As fewer insurers have a physical claims-handling presence in Northern Ireland, so the prevalence of CMCs has become more apparent. The number of CMCs has grown rapidly. We estimate that there are probably twice the number operating than a year ago, suggesting that it is a very lucrative enterprise. Adverts appear everywhere, pointing people to them if they have a car accident, et cetera. Of course, in GB, since the regulation came in, the number of CMCs operating has halved since 2019.
Another reason for the growth of CMCs is their attraction of higher personal injury awards in Northern Ireland, which makes it a lot more lucrative for them. The difference between Northern Ireland and England and Wales is striking. For whiplash, for example, in England and Wales a compensation of around £1,500 would be paid. In Northern Ireland, it could be up to £15,000 with psychological claims added on. Obviously, those higher awards feed directly into higher insurance premiums for consumers and businesses alike. In some cases, we see clear conflicts of interest. Vehicle hire, legal services and CMCs are brought together under the same commercial structure, creating clear conflicts of interest, with some CMCs operating various companies under different names but with the same overall ownership. Ultimately, these additional costs are paid by consumers through higher premiums.
As we all know, insurance is not a luxury; it is essential. It must be accessible and affordable for all. It is very unfair that we in Northern Ireland are paying a higher premium compared to those in Great Britain.
The consequences of no regulation at all of CMCs are becoming increasingly clear. Major insurers have already withdrawn from Northern Ireland and new entrants are refusing to come. Some insurers are refusing to insure young drivers at any cost, and some insurers are refusing to cover certain postcodes where there is a high prevalence of CMCs and perhaps more perceived evidence of collusion. One insurer has reportedly reduced its Northern Ireland motor business by 75% and customers of a major broker have seen their premiums rise by 45% between 2023 and 2026. All this, of course, could lead to market failure.
Northern Ireland consumers deserve access to affordable, fair and competitive insurances. To achieve that, we will need co-ordinated action from the Northern Ireland Executive, the Treasury, Westminster, regulators and industry alike. We have to work together to make this happen. Everyone agrees that there is a problem and now we have to fix it. The issue has become quite a political hot potato in Northern Ireland, because the Department of Justice, the Department of Finance, the Department for the Economy and the Department for Infrastructure have all been examining it.
The FCA is aware of the problem but powerless to protect consumers. The Treasury is aware of the problem. MPs and MLAs continue to hear from frustrated constituents, yet despite all this—and, I hope, an agreement between the Opposition Front Bench and the Liberal Democrat Front Bench—nothing has actually changed and there is no regulation. While responsibilities pass from one department, committee, regulator and jurisdiction to another, premiums remain higher, choice remains limited and opportunities are denied to people who can least afford it.
The solution does not require years of further review or consultation; it requires action. Primary legislation is needed and the Bill is the perfect vehicle to deliver it. The amendment is practical, proportionate and targeted. It seeks to address what may become a market failure and create the conditions for a more competitive, affordable and accessible insurance market in Northern Ireland.
This is not a party-political amendment; it simply seeks to ensure fairness in Northern Ireland for consumers and to stop the rip-off merchants operating in this field. I hope that the Government will engage constructively with the amendment and work with us before the Bill goes back to the other place so that we can get the regulation needed.
The Bill is all about regulation. This is in the one place in the United Kingdom where we do not have that regulation. We have the ability to make it happen and I hope that the Minister will have some positive things to say. I beg to move.
The noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, highlighted that part of the issue is that this has tended to fall between the cracks. It is not under the exact remit of any one particular department. Whatever the long-term issue is, it has become exacerbated in recent years, particularly since the end of Covid. In the last few years, we have seen shrinking choice. The number of insurance brokers and insurance companies has reduced for home and motor insurance. This has led to a vicious cycle of increasing premiums which, of itself, has meant more dependence on the role of CMCs. The direct impact of CMCs has been to raise overall premiums in Northern Ireland perhaps by around 30%.
As indicated by the proposer of this amendment, it is not purely the CMCs that have led to these increases, but they have played a very significant role. When part of the industry is unregulated, unaccountable and unchecked, it is no wonder that, for some, this has become almost a licence to print money. How this has then filtered down to the consumer has had a major impact. Any of us in Northern Ireland is used to the annual exercise, when we renew either our house insurance or our motor insurance, of our brokers quote us an exorbitantly increased level of cost. Generally speaking, we then try to probe that by asking them to explore whether there are any other options. At best, they will come back with something slightly less than what they originally quoted, but the prices go up and up for everyone. It is particularly acute for first-time motorists, for example. They face a situation either of exorbitant motor insurance costs or, in some cases, of simply not being quoted at all.
This is something which can be tackled. We have offered a very practical way forward through this amendment. The Government and, in particular, the new Prime Minister have put at the heart of the agenda the cost of living, not simply in a general sense but for every postcode in the country. If we are looking for something that can deliver on this promise then this is quite low-hanging fruit. I urge the Government either to accept the amendment or to find some formula, through discussions, in which its spirit can be brought forward so that we can actually start to tackle this problem once and for all. The amendment offers a solution by way of the Government intervening through the Treasury—or, at the very least, the sheer threat of the power may well lead to CMCs reducing back their costs. I hope that it may lead to good behaviour on their part. I urge the Government to give this very serious consideration. I look forward to the Minister’s response.