My Lords, the draft code of practice was laid before the House on 6 July 2026. I note the regret amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom. I am grateful for the opportunity to debate the code and will address the concerns raised by the noble Lord in my remarks.
The Government believe that strong trade unions are essential for tackling insecurity, inequality, discrimination, enforcement, and low pay. Trade union representatives play an important role and this Government are committed to ensuring that they have the capacity to represent employees and negotiate with employers. This Government recognise trade union equality representatives for raising awareness, promoting equal rights and developing policies that help organisations benefit from being equal opportunities employers. That is why, through the Employment Rights Act 2025, we strengthened the existing rights and introduced new rights for employees who are trade union representatives.
The three key changes are, first, the existing right to reasonably paid facility time for trade union representatives to carry out their duties has been strengthened. The legislation now makes it clear that where a trade union representative requests paid facility time, it should generally be treated as reasonable, and it is for the employer to demonstrate otherwise if challenged in a tribunal. Secondly, the Act introduces a statutory provision requiring that representatives be provided with reasonable access to facilities such as meeting spaces, communication tools and appropriate workplace resources to enable them to carry out their duties or undertake relevant training. Thirdly, the Act introduces a new right to reasonably paid time off for trade union equality representatives for specified equality-related purposes.
The ACAS code of practice, issued under Section 199 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, offers practical guidance on the legislation. The code has been updated to reflect Employment Rights Act changes, ensuring effective implementation when new rights come into force in October. It offers clear guidance for employers, trade unions and representatives on their practical application.
At end to insert “but that this House regrets that the draft Code of Practice will expand the scope of paid facility time for trade union equality representatives without sufficient evidence that this will improve workplace outcomes; risks increasing costs and administrative burdens on public sector employers at a time of persistently weak public sector productivity; and fails to demonstrate that requiring taxpayers fund additional staff time for equality, diversity, and inclusion activity represents an effective or proportionate use of public money.”
My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument, to which, as he noted, I have tabled a regret amendment. As he pointed out, under this code of practice, if a dispute reaches an employment tribunal over the amount of time that a union representative proposes to take off, it is for the employer to show that the amount requested was not reasonable. That applies not only to existing trade union representatives but to the new statutory equality representatives created by the Act.
How is that a fair starting point for an employer who is trying to run an organisation? The employer is responsible for delivering the service, meeting the order, keeping the production line moving, ensuring adequate staffing, serving customers and, in the public sector, ensuring that taxpayers receive the services for which they have paid. Yet when an employee asks to spend paid working time away from their ordinary duties undertaking trade union activity, the presumption now operates against the employer. If there is a challenge, it is the employer who must prove that the amount requested was unreasonable.
The Government’s own impact assessment acknowledges a possible consequence. It states explicitly that employment tribunal claims may increase because the Bill places the burden of proof on the employer. The code states explicitly that what is reasonable will depend on the circumstances in each case. That is an invitation to test every case, and we can have little doubt that it will be exploited aggressively by the trade unions to cow employers into submission.
The second issue is the creation of statutory rights for trade union equality representatives. Let us be precise about what this means. The Government are not creating a separate, new job title in every workplace. They are giving existing employees, who are appointed or elected as union equality representatives, a statutory entitlement to spend reasonable paid working time carrying out equality-related union functions. But those functions are extraordinarily broad. They include promoting equality in the workplace, arranging equality-related training, consulting the employer on equality issues, obtaining and analysing workplace equality information, and preparing to carry out all those activities. These regulations could encompass requiring businesses to carry out document reviews, data analysis and meeting preparation. There could also be a serious data protection issue: equality and pay information may identify individuals, and much of it may constitute special-category personal data. The draft code was silent on whether employers might be expected to create new material rather than simply provide information which already exists. I suppose we should be grateful that the code specifies that employer and union activities at least complement one another to avoid duplication.
My Lords, I speak in the space reserved for the noble Lord, Lord Davies, who, sadly, cannot be with us. I do not think anyone will be surprised by what I have to say. I was a member of a trade union before I was ever a member of any political party, and that union was in the Civil Service. First, I have not had a single representation asking me to oppose this proposal—not one. Secondly, I have been involved in a trade union consistently since the age of 16. I think I am probably the only person in this House who has actually been the president of two TUC-affiliated trade unions, and I am probably also the only person in this House who has addressed the party conferences of both Labour and the Conservatives and the Trades Union Congress. I have certainly been around the block, as they say.
