My Lords, in 2023, the European Union replaced its 2006 batteries directive with a new batteries regulation. This updated placing on the market requirements, covering design specifications for batteries and requirements relating to information and labelling. These requirements, designed to support the environmental and safety performance of batteries, relate to carbon footprint, performance and durability, recycled content, and removability and replaceability of batteries from devices.
The new EU regulation has also introduced specific safety requirements for stationary battery energy storage systems and updates the information requirements to include state of health and expected lifetime. Finally, the EU regulation also introduces the digital battery passport and supply chain due diligence policies for larger organisations. Previous requirements relating to the restriction of certain substances in batteries are carried forward.
I welcome the collaborative approach taken in the development of this instrument, which has drawn constructively on expertise from industry and government departments. The enforcement provisions set out in this SI meaningfully strengthen the application of the EU batteries regulation in Northern Ireland, where it has been law since its publication in 2023. By improving compliance in key areas such as battery safety, hazardous substances and environmental performance, it is reasonable to expect positive environmental outcomes through reduced risk of unsafe or environmentally harmful batteries being placed on the market.
I am also reassured by the de minimis assessment undertaken in respect of this instrument. Given that the associated costs are minimal and that the instrument introduces no contentious or disproportionate impacts, this approach seems to be both reasonable and appropriate.
At the end insert “, but that this that this House regrets that the draft Regulations impose a different legal requirement for the placing on the market of batteries in Northern Ireland in order to comply with the Windsor Framework; further undermine the integrity of the UK internal market; and could lead to higher costs for companies based in Northern Ireland.”
My Lords, I will speak to the amendment in my name and make four main points.
First, these regulations provide a graphic demonstration of the humiliating nature of the Windsor Framework. The substantive legislation which they enforce is EU Regulation 2023/1542. This legislation took effect in Northern Ireland automatically on 17 August 2023 by means of a dynamic aligning of the UK, with respect to Northern Ireland, with the EU, effectively treating part of the United Kingdom as an EU colony. Northern Ireland legislators were not even briefed on this matter. The first we learned of it was three years later, reading the Explanatory Notes to the regulations before us today, the purpose of which is to serve the EU by providing a means for enforcing its legislation.
Secondly, the enforcement that these regulations provide is deeply problematic. Speaking when these regulations were debated in another place on 8 July, the Minister stated:
“Offences are put in one of three penalty groups: summary-only offences, such as those subject to a fine, which can be unlimited; either-way offences; or imprisonment for up to 12 months and/or an unlimited fine for the most serious indictable-only offences. Offences include failure to keep appropriate due-diligence documentation; failure of a supplier of battery cells and modules to provide documentation to manufacturers; and failure by an importer to comply with certain battery safety-related obligations. Those fall into penalty groups 1, 2 and 3, respectively”.—[Official Report, Commons, Delegated Legislation Committee, 8/7/26; col. 4.]
Let us take a step back for a moment. If the norm of the 18th century was such that there could be no taxation without representation then plainly we cannot contemplate fines and imprisonment in the 21st century further to contravention of laws unless the citizens in question were represented in the making of those laws that they have broken. The EU is expecting the United Kingdom Government not only to subject part of themselves to EU law but to introduce a legislative mechanism whereby EU law can be imposed with sanctions depriving UK citizens of money in the form of fines or potentially of their liberty through imprisonment. This is constitutionally completely absurd and unacceptable.
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord McCrea, for moving this amendment so that we can again debate this crucial constitutional matter. I have every sympathy with the points he made, because what we face again here is legislation by sleight of hand. We are in fact approving comprehensive regulations for the battery sector, but we are told they are none of our business as a United Kingdom Parliament because it was determined in Brussels, without any of our representatives present, and formed into a directive which is directly acting in Northern Ireland, an important part of our country.
We are asked to debate today the much lesser issue of the impact of the enforcement mechanism, which we are allowed to discuss and approve, not the wider impact of the battery regulation on a growing and complex sector, with many businesses at stake. So the Minister is able to tell us—reasonably accurately, perhaps —that the impact assessment says that it is not going to cost very much because that impact assessment assesses only the administrative costs connected with creating these new offences. It does not go into the detail of what might happen if people actually had to pay the fines, of course, and it leaves out the question of the huge compliance costs with the underlying directive.
The case being made is that it already applies, so businesses have already had to impose it. It is rather odd that the Government have not got round to putting in the enforcement mechanism until now. We have been told that it is much delayed compared with the EU’s requirement upon us, but, none the less, they got there in the end. The noble Lord, Lord McCrea, made the powerful point that in a democracy, if you are imposing potential large fines or imprisonment on people, that is surely something which your country and elected Parliament should control, not something which you are told you have to do because of an EU imposition on part of your country.
