To ask His Majesty’s Government what plans they have, if any, to extend the scope of the BBC licence fee to households using streaming services; and what assessment they have made of the impact of any such change on (1) household bills, (2) consumer choice, (3) investment and (4) the creative industry.
My Lords, as noble Lords are aware, the ongoing charter review is considering how to secure the BBC’s long-term future, including by putting its funding model on a sustainable footing. As set out in the Green Paper, the Government are keeping an open mind on all options, including considering reforms to the licence fee. Among the things that the Government are considering as part of the charter review process is indeed the impact on households, consumer choice, investment and the wider creative economy. The Government will set out their decisions in the White Paper by the end of the year.
My Lords, yet again, we are seeing significant government policy being floated in the media before Parliament has been given any clarity at all. That was criticised previously and repeatedly under the previous Prime Minister. The Ministerial Code is clear that major policy announcements should be made first to Parliament when Parliament is in session. Whatever the merits of this proposal, potentially 4 million households could be affected. Can the Minister therefore give the House some certainty today? Are the Government considering extending the licence fee to households that currently use only streaming services? What options are on the table and when will Parliament be given a full statement on the Government’s plans?
I thank the noble Lord for his question. Of course, I agree that it is the job of the Government to share any major policy decisions first in the two Houses of Parliament. With regret, I am unable to answer the rest of the noble Lord’s question because, as I have said, the process of consideration is ongoing, and the results of the consideration will be published in a White Paper by the end of the year.
The noble Lord opposite makes a valid point about protecting household budgets, but does my noble friend the Minister agree that the BBC also needs sustainable funding? It is a very worthwhile investment for our country, given that it contributes £6.7 billion to the UK economy every year, supporting 77,000 jobs in the UK. It also performs a great duty in terms of social cohesion.
I thank my noble friend for that question. Of course, the Government believe that the BBC is vital to the country, the households that continue to enjoy it, and the 467 million people globally who appreciate and trust BBC News services, and that it is very important that we find a long-term, sustainable way to secure the future of the BBC. That will involve, and is involving, looking at a range of options to find a way in which we can support the BBC—of course—but also encourage and incentivise the BBC to look at commercial options and at diversifying its income sources.
I declare my previous interests. I am very happy to see the noble Baroness opposite in her place. We had the dubious and mixed pleasure of sitting together on the board of the New Millennium Experience Company—the Dome—leading up to the millennium. I will move away from the specifics to the principles behind the Government’s policy. Does the Minister agree with me that there are three principles that should underlie the Government’s policy for the BBC? One is that the BBC will not be put into competition for revenue. The second is that any new arrangement will be progressive, unlike the regressive nature of the licence fee, and will reflect people’s ability to pay. Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, is that the cost of the public investment in the BBC will reduce materially in future.
I thank the noble Lord for taking me back to the not entirely happy memories of being on the board of the Dome. I should say, for the record, that the Dome achieved over 6 million visitors and created a lasting legacy, which is now thriving as a commercial enterprise—but that is not the topic for today.
I thank the noble Lord for his principles. While I am not trying to pre-empt any of the findings that will be revealed in the White Paper at the end of the year —I apologise, as I am going to be repeating that point several times, I fear—I would like to comment. I start with the last, very important point that the noble Lord made. It is the case that the licence fee has been declining significantly over the past decade, and that has been one major source of challenge for the BBC. I do not think that I can yet say whether the changes published in the White Paper at the end of the year will explicitly meet the noble Lord’s point about avoiding a regressive source of public funding. Of course, the Secretary of State is on record as saying that the role of public funding continues to be a vital part of the vision for the future of the BBC. I would just question whether avoiding competitive finance is a rule that applies on all possible occasions. I can imagine some scenarios whereby it is of benefit to the BBC to be in a competitive environment and it can gain from that process, but that is not in any way to pre-empt any decision.
When we are looking at this, can the Government give us some idea whether they are considering making those who set the level of financing generated from the public a more independent body? This has become a political football, to be kicked hard and often into the long grass. Also, if a lot of these streamers and other services use BBC resources for news and reporting, would it not be a good idea if the Government opened up the door to saying that they should pay something for those services?
I thank the noble Lord for two very interesting questions. Of course, it is the case that regulation of the BBC is independent; that is a very important principle dear to this Government. Ofcom, as we know, is the independent regulator. I will take back his suggestion that setting the level of settlement for the charter review should also be given to an independent body; that is a very interesting thought, which I shall reflect on more and share with colleagues. Similarly, it is the case that streamers can use the resources of the BBC without paying for those services; that is something that can be considered in the options that lead up to the White Paper at the end of the year.
My Lords, in drawing up the White Paper, will the Government pay particular attention to the increasingly important role of the BBC in promoting local democracy through backing local news at a time when local newspapers are vanishing from the scene and the Government are pushing more and more decision-making down the track through devolution? It is increasingly important that the BBC’s local democracy initiative is given adequate funding.
I thank the noble Baroness for that important point, which applies not only to local news and local BBC services but to BBC services in the devolved nations, where the funding is equally vital.
Does the Minister agree that seeking to expand the definition of “usage” to justify a compulsory licence fee is misplaced, especially when trust in the BBC among some sections of the public is going down and some people are turning away from the BBC? As part of its charter discussion, has the department requested access to public trust data from the BBC that shows how it performs among different demographic groups? If not, will the Minister commit to doing so and to taking account of that in any decision that is made about future funding of the BBC?
I thank the noble Baroness, who is right to say that trust in the BBC has declined, but it is still at 59% of UK respondents, which makes it the UK’s most trusted news brand. In a context of diversification, one could fairly say that that is an admirable achievement on the BBC’s part. I would have to consult with colleagues on the question about the collection of data and I commit to getting back to the noble Baroness on that point.
My Lords, first, does the Minister agree that the most important thing is that the BBC is funded properly and that that funding is sustainable, especially given that we are on the front line of global misinformation? Secondly, how best can it engage more with young people?