My experience of trade union work was founded in the welfare area. When I first became a trade union official I was 16 years old, believe it or not. This is not because I demonstrated a great ability; it was because no one could agree who should have the job. The Communist Party, the Socialist Party of Great Britain and various bits of the Labour Party decided that it should be me because they thought I would be the easiest one to push around. They were wrong, but in those very early days I learned that much of the work we did was around welfare. It was not industrial work at all. I have not had a day on strike in my life, and I have not had a day out of a trade union either. What I learned first about TUs is that we look after members. The first chairman I had was a Red Clydesider. “All that matters, Richard,” he used to say, “is whether they are in compliance”. That meant whether they had paid their subs, and if they had, they were looked after. We had many cases where we looked after members because they had problems. It was simple as that.
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, might not be surprised to hear that I do not agree with him that the code is disproportionate and represents an unjustifiable burden on employers and taxpayers.
I will start with a technical point. The regret amendment suggests that the draft ACAS code will expand the statutory entitlement to paid facility time for equality reps, but, as the noble Lord knows, the Employment Rights Act did that, and the arguments were played out during that Bill’s passage. ACAS is now explaining how the statutory right is to operate in practice. The key question is whether ACAS has produced a sensible set of guidance for implementing the law that Parliament has enacted. I believe that it has.
To recall, the Employment Rights Act provides a right to reasonable time off for equality reps of a recognised trade union for a specified purpose. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, described the purposes as broad, but I emphasise that they are specified, which is helpful. The purposes are:
“promoting … equality in the workplace … arranging learning or training … providing information, advice or support to qualifying members … consulting with the employer … obtaining and analysing information”,
and “preparing” for those activities. Again, the Act provides a right to reasonable time off for relevant training. The amount of time off, and its purposes, occasions and conditions, have to be reasonable in “all the circumstances”, including the employer’s circumstances and the practical requirements of the workplace. The code does not turn that into an unlimited entitlement, so this is not some new, open-ended commitment for employers.
The regret amendment suggests that there is insufficient evidence that equality representatives will improve workplace outcomes. Of course, we should always ask what evidence supports a new employment right, but no one can provide proof that every single instance of paid time off will produce a measurable improvement in a particular workplace. However, there is long-standing evidence and experience that properly trained workplace representatives can contribute to better employment relations, and they do. The existing ACAS codes point to the positive benefits of effective workplace representation to employers, employees and union members, including helping to resolve problems and conflicts at work. The updated code adds that effective representation can help to build trust, improve communication and support early resolution of workplace disputes.
To conclude, if we believe that public money should be used proportionately, we should welcome guidance that encourages employers and unions to agree clear, workable and reasonable arrangements. That is what the code provides, and I hope the regret amendment will be accordingly withdrawn.
20 of 33 shown
During parliamentary scrutiny of the then Employment Rights Bill, this House sought clarity on how these rights would operate in practice, emphasising the need to update this code. The revised ACAS code provides guidance to help employers, trade unions and representatives to understand how the measures should be implemented in the workplace. It explains how these rights should be applied, including activities under statutory duties, factors determining requests’ reasonableness, union-employer communication about time off and how employer-union arrangements are agreed. Importantly, it supports constructive engagement between employers and unions, encouraging co-operation and clarity over rigid rules, to benefit both parties. The code offers clear guidance to help employers confidently handle requests and assist representatives in exercising their rights properly. In that sense, the laying of this code is a necessary step to ensure that the changes made by the Act operate as intended from day one.
The regret amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom, raises concerns about the code expanding the right of trade union equality representatives to paid time off. However, it is important that we are clear about the purpose and scope of the code before us. This code neither introduces nor extends any new rights or obligations. The Employment Rights Act established the statutory right for trade union equality representatives to take reasonable time off, recognising their vital role in supporting members and engaging with employers on equality issues. Effective industrial relations save money by reducing tribunal cases, improving training and lowering staff turnover. Trade union equality reps help to foster constructive engagement on workplace equality. Importantly, the Act clearly sets out the specific equality-related purposes for which this right to be paid for time off can be taken.
This code is not introducing any new requirements; it is narrow and necessary. Its purpose is to guide the effective implementation of the changes which come into force on 30 October alongside this code. I hope all noble Lords will be able to support this instrument.