My Lords, I support the amendment in the name of my noble friend Lord McCrea. The Government present the regulations as a technical measure concerned with the placing of batteries on the market. However, like so many regulations flowing from the post-Brexit arrangements for Northern Ireland, they raise issues that extend far beyond their immediate subject matter. They concern the principle of equal treatment within our United Kingdom, the burden placed upon Northern Ireland businesses and the continuing erosion of democratic accountability.
At the practical level, these regulations impose obligations on traders, manufacturers and distributors operating in Northern Ireland that are not faced by many of their counterparts elsewhere in the United Kingdom. Businesses will have to familiarise themselves with new requirements, maintain compliance procedures, keep appropriate documents and ensure that products satisfy the latest relevant regulatory standards. The Government may regard these obligations as modest but, for many small businesses and medium-sized enterprises, they are anything but.
A family-run wholesaler or retailer in Northern Ireland does not have a dedicated compliance department or a team of lawyers on hand to interpret evolving rules. Every new requirement means additional paper, additional administrative time, additional record keeping and, of course, additional cost. Businesses supplying both GB and Northern Ireland may find themselves having to operate under distinct regulatory arrangements. That can mean separate packaging, documentation, compliance checks and reporting requirements. These costs are very real for small traders working on very tight margins.
We must also consider the enforcement regime that accompanies these obligations. Businesses are not merely being asked to comply with another set of rules; they are being asked to do so under the threat of investigation, enforcement and sanctions if they fail. A trader who inadvertently breaks these technical requirements may face compliance notices, restrictions on the sale of products or further legal proceedings. The real concern is not simply the penalty but the risk that accompanies it.
My Lords, I will speak against the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord McCrea, although I understand the tenacity with which this point is being put on a very regular basis and how sincerely he feels about these issues. I also understand, having listened repeatedly to these points being raised, that it is not a case of persuading my good friends and colleagues in this House that this is just about batteries, that there is a pragmatic need to get on with this and that these are probably good regulations anyway, so what is the harm? Those arguments get nowhere in this debate: I recognise that. So I am going to seek to put this in a bit of context around how we have got to where we are.
The Windsor Framework is better than the Northern Ireland Protocol it replaced, but it is still unfortunately imperfect. It creates friction in the Irish Sea and additional burdens on businesses. It is probably wise to just be honest, open and upfront about this and not pretend otherwise. It is a fudge; it was necessary. I heard the noble Lord, Lord McCrae, say that he was not aware that these regulations would be coming into place. I can see why he says that, but surely, when the vote to leave the European Union took place, it must have been anticipated that there would need to be some kind of arrangement for Northern Ireland that would entail a huge amount of compromise—and, ideally, flexibility and understanding on both sides and a real determination to find a solution. I do not remember that atmosphere around those discussions at the time, so we are left with this unsatisfactory way of working. But it is the operational reality in which we find ourselves and, while it is there, it is one that we must make work.
I have heard it said that dual market access is imaginary and not a thing. I understand that there are problems with GB-NI trade; that is true. But it is not fair and not correct to say that there is no such thing as dual market access. There is and it is a position that businesses in Northern Ireland—small enterprises, big exporters and manufacturers—talk about wishing to take advantage of. You can see the growth that is being achieved in Northern Ireland as a consequence of dual market access and the unique economic position of Northern Ireland. Northern Ireland is succeeding, perhaps, you could argue, in spite of some of these challenges—and when was it not the case that business and enterprise were not able to overcome such things? My experience of talking to businesses in Northern Ireland is that they want clarity, they want certainty and they can deal with it. That is their intention.
My Lords, I welcome the opportunity to speak in this debate and to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, who made some very interesting points—some of which I do not agree with, but that is politics.
It is quite clear that there is a UK conformity assessment in this legislation. It is not going to be as simple as some people try to make out; that is the difficulty that we have. I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, that some people may see the Windsor Framework as positive in the business sense. Many others do not, and that is the difficulty. If you are running a small or medium-sized business, the extra burden of administration and bureaucracy put on to you sometimes makes it hugely difficult to find your way around it.
The second issue, which has been mentioned by a number of speakers, is the control that there will be on those who break the law. There will very severe penalties that, as has been highlighted, the UK will have no control over. I note that the instrument did not require a full consultation and that the de minimis amount has been put on it regarding costs. I am not sure what all that covers. Maybe the Minister can help us out and say what the best estimates are. I see the estimates in the legislation, but I am not sure whether they are the full amount.
