My Lords, the exodus that we have just seen was about as chaotic as the Government’s plans that we are about to debate. However, I thank the Minister for providing us with the opportunity to ask questions.
This latest Statement represents the fifth early release scheme that has been announced since the Prime Minister took office less than two months ago. With every new announcement, victims have been left in doubt as to which criminals will be released early. I hope that the Government recognise the impact that their lack of direction will have caused.
The Minister in the other place set out that the amended early release scheme will operate for the foreseeable future, as the Sentencing Act 2026 is the basis on which standard determinate sentences will be governed. However, given that the Act, as passed by Parliament, did not exclude any of the exemptions that were announced last week, I hope that the Minister will understand why questions remain. It is right that those convicted of the crimes set out by the Justice Secretary are exempt from the early release scheme.
If noble Lords cast their minds back to January, when the House debated the Report stage of this very Act, they may remember an amendment tabled by my noble and learned friend Lord Keen of Elie that would have achieved a very similar outcome. That amendment would have excluded a number of dangerous criminals—those serving time for some of the most serious offences—from early release.
However, the Government resisted our Conservative amendment and prevented it going into the Act. The Government were warned that the Act would reduce the time spent in prison for more than 60% of rapists and more than 80% of child sex offenders. Now, nine months later, the Government have belatedly accepted the problems with their early release scheme. Why has it taken them so long to acknowledge the warnings from my noble and learned friend? What has changed in their assessment of available prison spaces between January and September that they can now include these exemptions when they resisted them earlier this year?