The Government’s own impact assessment said that there is likely to be a cost to employers from representatives spending more paid working time on facility time. It also accepts that statutory equality representatives are likely to impose some additional paid facility time cost. The cost, particularly in the public sector, is already unsustainable. The TaxPayers’ Alliance, analysing reported public sector facility time data for 2023-24, calculated that at least 21,639 trade union representatives were costing £98.2 million in facility time across the public sector. It found 993 employees spending 100% of their working hours on facility time. At the same time, a report by the Institute of Economic Affairs found direct public sector equality, diversity and inclusion staffing and training costs of approximately £557 million annually. The latest Civil Service facility time guidance removes the previous departmental mandatory cap, which was set at 0.1% of the pay bill, and replaces it with a suggested guideline at the same number. Meanwhile the unemployment Act repeals trade union facility time publications requirements. I wonder why.
The Government cannot even get unemployment down, yet when people are in work, they are legislating to give them more paid time away from their actual jobs. The taxpayer is asked to fund additional facility time without a quantified estimate of the recurring public sector cost. The private employer faces additional paid absence facilities administration, data protection questions and potential litigation. Public service managers face further pressure on staff time at a point when productivity remains below its pre-pandemic level. The Government’s paymasters really have bought some nice perks; I say to them: enjoy them while they last.
For those reasons, I regret this code and ask the Minister to explain why the Government believe that this is a good use of business resources, public sector staff time and taxpayers’ money.
It is also worth remembering, and it comes up in this debate, that the employer often asked us to intervene. The call went out: “Do you think you could have a word with him or her, because you know what we’re up against here?” People who went sailing in thinking they had a cast-iron case to pursue discovered, when they spoke to their union rep, that they did not have much of a case at all. The union rep would say, “Look, Jim, we had this a couple of years ago, and this is how it ended up. What you want is not going to work”. We were as much a part of management as of any great plot to overthrow the state.
There is no legal requirement in this for employers to give paid time off. It all boils down to good will, and many things in the trade union movement do exactly that. People want a pleasant and happy workplace, and the job of a trade union is often to help build it. But if they cannot agree, they can resort to an employment tribunal, which is provided here. I would hope it does not have to be used very often, but if it does, complaints can be resolved by conciliation or by ACAS. It is not as though this is trying to build up disputes: it is actually a way of trying to solve them.
Finally, years ago we had a Prime Minister called Mrs Thatcher—she was never my favourite. When she was leader of the Conservative Party, central office had three people devoted to trade unions. They used to look at the agendas and go to the conferences, and they knew what they were talking about. My good friend John Bowis was there as the leader of that little band. I would ask that the present Conservative leadership look again at deepening its relations with the TUs, because I am afraid it gives the impression that it does not know what on earth is going on there, or how to influence it. It is quite easy to influence it: indeed, doing so is much the same as with my dog. Pat them on the head, give them a bit of love and you will be surprised by how far you can get.
These are not abstract benefits. A workplace dispute that is resolved at an early stage is less likely to become a formal grievance, a disciplinary dispute, an employment tribunal claim or a breakdown in the employment relationships. I have spoken to many employers who recognise that union reps can be a valuable source of intelligence for management, helping the employer to deal with a problem before it becomes expensive, entrenched or legally contentious. That matters very directly in equality matters. Issues involving discrimination, harassment, victimisation or unequal treatment are precisely the sorts of matters where trained representatives can help employees and employers and stop grievances getting out of hand.
I fully share the regret amendment’s concern about value for money. Every pound of taxpayers’ money should be spent responsibly, but I do not accept that the costs related to time off for equality reps will be disproportionate. As always, costs need to be measured against benefits. It is wrong to assume that the time spent by a trained representative is simply a cost with no corresponding benefit. The potential benefits of these measures are workplaces where disputes are dealt with efficiently, managers receive early warnings and accurate information about problems affecting their workforce, employees understand their rights and responsibilities, and problems are contained. Sometimes, an hour spent identifying and resolving a problem is an hour that saves many more hours later.
The amendment speaks of taxpayers funding “additional staff time”. Again, the legislation talks about reasonable time off, and there are conditions. To get paid time off, the employee must be
“a member of an independent trade union recognised by the employer”,
and must have been “appointed or elected” as an equality representative in accordance with the union’s rules.
The amendment is not keen on taxpayers’ money being spent on equality, diversity and inclusion activity. Bashing EDI has become a fashionable transatlantic sport, but leaving that aside, what does the code actually say? The statutory definition of equality in this context is not an invitation to pursue every conceivable form of EDI activity; it is tied to established concepts in the Equality Act 2010: eliminating discrimination, harassment and victimisation; advancing equality of opportunity between people who share protected characteristics and those who do not; and fostering good relations.