My final point goes back to the management of the entire Windsor Framework process. The noble Lord, Lord Murphy, who is in the Chamber, had a report out last year. He stated:
“The UK Government should work to make Windsor Framework related guidance accessible in a single ‘all-in-one service’ and do more to signpost businesses, especially small to medium-sized businesses, towards this support”.
I am not sure that has taken place yet. I am not sure whether there has been any progress on it. I would like to hear from the Minister about this. It will not resolve the issue of divergence between the UK and Northern Ireland, but it would, at least in the meantime, help small and medium-sized businesses in Northern Ireland by signposting to them so that they get the proper help and security they may need. I would like to hear whether there has been some progress on that.
My Lords, I am pleased to have the opportunity to support the noble Lord, Lord McCrea of Magherafelt and Cookstown. Surprisingly, I find myself in agreement with the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman of Darlington, who made a number of very fair points. Incidentally, it would be good to see her back on the Front Bench eventually; she is much missed on the Front Bench.
However, I think the noble Baroness has slightly rose-tinted spectacles in respect of the negotiations, of which I was a small part during the early part of the Northern Ireland protocol. It was never a binary choice between a hard border and nothing else. There were always the options, which were ignored by the May, Sunak and Johnson Governments, of technical solutions that Lars Karlsson, among others, pioneered in the Middle East, Norway and Sweden. I will perhaps pre-empt the perennial comments of the noble Lord, Lord Davies of Brixton, about how terrible Brexit is; in respect of Northern Ireland, there were always choices which were not pursued. However, we are where we are.
In applying EU law, the Windsor Framework relegates Northern Ireland’s citizens to second-class, violates territorial integrity and erodes UK sovereignty. Notwithstanding that this is a technical enforcement instrument, brought about because of the need to avoid legal jeopardy and litigation risk, I believe we are failing in our duty because we are not even fulfilling the traditional parliamentary role of scrutiny and oversight; incidentally, and ironically, nor are the European Parliament or the Northern Ireland Assembly, because this is generated from the European Commission. The European Parliament is not a parliament we would necessarily recognise in the traditional sense; it is in fact a body subject to huge amounts of lobbying by business in the interests of the countries of the European Union.
7:32 pm
20 of 36 shown
Of course, it is right that this House scrutinises delegated legislation carefully. I am satisfied this instrument falls within the scope of the parent Act and represents an appropriate use of powers. It is for these reasons that I beg to move.
Thirdly, we need to confront how these regulations are implicated in destroying the United Kingdom internal market for goods. By providing enforcement, the regulations before us today bring EU Regulation 2023/1542 into full effect, creating a new legal market for batteries as a matter of practice, subject to different rules from the rest of the United Kingdom. The regulations are called the “placing on the market” regulations, where the market in question is the EU internal market, not a United Kingdom internal market, which necessarily becomes, by default, a GB internal market for goods for these purposes. This presents an economic challenge for Northern Ireland. If we manufacture our own batteries, we will not do so on a level playing field with the rest of the United Kingdom, because we will be subject to EU regulations that do not apply to Great Britain. If, as a small and until recently completely integrated part of the United Kingdom economy, we get most of our batteries from GB, we will not be able to do so going forward unless GB companies provide batteries to the requirements of EU law and also pay to get additional Northern Ireland marking. Will they do this for a tiny market? This presents a very real supply chain concern.
Fourthly, the Explanatory Memorandum attending these regulations is unlike the memoranda accompanying many other regulations forged in deference to the Windsor Framework. Often they state that the Government are planning to prevent divergence between Great Britain and Northern Ireland by bringing GB into line with Northern Ireland, and thus with the EU. However, the Explanatory Memorandum accompanying these regulations does no such thing. This prompted real concern that, on this matter, London was ready to cut Northern Ireland off, which resulted in concerns being expressed to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee of your Lordships’ House.
In the other place, the Minister said:
“Let me be clear that we will take any steps necessary to continue to meet the Government’s commitment to protect the UK’s internal market. That is why we will consult in the autumn on an aligned regime in Great Britain that is consistent with the EU’s 2023 batteries regulation”.—[Official Report, Commons, Seventh Delegated Legislation Committee, 8/7/26; col. 5.]
Thus, along with the tumble dryers regulations and the machinery regulations, the battery regulations now become an early expression of the Government’s reset policy with the EU.
In closing, I want to anticipate and respond to the counterargument deployed by the Minister in another place when proposing this legislation in July. She said:
“Implementing the measures helps Northern Ireland to maintain its dual market access”.—[Official Report, Commons, Seventh Delegated Legislation Committee, 8/7/26; col. 4.]
The sense was that all the problems that I have outlined were worth while because of the great prize of dual market access. But let me be quite clear: dual market access is a myth. If Northern Ireland enjoyed dual market access, there would be no Irish Sea customs border or UK/Republic of Ireland customs border. Northern Ireland would enjoy unfettered input access, unfettered sales access to the rest of the United Kingdom, and unfettered input and sales access to the Republic. What has actually taken place is that Northern Ireland has been forced to exchange unfettered access to its home economy of nearly 70 million for unfettered access to another proximate economy of about 5 million.
Rather than becoming less problematic over time, the Irish Sea border is becoming more problematic with every new piece of legislation that is published to try to accommodate it. This position is completely unsustainable. The Irish Sea customs and international SPS border must go. I beg to move.
My second great worry about this is that it illustrates not only that laws are imposed on Northern Ireland without proper debate, democratic consideration or economic assessment, but that we end up with them in Great Britain as well. We are now told by the Government that the only way they think they can guarantee the very important integrity of our internal market—with a far bigger economic impact on both sides of the Irish Sea than the issues the EU is imposing, and with far less trade at risk—is that it all has to be taken for granted and that we have to adopt the measures that the EU is imposing on Northern Ireland, otherwise our internal market will be disrupted. Not only does the Windsor Framework now mean that Northern Ireland has to accept undemocratic law on itself, but we will probably end up with it in GB as well.
These are mighty issues arising out of what look like rather technical and small directives and statutory instruments to handle them. I again urge the Minister to take back to the wider Government that they cannot go on like this. They cannot go on pretending that we live in a sovereign democracy if, by the back door, these laws can be imposed on part of our country, and then perhaps on the whole country, without proper consideration. This must be the number one issue in the reset and the Government should not take no for an answer. There are easy solutions in a reset. Please get on with them.
This debate is therefore about far more than batteries. It is about democracy, accountability and equal citizenship. The issue is not simply an environmental policy; it is a question of equal treatment under the law. Businesses in Northern Ireland deserve legal certainty. They deserve democratic accountability and the same regulatory framework as their counterparts in the rest of the United Kingdom, unless there is a compelling justification otherwise. Increasingly, however, we see Northern Ireland subject to distinct requirements which create barriers within the internal market of our own nation.
My noble friend Lord McCrea’s amendment rightly highlights these concerns. It recognises that every new layer of regulatory divergence carries practical consequences for traders and constitutional consequences for Northern Ireland’s place within the United Kingdom. I support my noble friend Lord McCrea’s amendment.
It is right—if it is what you believe—to criticise the complexities of the current arrangements. But, equally, please do not ignore the concrete advantages that see Northern Ireland consistently expanding sales into the EU in advanced manufacturing, life sciences and aerospace, with local pioneers openly pointing to the Windsor Framework as a net positive, giving them access to a £6 trillion market. We should try, when we can, to have a calm, level-headed approach to all of this. The foundational agreements of the peace process stand. What is needed is flexibility, pragmatism and a real focus on making sure that we never lose the stability, prosperity and good governance that Northern Ireland will always need.
In effect, we are an appointment body for the market surveillance authority, which is the Office for Product Safety and Standards. That is our role in this sovereign Parliament and it is quite shameful, in my opinion. We are not even looking at the efficacy of the policy—the technical details on carbon footprint, standards, recycling, labelling, the battery passport and CE marking. We are of course diverging from the 2008 regulations affecting Great Britain.
This point was made in the committee in the other place: we may have warm words—as they say, warm words butter no parsnips—that Section 46 of the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020 has not been offended, but it has. We are clearly not abiding by that and by the territorial integrity and importance of the UK-wide, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland single market.
This goes to the point made earlier by one of the noble Lords from the DUP. We are talking here about criminal liabilities, not an overdue library book. We are talking about people potentially being the subject of criminal sanction and going to prison. That is not being debated in our sovereign Parliament, or indeed in the devolved Assembly in Northern Ireland, and I think that is a serious issue that should concern everyone, irrespective of their party. I challenge the Minister to talk about that issue, because these regulations are rules set by a body that no one voted for and cannot be removed.
I have three quick questions for the Minister. Will she give us more details on the GB-wide consultation? What are the likely producer responsibility requirements that will arise following that? Will she perhaps undertake to review the operation of the regulations, as between Great Britain and Northern Ireland, in respect of competitive advantage? Finally, if the noble Lord chooses to test the opinion of the House, he will have my strong support.